Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing "cool girl" or "cool wife" used as an insult

313 replies

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 11:08

I have been on a few threads recently where some posters have been really quite cruel to other posters, including me, for having different boundaries and preferences than they do.

The terms "cool girl" or "cool wife" are slung at them, with the implication made (sometimes directly) that said "cool" person doesn't really do/feel/enjoy the way the say they do, and are just trying to be cool.

Everyone has different boundaries, experiences, cultural influences, relationships, ages, backgrounds, etc- why is it not okay for one person to find for example strippers okay within their marriage and others not to, without the former being accused of being part of the "cool wives brigade".

Is it really that hard for people to understand and accept that we all have different boundaries and lines in the sand?

It really makes me angry and I find it just another way in which woman choose to tear other women down, when what we need to do is support one another.

OP posts:
SunnyD44 · 15/08/2022 13:18

It’s increasingly used here as a way to shut down other opinions.

I agree.

The same women also say the views are misogynistic to try and shut you down and make you feel ashamed for not being a good enough women.
When actually its misogynistic to think women should all have the same boundaries.

I’m not a fan of other terms that are thrown around either and I think they’re too overused but things like ‘pearl clutcher’ just means you’re a bit uptight whereas ‘cool wife’ means you basically have no boundaries and let your partner walk all over you, which is really offensive.

I agree with PPs that have said they’ve been called a cool wife and prude multiple times, depending on what boundary it is and what poster replies.
So as PPs have said these terms are never helpful.

Chubarubrub · 15/08/2022 13:17

I think it’s gender stereotyping. You can’t honestly like football? You’re just pretending to appease your man and be seen as a ‘cool girl’ I think it’s quite regressive actually.

waterlego · 15/08/2022 13:16

Happy Birthday @foxlover47!

BronwenFrideswide · 15/08/2022 13:13

I haven't noticed that.

Really @11GrumpsaGrumping ? You've never seen posters who are fine with porn telling women who are not that they are just uncool, pearl clutchers? You've even admitted you've seen the term Pearl Clutcher used against other posters, I fear you are being deliberately disingenuous.

You said this:

Is it really that hard for people to understand and accept that we all have different boundaries and lines in the sand?

and can't seem to see the glaring irony in that statement when those whose boundaries encompass porn and strippers attempt to shame posters who don't into accepting their view by insulting and dismissing them.

foxlover47 · 15/08/2022 13:13

I'm 48 today ! I feel a bit confused ... so if you're calling someone a "cool girl" it means you're basically saying they're a anything goes type who doesn't mind their partner going to strip clubs, not being at home to help with the kids at night , into porn , drinks a pint sort of thing ?
Is that also like a "pick me" who will do anything to keep / get the partner despite not being
Comfortable ?
So if say I would be angry my man is spending all weekend in the pub not helping at home that would make me a "uncool wife "
Wtaf

gnilliwdog · 15/08/2022 13:07

@NCHammer2022 Good post.

GiantSpaceHamster · 15/08/2022 13:06

housemaus · 15/08/2022 11:20

The original meaning of it (as a PP has pointed out, where it's used to make an OP feel shit for their response to a situation) had a use, but you're right - now it's just used to slag off anyone who doesn't have an 'appropriately' buttoned-up response to something.

I've seen it on threads about everything from parenting choices to sexual preference to how people communicate and the message seems to be: if you do things differently to the MN general consensus, you're obviously doing so to pander to men. Which is far more regressive than they realise, I think, and just says "I don't believe women have agency".

It’s like everything else we see (such as narcissist, gaslighting) where it has an actual meaning but people start throwing it around everywhere instead.

sunglassesonthetable · 15/08/2022 13:05

It’s increasingly used here as a way to shut down other opinions. It’s lazy, reductionist shit. It requires an unthinking, obedient conformity with a particular set of views being espoused. I read it and think ‘idiot’.

Yep like all the other monikers.

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 13:05

AdamRyan · 15/08/2022 13:01

Replying to someone and telling them what they have posted about a different thread is making this a TAAT

Obviously there were different perspectives on that thread. People can read it and see what side they are on. However you've chosen to insult me for pointing thar out. On a thread where OP is....complaining about being insulted for having a different opinion

I'm not responding to your personal attacks any more

There have been literally no personal attacks against you. There was a very disingenuous description of the other thread, and then you being upset when you were politely corrected.It is exactly as described; the people saying they enjoyed it were responding to a poster categorically stating that no-one did.

10HailMarys · 15/08/2022 13:04

PollyRockets · 15/08/2022 12:45

@Fluffymule
Not sure if you've done it intentionally but you've seriously misrepresented that anal sex thread

People only started saying they enjoy it when the first few posters came on stating it's a fact no woman actually likes it, and any who do, are just handmaidens.

