Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you even call it cheating?

283 replies

SlickShady · 15/08/2022 14:58

Inspired by another trending thread which I didn't want to derail, but actually it's not just that particular thread. How many times do people (usually women) complain their partner was cheating because they had sex outside of the marriage, yet they readily admit there was hardly or no sex within the marriage?

Can you really call that cheating?

I posit that cheating is only when you fulfil your side of the bargain but the other party doesn't. When one partner is always knackered or not in the mood, it's narcissistic to expect the other party just to do without. You can't even call it cheating if they find sex elsewhere.

Sure the favourite response is 'they have the option of leaving before cheating', but why is the onus of leaving on the partner who's deprived rather than the one depriving. Surely if one partner decides to hardly or never have sex anymore, it should be on them to leave.

OP posts:
endofline · 19/08/2022 18:07

PiecesofFive · 19/08/2022 17:31

You are doing what every immature man child does in a relationship when he is not getting his own way.

Instead of trying to 'fix' things you are stubbornly digging your heels in and acting like you want to wreak vengance on your wife for daring to not to fawn over you, even though you may not deserve sex.

In other words we don't know how much of a twat you've been.

Whatever your motives for the contract changes to wish to implant, it will backfire, you are going to make things worse, but go ahead, you will end up with the marriage you deserve.

Hopefully your wife will get the finacial settlement she deserves and a new partner who does not blackmail her into sex and maybe even a lovely stepfather to your children, someone who doesn't play games, is mature and makes his wife dream about him through the day. Yes it's possible for her life to change immeasurably instead of being with someone who whines about lack of sex and hasn't a clue how to make a woman feel desired, safe and loved.

Grow up, but you won't.

Excellent post.

Except for the bit about us not knowing how much of a twat OP has been.

Its pretty clear he has been a total twat and it’s not at all surprising that his wife has gone off sex with a man with the attitude displayed in his posts.

PiecesofFive · 19/08/2022 18:02

Crikeyalmighty · 19/08/2022 17:48

If it's such a dealbreaker for you OP - why haven't you initiated divorce??

Because of the money, the house, the pension, the pot washing, the clothes washing, ironing, the childcare, the breakfast, tea and dinner, the house admin, the housekeeper, all that shit for nothing that goes on which you can't even begin to know what she does for you.

Not having to be grateful, respectful, kind or atentative to the woman who carried and gave birth to his children and put him and her family before everyone else.

Meanwhile he wants to shag other women, take your job and and your lack of emotional understanding and f off with some random vagina and say hello to being an absent father.

Write back on here when you're 70, tell us how it's gone.
Regrets.

HTH1 · 19/08/2022 17:54

No offence @SlickShady (who I’m guessing is a lawyer) but your attitude is likely to be proving quite a turn off for DW! Most women probably would dig their heels in if told it’s their job to sleep with you and failure to do so will result in their being blamed and cheated on. Have you really tried to make your marriage work and to keep the romance and doing your bit around the house, with the DC etc?

If not, perhaps the two of you are incompatible and it’s time to call it a day, even if that does mean sacrifices on your part.

Crikeyalmighty · 19/08/2022 17:48

If it's such a dealbreaker for you OP - why haven't you initiated divorce??

Blizzardbeach · 19/08/2022 17:38

SlickShady · 15/08/2022 14:58

Inspired by another trending thread which I didn't want to derail, but actually it's not just that particular thread. How many times do people (usually women) complain their partner was cheating because they had sex outside of the marriage, yet they readily admit there was hardly or no sex within the marriage?

Can you really call that cheating?

I posit that cheating is only when you fulfil your side of the bargain but the other party doesn't. When one partner is always knackered or not in the mood, it's narcissistic to expect the other party just to do without. You can't even call it cheating if they find sex elsewhere.

Sure the favourite response is 'they have the option of leaving before cheating', but why is the onus of leaving on the partner who's deprived rather than the one depriving. Surely if one partner decides to hardly or never have sex anymore, it should be on them to leave.

TBH I'd say it's more narcissistic if one partner doesn't want sex because they are leavened after being the default parent, default cleaner, default cook who still goes to work then is cheated on.

I think that the relationship getting to the state where one is doing everything is the problem, then instead of the problem being worked on, one strays.

