Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is my SIL insensitive or deliberately spiteful?

134 replies

MissEDashwood19 · 15/08/2022 13:12

I have DC after over two years of infertility, a major surgery and subsequent IVF. I'm now pregnant again (with a frozen embryo).

We were very distressed dealing with infertility and shared our experiences and feelings very openly with our family.

Once our DC was born, my SIL showed no interest in said child and deliberately went out of her way to ignore the child at family events - even as child became a toddler and would go up and speak to her, saying "Aunty, hello Aunty". I would then distract child and tell DC that Aunty was busy, but never made a big deal of it.

I wondered if this was because SIL was going through something and never forced our DC on her or brought up her total lack of interest, bordering on being unkind to our DC.

I became pregnant again and SIL never acknowledged the pregnancy at all. No word of congratulations to either my DH or me, absolute silence. We live very near one another, so plenty of opportunity to say something in person too.

She became pregnant a couple of months after me, my MIL (with SIL's permission) shared the news with the family and I tried to ring SIL (she didn't pick up) so sent her a heartfelt congratulatory message which she did acknowledge.

When she next saw me in person she went out of her way to tell me she had conceived immediately with no issues and that she wouldn't be having any unnecessary tests or interventions like some women (I did the NIPT test and had an epidural with my first - both of which she knows).

The whole conversation deeply upset me. My husband said I'm being oversensitive and my best friend (the only other person I mentioned it to) thinks the comments were deliberate and spiteful. How should I handle this moving forward?

YABU - You're oversensitive
YANBU - Comments were deliberately unkind

OP posts:
KarenOLantern · 17/08/2022 08:20

Re: her ignoring your child, maybe when her own kid is born she'll start treating your DC normally if it was a jealousy thing, but if she doesn't, I'd just call her out. When your daughter tries talking to her and gets ignored, don't make excuses (aunty's busy) just say "some people are very rude, but you don't have to talk to them". Sod her.

MissEDashwood19 · 16/08/2022 17:24

rightonthyme · 16/08/2022 16:48

Is @LuftBalloons secretly your SIL, OP? 🕶

😂 🤣🤣🤣

OP posts:
rightonthyme · 16/08/2022 16:48

Is @LuftBalloons secretly your SIL, OP? 🕶

MissEDashwood19 · 16/08/2022 16:10

LuftBalloons · 16/08/2022 12:36

OP, you seem very hung up on hierarchy in you extended family: you were pregnant fist, you've been married longer ... etc etc. It appears a bit like insecurity. Just get on with your life, and stop obsessing over the perceived slights of your SiL. You're not close, she's not interested in a relationship, you've done your best. Leave it.

Ask yourself, why should she be friends with you, simply because you're married to her brother? It's not something she's chosen, and it seems, from your posts, that you are not particularly compatible.

Just let it go, and work on your own self-esteem.

I honestly couldn't care less about these facts and only shared them when asked for more context from other posters.

My SIL isn't married and doesn't believe in marriage. My DH and I having been together longer than her and her DP was a response to a previous question and not a judgement or something I'm remotely competitive about.

As for being competitive about who was pregnant first, again this is a fact and response to a previous question. I'm just grateful to have DC and be pregnant after infertility and treat it as a gift not a competition with anyone else.

In fact, I was delighted when my SIL announced her pregnancy as I thought it'd be lovely for our children to grow up together. My DC's other cousins live far away from us.

I am perfectly happy having a distant, polite relationship but not when someone makes pointed digs at me about how I conceived and birthed my children and deliberately ignores my DC when they try to speak to them (this has happened multiple times). The last one is particularly hurtful when it's only directed at my DC (a very young toddler) and not at any other children.

My DH desperately wants a close relationship with his sister, so I have made an effort for his benefit.

You seem to be deliberately misinterpreting everything I say, so I won't be responding any further.

OP posts:
Booboobeth · 16/08/2022 13:04

I agree. The OP seems to want to know why she’s not liked/loved by her SIL. Some people just don’t care that much about extended family or maybe they have nothing in common.

