Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Commonwealth has had its day?

333 replies

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 12:50

The Commonwealth is a colonialist institution based on a history of conquest and slavery.

"The origins of the Commonwealth come from Britain's former Empire. Many of the members of the Commonwealth were territories which had historically come under British rule at various times by settlement, conquest or cession. The administration of such colonies evolved in different ways, to reflect the different circumstances of each territory."
www.royal.uk/commonwealth

The Commonwealth Games have never been held in an African country. Although there have been exceptions, most years it is held in Britain, Australia, New Zealand or Canada. Since 1930 it has only been held three times in other countries. Or seven countries if you include youth games and paraplegic games.

The Commonwealth has no clear role; it confers no trade privileges upon its members, does not coordinate their defence or foreign policy, and lacks both the budget and the executive authority to make a practical difference in the world.

It is a colonialist hangover that has no clear role and should be abolished.
AIBU?

OP posts:
DuaneDibbley · 15/08/2022 17:48

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 13:05

Tom Daley doesn’t speak for all athletes. He only speaks for Tom Daley and given he has dubious morals I’m not sure I’d be taking him so seriously

This year there were 400 athletes who don’t agree with his stance

Dubious morals?

Namenic · 15/08/2022 17:46

If you look on the website at what they do - it doesn’t sound so bad. thecommonwealth.org/our-work/trade-and-economy
Trade advisors to improve export capabilities and fund to guarantee loans for import of good at competitive prices - for small nations (which many nations in commonwealth are).

I mean fair enough if Barbados and Jamaica see their future away from the commonwealth - if their people want that, then that’s the right thing for them. But on the whole I think some small countries do benefit; and I think U.K. can also learn from other commonwealth countries too.

Carpy88999 · 15/08/2022 17:45

Typical woke bullshit, mixed in with a hint of white saviour complex. Spouting off about a supposedly racist institution without knowing anything about it or why it might be beneficial to individual nations within the commonwealth.

itsgettingweird · 15/08/2022 17:39

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 16:42

But what do they get from being in the Commonwealth?
It does not achieve anything.

We'll surely they can decide that as a country. It's not for us to decide.

The same way it wasn't for the EU to decide if we remained with them or not.

We have to accept (or you do!) that these countries choose to be part of the commonwealth because they decide it's in their best interests. Why do you think they aren't capable of making those decisions for themselves?

Maireas · 15/08/2022 17:32

drbuzzaro · 15/08/2022 17:25

yes and it took them decades if not centuries to get there.

So that's an excuse not to start the process? Maybe get it done quicker? No logic there.

MarshaMelrose · 15/08/2022 17:32

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 16:57

Thanks for making my point for me. The Barbadian team’s attendance at the commonwealth games doesn’t demonstrate a love for or an affinity with the commonwealth. It just means that they want to compete internationally against a selection of nations with good athletes.

Nor does it mean that Barbados’s politicians have decided to stay in the commonwealth long term. You can’t know what they are thinking. We know what the Barbadians think of the head of the commonwealth, though.

The Commonwealth games gives opportunities to athletes that miss out ofvopportunities in other competitions. The Barbadians don't have to love the Commonwealth to compete. They don't even have to love or live in Barbados. It's just a competition. I should think, just like the vast majority of people in this country, they don't give the Commonwealth much thought in their day to day lives.

Only two countries have left the commonwealth and not rejoined. Ireland in the 1940s. And Zimbabwe because it had been suspended. Zimbabwe has already applied to rejoin. Countries, including India and Pakistan, have left but all have applied to rejoin. The last country to leave was the Maldives which left around 2015 but it has now rejoined. Do you think the leaders of the these countries, who experience the Commonwealth and see the benefits themselves know less than you? Do you think these countries are too stupid to know what's best for them. Sounds a bit racist to me. Briton knows better than them.

A third of the world's population lives in the Commonwealth. It's a big club that small island countries want to be part of because it gives them access to and equality with the big players in the world's trading and political spheres.

IcedPurple · 15/08/2022 17:26

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 13:40

I agree Commonwealth Citizens can not vote in Britain.
There are no real advantages.

And yet, the countries themselves clearly think there are.

That's why very few have chosen to leave, and some countries with no links to the British empire have chosen to join.

Or you know better than the people of these countries what's good for them? Sounds a tad colonial to me.

drbuzzaro · 15/08/2022 17:25

Maireas · 15/08/2022 16:44

No, but some countries manage to be inclusive, don't they?.

yes and it took them decades if not centuries to get there.

IcedPurple · 15/08/2022 17:21

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 12:52

Well the Barbadians certainly agree with you! As do the Jamaicans, judging by the scenes on that royal visit earlier in the year.

Neither country has made any indication that they wish to leave the Commonwealth. They could do so tomorrow if they wanted, as could all of the other members. Membership is entirely voluntary.

It's very likely that most if not all of the overseas realms will remove the monarch as HoS once Charles is on the throne. Again, that's something entirely withing their own control. But that's a very different thing from choosing to leave the Commonwealth, something which very few countries have done thus far. Clearly, they see benefits in membership.

Maireas · 15/08/2022 17:20

RichardMarxisinnocent · 15/08/2022 17:13

This wasn't the first time this has happened, the full integration started in Manchester 2002

That's good to hear.

