Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Commonwealth has had its day?

333 replies

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 12:50

The Commonwealth is a colonialist institution based on a history of conquest and slavery.

"The origins of the Commonwealth come from Britain's former Empire. Many of the members of the Commonwealth were territories which had historically come under British rule at various times by settlement, conquest or cession. The administration of such colonies evolved in different ways, to reflect the different circumstances of each territory."
www.royal.uk/commonwealth

The Commonwealth Games have never been held in an African country. Although there have been exceptions, most years it is held in Britain, Australia, New Zealand or Canada. Since 1930 it has only been held three times in other countries. Or seven countries if you include youth games and paraplegic games.

The Commonwealth has no clear role; it confers no trade privileges upon its members, does not coordinate their defence or foreign policy, and lacks both the budget and the executive authority to make a practical difference in the world.

It is a colonialist hangover that has no clear role and should be abolished.
AIBU?

OP posts:
HarrietPierce · 15/08/2022 20:03

antelopevalley · Today 13:40
"@antelopevalley I agree Commonwealth Citizens can not vote in Britain.
There are no real advantages."

Yes they can. My husband has a Canadian passport and certainly votes. (Not Tory by the way)

itsgettingweird · 15/08/2022 19:41

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:33

@itsgettingweird it doesn’t matter if they ‘choose’ it - commercial surrogacy is hiring someone’s womb and risking their life to fulfil the desire of a biological child. And it is often women who do it because they’re desperate money, not for altruistic reasons

I never said I agree with it.

I said we can't judge woman who make that choice for themselves or assume that in every case they haven't.

I don't agree with always assuming people have been forced into decisions because they aren't ones I'd make or agree with.

Barbadossunset · 15/08/2022 18:46

‘China has invested £685 billion across 42 Commonwealth countries since 2005, according to figures compiled by the American Enterprise Institute’.

Presumably China will have more influence over these countries than the Commonwealth given they’ve invested so hugely.

gatehouseoffleet · 15/08/2022 18:38

The Commonwealth has no clear role; it confers no trade privileges upon its members, does not coordinate their defence or foreign policy, and lacks both the budget and the executive authority to make a practical difference in the world.
It is a colonialist hangover that has no clear role and should be abolished

This infers pretty clearly that the members have no idea what they are doing and why they are members. OK you didn't mention the citizens, but there's a clear inference the leaders must be idiots.

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 18:36

Do you think the leaders of the these countries, who experience the Commonwealth and see the benefits themselves know less than you? Do you think these countries are too stupid to know what's best for them. Sounds a bit racist to me. Briton knows better than them.

It really is quite a leap of logic for you to claim that I am ‘a bit racist’ and think that people in other countries are ‘too stupid’. Shame on you. It’s rather sad that you can’t argue in a calm and respectful manner. It exposes the weakness of your argument.

Point to one post of mine where I have claimed to ‘know more than’ citizens of commonwealth nations. Or where I have called them ‘stupid’. Or where I have been ‘a bit racist’. You can’t.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:33

@itsgettingweird it doesn’t matter if they ‘choose’ it - commercial surrogacy is hiring someone’s womb and risking their life to fulfil the desire of a biological child. And it is often women who do it because they’re desperate money, not for altruistic reasons

itsgettingweird · 15/08/2022 18:27

He hired a woman’s womb in order to have children. Then barely mentioned her throughout the ’we are having a baby’ and birth announcements. I don’t like men who use women as commodities and then pretend they don’t exist

Surrogates choose to do it.

Whether you agree with surrogacy or not we can't pretend that woman are forced into it. Many want to do it and seek people looking surrogates.

itsgettingweird · 15/08/2022 18:26

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:16

Do you think the leaders of the these countries, who experience the Commonwealth and see the benefits themselves know less than you? Do you think these countries are too stupid to know what's best for them. Sounds a bit racist to me. Briton knows better than them.

Normally I loathe people jumping to ‘isms’ but I actually agree with this - there’s something off at people who are making assumptions about the decision making skills of certain countries

Second you with this.

That poster put it much better than I did upthread.

Runwalkskijump · 15/08/2022 18:25

Only two countries have left the commonwealth and not rejoined. Ireland in the 1940s

There were a number of Irish atheletes that have competed for Ireland in recent years, that wanted to compete for NI in Birmingham and got special dispensation from the sporting federation to do so

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:23

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 18:13

Yes, the elected government. Whose manifesto probably included waving goodbye to the queen as head of state. They were, after all, elected by people who are descended from slaves. The British royal family have done rather well from the slave trade over the years, starting with Elizabeth I, so it’s hardly a surprise that the Barbadians might not think kindly of the RF. Rather like the Jamaicans, who appear to think similarly.

If the people had felt aggrieved by the decision, there would have been widespread protests and the government would have fallen. There were not, and it didn’t.

In which case it’s understandable to remove the Queen as their HoS however being royalists is not a requirement of Commonwealth membership

IcedPurple · 15/08/2022 18:23

They still might. What makes you think that they won’t?

Because they've given zero indication that they intend to.

And because, if recent history is anything to go by, very few countries choose to leave the Commonwealth. The majority of Commonwealth countries do not have the British monarch as HoS, and haven't had for years. So becoming a republic does not at all imply a desire to leave the Commonwealth, however much you wish it were so.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:22

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 18:03

They still might. What makes you think that they won’t? They only binned off QE2 in November after all. They might have some good reasons for staying but those reasons are unlikely to include:

  • membership of a loose association of nations that were once part of the British empire.
  • a strong regard for the monarch at the head of the commonwealth.
  • ’friendship’ with other nations who happen to be members of the same commonwealth. I’m sure that Barbados is quite capable of forming diplomatic alliances with or without commonwealth membership.
  • nostalgia for the past.
  • a love of British culture.
which are the things that define the commonwealth. They might decide that their interests are better served by joining something else!

Can you provide evidence that those things ‘define the commonwealth’ or is it just a guess?

Runwalkskijump · 15/08/2022 18:22

LampLighter414 · 15/08/2022 18:07

Don’t let the gammons and Brexit types hear you utter any of this. YANBU OP

I'm neither.

Your statement says more about you.

drbuzzaro · 15/08/2022 18:21

Maireas · 15/08/2022 17:32

So that's an excuse not to start the process? Maybe get it done quicker? No logic there.

you say that like its like pressing a button. there are people in those countries fighting for their rights

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:21

They still might. What makes you think that they won’t?

Because they haven’t, when they literally leave tomorrow if they wanted to.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:20

DuaneDibbley · 15/08/2022 17:48

Dubious morals?

He hired a woman’s womb in order to have children. Then barely mentioned her throughout the ’we are having a baby’ and birth announcements. I don’t like men who use women as commodities and then pretend they don’t exist

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:18

Carpy88999 · 15/08/2022 17:45

Typical woke bullshit, mixed in with a hint of white saviour complex. Spouting off about a supposedly racist institution without knowing anything about it or why it might be beneficial to individual nations within the commonwealth.

I think OP should just admit she got confused with the British Empire and we can all be on our merry way.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 18:16

Do you think the leaders of the these countries, who experience the Commonwealth and see the benefits themselves know less than you? Do you think these countries are too stupid to know what's best for them. Sounds a bit racist to me. Briton knows better than them.

Normally I loathe people jumping to ‘isms’ but I actually agree with this - there’s something off at people who are making assumptions about the decision making skills of certain countries

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 18:13

Barbadossunset · 15/08/2022 18:03

One member did, Barbados, and we know how they voted. What do you suppose the result would be if every member held a referendum?

Barbados didn’t have a referendum. The Barbados government made the decision to remove the Queen.

Yes, the elected government. Whose manifesto probably included waving goodbye to the queen as head of state. They were, after all, elected by people who are descended from slaves. The British royal family have done rather well from the slave trade over the years, starting with Elizabeth I, so it’s hardly a surprise that the Barbadians might not think kindly of the RF. Rather like the Jamaicans, who appear to think similarly.

If the people had felt aggrieved by the decision, there would have been widespread protests and the government would have fallen. There were not, and it didn’t.

ajandjjmum · 15/08/2022 18:13

LampLighter414 · 15/08/2022 18:07

Don’t let the gammons and Brexit types hear you utter any of this. YANBU OP

Well that's a well founded argument! Grin

LampLighter414 · 15/08/2022 18:07

Don’t let the gammons and Brexit types hear you utter any of this. YANBU OP

Barbadossunset · 15/08/2022 18:03

One member did, Barbados, and we know how they voted. What do you suppose the result would be if every member held a referendum?

Barbados didn’t have a referendum. The Barbados government made the decision to remove the Queen.

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 18:03

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 17:09

So why do you think they didn’t leave altogether?

They still might. What makes you think that they won’t? They only binned off QE2 in November after all. They might have some good reasons for staying but those reasons are unlikely to include:

  • membership of a loose association of nations that were once part of the British empire.
  • a strong regard for the monarch at the head of the commonwealth.
  • ’friendship’ with other nations who happen to be members of the same commonwealth. I’m sure that Barbados is quite capable of forming diplomatic alliances with or without commonwealth membership.
  • nostalgia for the past.
  • a love of British culture.
which are the things that define the commonwealth. They might decide that their interests are better served by joining something else!
AndreaC74 · 15/08/2022 17:55

That would have more credibility if the very same Govt hadn't put in place barriers to EU trade, with a bloc that dwarfs the CW.

Desperate.

@Carpy88999 The moment someone attacks with "Woke" you know full well they have no argument and read the 'express.

Swipe left for the next trending thread