Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Commonwealth has had its day?

333 replies

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 12:50

The Commonwealth is a colonialist institution based on a history of conquest and slavery.

"The origins of the Commonwealth come from Britain's former Empire. Many of the members of the Commonwealth were territories which had historically come under British rule at various times by settlement, conquest or cession. The administration of such colonies evolved in different ways, to reflect the different circumstances of each territory."
www.royal.uk/commonwealth

The Commonwealth Games have never been held in an African country. Although there have been exceptions, most years it is held in Britain, Australia, New Zealand or Canada. Since 1930 it has only been held three times in other countries. Or seven countries if you include youth games and paraplegic games.

The Commonwealth has no clear role; it confers no trade privileges upon its members, does not coordinate their defence or foreign policy, and lacks both the budget and the executive authority to make a practical difference in the world.

It is a colonialist hangover that has no clear role and should be abolished.
AIBU?

OP posts:
IcedPurple · 16/08/2022 10:30

You have seized on this one point in a transparent attempt to disregard all the pertinent points re slavery colonialism and the history of the commonwealth .

Not that I have to in any way justify my posting history to you, but I've made several comments on this thread. It's you who has 'seized' on my recent correction of the OP's false statements.

Again, you are not the thread moderator so you don't get to dictate to others how they should post, let alone make nasty insinuations like the above.

Isn't making yourself a self-appointed thread moderator against MN guidelines?

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 10:26

Yes the point re the history of Rwanda has been made .

But it was one small point in a thread with wide historical and political connotations.

You have seized on this one point in a transparent attempt to disregard all the pertinent points re slavery colonialism and the history of the commonwealth .
Why would you want to do that ?
Don't you want to learn tue facts ?
( that is a rhetorical question)

IcedPurple · 16/08/2022 10:23

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 10:16

@IcedPurple yes the poster made a mistake re the history of Rwanda .

That does not negate all the other facts and links posted .

Now would you like to address any of the other pertinent facts thisthread has thrown up or would you prefer to continue to attempt to derail ?

So correcting the OP's latest inaccuracy is an 'attempt to derail' is it?

Would you prefer for her several false statements to go unanswered?

And unless MN made you thread moderator, I can respond in any way I see fit within the site guidelines. I don't tell you how to post, so I'd appreciate if you'd do the same.

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 10:16

@IcedPurple yes the poster made a mistake re the history of Rwanda .

That does not negate all the other facts and links posted .

Now would you like to address any of the other pertinent facts thisthread has thrown up or would you prefer to continue to attempt to derail ?

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 10:14

Because the topic of the thread is the Commonwealth and if if has a place in modern society . Its history is part of that .
The royals would like to ignore its history and theirs , re slavery etc ( no , 'reflection' is not good enough).
Maybe you would also like to ignore it

IcedPurple · 16/08/2022 10:14

HarrietPierce · 16/08/2022 08:26

Mozambique was a Portuguese colony.

Exactly. And Rwanda was also never a French colony.

Once again, the OP's 'arguments' are based on an ignorance of the facts.

derxa · 16/08/2022 10:01

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 09:50

You clearly haven't read the article .
Pointing out sexist commentary in an attempt to distract from the history will not work .

Once the usual legacy promises about urban regeneration and sports participation are stripped away, what value do the Games have unless they’re part of a genuine attempt to reckon with our own unconfronted history? Why do the Games have to be anything other than a great sports meet. Lots of good things have had troubling aspects. We used to beat pupils in school. Thankfully that's no longer the case.

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 09:57

"But then, the object of the Games had changed by the time they were founded. As the Observer explained back in 1930, they were largely about making us look good. “The British empire has been likened unto a family of nations: the mother country and her offspring scattered the world over … it is wise to maintain the idea of unity by careful cultivation, lest the attrition of time take effect.” They were, in the words of the historian Katharine Moore “a way to reconfirm and redefine” the empire. Through the 20th century they served to sportswash its reputation, a “friendly Games” between nations whose abiding connection is that they were all colonised by the same one.

The Commonwealth Games Federation had no choice but to try to move on from all this in the last few years, as part of a wider effort to reinvent the Commonwealth. It is all about shared values now: “equality, humanity, destiny”. The website even mentions the “historical injustice” of the empire. Worthwhile as it is, the effect is inevitably a little watery, like listening to one of those royal speeches about the “profound sorrow” of slavery. In Birmingham, protesters have already described these as the “Plantation Games” in the local press."

amp.theguardian.com/sport/blog/2022/jul/27/commonwealth-games-must-confront-the-truth-about-its-sportswashing-past

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 09:54

Twizbe · 16/08/2022 09:22

@Novella4 the common wealth heads of government have already confirmed they pick Charles to be the next head.

While the queen asked for it, there was no obligation on the heads of government to accept it. I can see why they did though. They are all elected officials and have no guarantees that they will still be HOG when the queen dies. Who was going to put their hand up as an alternative?

What I think Charles had planned was for a Harry to take on. Now that is unlikely they may move to a rotating presidency a la G7... but again that relies on all HOG wanting that.

The countries had wanted to elect a Head. Only the Queens intervention meant they agreed to Charles.

OP posts:
Novella4 · 16/08/2022 09:50

You clearly haven't read the article .
Pointing out sexist commentary in an attempt to distract from the history will not work .

derxa · 16/08/2022 09:48

Well you could object to any sports event on any number of grounds


  • the World cup in Qatar

  • sexist commentary

  • sponsorship by betting companies

  • doping

  • corrupt officials

etc. etc. The Commonwealth Games seems relatively innocent compared to all of that. It was a wonderful event this year

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 09:38

What has my watching of sport got to with anything?

Sport and politics are intertwined .

derxa · 16/08/2022 09:35

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 09:28

. @Twizbe - oh the queens asked and everyone was happy to oblige . That's alright then .

@derxa - I've seen some shallow and empty headed posts from royalists on here but yours takes the biscuit. Have you read the link ? Educate yourself .

Well do you watch sport?

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 09:28

. @Twizbe - oh the queens asked and everyone was happy to oblige . That's alright then .

@derxa - I've seen some shallow and empty headed posts from royalists on here but yours takes the biscuit. Have you read the link ? Educate yourself .

derxa · 16/08/2022 09:24

Do you ever just watch sport for entertainment?

Twizbe · 16/08/2022 09:22

@Novella4 the common wealth heads of government have already confirmed they pick Charles to be the next head.

While the queen asked for it, there was no obligation on the heads of government to accept it. I can see why they did though. They are all elected officials and have no guarantees that they will still be HOG when the queen dies. Who was going to put their hand up as an alternative?

What I think Charles had planned was for a Harry to take on. Now that is unlikely they may move to a rotating presidency a la G7... but again that relies on all HOG wanting that.

ChagSameachDoreen · 16/08/2022 09:15

Agreed.

They should get rid of things like the British Empire Medal and OBE/CBE etc. The British Empire had ended!

I'm surprised with all the wokery these days that these things persist.

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 09:05

Of course the Commonwealth is out dated. It was based on the an attempt to unify previously exploited colonies.

Naturally many of those former colonies have chosen to remove the queen has head of state and become republics. Many are waiting for the queen to die before following Sui - Australia notably.

Unfortunately for the commonwealths claims re democracy , it has been made known that the queen wants Charles to take over. So let's see . Any chance of an elected head?

Nations who have become republics can of course band together economically whichever way they wish. In fact the report blocs in the commonwealth could do some good in supporting former colonies in their fight for reparations or even an apology for what was done to them.
The history of the crown is the history of slavery.

The commonwealth serves a useful function within the Uk though- it soothes the uneasy souls of gammons who look back to empire as the good old days. A bit more PR for us too the royals may have thought ... not quite working though is as the embarrassing William and Kate tour showed.

Newrumpus · 16/08/2022 08:55

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 22:44

They are ex-French colonies. The move is widely seen as a way for them to reduce their reliance on France.

Do the other former colonial empires have anything similar to The Commonwealth? On a smaller scale perhaps?

RoseAndRose · 16/08/2022 08:35

Rwanda was a German colony and a Belgium protectorate, and has a long and complicated history with France.

HarrietPierce · 16/08/2022 08:26

Mozambique was a Portuguese colony.

IcedPurple · 16/08/2022 08:01

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 22:44

They are ex-French colonies. The move is widely seen as a way for them to reduce their reliance on France.

Could you give the dates when Mozambique and Rwanda were French colonies?

JacquelineCarlyle · 16/08/2022 04:40

Totally agree @RedToothBrush

MangyInseam · 16/08/2022 03:16

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 12:52

Well the Barbadians certainly agree with you! As do the Jamaicans, judging by the scenes on that royal visit earlier in the year.

Lots of people in Jamaica came out to see them happily.

The government has had a mandate to leave for years and have chosen not to, I suspect because it's a nice little political football.

Anyway, no country needs to remain in the Commonwealth if they don't want to.

I live in the Commonwealth and am quite happy to be part of it. I appreciate the historical and cultural connections which are very real. I also think constitutional monarchies are a very stable form of government that work well empirically as well as having other virtues and so am happy to keep that.

I do wish that Commonwealth membership still conferred benefits like being able to go to university or to work in the UK, but they saw fit to remove that right which is their prerogative of course but sad IMO.

Swipe left for the next trending thread