Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my SIL insensitive or deliberately spiteful?

134 replies

MissEDashwood19 · 15/08/2022 13:12

I have DC after over two years of infertility, a major surgery and subsequent IVF. I'm now pregnant again (with a frozen embryo).

We were very distressed dealing with infertility and shared our experiences and feelings very openly with our family.

Once our DC was born, my SIL showed no interest in said child and deliberately went out of her way to ignore the child at family events - even as child became a toddler and would go up and speak to her, saying "Aunty, hello Aunty". I would then distract child and tell DC that Aunty was busy, but never made a big deal of it.

I wondered if this was because SIL was going through something and never forced our DC on her or brought up her total lack of interest, bordering on being unkind to our DC.

I became pregnant again and SIL never acknowledged the pregnancy at all. No word of congratulations to either my DH or me, absolute silence. We live very near one another, so plenty of opportunity to say something in person too.

She became pregnant a couple of months after me, my MIL (with SIL's permission) shared the news with the family and I tried to ring SIL (she didn't pick up) so sent her a heartfelt congratulatory message which she did acknowledge.

When she next saw me in person she went out of her way to tell me she had conceived immediately with no issues and that she wouldn't be having any unnecessary tests or interventions like some women (I did the NIPT test and had an epidural with my first - both of which she knows).

The whole conversation deeply upset me. My husband said I'm being oversensitive and my best friend (the only other person I mentioned it to) thinks the comments were deliberate and spiteful. How should I handle this moving forward?

YABU - You're oversensitive
YANBU - Comments were deliberately unkind

OP posts:
Peanutbuttericecream1 · 15/08/2022 13:49

Ps: my SIL sounds just like yours. What winds her up no end is when we (DH and I) spend time alone with PIL. She flips out whining and complaining why she is being excluded even though she is 42 and get 95% of PILs attention.
we are unable to arrange a simple lunch or dinner with PIL without SIL having tantrums.
Suggest you try this. It gave me such a warm fuzzy feeling inside knowing SIL is flying off the rails when we (DH and I) attempt nurture individual relationship with PILs.

RandomMess · 15/08/2022 13:47

From your updates she's jealous.

MissEDashwood19 · 15/08/2022 13:47

whynotwhatknot · 15/08/2022 13:40

sounds like a bitch delibratly ignoreing her niece-thats jut downright nasty

does your dh also think thats ok

My DH was very hurt by it and thought it might be because something was going on with his sister, like her DP didn't want kids.

SIL is in her late thirties and a fair bit older than DH and me, so my DH has also suggested she might be annoyed he had a child before her.

DH asked SIL to be DC's Godmother over my head as he desperately wanted SIL to show an interest as she generally likes children, just not ours!

OP posts:
drpet49 · 15/08/2022 13:46

“OP why are you going out of your way to be 'kind ' to someone who ignores you and your child ?
Have a real think about that.... anyone who ignores a young child,deliberately, is a nasty piece of work.”

^This.

MumChats · 15/08/2022 13:44

What a cow! YANBU. IMO your best way forward is to just disengage, have as little to do with her as possible and be civil and on friendly terms whilst mentally dismissing everything she does and says.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/08/2022 13:43

I've just read your update that she is a teacher...what does your husband think about her ignoring your child?

badgerstink · 15/08/2022 13:42

Sounds like she didn't like not being the centre of attention, possibly with her parents if they were doting on new DGC.

Be prepared for the new baby to be the most advanced, gifted child to ever walk gods green earth. I'd suggest you start preparing your non-plussed responses to her now as you'll be subjected to comparisons for years.

JenniferBarkley · 15/08/2022 13:42

Whatever the underlying cause, you won't get anywhere here. Be polite when you happen to see her, and give her absolutely zero headspace otherwise, for your own sake.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 15/08/2022 13:41

I say you watch and smile.

