Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you even call it cheating?

283 replies

SlickShady · 15/08/2022 14:58

Inspired by another trending thread which I didn't want to derail, but actually it's not just that particular thread. How many times do people (usually women) complain their partner was cheating because they had sex outside of the marriage, yet they readily admit there was hardly or no sex within the marriage?

Can you really call that cheating?

I posit that cheating is only when you fulfil your side of the bargain but the other party doesn't. When one partner is always knackered or not in the mood, it's narcissistic to expect the other party just to do without. You can't even call it cheating if they find sex elsewhere.

Sure the favourite response is 'they have the option of leaving before cheating', but why is the onus of leaving on the partner who's deprived rather than the one depriving. Surely if one partner decides to hardly or never have sex anymore, it should be on them to leave.

OP posts:
jadedspark · 15/08/2022 17:41

What? Of course it's cheating. If you're not happy in your relationship then you talk to your partner about it or you leave. I sympathise when kids are involved as it's much harder but it still doesn't give you a free pass to go and cheat.

Popcorncovered · 15/08/2022 17:35

1WomanWonder · 15/08/2022 16:48

Do you know what I like? Fudge. No idea how to make though. Presumably sugar and cream is involved. Any ideas?

There's a really good recipe on the Carnation condensed milk tins!
Although Carnation is made by Nestlé. How do you feel about that?

Tigerstigers · 15/08/2022 17:35

I think there is difference between a relationship with infrequent sex, or a dry patch, as opposed to a sexless marriage where both of you know it's not going to happen again, and one party has made that clear. Obviously a discussion should come first, but I can see why in those circumstances the person who does still want sex who has been told "no, never again" feels the need to find it elsewhere. No one should be forced to a life of celibacy. Yes, honesty is always best, and an open conversation about what eachother wants, in or outside the relationship is the best way to address this, but I can see why sometimes that isn't possible, and can totally understand why in those circumstances someone may look for sex outside of the marriage. If my husband and I stopped having sex in later life, and he still wanted it, I can't imagine us having an open conversation about it, but I would be happy to turn a blind eye to it if I thought he was fulfilling that need elsewhere, as I value his companionship, and our family life, I wouldn't want us to split over such an issue. I wouldn't consider it cheating. The only issue I could see with this arrangement is the potential for deeper feelings with an AP to arise

dworky · 15/08/2022 17:29

In the same way as when a woman wears revealing clothes, it's not rape 🙄
You should seek professional help.

DurhamDurham · 15/08/2022 17:24

Of course it's cheating @SlickShady
I'm amazed you had to ask.

PermanentlyTired03 · 15/08/2022 17:14

It's still cheating as you are with someone else. A sexless relationship is not a free pass to shag other people. Address it with your partner "I want more sex" my husband said it to me when sex died out after having a baby. Uncomfortable conversation but I'm glad we had it... I assume he didn't screw someone else in the meantime!

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 15/08/2022 17:09

I mean, if DH felt he wasn't getting enough sex at home, id expect a conversation about it first and foremost.

In fact, DH has admitted that he'd like us to have more sex but wanting it and actually fitting it in are different. We both work full time, have a child, have commitments, try and socialise, try and keep the house nice and tidy, try and exercise regularly blah blah blah. Regardless of if you can fit in sex every 2-3 days on top of all that, we both find it tough! At best we get once a week. If it was a genuine problem for DH, I'd expect an honest conversation from him and I'd work harder.

I would consider it cheating. 100%. Our relationship is built on trust and honesty. It breaks trust to run out and have sex outside of your marriage. It usually comes with a load of other lies and deceit. It's also very easy to develop feelings for someone you're having sex with. If he develops feelings for someone else then our relationship is over anyways.

queenMab99 · 15/08/2022 17:09

The point is, that whatever is happening needs to be known to both parties, otherwise it is cheating! If you both agree to go on a diet but one of you is secretly stuffing their face with chocolate, they are cheating. If you both agree to be faithful to each other, but one of you is shagging the next door neighbour, that is cheating. If, however one person says I need more sex than you are willing to share, I am going to do it with other people, then the other partner can choose to stay in the marriage or leave, because they are fully informed. What usually happens is the one who wants more sex, sneaks about telling lies about where they are, in order to shag other people, and that is cheating.

Eunorition · 15/08/2022 17:08

I mean, would anyone actually trash an otherwise good marriage, happy kids, good partnership, stable life, but then declare sex to be more important any of that, sell the house and send your kids to live in a mold ridden bedsit, wreck their mental health, destroy your once beloved spouse, tell the parents you just really need sex more than your family, and, what, start sitting in bars hoping someone's going to find your impulsiveness attractive?

People post 'no sex, end the marriage! divorce time! Sex is a duty! Have it even if you hate it! Have it if it hurts! Go to the doctor, those fountains of knowledge about gynecological matters, psychological distress, depression, domestic abuse and exhaustion! Fuck your spouse, fuck the kids, kick me out and get some sex, because that's all that matters' and it seems a bit, well... Over the top. You might end your marriage and still find no one wants to have sex with you.

SunnyD44 · 15/08/2022 17:06

Of course it’s cheating.

If someone is unhappy with the amount of sex then they need to communicate it with their partner and if things don’t change they need to leave and find someone more compatible.

In 90% of all situations like this the partner who is unhappy with the lack of sex is the one that has let themselves go, aren’t taking care of their hygiene or doing something that turns their partner off.