Or the SIL just dislikes her for no reason and that’s perfectly fine. The OP can be married first, have the first child, and be “the first” for everything. Maybe SIL just doesn’t care. SIL might be a perfect nice and normal person who doesn’t want to get to close for whatever reason. Maybe she’s discreet, shy, get on with her own life.

what I can tell from the previous posts is that the OP doesn’t accept that her SIL doesn’t acknowledge her the way she wanted to be acknowledged. I’m sorry but I’m with the SIL in this one.

LuftBalloons · 16/08/2022 12:36

OP, you seem very hung up on hierarchy in you extended family: you were pregnant fist, you've been married longer ... etc etc. It appears a bit like insecurity. Just get on with your life, and stop obsessing over the perceived slights of your SiL. You're not close, she's not interested in a relationship, you've done your best. Leave it.

Ask yourself, why should she be friends with you, simply because you're married to her brother? It's not something she's chosen, and it seems, from your posts, that you are not particularly compatible.

Just let it go, and work on your own self-esteem.

VainAbigail · 16/08/2022 12:33

I see it as jealousy. You had a child first, a girl and you’ve stated up thread that she also wants a girl first. The first grandchild in the family was a girl and she probably wanted to be the person to give that first grandchild/granddaughter. It’s just jealousy on her part. Do you see that’s what it is? I wonder if her reaction would’ve been different if your son had been born first.

MissEDashwood19 · 16/08/2022 11:45

Booboobeth · 16/08/2022 10:16

My experience being in your SIL shoes:

I dislike my SIL simply because I was not allowed to celebrate my own first pregnancy (conceived naturally) because she was having trouble conceiving her SECOND child via IVF.

our MIL actually cried because she didn’t know how to break the news for her and we needed to wait for my 20weeks scan. This was because if there was something wrong with my baby I could terminate my pregnancy and never tell her I was actually pregnant.

I know it’s not her fault (or I presume so) but I can’t just go ahead and like her and her children now. I want her away from me and I avoid any contact. And yes I’ll go out of my way just to avoid her if I can. I think it might have some backstory that you perhaps are not aware of.

That may have been your experience, but it isn't the case here.

I hardly stole her thunder during pregnancy (as I was pregnant before her both times) and, in fact, my SIL never congratulated or acknowledged either pregnancy, which we accepted as we didn't know her circumstances.

My SIL also announced this pregnancy at six weeks, so there was no expectation that she had to conceal her happiness or wait for weeks/months to "break" the news to us.

I also gave her lots of baby things for her unborn baby and wrote her a lovely message and card.

I also never begrudged or stopped my siblings from celebrating their pregnancies/ babies due to my infertility. Nobody put their lives on hold for us and we didn't expect them to. I think this is a very unfair assumption.

That said, I would completely understand if someone had to distance themselves from me due to their heartbreak with infertility. I'm extremely lucky to have a DC and I know many women (including a friend) who IVF didn't work for and I don't need them to put their mental health at risk to congratulate me on "achieving" something that they desperately wanted.

OP posts:
Grumpusaurus · 16/08/2022 11:05

Those are deliberately and very unkind words. I know it is mean but I hope that she does not have an easy pregnancy and a long delivery, let's see her stance then on no intervention...

Booboobeth · 16/08/2022 10:16

My experience being in your SIL shoes:

I dislike my SIL simply because I was not allowed to celebrate my own first pregnancy (conceived naturally) because she was having trouble conceiving her SECOND child via IVF.

our MIL actually cried because she didn’t know how to break the news for her and we needed to wait for my 20weeks scan. This was because if there was something wrong with my baby I could terminate my pregnancy and never tell her I was actually pregnant.

I know it’s not her fault (or I presume so) but I can’t just go ahead and like her and her children now. I want her away from me and I avoid any contact. And yes I’ll go out of my way just to avoid her if I can. I think it might have some backstory that you perhaps are not aware of.

MissEDashwood19 · 16/08/2022 08:30

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 15/08/2022 22:18

I think she maybe did struggle to conceive. How long has she been with her partner? Longer than you and your husband?

She may have struggled and was annoyed and jealous that you 'beat' her. Now she's trying to claim she had no issues at all.