She'll be one of those people who loudly judge mums and come out with the "my child won't do that when I have them..." having no real idea about babies and toddlers...

Hankunamatata · 15/08/2022 13:41

Who's the oldest out of sil and dh?

whynotwhatknot · 15/08/2022 13:40

sounds like a bitch delibratly ignoreing her niece-thats jut downright nasty

does your dh also think thats ok

Yorkshirepuddingwithsyrupnotgravy · 15/08/2022 13:39

She's the golden child of her parents (they pay for her house and horses), but you and your DH have given them their first DGC. She's simply jealous. Expect her to demand more of GPs time than your DC have once her child is born

TrashPandas · 15/08/2022 13:38

How should I handle this moving forward?

Do you need to do anything? It doesn't sound like you see her much, and she mostly ignores you, so at family events or whatever just exchange polite small talk and then move away.

CourtneeLuv · 15/08/2022 13:37

MissEDashwood19 · 15/08/2022 13:12

I have DC after over two years of infertility, a major surgery and subsequent IVF. I'm now pregnant again (with a frozen embryo).

We were very distressed dealing with infertility and shared our experiences and feelings very openly with our family.

Once our DC was born, my SIL showed no interest in said child and deliberately went out of her way to ignore the child at family events - even as child became a toddler and would go up and speak to her, saying "Aunty, hello Aunty". I would then distract child and tell DC that Aunty was busy, but never made a big deal of it.

I wondered if this was because SIL was going through something and never forced our DC on her or brought up her total lack of interest, bordering on being unkind to our DC.

I became pregnant again and SIL never acknowledged the pregnancy at all. No word of congratulations to either my DH or me, absolute silence. We live very near one another, so plenty of opportunity to say something in person too.

She became pregnant a couple of months after me, my MIL (with SIL's permission) shared the news with the family and I tried to ring SIL (she didn't pick up) so sent her a heartfelt congratulatory message which she did acknowledge.

When she next saw me in person she went out of her way to tell me she had conceived immediately with no issues and that she wouldn't be having any unnecessary tests or interventions like some women (I did the NIPT test and had an epidural with my first - both of which she knows).

The whole conversation deeply upset me. My husband said I'm being oversensitive and my best friend (the only other person I mentioned it to) thinks the comments were deliberate and spiteful. How should I handle this moving forward?

YABU - You're oversensitive
YANBU - Comments were deliberately unkind

I'd cut her off. She's laid the battle lines. Fuck her.

Peanutbuttericecream1 · 15/08/2022 13:36

I have many issues with my SIL and in-laws in general. Whenever I have posted on MN for advice or help, concensus has been to keep them at arms length. Therefore I suggest what has been suggested to me. Do the bare minimum Xmas, Easter and one birthday. Protect DC from rejection and expose her to family members that show her love. Lead by example, your DC should not expose themselves to people that persistantly reject them. It will lead to the wrong sort of relationships in adult life.

MissEDashwood19 · 15/08/2022 13:36

Putonyourshoes · 15/08/2022 13:20

I think the lack of interest in your children and the conversation you had the first time you saw her after her pregnancy announced are separate issues.

The first, although you could have found it hurtful, I think you should let go. Some people have no interest in babies/children until they become mothers themselves. And even then some only really care about their own children. Ignoring your DC for example could be down to simply not really knowing how to interact with them. My SIL is similar with other’s children but is a great Mum herself, it just doesn’t come naturally to her to be around children.

The latter, is insensitive, yes. Commenting on how fast and easily you conceived to someone you know had issues is very thoughtless and could be seen as intentionally cruel. The comments about avoiding unnecessary tests or interventions, I think you are maybe reading into more than you need to, lots of people have this mindset and it isn’t a direct insult to you if your choices differ.

I completely understand which is why I never pushed it. I have friends who openly admit they find children boring, which I completely accept and I don't discuss my DC with them as I have other topics of conversation.