Purplecatshopaholic · 15/08/2022 17:03

Yes it’s cheating. The one doing the cheating may consider it more acceptable, ie they would argue they are only cheating because they aren’t getting it at home. But it’s still cheating..

erikbloodaxe · 15/08/2022 16:59

If a man/woman is feeling celibate within a marriage (and it hasn't been previously agreed upon) I'd suggest they were the ones not fulfilling their side of the 'bargain' somewhere within the marriage.

A supportive, kind, understanding partner who shoulders half of the responsibilities and half of the drudgery is going to having sex regularly with a willing spouse.

Not getting it? Look to yourself and your behaviour rather than this childish idea!

1WomanWonder · 15/08/2022 16:54

Or is that toffee? I much prefer fudge.

brookstar · 15/08/2022 16:52

Please explain where in the marriage vows there is a promise of a set amount of sex at a set regularity?

This.

If you have sex with someone who is not your husband/wife/partner without permission then it is cheating.

It's pretty straightforward

PetraBP · 15/08/2022 16:49

PS, why not just have a wank and think about your wife when you’re doing it?

EverythingHeadinSouth · 15/08/2022 16:49

Surely it's down to the other partner in the relationship to define? Otherwise we might as well ask thieves to decide when stealing might be excusable and to hell with the views of the victims.

For me cheating, in this context, is all about the lack of honesty and respect. My wife and I have barely had intercourse for eight years due to a combination of menopause tanking her libido and an operation to correct a prolapse making intercourse anything between uncomfortable and downright painful for her. Personally, I still have a strong sex drive but she doesn't so it is what it is. Not ideal for me but I would never ask her to open the marriage as I don't want anyone else and I know it would hurt her deeply. I sure as hell wouldn't go elsewhere behind her back and would not expect any sympathy or forgiveness if I did.

Onlyforcake · 15/08/2022 16:48

Cheats just don't have the emotional strength to get up and walk away for someone else BECAUSE they are only in any of their relationships for their OWN gain, anyone else's feelings matter not one shiny shit to them, never did, never will.

People in open/ negotiated relationships (real one's, not just where one partner has lost all boundaries and self esteem to hang on to something they never had) are continually dealing with emotions, realities and working at things.

PetraBP · 15/08/2022 16:48

I’m looking into my crystal ball… woooooo….

I see a man…

Feeling guilty…

Because his wife and he have different sex drives…

There’s a hint in his thinking that marriage somehow means entitlement or promise of sex… it doesn’t.

He is thinking that if he sleeps with someone else to satisfy his urges, it isn’t really cheating because she isn’t offering it anyway…

He wants to assuage his conscience by looking for female validation of his feelings here…

But alas, no…it’s cheating.

Woooooo…..the orb is dimming…..

InPraiseOfBacchus · 15/08/2022 16:48

My partner doesn't owe me sex. If they stop wanting it, they're not "withholding" or "depriving" because I'm not owed that act from them. They haven't done anything wrong to me, unless they decide to frame their decision as an attack, which is a different issue entirely.

My partner is not responsible for my needs. It's not "on them" to leave. If I'm not happy I have to figure out a way to respond to that - deliberately breaking a promise to them by cheating (with all the emotional and health risks associated with it) is not a good response.

OP, you think it's clever to use "I'm so objective" language to make a really bad argument, but it's not.

1WomanWonder · 15/08/2022 16:48

Do you know what I like? Fudge. No idea how to make though. Presumably sugar and cream is involved. Any ideas?

pinkfondu · 15/08/2022 16:45

SlickShady · 15/08/2022 14:58

Inspired by another trending thread which I didn't want to derail, but actually it's not just that particular thread. How many times do people (usually women) complain their partner was cheating because they had sex outside of the marriage, yet they readily admit there was hardly or no sex within the marriage?

Can you really call that cheating?

I posit that cheating is only when you fulfil your side of the bargain but the other party doesn't. When one partner is always knackered or not in the mood, it's narcissistic to expect the other party just to do without. You can't even call it cheating if they find sex elsewhere.

Sure the favourite response is 'they have the option of leaving before cheating', but why is the onus of leaving on the partner who's deprived rather than the one depriving. Surely if one partner decides to hardly or never have sex anymore, it should be on them to leave.

@SlickShady and the purpose of sex is to be enjoyable, if it's not enjoyable why would the other person do it. In your argument, tge women could go and sex elsewhere because she doesn't want the sex on offer as it's not enjoyable, or should she do it anyway?

JimmiChoux · 15/08/2022 16:44

ReluctantCourier · 15/08/2022 16:40

What does your editor think?

🤣

MaryBlighthouse · 15/08/2022 16:42

It’s cheating because you are lying to your partner and deceiving them. The clue is for in the name ‘cheat’ really.

it’s a valid argument that a relationship can become unsustainable if one partner no longer wants sex and the other does.

But if one partner believes that there is emotional and sexual monogamy ( whether or not sex takes place) whilst the other is secretly in a relationship with an affair partner, then yes, that is obviously cheating.

Eunorition · 15/08/2022 16:41

I suppose it depends why sex stopped. Perhaps the man became angry, aggressive, said cruel things, started throwing items and smashing things, then demanded sex. Maybe he is the cause of the libido loss. Then he cheats. And it's all her fault?

Sex is a privilege, not a right.

ReluctantCourier · 15/08/2022 16:40

What does your editor think?