Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you even call it cheating?

283 replies

SlickShady · 15/08/2022 14:58

Inspired by another trending thread which I didn't want to derail, but actually it's not just that particular thread. How many times do people (usually women) complain their partner was cheating because they had sex outside of the marriage, yet they readily admit there was hardly or no sex within the marriage?

Can you really call that cheating?

I posit that cheating is only when you fulfil your side of the bargain but the other party doesn't. When one partner is always knackered or not in the mood, it's narcissistic to expect the other party just to do without. You can't even call it cheating if they find sex elsewhere.

Sure the favourite response is 'they have the option of leaving before cheating', but why is the onus of leaving on the partner who's deprived rather than the one depriving. Surely if one partner decides to hardly or never have sex anymore, it should be on them to leave.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 15/08/2022 16:40

I do think a sexless marriage is likely a dying one and there is frequently a head in the sand attitude to that on MN. A belief partners should just put up with it and women who don’t want sex shouldn’t feel like they have a bit of an obligation to try and change that if they want their marriage to last. Which I think is unrealistic and unreasonable.

But that doesn’t mean that seeking sex elsewhere isn’t cheating. A sexless marriage is not deceptive, it means both partners know what’s going on even if they don’t like it. Having an affair (or one night stands, or using prostitutes, etc) deceives your partner - that’s why it’s called cheating.

PeekAtYou · 15/08/2022 16:39

Yabu
if your reasoning was fair then part of the marriage vows would involve a promise to have sex at least once a week (or whatever)
In reality, life causes people's libido to vary. For example, if you've just had a bereavement or a baby, you may not feel like having sex. To fulfill a promise to have sex (say once a week) , you'd have to never be sick, never be apart longer than a week etc. I never want sex when I have my period so would need that as an exception to any sex obligation lol.

It's not unreasonable to want sex or not want sex. If you know that your partner has a wildly different libido then you can choose not to marry them, have an open marriage or remain single so you can have sex with lots of different people. If you're the partner with low libido then you should seek medical advice about whether it's something fixable as it sometimes is. If you're the person with a higher libido then it's worth looking into what you can do to help a partner be less stressed. For example if your partner does most of the childcare and housework, they are unlikely to feel as horny as someone whose partner does 50% of the childcare and housework.

Bretonbear · 15/08/2022 16:37

If you are not happy in your marriage tell the person you are married to. Then work a way through it. Do the person you're married to a favour and give them the option to get out - for all you know they feel the same as you.

SerenaVanDerWoodsenHumphrey · 15/08/2022 16:37

Well, Bro, it depends. Your post history sends out clear "I don't understand consent" vibes, but previous posters have already told you that.

But let's forget about you for the moment and talk about how we know if a relationship is or is not exclusive.

If you're in a genuinely open relationship where both parties are happy to have sex, romance, life commitment, etc. with others, then have at it - although of course there's no one size fits all so there are mutually agreed-upon boundaries and if you violate or lie, there's no excuse and your partner will dump you (or vice versa).

If you have some kind of explicet agreement with a partner about sexual fidelity then yes, it's "cheating" to break that agreement.

If you have an agreement with some kind of partner that you're "together" in some way but not sexually (or emotionally, romantically, or whatever) exclusive, then only the two of you know when or if someone has violated the line on that agreement.

If you're just casually having sex with someone and you happen to also be having it with other people, then use your common sense: does the other person know what you're doing? You're not required to tell all, but pick up a culturally specific clue: maybe in any ongoing relationship, it's good to talk and agree about these things.

If your partner's a woman and you're a man, there are a whole host of extra things that come into play like risk of pregnancy, variable vulnerability to sexually transmitted diseases, etc. that everyone involved should be considering. I'm sure you knew that, though.

DashboardConfessional · 15/08/2022 16:36

At least half of why I would kick my DH out for being intimate with another woman is the lying and betrayal in order to get the sex. If a man is lying and hiding the sex it's because he knows it's wrong to do so rather than initiate a split.

houseonthehill · 15/08/2022 16:34

Shag, not shaggy. DYAC.

houseonthehill · 15/08/2022 16:34

I always enjoy those stories where a man persuades a reluctant wife to open the marriage, because he has his eye on someone and thinks it's the way to shaggy them legitimately. Intended affair partner turns him down, but wife has a wild time tearing her way through a series of willing men.

PiecesofFive · 15/08/2022 16:32

Be very careful how you apply this wonderfu logic, you are on the cusp of losing your family, half your wealth and the chance to be called a good father.

By your logic, no sex means a free pass to go with another woman.
By the same logic, same horrible selfish man gets replaced by new man who is a much better father to his children, keeping the wife satified at home, in body and mind.

Quick sticks crack on so she can have a better life, I bet she can't wait, I bet she's wanted rid for ages.

You're a dud and she must be kicking herself for picking you.

RealBecca · 15/08/2022 16:31

Is this another installment of the incel threads this week

FloydPepper · 15/08/2022 16:31

SlickShady · 15/08/2022 15:00

Address the post not the poster.

Doesn’t matter if you’re a man or woman tbf

Yes still cheating, clearly so.

RealBecca · 15/08/2022 16:29

If the husband cheats because he isnt getting what he thinks is enough, can she cheat because there is another man who makes her feel special?

RealBecca · 15/08/2022 16:27

At least a strong friendship does 50% of the effort. I think the real question is why would someone want to shag you? (The general "you" notamed at OP. Are you doing your fair share, not just brining in a higher salary. Are you making cups of tea? Are you taking a load off and making things easier? Are you making your would-be lover feel special and relaxed and in the mood for sex?

Sounds rapey to want your lover to put out when they dont want it. Does anyone enjoy that sort of sex? I know if my DH wasnt in the mood and i was groping an unenthusiastic body it wouldn't do it for me. Would it do it for you?

houseonthehill · 15/08/2022 16:26

Sure, you can hold this view, although 'cheating' is probably the wrong word. As long as you are clear and open with your partner/spouse about your Very Clever Philosophy on sex and relationships and don't hide it... because why would you?

xogossipgirlxo · 15/08/2022 16:19

Well, it is cheating despite the background.

DarkShade · 15/08/2022 16:14

Hilarious OP, goadiest thread of the week I think. Assume you're in England and the school holidays are still in swing.

Yes obviosuly it's cheating. The person should leave. The "onus" is on them because the "onus" is on the person who is unhappy, not the person who is happy, obviously.

SleepingStandingUp · 15/08/2022 16:14

Ok, lets pretend you're right. I have an obligation to provide DH with sex and if i won't he's entitled to go elsewhere.

who decides how much? Say we settle on once a week and four times over the weekend, how do you re negotiate for say late pregnancy, an emergent medical need, post birth etc?

If we settle on a post birth number of 7 per fortnight, and i get flu what happens then? If I'm just not feeling it can i just lie there like a piece of meat whilst he fucks me or do I have to feign interest?
.
If we're averaging one day less oer week than agreed can he only cheat on me once a week or could he save them up over a month and then use them all together on one person or a few prostitutes?

InTheFridge · 15/08/2022 16:12

Oh wow.

Cheating is cheating whatever way you try and dress it up.

FOJN · 15/08/2022 16:11

I guees what I really want to tease out is the indignation.

Indignation? That's one way to trivialise the betrayal of infidelity.

Agree with PP you sound like a through and through misogynist regardless of whether you are male or female.

IReallyLikeCrows · 15/08/2022 16:08

Sometimes marriage is hard to differentiate from friendship, sex notwithstanding, because if you're not friends, if you don't have mutual respect and love, which one also has with the very closest of friends, then your marriage is only going one way. If you see sex as the only thing that makes a marriage different to a cohabiting friendship then, well, I don't know quite how your logic works but it's a bit fucked up.

Sex ebbs and flows throughout a long relationship, married or living together and mature adults understand this. Would it be cheating if a man decided that because his wife had just had a child and didn't want/really couldn't have sex for a period of months, then he was entitled to stick his dick in anyone who would have it? I mean seriously what on earth are you thinking?!

I know the thread you're talking about. There wasn't no sex, there was sex just not as often as he wanted, despite the fact that she also initiated sex ... at what point does one person's need for sex around the clock make another's lack of desire for that much sex become "fuck you, you don't give out on demand ergo I can have sex outside the marriage without telling you and it's not cheating because my logical process tells me that it's all about me and I can do what I want!" ?

If one partner wants more sex then it's a sit-down and talk about it situation. Funnily enough, that's what really holds a relationship together, the ability to communicate and not making every issue that comes up in the relationship to be all about you. I would hate to be your friend or your partner because you seem to have the most fucked up moral compass I've ever come across and I've known some real arseholes.

Hydrangeapetals · 15/08/2022 16:07

SlickShady · 15/08/2022 15:20

@MaybeIWillFuckOffThen

Thanks for your long reply. You're quite right that marriage isn't a promise of sex on demand or whatever, but marriage/cohabitation can be - at least partly - defined as a sexual relationship. Barring that aspect, it lacks one of the fundamentals of marriage.

I guees what I really want to tease out is the indignation. In so many cases you'll have one partner (usually the woman) admitting that she was rarely up to sex, yet she still feels betrayed and extremely hurt when she finds out her husband sought it elsewhere? Why? Surely you can't expect the other party to be celibate, much less so feel hurt if they sorted themselves out. Why do people feel, for lack of a better word, entitled to enforce celibacy on their partner?

I’m unsure why you think it’s usually the woman who decides the relationship will not include sex - multiple posts on here daily of women who have a male partner who doesn’t want sex. One Reddit sun dedicated to this topic is mostly women and there are several other ‘support’ places eg Facebook groups for women in this situation.

orbitalcrisis · 15/08/2022 16:04

I don't think that most humans were built for lifelong monogamy but I would still say yes, it is cheating.

When two people enter into a partnership they agree on certain rules. Those rules can change as the dynamics of the relationship change. If you want to make a change such as this, you talk it through and agree it with the other partner. It's not a partnership if you don't include the other partner.

It is not part of the marriage contract that you allow the other to have sex with you whenever they feel like it, but it is part of the contract that you only have sex with each other for the duration of the marriage.

PumpkinClementina · 15/08/2022 16:03

You've been listening to too much Andrew Tate OP.

Fladdermus · 15/08/2022 16:00
  • man obviously
PollyRockets · 15/08/2022 15:59

@Kashmirsilver there are many areas where you can claim an annulment

Not consummating the marriage is just one

Plus, key there it's possible, not enforced

Fladdermus · 15/08/2022 15:58

Tell me you're a man without saying you're a mam ...