That said, my SIL has always been very interested in her godchildren constantly talking about them and is a primary school teacher, so seemed strange that she was so disinterested in/borderline hostile towards our child. Our DC is very easygoing, gentle and undemanding, so can't believe its anything my DC is doing.

She repeated how easily she conceived to my DH twice, as well.

OP posts:
LadyEloise1 · 15/08/2022 13:34

frazzledasarock · 15/08/2022 13:18

yeah she’s deliberately being a bitch.

ignore the nastiness. She has no idea what tests and intervention she’ll want as her pregnancy progresses. And she’ll certainly have no idea what she’ll want when she’s in labour.

let her get on with it. Just keep in mind she’s not a nice person and doesn’t like you.

This. 💯
She's not a nice person.
Keep your distance.
Be polite but disengaged.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 15/08/2022 13:32

She is being a cow.

I conceived really quickly and it was such a shock (literally one week decided to start trying, 2 weeks later I was pregnant) that I think it contributed to pre natal depression (thought I'd ruined my life etc). However I didnt mention it to anyone, even though it might have helped to talk about it, because I knew it was nothing compared to what other people were going through and was trying to be sensitive to people with fertility struggles.

And the 'unnecessary interventions' comment, unless you were asking her about her birth plan, is completely out of context and basically just designed to make you feel shit.

If it was just a one off then I'd say give her the benefit of the doubt but her behaviour in general stinks. I dont like other peoples kids and don't go out of my way to interact with them but I'd not ignore one, and I still manage to congratulate people on their pregnancies.

I have the feeling she is going to be one of those people who send you lists of expensive presents that their child wants and expects a lot from you but doesnt get your child anything at all. Be aware of this in your future relationship and make sure you never go out of your way for her.

I'm a but disappointed in how your husband has reacted...he might be desperate to not face up to how much of a cow she is and want to believe that she didnt mean it hastily...but it's very harsh to basically blame you for reacting in a normal way to her shit behaviour. Most people will be sensitive about infertility issues. I hope he has your back in future as unfortunately she is clearly seeing all aspects of motherhood as some sort of competition so it wont be the last time something like this happens

Aquamarine1029 · 15/08/2022 13:31

Stop trying to make nice with this arsehole. She's not interested and she's definitely not worth it. She would cease to exist in my world.

Thornethorn · 15/08/2022 13:29

Probably jealousy.

I wouldn't waste thinking time on it. She's not a friend.

Whataretheodds · 15/08/2022 13:29

Both - she's been a bitch but there is absolutely no need to (or benefit in) taking it personally. I'd do the minimum required to be civil, no more.

MissEDashwood19 · 15/08/2022 13:26

lamaze1 · 15/08/2022 13:17

As she knows your history YANBU sounds like a deliberate dig. Do you get on generally, or are relations strained?

There's never been any overt unkindness or falling out. I have wondered if she resents PIL's interest in DC, their first grandchild.

That said, PIL are extremely generous to SIL in terms of financial assistance, practical support and time.

I know my DH struggled with the fact my PIL bought her a house and paid for the upkeep of her horses, but I never got involved in any of that as it was between them (PIL and their children).

OP posts:
StClare101 · 15/08/2022 13:25

She sounds nasty and I would give her very little time and energy.

When she’s in labour you can smile quietly to yourself while you wonder if she endures it pain free or shock horror with an epidural… have a lovely glass of wine and celebrate her impending arrival while you do!

LairyMcClairy · 15/08/2022 13:24

Maybe she thinks you were overly dramatic sharing all the details of your ivf etc and wants to show she can manage pregnancy/parenthood effortlessly. A weird kind of showing off for being super fertile and laid back with it? Just ignore her or tell her to stop being such a nob.

catandcoffee · 15/08/2022 13:23

OP why are you going out of your way to be 'kind ' to someone who ignores you and your child ?
Have a real think about that.... anyone who ignores a young child,deliberately, is a nasty piece of work.