Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP accusing me of health anxiety

63 replies

veniceorna · 15/08/2022 14:42

I went to see my Gp today - lump in breast. I've had a lump before but that was 2 years ago and a blocked milk duct. This one hasn't gone and it's been around for a few weeks. I thought the sensible thing was to get checked out

He agrees there's a hard lump as has referred me to breast clinic. Then, he said to me 'do you think you worry about your health? And probably look for things a lot that probably aren't really there?'

I said no... but I do get anything that needs looking at, looked at. As that's the general advice. He said 'yes but you have had a lot going on, are you sure you aren't looking for things?'

I wasn't sure how to reply so jusr said 'I don't think so'

In the last year I've had my gallbladder removed because of gallstones, (medically proven as seen), and investigations of my cervix due to heavy and irregular bleeding (again, proven as GP saw himself)

I also had a prolapse of the bowel sorted by surgery 18 months ago.

AIBU to think it's a bit unfair to ask me if I'm looking for things? Confused they aren't in my head. Hence the bloody surgeries and medical evidence

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Starlightunicorn · 15/08/2022 19:26

I worked in a GP setting for 4 years and left only recently from what you have said you are not 'looking for health problems' if it's proven, and you definitely don't come across as I'd you have health anxiety although lots of people are suffering with it after COVID. We had one lady who did (one out of 6.5k patients) and you could hear it in her tone and the things she said and if she didn't get a call back asap she'd be back on the phone multiple times that day.
There are actual indicators of this and having proven health issues which need referring etc. This is not health anxiety, don't stop getting these things checked out because the Dr is making you feel like a nuisance, put it in writing to the practice manager or better still to NHS England (assuming you're in England!)

dizzydizzydizzy · 15/08/2022 19:11

I'm kind of the opposite. My lovely and kind GP recognized anxiety the first time she met me, but didn't press the issue. She eventually gently suggested I read up about anti anxiety drugs. It actually took months for me to accept she was right.

OP, I think the fact that you saw a locum says it all. Most locums are not that good - if they were, they would have permanent jobs. There are exceptions of course.

QOD · 15/08/2022 19:07

you know what, i feel like you because i have had so many operations.... my MIL had genuinely diagnosed Munchausen's, not by proxy, it was her that was "ill" for 40 years but there was never a need for surgery or anything on scans etc
I go and like you, there's a problem - i have a scan, there it is, have surgery - all good.
But people "joke" that I have a problem
(i do ... it's a decrepit body)

ShitPuffin · 15/08/2022 18:57

Lennybenny · 15/08/2022 18:48

Tbf my ex has persuaded many GPs he needs surgeries and has lots of medical issues.
Perhaps the gp is just saying you contact them a lot in between the other issues.

I don’t see how anyone can persuade a gp or specialist they need surgery or have a diagnosable chronic condition! To suggest so is ridiculous, frankly.

Lovesplasticstraws · 15/08/2022 18:55

@DeclineandFall this resonates with me. I had a tosser GP locum even suggest I look up a condition on the NHS website for "self care". I did and it said go in.

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 15/08/2022 18:51

Same with opticians actually. I have high myopia, moderate astigmatism, myopic discs with peripapillary atrophy, and am at risk of retinal detachment and unrelatedly of retinopathy, for which I have screening. I'm also prone to false high readings on non-contact tonometry. In other words I got eye shit going on. Eye records don't always get passed on because it's private, so when I've been told stuff about my eyes, I pass that on to the professionals examining me using the terminology that was used by the other professional, to make sure I'm not communicating it wrong (except maybe I'd say "very short-sighted" rather than "high myopia", or just not mention it because it's obvious, and maybe talk about eye pressure rather than tonometry).

I'd say about a quarter of the time, I get asked if I have a medical background. Just for using words like retinopathy, which is written at the top of my screening letter every year, or for mentioning my myopic discs if they comment on the way the back of my eye looks.