That seems completely narcissistic to me.

And no, that's not my excuse to not fuck my husband

PiecesofFive · 19/08/2022 17:31

You are doing what every immature man child does in a relationship when he is not getting his own way.

Instead of trying to 'fix' things you are stubbornly digging your heels in and acting like you want to wreak vengance on your wife for daring to not to fawn over you, even though you may not deserve sex.

In other words we don't know how much of a twat you've been.

Whatever your motives for the contract changes to wish to implant, it will backfire, you are going to make things worse, but go ahead, you will end up with the marriage you deserve.

Hopefully your wife will get the finacial settlement she deserves and a new partner who does not blackmail her into sex and maybe even a lovely stepfather to your children, someone who doesn't play games, is mature and makes his wife dream about him through the day. Yes it's possible for her life to change immeasurably instead of being with someone who whines about lack of sex and hasn't a clue how to make a woman feel desired, safe and loved.

Grow up, but you won't.

Blossomtoes · 19/08/2022 17:20

I really wish I hadn’t opened this thread, it’s beyond awful.

PiecesofFive · 19/08/2022 17:16

From the POV of the cheating partner is where it gets more complex. The
simplistic view, which seems to be the predominant one here, is that
they should first leave the relationship before pursuing sex elsewhere.
And I don't necessarily disagree with that, but I think it's more
complex and nuanced. After all this partner isn't the one who
unilaterally changed the situation, so why should they be the one to
suffer?

At a guess I would say your wife is suffering in some way at the moment.
Very rarely do women not have sex just "because', there is always a reason and it sounds as though you don't really want to get to the bottom of why she doesn't.

Have you actually asked her why she no longer feels safe to have sex with you anymore?
And have you told her about your views on this subject and your view that you are going to be actively looking for sex outside the marriage or is that only for us to hear.

You say you did nothing to change the situation and you are suffering, do you really believe that between two people in a marriage that you have not contributed to this change in your wife.

ThePants999 · 19/08/2022 17:12

@SlickShady

Your thread is titled "Can you even call it cheating?", and you put this in your OP:

"I posit that cheating is only when you fulfil your side of the bargain but the other party doesn't."

And this:

You can't even call it cheating if they find sex elsewhere.

So yes, it absolutely was about "the technical definition of the word 'cheating'". If you now want to move the discussion on and talk about whether cheating is morally acceptable in certain circumstances, fine, but that's best done in conjunction with an admission that the original question was misphrased so that people don't get hung up on it.

SlickShady · 19/08/2022 17:12

Nobody is owed sex and cheating is never justifiable.

But nobody is owed fidelity either.

Oh you mean the agreement, implicit and explicit, when the couple decided to become a thing? Well that was an implicit agreement that both parties take care of their OH's needs, be they emotional, physical, financial etc.

OP posts:
pointythings · 19/08/2022 17:05

I mean even if PIV is out, there can be all the rest, cuddling, kissing, even culminating with oral or a handjob. Surely that makes all the difference.

@SlickShady you really do think women are there to service men sexually no matter what, don't you? Following a traumatic birth, why should a woman in pain service a man when there's nothing in it for her? Why can't the man give her time to recover? It's truly tragic that you see relationships in this way. Nobody is owed sex and cheating is never justifiable.

SlickShady · 19/08/2022 16:58

HappinesDependsOnYou · 18/08/2022 20:55

I do consider it cheating as they really having sex with someone else when in a committed relationship. I think if there are issues where someone is withholding sex then communication can resolve that. I with-held sex after feeling a lot of pain following giving birth to our child. It took a while to resolve and I didn't reveal the full extent of the issue as didn't want my husband to feel horrendous for the pain it was causing me. I should have spoken up but I didn't. He had an affair and I was devastated. Do you think I had no right to feel that way because I withheld sex due to it hurting? Both partners should be prepared to discuss the issue rather then having their cake and eating it through an affair. It's cruel it hurts, it destroys the trust and the betrayed partner. Any sex outside of a relationship is cheating regardless of whether sex is an active part of that relationship.