And some posters did judge, saying women who enjoyed anal were disgusting, the terms they used to describe them too 'fighting for the right to shove shit up your dirty arse'

And openly admitted they were judging because apparently it's a good 'tool'

Yes, this is exactly it. There is a certain type of Mumsnetter who thinks anyone who doesn't feel the same way as them about certain things must somehow be brainwashed by the patriarchy. It's incredibly patronising and it reeks of internalised misogyny.

midsomermurderess · 15/08/2022 13:03

It’s increasingly used here as a way to shut down other opinions. It’s lazy, reductionist shit. It requires an unthinking, obedient conformity with a particular set of views being espoused. I read it and think ‘idiot’.

waterlego · 15/08/2022 13:02

@djdkdkddkek I must admit that the ‘cool girl’ monologue in Gone Girl was a bit of a lightbulb moment for me, personally. As a younger women, I had often bitten my tongue, blurred my own boundaries and put up with a lot of shit so that men would like me.

But I’m not suggesting that all women who have different boundaries to me are in that same boat. I suspect some are, but I’m not inside other people’s heads so I can’t presume to know what’s really going on there.

AdamRyan · 15/08/2022 13:02

NCHammer2022 · 15/08/2022 13:01

Rough sex is a difficult one because I do accept that there are some women who will genuinely enjoy it, and I don’t want to kink shame. But to women overall it’s undoubtedly a harmful development that more and more men are demanding and expecting it as the norm in heterosexual relationships and I really don’t think that’s anything to be celebrated.

I kind of think the onus is on those who do, for example, enjoy rough sex, lap dancing clubs, pornography etc to understand that they might well be the outliers and it’s not necessarily a common desire. It’s not “prudish” or “pearl clutching” to not like those things, it’s those women who do who are the ones at the extreme.

And that’s assuming that the posters being accused of being cool girls actually do like these things in the first place. Women are very capable of convincing themselves they are ok with something when they might actually not be. I went to a lap dancing club myself in my 20s, because I was trying to impress my boyfriend. I pretended to enjoy certain sex acts, pretended to want to watch porn while having sex, etc. I didn’t enjoy any of it, really. I’m sure I’d have objected to being a cool girl back then but that is absolutely what I was doing. A decade on with a better relationship, a bit more wisdom and stronger boundaries I can see that clearly but I couldn’t at the time. I’m furious at 20-something me for being part of normalising stuff that is damaging to women as a whole. This isn’t to deny women agency over their own likes and dislikes and boundaries which may be different to mine, it’s recognising that we all make our choices within a context and subject to particular influences.

On balance of harms I’d rather a few women get pissed off by being called a cool girl than a generation of girls get the impression there’s something wrong with them if they don’t enjoy rough sex and lap dancing clubs.

That’s a bit rambling, I’m not sure I’m explaining myself well.

Great Post- I wholeheartedly agree

Glitteratitar · 15/08/2022 13:01

10HailMarys · 15/08/2022 12:58

YANBU at all. There are definitely people on Mumsnet who seem to think it's a betrayal of the sisterhood if you don't have the same views as them on certain issues, particularly when it comes to the behaviour of partners. There are some women on Mumsnet who seem to think that you are some sort of 'Cool Wife' who desperately wants men to like her if:

  • You don't hate porn
  • You don't mind your partner having female friends
  • You don't think it's a big deal if your partner goes to a strip club
  • You share your partner's keen interest in football
  • You don't expect your partner to keep in constant contact with you on a stag weekend
etc etc. It really annoys me. For example, I actually would definitely be annoyed if my DP went to strip clubs. That's one of my boundaries. But I don't make weird judgements about women who would be totally OK with this! We all have different lines that we draw in the sand, and that's fine.

I do think there are definitely women who are desperate for men's approval and also have a lot of internalised misogyny going on, so want to prove that they are 'not like other girls' to make men like them. Those women do exist. But yeah, on Mumsnet when people start throwing around the 'cool wife' or 'pick me girl' stuff around, it's invariably just because they think everyone should have exactly the same boundaries or interests that they do.

Exactly this. Any woman who is ok with such things is often called a cool wife. It’s insulting and unnecessary.

AdamRyan · 15/08/2022 13:01

PollyRockets · 15/08/2022 12:56

@AdamRyan

You mentioned not making this a TAAT

When I was merely replying to someone who had already done that

Hence not reading properly

Something you tried arguing before you didn't do

Laughable

Replying to someone and telling them what they have posted about a different thread is making this a TAAT

Obviously there were different perspectives on that thread. People can read it and see what side they are on. However you've chosen to insult me for pointing thar out. On a thread where OP is....complaining about being insulted for having a different opinion

I'm not responding to your personal attacks any more

NCHammer2022 · 15/08/2022 13:01

Rough sex is a difficult one because I do accept that there are some women who will genuinely enjoy it, and I don’t want to kink shame. But to women overall it’s undoubtedly a harmful development that more and more men are demanding and expecting it as the norm in heterosexual relationships and I really don’t think that’s anything to be celebrated.

I kind of think the onus is on those who do, for example, enjoy rough sex, lap dancing clubs, pornography etc to understand that they might well be the outliers and it’s not necessarily a common desire. It’s not “prudish” or “pearl clutching” to not like those things, it’s those women who do who are the ones at the extreme.