Lennybenny · 15/08/2022 18:48

Tbf my ex has persuaded many GPs he needs surgeries and has lots of medical issues.
Perhaps the gp is just saying you contact them a lot in between the other issues.

PurpleFlower1983 · 15/08/2022 18:43

I’m not a complainer but I would complain about this, this is why so many are reluctant to go to the GP.

ShitPuffin · 15/08/2022 18:39

This really pisses me off.

Having multiple confirmed health conditions - or confirmed causes for investigation - is so obviously not indicative of hypochondria or anxiety!

I’ve often been made to feel like this by doctors as I’ve had a shit ton of issues…but they’ve all been confirmed by specialists and some have required surgery!

Please complain, OP. I always think of the vulnerable, timid folks who would lack the confidence to advocate for themselves - and be reluctant to seek treatment again - if they’d been made to feel this way.

Nellynoo182 · 15/08/2022 18:38

You should buy him Kris Hallenga’s new book ‘Glittering a Turd’!

ClumpingBambooIsALie · 15/08/2022 18:34

@DeclineandFall Medical types often seem to think that we're not allowed to know the words that they know.

I took a relative's pets to the vet a while back, and the vet explained to me that their gums were sore and red because of germs getting in — I said something like "They've got gingivitis?" because it would be easier for me to pass on a single word rather than a long detailed description, and the vet responded, "Yes, that's right! You have a medical background, do you?" Not in a hostile way, just surprised, like I couldn't possibly know technical terminology like gingivitis unless I'd been to university for it Confused I mean, I could've said "gum disease" I suppose, but gingivitis is a normal word for me and was what came to mind.

rarelyontime · 15/08/2022 18:34

Not the same issue, but I had a GP with a very similar bedside manner. I never made a complaint about him because I didn't have the headspace to deal with him at the time, and I've always regretted it. If you're able to, complain.

He clearly thinks it's worthy of investigation, or he wouldn't have sent you to the breast clinic.

You haven't been to the GP with problems that aren't there; you've been there with real problems. The man is a complete tosser and should be reported before he indirectly kills other women by convincing them to stay at home next time they spot something problematic that would be treatable if caught in time.

When I was younger, it didn't bother me whether I was seen by a male or female doctor. Now that I'm old, I would much prefer to be seen by a female doctor because she's less likely to think any serious women's issues are imaginary.

DeclineandFall · 15/08/2022 18:27

I wonder is it a thing they have been trained on recently. I took my DS (13) to the GP as he has classic
migraines.

He asked my son about them and my son said the word aura and kaleidoscope in describing them. The GP accused him of using technical language he had got from the internet and said it was health anxiety. I had to v robustly point out both me and my husband had migraines we were treated for and that as my son had been to the GP a sum total of 3 times in his life, the last being 6 years ago it was hardly likely he had health anxiety.

I thought it was because I was a N Irish female and people tend to think that I'm a bit thick and my child wouldnt know big medical words. Never occurred to me it was some sort of new GP training. Complain OP.

FlorettaB · 15/08/2022 18:16

’Health anxiety is a real thing … None of those symptoms manifest themselves as fucking hard breast lumps, gallstones, prolapses or random gushing blood. What a twat.’

^ That

FancyFelix · 15/08/2022 18:16

Essexgalttc · 15/08/2022 14:48

I do not want people to think I’m talking about every GP but from mine and my friends experience it seems like “mental health” “health anxiety” are comments that our GP’s make if we go in for an appointment.

I would completely understand if you had been to quite a few appointments regularly with health concerns and they never found anything wrong and he asked that question but the fact that you have genuine reasons to see him and also found a hard lump in your breast for him to ask this I think is awful

100% this. I wonder how many men they accuse of anxiety

badgerybadgerboo · 15/08/2022 18:15

Well I am going to diagnose him with pantronisingtwatitis.

YANBU op.

My male GP is also like this. I requested to change GPs and they turned me down. He's an absolute asswit who is well known locally for dismissing actual issues as "just a virus" - including symptoms of MS which he failed to spot.

comfortablyfrumpy · 15/08/2022 18:14

I would flag this up with the Practice Manager.

