Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the Commonwealth has had its day?

333 replies

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 12:50

The Commonwealth is a colonialist institution based on a history of conquest and slavery.

"The origins of the Commonwealth come from Britain's former Empire. Many of the members of the Commonwealth were territories which had historically come under British rule at various times by settlement, conquest or cession. The administration of such colonies evolved in different ways, to reflect the different circumstances of each territory."
www.royal.uk/commonwealth

The Commonwealth Games have never been held in an African country. Although there have been exceptions, most years it is held in Britain, Australia, New Zealand or Canada. Since 1930 it has only been held three times in other countries. Or seven countries if you include youth games and paraplegic games.

The Commonwealth has no clear role; it confers no trade privileges upon its members, does not coordinate their defence or foreign policy, and lacks both the budget and the executive authority to make a practical difference in the world.

It is a colonialist hangover that has no clear role and should be abolished.
AIBU?

OP posts:
drbuzzaro · 15/08/2022 16:04

Maireas · 15/08/2022 16:01

Well, his argument seemed to blame the British for it in some countries, so I don't know how he accounts for it in others.
Also, they have had a few decades to get rid. The UK isn't stopping them.

he was talking about commonwealth countries, why does he need to account for other countries? Obviously they have there own history and their own causes for honophobia

Maireas · 15/08/2022 16:01

drbuzzaro · 15/08/2022 16:00

no one is saying all homophobia everywhere is a result of British colonialism

Well, his argument seemed to blame the British for it in some countries, so I don't know how he accounts for it in others.
Also, they have had a few decades to get rid. The UK isn't stopping them.

Runwalkskijump · 15/08/2022 16:01

SleeplessInEngland · 15/08/2022 15:55

Hey, I'm not criticising him. He was right the first time.

So when you lose you can bad mouth something, when you win you can shout it's the best thing since sliced bread.

He was angry because he lost. Nothing to do with how he felt. If he was that against it he wouldn't have competed, if it's 'only the comminwealth games' (he didn't have to he isn't at the Europeans) and he wouldn't have made the fuss he did when he won.

iwishiwasafish · 15/08/2022 16:00

How would you propose to “get rid of it” then OP?

How do you get rid of an entirely voluntary collective? Ban it? Make it illegal under international law? What would the punishment be for being in a commonwealth? Would it also apply to other commonwealths? (The one you take exception to is not the only one in existence you know.)

drbuzzaro · 15/08/2022 16:00

Maireas · 15/08/2022 15:45

So he said. How does he explain Iran, Russia, or any number of hostile nations to his sexuality?
You can blame Britain if you like, but they're not responsible for gays being tortured and executed in nations with which they had no connection.

no one is saying all homophobia everywhere is a result of British colonialism

Maireas · 15/08/2022 15:57

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 15:54

I think she went on a bit of a personal woke crusade and confused the Commonwealth with the British Empire. And Harry, hardly the sharpest tool in the box, didn’t bother to tell her they’re not the same

I absolutely agree. I think that (like many on here) she has mistaken the Commonwealth for the British Empire.

SleeplessInEngland · 15/08/2022 15:55

Runwalkskijump · 15/08/2022 15:51

He'd just lost his title and pushed out of the medals by his mates. (Who was stood next to him when he made it)

Hardly the best statement to make at the time. It came accross as bitter.

He certainly didn't think that way when he won later in the week.

Hey, I'm not criticising him. He was right the first time.

MrsOwainGlyndŵr · 15/08/2022 15:54

Iamthewombat · 15/08/2022 12:52

Well the Barbadians certainly agree with you! As do the Jamaicans, judging by the scenes on that royal visit earlier in the year.

Barbados is still in the Commonwealth

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 15:54

Maireas · 15/08/2022 15:41

I know.
My point was that at some point she must have agreed with it. Also Harry.
Why they altered their thinking is anyone's guess.

I think she went on a bit of a personal woke crusade and confused the Commonwealth with the British Empire. And Harry, hardly the sharpest tool in the box, didn’t bother to tell her they’re not the same

MrsOwainGlyndŵr · 15/08/2022 15:53

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 12:55

The Commonwealth is not the same as the British Empire. It’s voluntary membership and those countries can opt out if they wish, and many have before now!

And some, which were never part of the Empire, have joined.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 15:52

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 15:38

Britain generally looks too much at the past and not the future. The Commonwealth is an example of that.

In what way does the Commonwealth focus on the past?

Runwalkskijump · 15/08/2022 15:51

SleeplessInEngland · 15/08/2022 15:41

He meant it at the time though.

He'd just lost his title and pushed out of the medals by his mates. (Who was stood next to him when he made it)

Hardly the best statement to make at the time. It came accross as bitter.

He certainly didn't think that way when he won later in the week.

Maireas · 15/08/2022 15:51

I think it's a bit racist to think that African, Asian and Caribbean countries are too daft to leave the Commonwealth if they wanted to, or that only persecute gays because the British told them to in 1894.

MarshaMelrose · 15/08/2022 15:49

Britain generally looks too much at the past and not the future. The Commonwealth is an example of that.

OMG. The Commonwealth is the future. It rose out of colonialism but is now an equality of nations. Or do you think these countries are so incompetent or stupid that they're staying in an organisation that is against their interests?

MarshaMelrose · 15/08/2022 15:45

AndreaC74 · 15/08/2022 15:34

So very much second string then?

England spends too much time looking back at its past and not enough looking forward.

Thats the problem with the Commonwealth & of course poor countries want to belong to an organisation headed by a few very rich countries but how many of these developing Commonwealth countries are supporting the UK etc against Putin?

Very few, India is actively supporting Russia with trade that we have banned, as is most of the African states.

Of course it's second string to the Olympics or the World Championships. 🙄 So are the European Championships, African championships etc, but it doesn't make them unworthwhile.

The Commonwealth og Nations is not a dictatorship. Countries are allowed to make their own foreign policy decision according to their countries interests. You'd think that people who make it out as a colonial, repressive organisation would be pleased about that!

Maireas · 15/08/2022 15:45

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 15:36

Those laws were introduced as a direct result of colonialism.

So he said. How does he explain Iran, Russia, or any number of hostile nations to his sexuality?
You can blame Britain if you like, but they're not responsible for gays being tortured and executed in nations with which they had no connection.

Maireas · 15/08/2022 15:41

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 15:37

I know.
My point was that at some point she must have agreed with it. Also Harry.
Why they altered their thinking is anyone's guess.

SleeplessInEngland · 15/08/2022 15:41

PaddingtonBearStareAgain · 15/08/2022 15:19

Which he then sincerely apologised for.

He meant it at the time though.

AllPowerfulLizardPerson · 15/08/2022 15:39

So very much second string then?

Only in the sense that everything that’s not a world championships or the olympics is second string.

Though looking at the size, scope and achievments of the Commonwealth Games compared to those two and other regional games it’s very much

  1. Olympics

  2. individual sports world championships

  3. Commonwealth Games

  4. the rest

Namenic · 15/08/2022 15:39

For people who think it is outdated, do you think the positive things it does (eg election observation, collaboration on education) are insignificant? Or do you think that it would be better if a different membership body did these things (or already does)?

derxa · 15/08/2022 15:39

So very much second string then?
Did you actually watch any of it? The athletics? Jam packed with world class athletes.

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 15:38

AndreaC74 · 15/08/2022 15:34

So very much second string then?

England spends too much time looking back at its past and not enough looking forward.

Thats the problem with the Commonwealth & of course poor countries want to belong to an organisation headed by a few very rich countries but how many of these developing Commonwealth countries are supporting the UK etc against Putin?

Very few, India is actively supporting Russia with trade that we have banned, as is most of the African states.

Britain generally looks too much at the past and not the future. The Commonwealth is an example of that.

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 15:37

Maireas · 15/08/2022 14:55

Meghan had all the flowers of the Commonwealth embroidered on her wedding veil.
I know they're no longer doing the job, but H and M were keen to take on a Commonwealth role, so it can't all be a bad thing.

Really? As they seem to share the same views as the OP amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2020/jul/06/harry-and-meghan-say-commonwealth-must-acknowledge-the-past

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 15:36

Maireas · 15/08/2022 15:26

I watched it, but his argument made no sense. How come the UK doesn't persecute gay people, if it is at the heart of the commonwealth and the originator of the Empire?
How come you can be executed for homosexuality in countries which are not in the commonwealth and in some countries which have never been in the Empire ?
I found his argument to be deeply flawed because there isn't really a link.

Those laws were introduced as a direct result of colonialism.

OP posts:
AndreaC74 · 15/08/2022 15:34

MarshaMelrose · 15/08/2022 15:28

In some sports, athletes would never have a chance of winning when competing with certain countries like the USA or China. This gives an opportunity to many athletes to compete and win on an international stage. In some sports, there is already dominance by commonwealth countries and, again, it gives youngsters to compete and progress through rounds to run with heroes of theirs.

So very much second string then?

England spends too much time looking back at its past and not enough looking forward.

Thats the problem with the Commonwealth & of course poor countries want to belong to an organisation headed by a few very rich countries but how many of these developing Commonwealth countries are supporting the UK etc against Putin?

Very few, India is actively supporting Russia with trade that we have banned, as is most of the African states.

Swipe left for the next trending thread