AndreaC74 · 15/08/2022 17:18

RichardMarxisinnocent · 15/08/2022 17:13

This wasn't the first time this has happened, the full integration started in Manchester 2002

That most definitely is a positive :)

Maireas · 15/08/2022 17:18

@ajandjjmum - that's good! There did seem to be a great atmosphere, and as I said upthread it was nice to see so many small countries doing well.

AndreaC74 · 15/08/2022 17:17

PurpleWisteria · 15/08/2022 16:46

Friendship between countries. That's nice, I think.

Many Commonwealth countries are not supporting us against Russia, indeed instead of staying neutral (bad enough) are buying their gas/raw materials with the intention of increasing such trade.

Some friendship.

etulosba · 15/08/2022 17:16

Ignore my post above. It is way out of context.

etulosba · 15/08/2022 17:16

We only fought for independence

Was there actually any fighting, or is that a figure of speech?

RichardMarxisinnocent · 15/08/2022 17:13

SummaLuvin · 15/08/2022 13:11

Let's also not forget that for the first time para athletes were included in the 'main' event rather than a second event.

This. I saw some swimming and table tennis events and the para-athletes races and matches, were just treated as events in the scheme alongside the standard ones, mixed in and given equal gravitas and importance. I loved it.

This wasn't the first time this has happened, the full integration started in Manchester 2002

ajandjjmum · 15/08/2022 17:12

This is just @antelopevalley 's anti-establishment thread of the day. Tiresome or amusing, depending on how you look at it.

I attended several events during the Commonwealth Games, the atmosphere was great and everyone seemed very happy to be there.

PetraBP · 15/08/2022 17:12

Hmm… last time I checked a country didn’t need “permission” to leave the Commonwealth any more than it needs “permission” to leave the monarchy.

Even though you may not like it, the British Empire, which had good and bad about it- history isn’t binary- evolved into the Commonwealth and member countries are free to leave at any time.

Those that choose to keep Queen as their head of state have no obligation to do so.

Those that continue to send their final legal appeals to the Supreme Court in London have no obligation to do so.

The relationships of the Commonwealth countries with the UK are all different,
complicated and historically interesting.

A lot is left out of the history of the Empire and Commonwealth based on the agenda of who is talking about it.

Conservatives tend to harp on about democracy, free speech and the rule of law as well as trains, roads, civil service etc and an historic sense of a benevolent civilising mission.

Socialists tend to harp on about slavery (abolished before most of the countries of the Empire actually became British colonies) and how those who set out to “civilise” were always in it for
themselves.

This binary view of “all bad” or “all good”
is unhealthy.

Like those who think that either:

Churchill was an evil racist who cannot possibly be a 20th century hero because of a few ill chosen words early in his political career…

vs

…those who think that Churchill was second only to God and that even to point out any of Churchill’s human faults is literally treason.

Read, read, read.

Educate, educate, educate.

Question, question, question.

Just be aware that whoever is writing may have an agenda and don’t believe everything that you read.

Final thought… if the Commonwealth was so bad surely all the members would have left except for maybe Canada and Australia who like to pretend they’re European to distance themselves from their US ally?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 17:12

ajandjjmum · 15/08/2022 17:03

I think they get confused between the Empire and the Commonwealth.

A massive schoolboy error for two members of the RF

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 17:09

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 17:00

I do. How many of them voted to reject the queen as their head of state in a democratic vote in the last couple of years? One member did, Barbados, and we know how they voted. What do you suppose the result would be if every member held a referendum? We’ve had a pretty strong indication of the feelings of the Jamaican people.

So why do you think they didn’t leave altogether?

Twizbe · 15/08/2022 17:07

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 16:52

It costs a lot of money for friendship.

And all the nations in the commonwealth have the free choice to pay that money if they wish.

As we've said several times, no country is forced to be part of it. They can leave at any point.

Neither the British government, nor the Queen, have any control over what the member nations do with their own laws or systems of government.

ajandjjmum · 15/08/2022 17:03

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 15:37

I think they get confused between the Empire and the Commonwealth.

Maireas · 15/08/2022 17:03

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 16:52

It costs a lot of money for friendship.

I'm guessing that independent nations make their own judgements about what benefits them and how. If it doesn't work for them, they leave.

toastofthetown · 15/08/2022 17:02

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 16:57

Thanks for making my point for me. The Barbadian team’s attendance at the commonwealth games doesn’t demonstrate a love for or an affinity with the commonwealth. It just means that they want to compete internationally against a selection of nations with good athletes.

Nor does it mean that Barbados’s politicians have decided to stay in the commonwealth long term. You can’t know what they are thinking. We know what the Barbadians think of the head of the commonwealth, though.

Of course it doesn’t say anything about the athletes desires. It does show that the Barbadian federations valued attendance at the games, despite having recently removed the Queen as head of state. Athletes don’t just show up for games. If Barbados were passionately against the Commonwealth and everything it stood for, why would they as a nation send more athletes than ever before to a competition representing something they are working so hard to remove from their national identity? Surely they would boycott, as nations boycotted South African events during apartheid.

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 17:00

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 16:53

You do realise that 2/3
commonwealth countries don’t have the Queen as their head of state?

I do. How many of them voted to reject the queen as their head of state in a democratic vote in the last couple of years? One member did, Barbados, and we know how they voted. What do you suppose the result would be if every member held a referendum? We’ve had a pretty strong indication of the feelings of the Jamaican people.