Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Commonwealth has had its day?

333 replies

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 12:50

The Commonwealth is a colonialist institution based on a history of conquest and slavery.

"The origins of the Commonwealth come from Britain's former Empire. Many of the members of the Commonwealth were territories which had historically come under British rule at various times by settlement, conquest or cession. The administration of such colonies evolved in different ways, to reflect the different circumstances of each territory."
www.royal.uk/commonwealth

The Commonwealth Games have never been held in an African country. Although there have been exceptions, most years it is held in Britain, Australia, New Zealand or Canada. Since 1930 it has only been held three times in other countries. Or seven countries if you include youth games and paraplegic games.

The Commonwealth has no clear role; it confers no trade privileges upon its members, does not coordinate their defence or foreign policy, and lacks both the budget and the executive authority to make a practical difference in the world.

It is a colonialist hangover that has no clear role and should be abolished.
AIBU?

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 16/08/2022 15:18

@MarieIVanArkleStinks
And yes, it does stink of the hangover of colonialism.

If it stinks of that, why do you think colonial countries want to stay in it? Why do countries want to join it? Why do countries who have left it, what to get back in it?

Is it at all possible that you actually know zippity squat about the Commonwealth of Nations and what it offers its members and are just talking out of your arkle?

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 15:17

A 'royal expert ' Richard Fitzwiliams is quoted :

While the Royal Family needed to “deal more fully with the problematic legacies of empire” such as structural racism, violence, coercion and the extraction of natural resources

Deal more fully . Someone else who recognises that 'sorrow ' isn't adequate .

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 15:13

I don't follow the royals so I could be wrong but wasn't part of the Edward and Sophie tour axed last minute once they realised they weren't wanted?

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 15:13

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:59

Because you can’t apologise on behalf of someone who has long since been dead, someone you have never ever met, without it being insincere. If I apologised on behalf of someone else that holds no water. The most sincere thing at this stage in time would be to acknowledge the wrongdoing and effects of the atrocities - which both Charles and William have done.

Beaides, let’s say they did apologise - would that change your view on the commonwealth?

You can acknowledge the part your family played in slavery.
The statement was so wishy-washy as to be menaingless.

OP posts:
MarshaMelrose · 16/08/2022 15:12

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 13:54

As I'm sure you are aware a majority of commonwealth nations are republics or do not have the queen as head of state .
Others are debating or planning to removed the British monarch as head of state .

That's as it should be because the Commonwealth is actually nothing to do with the Queen. Yes, she is the Head of it but the members could remove her if they so wish. The fact that they have chosen not to, shows their admiration and respect for her. William has already conceded that he won't be the head when he becomes king.

The new countries that have joined have their own heads of states - it's not like they're asked to swear fealty to the Queen. 🙄 The King of Malaysia and the Queen of the UK aren't duking it out in Piccadilly Square for who's the top dog monarch!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:59

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 14:54

Why does it have to be insincere?

Because you can’t apologise on behalf of someone who has long since been dead, someone you have never ever met, without it being insincere. If I apologised on behalf of someone else that holds no water. The most sincere thing at this stage in time would be to acknowledge the wrongdoing and effects of the atrocities - which both Charles and William have done.

Beaides, let’s say they did apologise - would that change your view on the commonwealth?

MarshaMelrose · 16/08/2022 14:58

The last time a country left was the Maldives in 2916, it they have since rejoined. Before that. Zimbabwe in 2003.

And Zimbabwe officially applied to rejoin in 2018.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:57

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 14:53

Well if it’s in the DM it must be true.

I was expecting a press statement from the RF website

MarshaMelrose · 16/08/2022 14:55

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 12:20

@MarshaMelrose so what are these benefits?

I've already posted several times in response to your previous posts what the benefits are. All the leaders of the countries speak in equal terms. For smaller countries, they have access to the leaders of some of the largest economies in the world and they can lobby for their interests to be put forward when those leaders meet in financial and political forums. 2.5 billion people give countries opportunities in trade. And the CW also provides support and financial assistance in developing economic development, including education. They all press for democracy and rule of law in countries and suspend countries which do not comply with their stipulations over democracy.
They have different areas of investment set up. If you're truly interested and not just wedded to the idea that you believe the Commonwealth = the British Empire, why not read about what they do? Why would countries that have gained independence from the UK and countries that were never a British colony want to be members if it didn't serve a useful purpose for them? If it truly is an outdated, pointless leftover of colonialism, why is it a growing organisation? If it serves no purpose why would all the countries that have left the Commonwealth bar one (Ireland), want to rejoin?

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 14:54

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:50

Do you want an insincere apology from someone who is barely 40 who is several generations younger than the last person who hired slaves in GB?

Would that REALLY make you feel better?

Why does it have to be insincere?

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 14:53

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:49

Did they? Do you have a source for that?

I read better ones at the time, but a 2 second google threw this up.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10770075/Prince-William-plans-modernise-monarchy-Duke-Cambridge-holds-crisis-meeting-aides.html

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:50

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 14:49

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet
Are we supposed to praise the royals for not denying historical fact?
I agree they would if they could .

'Sorrow' is not the same as openly apologising for their prominent role in slavery and exploitation

Do you want an insincere apology from someone who is barely 40 who is several generations younger than the last person who hired slaves in GB?

Would that REALLY make you feel better?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:49

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 14:48

I agree. Even William and Catherine acknowledged it had not been a success with their blaming of the palace aides.