If this Dr is a locum, they need to know he isn't doing their practice's reputation any favours!

He sounds patronising and misogynistic.

I hope your lump turns out to be nothing
.

Clovacloud · 15/08/2022 18:14

Change GP, and let the practice manager know exactly why you are changing. Ones like that do not take women’s health seriously. My Mum’s best friend had secondary breast cancer in her bones, and was told it was ‘stress, because her husband was depressed’. The fact she couldn’t lie down and could barely sit because of the pain was all in head according to him. Some GP’s are misogynistic twats.

JustLyra · 15/08/2022 18:13

women are routinely patronised and have their conditions down-played by HCP’s. It’s ridiculous.

I had a similar situation last year when I had a run of ill health (gallstones, chest infection that wouldn’t shift, then ended up with appendicitis). When I ended up with an infection post having my appendix out the Dr said that I “couldn’t have antibiotics every five minutes, or a constant stream of appointments as other patients need seen”.

Unfortunately for him I was in the kind of mood to take no shit so asked which of the recent things I should have ignored exactly.

i ended up with a written apology and I don’t get appointments with him any more. If he puts people off seeking help when they’re ill he’ll cause someone to end up in hospital, or worse.

RainyDays22 · 15/08/2022 18:09

Sounds like a typical arsehole GP.

I have had this my entire life. They couldn't find anything wrong.... until I was diagnosed with Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome in my 30s by a GP who actually took the time to read my entire NHS medical record.
Suddenly everything made sense and the GP apologised to me for me being treated so damn badly over the years.

Don't let it put you off. Some GPs are just there to be paid, they don't care about their actual job.

lunar1 · 15/08/2022 18:06

He sounds like an asshole, aren't we supposed to be looking for breast lumps ffs.

Violinist64 · 15/08/2022 18:03

It isn’t only male gps. A few months ago, I had very bad earache - it was so bad that l could only keep my head upright. I felt a lump behind my ear and was worried that it might be acute mastoiditis as l have had mastoid problems and operations several times over my lifetime on my other ear. I am having a procedure done on this one tomorrow. I saw a female gp that I had never seen before. She was extremely dismissive,, pooh-poohing my concerns and spoke in a very patronising manner. I am not a doctor myself and know very little about most ailments and their symptoms but I would guess that I knew rather more about my ears because of a lifetime’s experience than she did as it is a specialised area that is not generally treated by a gp. Gps, by the title, are general practitioners and know a certain amount about a lot of conditions without a great amount of depth about most of them, which is why the specialists are there. My normal gp, whom I normally see, defers to this and says that he will leave it to the experts but prescribe antibiotics/ear drops to tackle the immediate problem. To be fair, she did grudgingly prescribe me these but left me feeling far worse than when l arrived. There are some brilliant gps around but a growing number need to attend to and improve their bedside manner.

Runningintolife · 15/08/2022 18:01

I swear I have health anxiety written in large letters on my notes since gp couldn't find anything when I felt loads of pressure and thought incorrectly I had had a prolapse - they could not find anything because it was a huge fibroid that wasn't pressing once I lay down. A monster according to the consultant who did my hysterectomy when it was correctly diagnosed. Yanbu OP, and I treat health anxiety.

veniceorna · 15/08/2022 17:45

OP, Given that he was a locus

Brilliant typo Grin

OP posts:
poetryandwine · 15/08/2022 17:26

OP,

Given that he was a locus, I would definitely report this to the Practice Manager or partners, in a factual manner. My only question for you first is whether there is a back story of other concerns that did not lead onwards that you've not mentioned? Just trying to help you think everything through ahead of time.

But the main point is that, absent loads of other concerns that were, justifiably, not progressed, this guy is raising the possibility of health anxiety based on the fact that you've been raising serious, objectively validated concerns. That is wrong of him and people need to know.

Swipe left for the next trending thread