But even if that's not the case, or if it is, she's still a bitch and needs to grow up.

I honestly don't know. My husband and I have been together longer, but she's been with her DP for some time (about five years). I wonder if her DP was stalling about having children as I can't imagine she would lie about conceiving very easily.

She also quit working earlier this year before getting pregnant, but I don't know if that's connected.

My SIL has always been heavily assisted by her parents (house bought for her, her three horses and a new stable built and paid for, constant practical help and emotional support), so I don't know if she worries our DC may reduce this ongoing help.

OP posts:
MissEDashwood19 · 16/08/2022 08:14

miltonj · 16/08/2022 06:24

She wanted to have the attention of having the first grandchildren. That didn't happen so she basically hates you and your kids. She's trying to salvage the situation by inferring her kid will be better and more legit than yours because she conceived them 'better' and plans to birth them 'better'. She's basically insane and not worth another thought.

This is what my best friend suggested she was doing. Implying that I was less of a woman as I couldn't conceive naturally and had an epidural and my children are less than because they're IVF babies.

I do think she was put out that my DC receives so much attention from her parents as my DH has never been a focus for them.

OP posts:
MissEDashwood19 · 16/08/2022 08:01

DangerouslyBored · 16/08/2022 07:45

Well, she’s either thick or spiteful. Either way, she’s a bit of a prick.

Congrats on your successful IVF (currently pregnant with a little frosty 😊)

Thank you so much! Congratulations to you too! 👏

OP posts:
MissEDashwood19 · 16/08/2022 07:59

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 16/08/2022 07:15

LuftBalloons Sharing a distressing situation with your nearest and dearest isn't an indication you expected your dc to be central to their lives or necessarily likely to be over-sharing to my mind. It is normal to turn to loved one's when you need some support.
SIL herself is saying conception was quick, why would she say that out of (this theoretical) distaste and not 'we were struggling to but don't make a habit of going round telling people' or similar. So I think you're projecting a bit here.

Thank you for this! We weren't going around broadcasting our situation or desperately craving attention like PP suggested.

Both sets of parents kept mentioning grandchildren, so we disclosed our situation to them and to our siblings. We didn't discuss it at length only to say we were struggling to conceive and undergoing infertility treatment. I also had an operation, which would've been difficult to conceal from close family members. There was no attempt to be centre stage during this distressing time.

We didn't provide our immediate families with constant updates during our treatment and having been through infertility, I don't shove my child in people's faces or expect DC to be the centre of the universe.

My parents have a huge number of grandchildren, my PIL only have one so naturally they were very excited and focused on DC. We never pushed it.

OP posts:
shandon14 · 16/08/2022 07:57

She's obviously quite a damaged (some would say spiteful) individual and as you've only every had negativity from her, draw a line under it now and reduce your contact as much as you possibly can. Expect nothing and give nothing.

Rise above it all, practise that tinkly laugh for when she comes out with nasty outrageous statements, We live our best lives when we remove people like her from our lives.

Your husband sounds weak - you need to become the person that he has to appease rather than her, so put your foot down and do not accept any attempts by him to pander to her.

DangerouslyBored · 16/08/2022 07:49

Rtmhwales · 16/08/2022 03:42

She sounds unpleasant and spiteful.

My own SIL while not spiteful was a bit ridiculous about it all. Pointed out she was absolutely not having an epidural as it's crap for the baby (obviously I had one) and once said she doesn't believe in C sections as it's not a birth it's a removal, like a parasite.

Imagine my delight last month when she had to have an emergency c section with epidural. Her and her parasite are doing just fine.

People are shit. Just disengage and realize their shittiness isn't your issue.

Her and her parasite are doing just fine

Grin
DangerouslyBored · 16/08/2022 07:47

LuftBalloons · 16/08/2022 05:55

We were very distressed dealing with infertility and shared our experiences and feelings very openly with our family.

Hmmmm. I suspect that maybe she had conception issues of her own and found your “sharing” distasteful.

I’d find what sounds like over-sharing to be rather distasteful. You seem to expect that your fertility and subsequent DC should be central to everyone else’s lives.