Did they? Do you have a source for that?

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 14:49

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet
Are we supposed to praise the royals for not denying historical fact?
I agree they would if they could .

'Sorrow' is not the same as openly apologising for their prominent role in slavery and exploitation

antelopevalley · 16/08/2022 14:48

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/08/2022 14:19

That was but one of all the Commonwealth and other international tours done to mark the Platinum Jubilee.

Even that one was for the most part exceptional and successful, with large crowds turning out and positive local press coverage.

I'm unsure how anyone could possibly follow that tour and draw the conclusion that it was for the most part 'successful'.

It was an unmitigated disaster and embarrassed this nation on an international stage.

I agree. Even William and Catherine acknowledged it had not been a success with their blaming of the palace aides.

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:47

*2016 not 2916 🤣

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:46

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 14:15

Such as? Or do you mean problematic history of BE?
@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet

if you read the link the commonwealth and apartheid is examined in some detail.

And if you want something more up to date, the royal family's failure to address their links to hundreds of years of slavery and colonialism.
'Sorrow ' and a bit of 'reflection' don't cut it

The RF doesn’t deny their links to slavery.

What do you expect them to actually do - turn back time?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:45

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/08/2022 14:13

From what I can see it's unfolding organically anyway. As far as those member states which have Elizabeth Windsor as their unelected Head of State are concerned, I suspect once her time is done it will end with a whimper, not a bang. More and more member states will quietly fall off the edge as a process of evolution, rather than revolution. Ironically, that has usually been the British way.

William and Kate, with that disastrous, misguided, patronizing 'tour', hastened the end of Jamaica's membership. The influence of China, undesirable though that may be to the West, will likely hasten others on the back of Barbados. Australia's republic referendum only voted to keep Queenie as their Head of State by the skin of its teeth, and that was as long ago as 1999. Once Charles is at the helm, if he manages to stay upright and keep off the sauce for as long as five years we'll see what they think to him then. There is of course always the possibility that citizens of the UK will want to rethink our own constitution.

And yes, it does stink of the hangover of colonialism. There will be some interesting questions asked and some local and global changes after our current Head of State's time is past, is my prediction.

Jamaica has not ended their membership on the Commonwealth.

The last time a country left was the Maldives in 2916, it they have since rejoined. Before that. Zimbabwe in 2003.

Not sure why people are taking like it’s rats leaving a sinking ship

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/08/2022 14:41

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 14:01

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet what do you think it indicates lol?
They do not want the queen as head of state .

I think only 15 of the commonwealth countries retain the queen as head of state .
If you a small country ( and many are very small) they may feel they benefit from being connected .
They do not need the queen as head of the commonwealth and as indicated below , may not continue with the link .

There is a lot of unhappiness brewing as the disastrous W and K trip highlighted

Yes, well done. It you seem to be implying that signifies more?

By unhappiness brewing do you mean 1 country has made noises about removing the Queen as HoS? What do you think they will do? Because it seems Commonwealth countries are happy being in the Commonwealth

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/08/2022 14:19

That was but one of all the Commonwealth and other international tours done to mark the Platinum Jubilee.

Even that one was for the most part exceptional and successful, with large crowds turning out and positive local press coverage.

I'm unsure how anyone could possibly follow that tour and draw the conclusion that it was for the most part 'successful'.

It was an unmitigated disaster and embarrassed this nation on an international stage.

Luredbyapomegranate · 16/08/2022 14:18

Countries can just not be in it if they want?

I am not sure they need your help deciding.

It will gradually fade away like anything.

The games will be around for a good while I’d think.

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 14:17

@MarieIVanArkleStinks
You put it much better than I did .
'The stink of colonialism' exactly .

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 14:15

Such as? Or do you mean problematic history of BE?
@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet

if you read the link the commonwealth and apartheid is examined in some detail.

And if you want something more up to date, the royal family's failure to address their links to hundreds of years of slavery and colonialism.
'Sorrow ' and a bit of 'reflection' don't cut it

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/08/2022 14:13

From what I can see it's unfolding organically anyway. As far as those member states which have Elizabeth Windsor as their unelected Head of State are concerned, I suspect once her time is done it will end with a whimper, not a bang. More and more member states will quietly fall off the edge as a process of evolution, rather than revolution. Ironically, that has usually been the British way.

William and Kate, with that disastrous, misguided, patronizing 'tour', hastened the end of Jamaica's membership. The influence of China, undesirable though that may be to the West, will likely hasten others on the back of Barbados. Australia's republic referendum only voted to keep Queenie as their Head of State by the skin of its teeth, and that was as long ago as 1999. Once Charles is at the helm, if he manages to stay upright and keep off the sauce for as long as five years we'll see what they think to him then. There is of course always the possibility that citizens of the UK will want to rethink our own constitution.

And yes, it does stink of the hangover of colonialism. There will be some interesting questions asked and some local and global changes after our current Head of State's time is past, is my prediction.

Novella4 · 16/08/2022 14:01

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet what do you think it indicates lol?
They do not want the queen as head of state .

I think only 15 of the commonwealth countries retain the queen as head of state .
If you a small country ( and many are very small) they may feel they benefit from being connected .
They do not need the queen as head of the commonwealth and as indicated below , may not continue with the link .

There is a lot of unhappiness brewing as the disastrous W and K trip highlighted

Swipe left for the next trending thread