Look while I'm very sympathetic with your pain, you can't blame the lack of communication just on your husband. You withheld sex. Did you communicate the problem or did you leave him to feel rejected? Also, and sorry for being blunt, did you attempt to accommodate him in any other way? I mean even if PIV is out, there can be all the rest, cuddling, kissing, even culminating with oral or a handjob. Surely that makes all the difference.

To answer your question:
Do you think I had no right to feel that way because I withheld sex due to it hurting?

It depends. If you just rejected him, no explanation, empathy etc, and made him feel worthless and rejected, then no you have no right to feel that way. But if you were communicative and accommodating yet he still cheated, then obviously he was totally out of order.

OP posts:
SlickShady · 19/08/2022 16:51

@ThePants999

I haven't changed the premise as it was always two-pronged. And my question was never about the technical definition of the word 'cheating', but rather the moral implications thereof.

In a situation where one partner has stopped being intimate with the other, then from the POV of the partner being cheated on, I don't think they have any right to the moral high ground. And I fail to see how they can be outraged that the other partner got it elsewhere, when it was their own fault that partner couldn't get it within the marriage. In fact I'd posit that was appears as moral outrage is just bitterness at having lost the power.

From the POV of the cheating partner is where it gets more complex. The simplistic view, which seems to be the predominant one here, is that they should first leave the relationship before pursuing sex elsewhere. And I don't necessarily disagree with that, but I think it's more complex and nuanced. After all this partner isn't the one who unilaterally changed the situation, so why should they be the one to suffer?

Imagine uprooting your life and moving across the country to work for a company with a promise of a long-term job, and 18 months later they change the entire nature of your work. Yes you can leave, but to what? You've made major changes in your life for this job and perhaps given up many things, so now what?

Leaving a marriage isn't something you just do willy-nilly, and it comes with much stress and financial costs. Not to mention minimum 50% restrictions in seeing your kids. So the choice of leaving isn't really a choice, and men/fathers are just as much trapped within the marriage as women.

As to those who have a problem with me seeing marriage as transactional, hello, every relationship is transactional. Why are you together with your other half? Because you love them? Unconditionally? Are you saying if they stopped providing for your needs (whichever ones you have met in the relationship, emotional, financial or whatever), you would continue to love and care for them just like before?

I'm not talking if the OH became incapacitated or ill, but just because they can't be bothered. Is anyone seriously saying they would still be loving and giving, because after all it's not transactional?

Marriage is loving and giving, but of course there is also an expectation of reciprocity.

OP posts:
SlickShady · 19/08/2022 16:31

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 18/08/2022 19:40

I’m not comfortable with the OP’s term of having to go “crawling” to his/her partner to raise the subject. This is a very immature attitude and immediately implies huge cracks in the foundation of the relationship if that’s how he/she feels about communicating an issue with his/her partner

Indeed. OP clearly feels it is beneath his dignity to actually raise the issue with his partner as from his POV there is nothing to discuss - she is the faulty appliance that has ceased to function and thus it is entirely on her to sort it out spontaneously, otherwise he's well within his rights to start using the sexual equivalent of the launderette 🙄

For argument's sake let's say that the hypothetical situation from the OP is my real life story. Well perhaps I do feel some resentment that my wife has just stopped having sex because 'she's fine without'. That's quite natural.

OP posts:
Hira3 · 19/08/2022 10:11

Peanutbuttericecream1 · 15/08/2022 15:10

As soon as I read it I thought:
this is a man

"fulfill your side of the bargain" ewwww marriage is not a transaction you douchebag

I agree its a hairy hand for sure.

shreddednips · 19/08/2022 09:27

'Fulfilling your side of the bargain' is a really gross way of putting it. I'm generalising, but most of the women I know well enough to have these conversations with (including me) enjoy sex and want to have it- with someone who treats us with respect and dignity, cares about our pleasure, doesn't leave the lion's share of the child rearing and housework to us, etc etc. If the sex has waned, there's often a reason for it- medical or because the relationship isn't secure or loving outside the bedroom. The talk of 'bargains' doesn't make me think loving, mutually-pleasurable sex. It sounds like the spouses are expected to service each other. That's not sexy.

If it really is the case that either party just doesn't want to have sex any more simply because they don't want to, then there needs to be a conversation and a decision reached about whether to stay married/open it up etc. As for the 'it's too expensive/unfair/annoying to get divorced' argument- that's the risk you run when you enter into any relationship. It might not last forever, especially if one partner decides to cheat instead of 'crawling' to the other to discuss a problem in the marriage that could potentially be solved with some good communication.

Popcorncovered · 19/08/2022 08:22

FunnyBeaux · 18/08/2022 22:38

He had an affair and I was devastated.

I'd love to actually explore this. Why were you devastated? I mean you knew you were withholding sex, so why did it bother you if your husband got it elsewhere?

She was in a lot of pain after giving to their child! There's isn't anything to "explore"

vivainsomnia · 19/08/2022 08:22

Your argument is very black and white and fail to take into consideration the reasons why sex might not be on the cards any longer. Most importantly, you fail to consider that although sex is indeed an expectation of marriage, so is respect, honesty, and more importantly, caring.

There are various reasons why a woman or a man might not want sex any longer. Some might be selfish, IE. never enjoyed it but pretended just to have the kids, but for many, it is an expression of frustration.

If the marriage is strong and happy but for the issue of intimacy, surely the respectful way forward is to work together to understand and tackle the reason, not to just act like a kid who doesn't get what they want so go elsewhere for it.

There are two scenarios most often. The marriage is deep down down but neither want to admit it because neither want to face the consequences of divorce so the marriage continue on pretence but cheating still feels like a betrayal. These couples really need to accept the marriage is dead and move on.

Then there are those who still love each other but communication has broken down and is being replaced by frustration on both sides and instead of finding ways to learn to communicate again, focus on satisfying their frustrations.

kateandme · 19/08/2022 07:37

But is wife was handed over to him by her father! He must be outraged.

KittensWearingWoollyMittens · 18/08/2022 23:07

Well, given that one of the 5 legal grounds for divorce in the UK is adultery, I think you are being ridiculous, but I think you know that. You can't divorce someone for "enforced celibacy" as you so charmingly put it 🙄

FunnyBeaux · 18/08/2022 22:40

The function of sex I to make babies and provide conditions optimal to their rearing.

For animals maybe but not for humans. Intimacy for pleasure and emotional connection is intrinsic to human relationships.

FunnyBeaux · 18/08/2022 22:38

He had an affair and I was devastated.

I'd love to actually explore this. Why were you devastated? I mean you knew you were withholding sex, so why did it bother you if your husband got it elsewhere?

HappinesDependsOnYou · 18/08/2022 20:55

I do consider it cheating as they really having sex with someone else when in a committed relationship. I think if there are issues where someone is withholding sex then communication can resolve that. I with-held sex after feeling a lot of pain following giving birth to our child. It took a while to resolve and I didn't reveal the full extent of the issue as didn't want my husband to feel horrendous for the pain it was causing me. I should have spoken up but I didn't. He had an affair and I was devastated. Do you think I had no right to feel that way because I withheld sex due to it hurting? Both partners should be prepared to discuss the issue rather then having their cake and eating it through an affair. It's cruel it hurts, it destroys the trust and the betrayed partner. Any sex outside of a relationship is cheating regardless of whether sex is an active part of that relationship.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 18/08/2022 19:48

Reading the posts people misunderstand the concept of sex and its function

The function of sex I to make babies and provide conditions optimal to their rearing. Nothing more. Beyond that it means whatever it means to the two people involved - BOTH of them. So for the type of men who use it as a surrogate for almost everything else - leisure activity, physical release, emotional connection and expression, personal validation - going without it can I'm sure feel very physically and emotionally distressing. However. That does not make the woman in their life obliged to carry the entire weight of that man's extensive needs, which have all been bundled up in this one need for sex, on the back of her own sexuality. Which is apparently what marriage is according to the OP.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 18/08/2022 19:40

I’m not comfortable with the OP’s term of having to go “crawling” to his/her partner to raise the subject. This is a very immature attitude and immediately implies huge cracks in the foundation of the relationship if that’s how he/she feels about communicating an issue with his/her partner

Indeed. OP clearly feels it is beneath his dignity to actually raise the issue with his partner as from his POV there is nothing to discuss - she is the faulty appliance that has ceased to function and thus it is entirely on her to sort it out spontaneously, otherwise he's well within his rights to start using the sexual equivalent of the launderette 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread