Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Commonwealth has had its day?

333 replies

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 12:50

The Commonwealth is a colonialist institution based on a history of conquest and slavery.

"The origins of the Commonwealth come from Britain's former Empire. Many of the members of the Commonwealth were territories which had historically come under British rule at various times by settlement, conquest or cession. The administration of such colonies evolved in different ways, to reflect the different circumstances of each territory."
www.royal.uk/commonwealth

The Commonwealth Games have never been held in an African country. Although there have been exceptions, most years it is held in Britain, Australia, New Zealand or Canada. Since 1930 it has only been held three times in other countries. Or seven countries if you include youth games and paraplegic games.

The Commonwealth has no clear role; it confers no trade privileges upon its members, does not coordinate their defence or foreign policy, and lacks both the budget and the executive authority to make a practical difference in the world.

It is a colonialist hangover that has no clear role and should be abolished.
AIBU?

OP posts:
RoseAndRose · 16/08/2022 13:58

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:55

But what do you think that indicates?

That countries have, and should continue to have, self-determination

Which means making their own decisions in their own time, and British commentators realising that and refraining criticising currently preferred arrangements. It’s not our business any more, but I do think there are some who can’t let go of the idea that Britain should still be telling other countries what to do

DownNative · 16/08/2022 13:56

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 13:54

As I'm sure you are aware a majority of commonwealth nations are republics or do not have the queen as head of state .
Others are debating or planning to removed the British monarch as head of state .

31 Republics in the Commonwealth, 5 have their own Monarch and 14 have Queen Elizabeth as Head Of State.

And?

This is not evidence the Commonwealth will disappear any time soon which seems to be your implication.

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 13:55

Odd and disrespectful? A strange choice of words when it was the local people protesting at William and Catherine being present.
There was a lot of opposition to the tour, as well as some local people who welcomed it.

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:55

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 13:54

As I'm sure you are aware a majority of commonwealth nations are republics or do not have the queen as head of state .
Others are debating or planning to removed the British monarch as head of state .

But what do you think that indicates?

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 13:54

As I'm sure you are aware a majority of commonwealth nations are republics or do not have the queen as head of state .
Others are debating or planning to removed the British monarch as head of state .

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:50

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 13:40

And as I also mentioned , there is a difference between a commonwealth country with the queen as head of state and the increasing number of republics within it .

What’s the difference you refer to?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:50

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 13:39

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet . Not at all . I know there is a difference as any of the links I powered would make clear .

This still does not negate the problematic history of the commonwealth

Such as? Or do you mean problematic history of BE?

What do you propose the solution is? A PP asked a good question upthread about if countries should be forced out of something they like being part of. OP hasn’t answered funnily enough

RoseAndRose · 16/08/2022 13:44

not quite working though is as the embarrassing William and Kate tour showed

That was but one of all the Commonwealth and other international tours done to mark the Platinum Jubilee.

Even that one was for the most part exceptional and successful, with large crowds turning out and positive local press coverage.

The two or three events (out of the scores of events if you look at all the tours) that were extensively commentated on in UK aren’t that representative, but it does show there are still plenty here who want to tell the little countries what they should be doing or thinking.

When it’s entirely up to them. Leaving the Commonwealth is easy. Independence and also the separate issue of replacing Queen as Head of State are both straightforward. Once countries announce that is their wish, the handover planning begins and the date is set.

I find it somewhere between odd and downright distasteful that there persists a school of thought that says we know better than the actual countries concerned and that self-determination is less important than opinions originating in Britain

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 13:40

And as I also mentioned , there is a difference between a commonwealth country with the queen as head of state and the increasing number of republics within it .

DownNative · 16/08/2022 13:40

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 12:57

I can see how it provides a forum to lobby the UK.

"Although the 1971 Singapore Declaration of Commonwealth Principles expressed the Commonwealth’s opposition to apartheid, it took another seven years – and the determined efforts of the international sporting community – to turn the Commonwealth’s rhetoric into action."

www.global-briefing.org/2012/07/moving-sport-into-the-political-arena/

The Commonwealth, much like the Royal Family, are good at grand statements, and less good at anything concrete.

It usually takes time for organisations with lots of members or countries with large populations to effect change.

Much smaller organisations and countries are able to effect change faster due to their small size.

But that's not a strong argument for disbanding the Commonwealth as everything you can think of in life has drawbacks to go with benefits.

What's your point?

You asked for benefits, but, when given examples of them, you proceed to shift the goalposts which is a fallacy.

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 13:39

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet . Not at all . I know there is a difference as any of the links I powered would make clear .

This still does not negate the problematic history of the commonwealth

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:25

Here’s what Canada has to say about being in the Commonwealth

www.international.gc.ca/world-monde/international_relations-relations_internationales/multilateral-multilateraux/commonwealth.aspx?lang=eng

AlecTrevelyan006 · 16/08/2022 13:24

factoid

32 of the worlds 42 small states (countries with a population of less than 1.5million) are members of the Commonwealth.

thecommonwealth.org/our-work/small-states

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:23

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 12:57

I can see how it provides a forum to lobby the UK.

"Although the 1971 Singapore Declaration of Commonwealth Principles expressed the Commonwealth’s opposition to apartheid, it took another seven years – and the determined efforts of the international sporting community – to turn the Commonwealth’s rhetoric into action."

www.global-briefing.org/2012/07/moving-sport-into-the-political-arena/

The Commonwealth, much like the Royal Family, are good at grand statements, and less good at anything concrete.

Aside from posting about something that happened 50 years ago as ONE example of your weak argument, do you have anything more concrete and up to date to suggest the Commonwealth is all fur coat and no knickers?

I do wish you’d just admit you thought it’s the same as the British Empire

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:20

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 12:20

@MarshaMelrose so what are these benefits?

I posted upthread a link from the Australian government website listing the benefits and pride in being part of the Commonwealth.

Did you read it?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:18

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 10:14

Because the topic of the thread is the Commonwealth and if if has a place in modern society . Its history is part of that .
The royals would like to ignore its history and theirs , re slavery etc ( no , 'reflection' is not good enough).
Maybe you would also like to ignore it

Another one who is confusing the Commonwealth with the British Empire

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 13:16

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 09:28

. @Twizbe - oh the queens asked and everyone was happy to oblige . That's alright then .

@derxa - I've seen some shallow and empty headed posts from royalists on here but yours takes the biscuit. Have you read the link ? Educate yourself .

Well yeah it is alright because it’s their informed decision.

So patronising for random posters to think they know what’s better for a country than the country itself does

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 12:58

I am not a Scottish Nationalist. If you keep repeating untruths about me I will start reporting every one of your comments that does this.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 12:57

I can see how it provides a forum to lobby the UK.

"Although the 1971 Singapore Declaration of Commonwealth Principles expressed the Commonwealth’s opposition to apartheid, it took another seven years – and the determined efforts of the international sporting community – to turn the Commonwealth’s rhetoric into action."

www.global-briefing.org/2012/07/moving-sport-into-the-political-arena/

The Commonwealth, much like the Royal Family, are good at grand statements, and less good at anything concrete.

OP posts:
DownNative · 16/08/2022 12:48

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 12:20

@MarshaMelrose so what are these benefits?

The Commonwealth does have benefits for member states which is why they've joined with the most recent application having been made in 2018 which is still being decided by its members.

African States, in particular, have set out how they benefit:

  • amplifies the voice of African nations
  • provides an additional means of lobbying major donors and diplomatic players like the UK, India and Canada.
  • provides a potential framework for resolving disputes between African members.

"...the beauty of the Commonwealth is that its member states feel that they can approach each other [when serious tensions arise between them]."

  • former Ugandan Foreign Minister Martin Aliker in 2015

The above appears to be very important benefits for African nations in joining the Commonwealth.

"It’s important to remember that despite its imperial origins, the Commonwealth also has a strong radical tradition. In the 1960s and ‘70s, it played a leading role in condemning racial discrimination, most notably with its landmark Singapore Declaration of Commonwealth Principles in 1971.

In the 1980s and ’90s, it campaigned for debt relief for some of the world’s poorest nations. The organisation consists of a variety of networks developed over decades. These include a range of organisations such as the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association and the Association of Commonwealth Universities.

In recent times, campaigners have used these networks to raise awareness around climate change, LGBTQ+ rights, and other global issues. They have often challenged the policies of their own governments.

Online technology offers fresh opportunities to reinvigorate these networks by connecting grassroots activists around the world, and in the process reconnecting the Commonwealth to its radical past. If it is to continue to be relevant to Africa in the 21st century, that radicalism certainly needs to be rediscovered."

  • Philip Murphy, Director of the Institute of Commonwealth Studies; Professor of British and Commonwealth History; and Joint editor of the Journal of Imperial and Commonwealth History.

So, the Commonwealth has itself done a lot of good during the course of its own evolution.

And it will continue to evolve further as the 21st Century progresses. The benefits of its work should continue to be experienced as a result.

Of course, being a Scottish Nationalist, I'm sure you're keen to sweep this under the carpet as though it doesn't exist.....

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 12:20

@MarshaMelrose so what are these benefits?

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 16/08/2022 12:13

Of course the Commonwealth is out dated. It was based on the an attempt to unify previously exploited colonies.

This just shows a basic non-undersrandung of what the Commonwealth is today. 56 countries voluntarily joining together in a free association for the betterment of their future, both economically and politically. There is no enforced joining. Any country can leave at any time and have done. And all but one of those has asked to rejoin. I should think that those who are involved in the governance of those countries would know more about the benefits than random posters online who carry their own prejudices.

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 10:37

@Novella4 No problem.
She is just trying to undermine me.

OP posts:
Novella4 · 16/08/2022 10:36

sorry @antelopevalley I took @IcedPurple at her word re you making a mistake

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 10:31

I see some people are misquoting what I said. I said Toga and Gabon are ex-French colonies.
No mistake was made by me.
But it is easy to quote a sentence out of context i.e. They were ex-French colonies, while omitting what countries I was actually talking about. It is a well know tactic to undermine someone.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread