Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be confused about social services

427 replies

whentheraincame · 15/08/2022 19:06

Bit of a long one but it's something I have thought about a long time. There's two narratives:

SS don't do enough; don't act to remove children in obvious danger (happens sometimes of course)

SS are overzealous; remove children from loving homes (going to happen at times, right?)

there was a show over ten years ago called I Want my Baby Back and it was absolutely heartbreaking and admittedly it terrified me. Basically hairline fractures were found in children and parents were blamed for abuse. The argument was (I forget details and could never watch again) from some doctors that these were the result of Vitamin D deficiency (which let's face it, was endemic a while back and in the news loads)

So the argument was those children were wrongly removed. One mother cried "I want my baby" and honestly it's never left me. I'll have a cry about this later as I always do if I think too much about a child being removed from a loving mum.

So my question is if anyone has proper insight. I'm scared of SS in general. Although I actually had involvement with them myself when I left an abusive ex and they came to check I was not going to go back, nothing further happened once they met me - so proof they are fine I guess.

But I remember seeing a lady on the news, well spoken, and saying SS need to return her children who were removed. I had a friend tell me in work once that a friend with undiagnosed autism got the children removed due an incident where one got hurt by the other (which happens. these things happen, children do get hurt and it's often an accident that couldn't be prevented)

I guess I just don't want to see SS as evil child snatchers, and want insight into how they operate in reality and what actually gets children removed from parents' care?

OP posts:
whentheraincame · 15/08/2022 20:11

Mudblast · 15/08/2022 19:45

Its sometimes both. People will say they leave children in dangerous homes, others will argue that their baby was taken for no reason

I work closely with them and have seen cases where in my opinion theyve been either too harsh or too lax. Ive seen them work very hard to keep children in homes

What i will say though is that often the people who have their babies taken are the people who dont engage. The people who believe their baby was taken for no reason, are usually the people who dont work with them then shout about it.

For example

A+B have 2 houses that are identically dirty.

Parent A admits the house isnt good, and asks for help. The children are seen playing with something boderline dangerous. Shes upset by this and takes on board social services feed back (even if she doesnt think all of it is true). She keeps her appointments with them, and social services feel she can adequately risk assess, see the improvement and believe her when she says it wont get like this again

Parent B feels their house is fine. When social services tell them its not, they argue about it. All the engagement is tense, shes not always in for appointments, the house barely changes or if it does they dont feel she understood what was dangerous in the first place and dont feel the change is lasting.

Or in the case of police being called to domestic disputes

Person A agrees that its not okay, engages in the freedom programe, akbowledges its not alright for kids to see this. They acknowledge dad is a risk to the kids. Ss then believe that shes got it, and wont be having him back

Parent B thinks the person who called the police was over reacting, and theres no risk to kids. They dont seem commited and there is a fair certainty they will be back with the partner in no time and the cycle goes on.

In both situations person B will be the one raging all over facebook, talking to media etc about how they didnt do anything wrong, and there was never any danger. That belief makes them a lot more vocal but also normally means that they wont have done anything to change the situation and that ss will be confident they will go back to the same pattern again

I was amazed in the field how many women didnt think it was an issue that the police being called to their address etc to break up fights etc. My main advice would be that even if people think they are over reacting, work with them acknowledge faults, and put in place what they ask (even if you dont agree)

In the dv cases i used to compare it to a pet tiger in the house. The person who recognises its a tiger, shouts "its a tiger!", shuts the kids away from playing with it then seeks help to remove the tiger isnt a risk, even if they didnt recognise it to before it growled. You know even if a tiger breaks in, that theyl call someone and get the kids away.

The person who is a risk is the one who says "thats not a tiger, its just a cat, its never hurt my kids, it only bit me once", or "i was trying to train it" or people that get rid of the tiger but keep inviting it back in. You know even if the tigers not there the day you visit, that the tiger will be back soon and their lack of danger awareness will mean they wont keep their kids safe

thank you. that makes a lot of sense.

can I ask about a dirty house? what would that entail?

If that mother left that dad, and he had been abusive to her but not the children, would he get contact allowed by the court?

OP posts:
Neverfullycharged · 15/08/2022 20:10

Children are only removed from the family home when it is not safe for them to remain.

I think it is important to amend the above quotation - when it is perceived it is not safe for the, to remain.

In many of these cases, the majority of reasonable people would agree. In others, ‘not safe’ is a little more blurry.

calmlakes · 15/08/2022 20:10

That term “adoptable” is abhorrent, it chills me to think of the contexts in which that is used

Adoptable simply means that there may be people willing to be the dc's adoptive parents and the dc would thrive in an adoptive placement.

Not something every dc would experience. Dc over the age of seven, dc with disabilities, dc in sibling groups, dc with a history of experiencing sexual abuse, dc with behavioral issues are all harder to place.

Soubriquet · 15/08/2022 20:09

I know two people who have had children taken from them by SS. I am only in “contact” with one as a fb friend.

She regularly talks about how she misses her children, how evil SS, about the “quota they have to get for bonuses” and that she only lost her children because she got diagnosed with depression.

In actual fact, she was with an abusive partner that she refused to leave and when she did leave, she would return to him too often for SS to be content to leave the children with her. Her last child was even taken at birth.

Yes I feel slightly sorry for her but at the same time, those kids are safer.

MajorCarolDanvers · 15/08/2022 20:07

So are you able and willing to share the kinds of things that children can be removed for where parents love them, but are less obvious as violence or flying into tempers?

Children are only removed from the family home when it is not safe for them to remain. This will be in cases where there is serious neglect, physical, sexual, emotional or psychological abuse.

Parents are offered a wide array of support to try to enable the children to be rehabilitated back to the family home. Some parents will totally engaged with this support, some will dip in and out and some just don't bother.

If it is at all possible to do so safely families will be supported to keep children in the family or to be rehabilitated to the family. Outcomes for children in care are not great and if the family can be kept together that is a better outcome.

Most of the families I have seen in these situations do love their kids. And their kids love them. But sometimes parents just can't cope, are too badly damaged themselves, are too unwell, are addicted and can't look after their kids safely.

Its worth trying to remember that children are only removed for their safety, its not something that is done to punish the parents.

calmlakes · 15/08/2022 20:06

Why would a social worker want a child who is adoptable to be adopted instead of with the parents? What incentive do they have?

The safety of the child.
There are no incentives for social workers to have dc adopted.
There is only a significant amount of work, not something SW's are short of.

Some dc will be taken into care who could have stayed with parents, other dc will be left with parents who should have been taken into care.

Social workers can't read minds and will as they are human sometimes get it wrong.

Overall thresholds are probably too high rather than too low at present.

Mudblast · 15/08/2022 20:06

whentheraincame · 15/08/2022 19:50

So are you able and willing to share the kinds of things that children can be removed for where parents love them, but are less obvious as violence or flying into tempers?

I would be really interested in shedding light as this is the area I'm dark on specifically.

Is it always risk of physical harm? Or something else?

In my experience the risk of emotional harm is the harder one.

Things like neglect are much less black and white. I know many cases where parents loved their children but couldnt give what they needed. Often its stability thats the issue, parents where they might be able to briefly stick to a clean house, but couldnt sustain it, or were completely erratic emotionally so there was no consistent care.

Children need sustained change. Being a parent is hard work, its constant and you need to be able to meet their needs every day.

I work in mental health so see sad cases where things like depression, addiction etc means that the parent cant get things together enough to reliably be up and about, engaging and providing things like decent meals or clean clothes even when they really want to.

Domestic violence is another one. Its such a tricky situation, it often takes multiple attempts to leave and multiple incidences. People who have been in that situation are more likely then to go into further poor relationships because their vulnerable. My heart goes out to women, but the children sometimes cant wait for the change to happen and cant go through that level of instability

Often people are vulnerable due to no fault of their own, eg learning disabilities, poor family support, and poor parenting themselves which mean they just arent properly equipped to know how to prioritse and build safe environments

LostForWordsagain · 15/08/2022 20:05

Neverfullycharged · 15/08/2022 20:00

It is tricky. I don’t think anyone would disagree there.

And of course SS can’t just swoop in and remove children, but to speak frankly here, they do have the power to present information in a certain way, which ultimately will make removal a distinct possibility.

The pro adoption lobby don’t tend to accept that children are sometimes wrongly removed, and the baby snatching tinfoil hat brigade don’t want to hear that removal is sometimes necessary - but there is a debate to be had somewhere in the middle, I feel.

I agree. Very often there are valid reasons for removal but also very often cases of clear abuse are totally missed then you have the cases where nothing is clear at all.

I have a feeling that there’s currently too much focus on emotional harm / future emotional harm / FII and they are casting the net wide to catch the few genuine cases of this and in the process catching a whole load of totally innocent families who have complex circumstances but no safeguarding issues but they end up on CP/losing their children.

The focus needs to shift back a bit and then maybe we would stop seeing in the news these awful cases of clear abuse and neglect where nothing was done

Tandora · 15/08/2022 20:04

Honestly I fail to see how it’s so bloody hard for them to get it right. If a child is being badly abused the evidence is there. No need for over zealous action, just basic competence. That term “adoptable” is abhorrent, it chills me to think of the contexts in which that is used

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 20:02

@Neverfullycharged yes absolutely. Sadly some people will get the extreme SWs - be it too heavy handed or too much kick to miss big red flags - and the children suffer either way, more than if someone normal comes along

AdelaideRo · 15/08/2022 20:02

I work in healthcare. I see a lot of families having tremendous support to keep their children at home and do the basics (school/ dentist/ doctor etc).

Sometimes I wonder if it really is in the children's best interests or if it is for the parents.

Neverfullycharged · 15/08/2022 20:00

It is tricky. I don’t think anyone would disagree there.

And of course SS can’t just swoop in and remove children, but to speak frankly here, they do have the power to present information in a certain way, which ultimately will make removal a distinct possibility.

The pro adoption lobby don’t tend to accept that children are sometimes wrongly removed, and the baby snatching tinfoil hat brigade don’t want to hear that removal is sometimes necessary - but there is a debate to be had somewhere in the middle, I feel.

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/08/2022 19:58

So are you able and willing to share the kinds of things that children can be removed for where parents love them, but are less obvious as violence or flying into tempers?

Your starting point is wrong I think. Parents can love their kids but neglect them, be emotionally abusive, physically abusive, they can struggle to care for children with complex needs etc. My two kids are adopted - I know their birth mother loved them. I also know her neglect of them, the impact of substance misuse in pregnancy and a whole range of other adverse experiences have left them with life long complex needs.

It’s not as simple as love=care, neglect/absurd=no care.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 19:57

gwenneh · 15/08/2022 19:50

This is very, very interesting to hear. It feels like there SHOULD be the same in place for adjacent family members...but is there?

I’m sure in the recent Panorama doc the parents who spoke had to get special permission to do so from the High Court

3WildOnes · 15/08/2022 19:56

I work within children's services, however, I am not a social worker. In my experience children aren't moved out of their family home quick enough and families are given far too many chances. It can be really tricky to call.

Emmelina · 15/08/2022 19:56

Everything @Mudblast said.

LostForWordsagain · 15/08/2022 19:51

User8273738273737 · 15/08/2022 19:48

@LostForWordsagain where do you take this information from, that children are preemptively removed from their families in case in the future there is emotional harm where there has been no harm/abuse to date?
References, case studies, law, policy, guidance, please. Not ‘my neighbour heard it happened to her cousin’s friend’

I can’t give any details as it would possibly be identifying and not ok but take a look at the ‘fiightback’ website - they support parents who have accusations of FII/future emotional harm.

Also the SW Cathie Long has recently produced guidance on this which is a very interesting read

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/08/2022 19:51

There's a great speaker who goes around telling her story of her dc being (she says rightly) removed and how she turned her life around and now can't get her dc back.

If a child is placed for adoption or on a permanence order there is no possibility of the child being returned, that’s the nature of permanence planning.

And local authorities spend many millions of pounds on providing support to parents before children are removed - some can’t make the changes needed at all, and some can’t get there quickly enough for their child.

The question I guess is how long do you think we should leave children at risk of significant harm before we intervene.

gwenneh · 15/08/2022 19:50

LostForWordsagain · 15/08/2022 19:48

The family courts have to protect the identities of the children so if parents reveal any details they can and have been jailed

This is very, very interesting to hear. It feels like there SHOULD be the same in place for adjacent family members...but is there?

whentheraincame · 15/08/2022 19:50

Jellycatspyjamas · 15/08/2022 19:32

SS are overzealous; remove children from loving homes (going to happen at times, right?)

I can count on one hand the number of children I’ve recommended be removed from homes where parents showed no love for their children. In most cases the parents do love their children very much, but cannot care for them safely. Often due to their own experiences of being parented, neglect, mental health, substance misuse, abuse, trauma, domestic abuse etc etc. The reality is that love simply isn’t enough in some cases for a parent to overcome their own hurdles (even with extensive support) and care adequately for their child.

So yes, social workers will recommend removal of children from loving homes where, for many reasons, the child is at risk of harm.

So are you able and willing to share the kinds of things that children can be removed for where parents love them, but are less obvious as violence or flying into tempers?

I would be really interested in shedding light as this is the area I'm dark on specifically.

Is it always risk of physical harm? Or something else?

OP posts:
LostForWordsagain · 15/08/2022 19:48

gwenneh · 15/08/2022 19:45

Parents can’t - if they make compliant a these are seen as ‘red flags’ and used against them and if they go to court they are gagged and cannot reveal any details of their case.

Interesting. I know of one case where they have a whole "SS stole my babies." website but maybe that's run by an adjacent family member and not the parent. So it's good to know parents can't reveal the details of their case.

The family courts have to protect the identities of the children so if parents reveal any details they can and have been jailed

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 19:48

Strawberries86 · 15/08/2022 19:37

The thing is op we don’t have a crystal ball. We are human. You might think it’s easy to tell a loving mother from an abusive one but the nastiest absusers, they are smart, they are believable and I have seen good parents so bad things which we work through. And Iv seen seemingly loving parents comment awful acts of abuse.

When we had SS involvement we kept getting told about what other people were like.

“Other people do this, that, lie, manipulate”.

I am not other people. No other profession would get by by limping all people into one personality type.

User8273738273737 · 15/08/2022 19:48

LostForWordsagain · 15/08/2022 19:37

A lot of children are now removed for ‘risk of future emotional harm’
In many of these cases there had been no harm to date and the type of ‘future harm’ wasn’t specified . It’s a vague and dangerous term and is unfortunately, misused and overused especially in families where the children have SEN or medical problems (leading professionals down the route of ‘perplexing presentations’ and patent blame rather than looking for the real cause which then leads to FII allegations)

@LostForWordsagain where do you take this information from, that children are preemptively removed from their families in case in the future there is emotional harm where there has been no harm/abuse to date?
References, case studies, law, policy, guidance, please. Not ‘my neighbour heard it happened to her cousin’s friend’

LilacSky95 · 15/08/2022 19:47

I saw that documentary

Fucking heartbreaking

IncessantNameChanger · 15/08/2022 19:46

Where I live childrens SC is so underfunded I cant image what the bar is to sustain their gaze. I have got to stage 3 of a complaint because my LGO do not believe they can discipline contract staff and they dont agree the legal responsibility lies with the LA. You could not make my situation up.

So God help these poor kids who need them. SW arent a bad bunch but they sure are underfunded. Like equipping a fireman with a watering can. But more than that the bosses do not care. Theres no outrage at the underfunding, just pushback to the parents telling them they should be grateful SC even exist