YABU

🙄

DangerouslyBored · 16/08/2022 07:45

Well, she’s either thick or spiteful. Either way, she’s a bit of a prick.

Congrats on your successful IVF (currently pregnant with a little frosty 😊)

CleopatrasBeautifulNose · 16/08/2022 07:15

LuftBalloons Sharing a distressing situation with your nearest and dearest isn't an indication you expected your dc to be central to their lives or necessarily likely to be over-sharing to my mind. It is normal to turn to loved one's when you need some support.
SIL herself is saying conception was quick, why would she say that out of (this theoretical) distaste and not 'we were struggling to but don't make a habit of going round telling people' or similar. So I think you're projecting a bit here.

miltonj · 16/08/2022 06:24

She wanted to have the attention of having the first grandchildren. That didn't happen so she basically hates you and your kids. She's trying to salvage the situation by inferring her kid will be better and more legit than yours because she conceived them 'better' and plans to birth them 'better'. She's basically insane and not worth another thought.

LuftBalloons · 16/08/2022 05:55

We were very distressed dealing with infertility and shared our experiences and feelings very openly with our family.

Hmmmm. I suspect that maybe she had conception issues of her own and found your “sharing” distasteful.

I’d find what sounds like over-sharing to be rather distasteful. You seem to expect that your fertility and subsequent DC should be central to everyone else’s lives.

YABU

ajarintennessee · 16/08/2022 04:07

I think you need to keep your distance, and be prepared for the worst with your pil as they’ve obviously indulged her forever, in particular compared to your dh. I have one a bit like this, not at all spiteful but very needy and self centred. Pil don’t have much time because they are busy with her dc, couldn’t really visit my baby for months (still helped regularly with our other dc, it just always had to be their house so they could also have her dc) so I just stay away really and I feel zero obligation to preserve what I would usually consider basic standards - offer help etc, knowing she’s never put herself out for us in any way. We are quite busy so if Dh wanted to spend a day helping her I’d probably say I’ll be out that day - I won’t do a day of solo parenting so he can support her if I’m tired with children who don’t sleep and the house is a dump and I’m behind on work - her children get looked after every day, regular overnights, and she only works a few hours so i need my time to look after me and my family thanks.?

Rtmhwales · 16/08/2022 03:42

She sounds unpleasant and spiteful.

My own SIL while not spiteful was a bit ridiculous about it all. Pointed out she was absolutely not having an epidural as it's crap for the baby (obviously I had one) and once said she doesn't believe in C sections as it's not a birth it's a removal, like a parasite.

Imagine my delight last month when she had to have an emergency c section with epidural. Her and her parasite are doing just fine.

People are shit. Just disengage and realize their shittiness isn't your issue.

Summerfun54321 · 16/08/2022 02:20

She sounds petty and jealous. She may well have had a lot of insecurities about being late 30s and childless while her young brother had children. Just rise above it and don’t make a big deal out of it. She’s only your SIL, she isn’t your friend. All your relationship needs to be is civil and polite for the sake of your DH and his family. It doesn’t stand to benefit your DH if you get too invested or worked up over this relationship. She’s shown her true colours so just take a step back and only engage in polite conversation with her.

Changechangychange · 16/08/2022 01:57

Spinasaurus · 15/08/2022 23:18

It does sound like she's the golden child in the family and hasn't enjoyed being replaced by a grandchild, your DC.

My DSIS can be a bit like this. I don't think it's necessarily malicious. But literally every time something goes down in my family for someone other than her, she has to have something happen with her. My mum finds it amusing TBH as do I. In all honesty, the dynamic between her and my DF is becoming boarderline weird. I keep my distance now and don't engage.

This. We have somebody in our family who behaves similarly, to the point of throwing a “four and a half month birthday party”, complete with cake and presents, for their PFB on my DS’s 4th birthday and demanding the wider family attended that and not DS’s little family tea.

I’d expect your PIL to be monopolised every Christmas, and some sort of present wars (either demanding the moon on a stick for their DC, or getting yours absolutely nothing). And constant bragging. Try to rise above it, and see your PIL separately if you can.