And that’s assuming that the posters being accused of being cool girls actually do like these things in the first place. Women are very capable of convincing themselves they are ok with something when they might actually not be. I went to a lap dancing club myself in my 20s, because I was trying to impress my boyfriend. I pretended to enjoy certain sex acts, pretended to want to watch porn while having sex, etc. I didn’t enjoy any of it, really. I’m sure I’d have objected to being a cool girl back then but that is absolutely what I was doing. A decade on with a better relationship, a bit more wisdom and stronger boundaries I can see that clearly but I couldn’t at the time. I’m furious at 20-something me for being part of normalising stuff that is damaging to women as a whole. This isn’t to deny women agency over their own likes and dislikes and boundaries which may be different to mine, it’s recognising that we all make our choices within a context and subject to particular influences.

On balance of harms I’d rather a few women get pissed off by being called a cool girl than a generation of girls get the impression there’s something wrong with them if they don’t enjoy rough sex and lap dancing clubs.

That’s a bit rambling, I’m not sure I’m explaining myself well.

Glitteratitar · 15/08/2022 13:00

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 15/08/2022 12:54

It’s usually reserved for the women who are super casual about their DHs getting a stripper or going out every night to the pub while she puts the kids to bed, or who are happy for them to spend 12 hours each Saturday and Sunday playing golf. And it’s usually those women who are putting down the women who object to these things.

Actually no. There was a thread a while back because her husband was out, which he didn’t often do, and she was annoyed that he didn’t check in with her throughout the night. I was called a cool wife for saying she’s verging on controlling behaviour and he’s not done anything wrong.

It’s used by many MNers against women who have different views when it comes to something a man does.

Crikeyalmighty · 15/08/2022 13:00

I think @ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler has it bang on. It's not because of the differing boundaries, it's because many of those with differing boundaries seem to feel that those of us who have different boundaries should act/think like them and make their view known and the rest of us are just fussing about nothing and are seriously 'uncool' -

waterlego · 15/08/2022 12:58

@sunglassesonthetable and @queenMab99, yes, agree.

I think it’s what sometimes happens when posters respond quickly and reactively. A poster feels insulted or angry and immediately posts a reply. I have often got over invested in MN threads (and Twitter spats) and I try really hard these days to take some deep breaths, close the browser and go and do something else for a while so that I can collect my thoughts and try to come back later with a measured response. (Not saying I always succeed, mind you!)

10HailMarys · 15/08/2022 12:58

YANBU at all. There are definitely people on Mumsnet who seem to think it's a betrayal of the sisterhood if you don't have the same views as them on certain issues, particularly when it comes to the behaviour of partners. There are some women on Mumsnet who seem to think that you are some sort of 'Cool Wife' who desperately wants men to like her if:

  • You don't hate porn
  • You don't mind your partner having female friends
  • You don't think it's a big deal if your partner goes to a strip club
  • You share your partner's keen interest in football
  • You don't expect your partner to keep in constant contact with you on a stag weekend
etc etc. It really annoys me. For example, I actually would definitely be annoyed if my DP went to strip clubs. That's one of my boundaries. But I don't make weird judgements about women who would be totally OK with this! We all have different lines that we draw in the sand, and that's fine.

I do think there are definitely women who are desperate for men's approval and also have a lot of internalised misogyny going on, so want to prove that they are 'not like other girls' to make men like them. Those women do exist. But yeah, on Mumsnet when people start throwing around the 'cool wife' or 'pick me girl' stuff around, it's invariably just because they think everyone should have exactly the same boundaries or interests that they do.

PollyRockets · 15/08/2022 12:56

@AdamRyan

You mentioned not making this a TAAT

When I was merely replying to someone who had already done that

Hence not reading properly

Something you tried arguing before you didn't do

Laughable

djdkdkddkek · 15/08/2022 12:56

I really appreciated the cool girl/cool wife insult. Once I properly looked into what it meant I realised it’s what I did. Just totally pretended all these things were “cool and ok” because I believed that I was supposed to find them “cool and ok” and the fact that I didn’t was some kind of character flaw in me? I was too insecure, too jealous, not open minded enough and blah blah

but reading the cool wife definition was just so enlightening to me and I loved that actually, I wasn’t “uncool” for not wanting any guy drooling over half naked pics online, or embarrassing me

and also, I need to show my son that women are worthy of being treated with dignity. How am I showing that if I put up with any old male-identified shit? Nah.

I love the phrase! And the more of us who are triggered by it… the more of us need it.

HannahSternDefoe · 15/08/2022 12:56

I was hoping for some tips about keeping cool...being peri and overweight...
Sometimes this world speaks a language I don't understand.

sunglassesonthetable · 15/08/2022 12:55

Oh yes, that's another one . Karen

But more mainstream and tends to get picked up and told off on MN.

PollyRockets · 15/08/2022 12:55

queenMab99 · 15/08/2022 12:53

Name calling instead of sensible debate helps no one, whether it is Cool Wife, Karen, or any of the other shorthand terms for people we disagree with.

It's telling that the only insults you'll get banned for using on MN are aligned with a certain type of user

I've often asked for it to be broadened to include the frankly misogynistic terms such as handmaiden but they refuse to....

Swipe left for the next trending thread