Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing "cool girl" or "cool wife" used as an insult

313 replies

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 11:08

I have been on a few threads recently where some posters have been really quite cruel to other posters, including me, for having different boundaries and preferences than they do.

The terms "cool girl" or "cool wife" are slung at them, with the implication made (sometimes directly) that said "cool" person doesn't really do/feel/enjoy the way the say they do, and are just trying to be cool.

Everyone has different boundaries, experiences, cultural influences, relationships, ages, backgrounds, etc- why is it not okay for one person to find for example strippers okay within their marriage and others not to, without the former being accused of being part of the "cool wives brigade".

Is it really that hard for people to understand and accept that we all have different boundaries and lines in the sand?

It really makes me angry and I find it just another way in which woman choose to tear other women down, when what we need to do is support one another.

OP posts:
WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 13:47

@WalkingOnTheCracks last post is a classic DARVO. It uses progressive language (language developed in order to fight inequality) and turns it on those who are pointing out that women are oppressed and abused. It claims that those who are pointing out structural abuse are actually the abusers - that the very act of naming abuse is abusive to those who are abused.

It's nuts; it has an agenda, and the agenda is to make sure women STFU by spreading uncertainty and confusion.

It's also the language of Trump, Bolsonaro, and other populist 'radical' individualist ideologues/demagogues.

Luredbyapomegranate · 15/08/2022 13:46

Hobbesmanc · 15/08/2022 11:20

meh. It's just like the yummy mummies, Hand Maids, Serena Joys, Pearl Clutchers. Meaningless clichés that we use to put down women

I think it shows a lack of imagination to be honest

A bit of this, it’s kind of lazy.

But it’s like anything, sometimes the accused might be defending the indefensible, or telling another poster they can’t have different boundaries.

Or sometimes they are being totally reasonable and the person calling them that is rude or a nutter that checks their husband’s phone hourly, or has a lot of internalised misogyny.

Overall I just think you need to be robust and call it when you think it’s bollocks. This is a debate forum so there will be disagreement, and I don’t think women supporting women means they need to agree or always Be Kind.

sunglassesonthetable · 15/08/2022 13:46

OP has got her arse out because someone said "you're so cool" - I think its been deleted now

Fab! Nuanced discussion 👍🏻

Crikeyalmighty · 15/08/2022 13:46

@BronwenFrideswide 100% agree. My biggie is that so many things are sexualised these days that there seems very little room for romance or build up

It got to the point with regards to porn and secrecy that I thought maybe it was just me having an issue - had a chat with a few friends, out of 6 of us varying from 37 to 62 in age, only 2 wouldn't have an issue with it in a long term live in relationship - and 1 of those said she would have an issue if it was more than a couple of times a week at most.

If both people in a relationship are ok with it and it's not all a big secret then I'm fine with that , but so often this isn't the case. Same goes with most sex industry stuff !

AdamRyan · 15/08/2022 13:44

123ROLO · 15/08/2022 13:31

I think there's two extremes and neither are right.

There's the complete opposite of the 'cool wife' who gets angry if their parents even so much as mention another woman's name.

And there's the trying too hard 'cool wife' who is okay with things I just don't understand, and to be honest I doubt the commitment to the marriage/relationship for being okay with certain things.

I'm guessing this is bought on by the lap dance post.

I think of myself as fairly easy going. My boyfriend has many female friends, he will go out with them, show friendly affection towards them, he enjoys their company and they bring him a lot of joy. I do not have an ounce of jealousy or worry when he has plans with them.

But the thought of him sat there, with an erection, naked woman's boobs in his face and getting sexual gratification of another woman makes me feel sick. To me it undoes the years of commitment between us. And to push that this is okay as its 'just what guys do on stag do's' isn't ok, it's gross.

Unless you have some pre discussed open marriage type thing then maybe thats different. But in a committed loving monogamous relationship, I don't think any man or woman should enjoy another person's body in the flesh sexually or romantically.

It's actually this thread

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4609773-porn-culture-has-led-to-women-suffering-injuries-during-sex?page=1

OP has got her arse out because someone said "you're so cool" - I think its been deleted now

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 15/08/2022 13:43

VladmirsPoutine · 15/08/2022 13:41

No I don't think we should support all women just because they are women. Theresa May and Priti Patel are two politicians who've done unspeakably cruel things. I don't support them.

But re the cool girl / wife thing I do genuinely think people have different boundaries which some might find odd but doesn't make it unhealthy.

You see I do think the lack of concern about the damage the "sex industry" does to all women is unhealthy and damaging to all women.

BronwenFrideswide · 15/08/2022 13:42

However I personally think porn , strip clubs , the "sex industry" harms all women. I won't call women who think these are fun / "empowering" "a choice" , insert cliché of choice -"cool girls".

I will however criticise such misguided and dangerous views and certainly won't support women who hold these views just because they are women.

I agree with you @TheLassWiADelicateAir and it's amazing how defensive they get when challenged or criticised.

AdamRyan · 15/08/2022 13:42

Chubarubrub · 15/08/2022 13:27

Reducing it to liking football is a very easy way of trying to sweep the whole concept under a rug. It’s minimising it without actually engaging in the topic.

I wasn’t actively trying to reduce it, see my comment above. I think I’ve misunderstood the meaning.

genius.com/Gillian-flynn-gone-girl-cool-girl-monologue-book-annotated

I recognise the behaviours she describes but I also think its over used as an insult

VladmirsPoutine · 15/08/2022 13:41

No I don't think we should support all women just because they are women. Theresa May and Priti Patel are two politicians who've done unspeakably cruel things. I don't support them.

But re the cool girl / wife thing I do genuinely think people have different boundaries which some might find odd but doesn't make it unhealthy.

WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 13:40

The implication is that you are part of the patriarchy but can't see it.

For example -

Liberal feminist: 'It's her choice to be a lapdancer - and choice is what feminism is all about.'
Feminist: 'Choice is not what feminism is about. Absolute equality for women is what feminism is about. Choices don't happen in a vacuum - they are limited by the social structures we live in. By pretending that this is not so, you are preventing women from understanding this fact and perpetuating sex inequality.'

Patriarchy (and all structural power) must always co-opt some members of the disempowered class to police the system from within the ranks. The co-opted get special privileges (in this case, the implication is that male validation is the special prize.)

Could also substitute 'liberal feminist' or 'choice feminist' ( or 'no feminist' in my book).

I have some sympathy because it's very hard to see the air that we all breathe. And to admit that you / all of us are being abused to one degree or another. But not that much sympathy, after many decades of debating this.

One useful thought experiment is to substitute a nationality (or age group or race) for 'women' and imagine how you would view the society in which one nationality did all the domestic shitwork, all the childcare (and suffered the consequent loss of economic status and thus agency), and whose ability to consent to sex was often trampled over by the accepted 'needs' of the ruling nationality, or removed entirely by economic circumstances which favour the ruling nationality.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 15/08/2022 13:32

sunglassesonthetable · 15/08/2022 12:03

You can disagree with other posters without being nasty. It's not difficult.

Hmm not on Mumsnet.

Chucked about with Pearl clutching, Hand Maidens , Yummy Mummy.

Everyone has to be the same. Can never get over the way posters think that.

The same = the same as them

Even on threads about tree boundaries. 😂

Quite.

All those phrases, including 'Cool Girl', are ways to enforce orthodoxy. There's a faction here that are preoccupied with keeping everyone's toes firmly on the line.

Of course, they drew the line.

Onlyforcake · 15/08/2022 13:31

Being a doormat so people like you is just not good for your mental health.

But insulting someone because they are heavily conditioned to put others needs first is a bit much. It's easy to forget it's not a chosen behaviour

123ROLO · 15/08/2022 13:31

I think there's two extremes and neither are right.

There's the complete opposite of the 'cool wife' who gets angry if their parents even so much as mention another woman's name.

And there's the trying too hard 'cool wife' who is okay with things I just don't understand, and to be honest I doubt the commitment to the marriage/relationship for being okay with certain things.

I'm guessing this is bought on by the lap dance post.

I think of myself as fairly easy going. My boyfriend has many female friends, he will go out with them, show friendly affection towards them, he enjoys their company and they bring him a lot of joy. I do not have an ounce of jealousy or worry when he has plans with them.

But the thought of him sat there, with an erection, naked woman's boobs in his face and getting sexual gratification of another woman makes me feel sick. To me it undoes the years of commitment between us. And to push that this is okay as its 'just what guys do on stag do's' isn't ok, it's gross.

Unless you have some pre discussed open marriage type thing then maybe thats different. But in a committed loving monogamous relationship, I don't think any man or woman should enjoy another person's body in the flesh sexually or romantically.

BronwenFrideswide · 15/08/2022 13:30

When a poster says they are unhappy with their partners use of porn or prostitutes or visiting strip clubs or having lap dances or wanting anal sex or rough sex which the poster doesn't want/enjoy exactly what is the point of other posters coming on and saying how happy they personally are with any or all of the above and perhaps the poster complaining should stop being such a prude?

Frankly posters who do that are just bragging/showing off and wanting adulation for being so, um cool, enlightened, not like those stuffy vanilla pearl clutchy types. They make the thread about them and their preferences/boundaries and dismiss the poster's preferences/boundaries out of hand - that is my issue. I'm not interested in their preferences or boundaries I'm interested in supporting the poster in upholding their boundaries and preferences and not being shamed or ridiculed for doing so.

Topgub · 15/08/2022 13:28

@SunnyD44

Do you think mysoginy doesn't exist? Or sexism?

MangoBiscuit · 15/08/2022 13:27

I've only seen the phrase used on MN, and I've only seen it used on threads where the OP has asked if they're UR for being upset with their partners behaviour.

It's usually along the lines of:
AIBU to be upset that DP went to a strip club?
Several posters saying no, that would be a deal breaker for me.
Some posters saying they'd have problem with it, it isn't cheating, so the OP should relax.
Those posters then get called "cool wives" etc

In that context, I'm ok with it being used. You don't get to imply that someone else's boundaries are wrong, then get huffy when your own get challenged.

Fact is, neither boundary is wrong. They're personal.

Brefugee · 15/08/2022 13:27

I think it’s gender stereotyping. You can’t honestly like football? You’re just pretending to appease your man and be seen as a ‘cool girl’ I think it’s quite regressive actually.

that is not correct use of the term Cool Girl though and would be roundly laughed at (I like football, i love beer, i love heavy metal and so on. I am not a cool girl because i don't insist that women who don't like that are stupid, type of thing)

Cool Girl (Cool Wifes) is a good shorthand to describe something that takes a couple of paragraphs, in 2 words.

And seeing it next to "Karen" up there has made me think a bit more about it. Because while i understand what "Karen" is shorthand for - i am very much against it being used, since while i know the origin is that it's about entitled white women especially shitting on black staff in shops, now it is used in an ageist and sexist and a way to put down women who have boundaries. So while i don't use Cool Wife often, i think i won't be using it again.

Chubarubrub · 15/08/2022 13:27

Reducing it to liking football is a very easy way of trying to sweep the whole concept under a rug. It’s minimising it without actually engaging in the topic.

I wasn’t actively trying to reduce it, see my comment above. I think I’ve misunderstood the meaning.

Chubarubrub · 15/08/2022 13:26

Accepting* I’m not that dense I promise 🥴

djdkdkddkek · 15/08/2022 13:26

Reducing it to liking football is a very easy way of trying to sweep the whole concept under a rug. It’s minimising it without actually engaging in the topic.

Yes it’s true many women will pretend they are fine with various personal issues because thei don’t want to alienate themselves from men and also want to be seen as so much more englightened than other women

it’s not just about supposedly enjoying football and I think we all know that

Chubarubrub · 15/08/2022 13:25

waterlego · 15/08/2022 13:20

I’ve never seen it used against a woman who likes football. I agree it’s ridiculous in that context.

It is less ridiculous when it’s used against a woman who appears to accept all manner of bad behaviour from her partner.

I agree with your point about excepting bad behaviour. I thought the ‘cool girl’ trope was coined in the Gone Girl book, which just seemed to be taking a swipe at women who drink beer and other things society deems ‘male’. I’ve probably got the wrong end of the stick though, I often do 😂

Crikeyalmighty · 15/08/2022 13:21

I used to be a very'cool wife' 100% not bothered about female friends, would have said porn didn't bother me etc

However at 60 I'm afraid I'm not so cool these days simply because I myself and friends too have been on the receiving end of some behaviour from men and husbands that was upsetting, unkind and downright disrespectful - and from men you would least expect it from too- consequently I'm far more cynical of certain behaviours because I have far more to lose in life materially than when I was far 'cooler'

In my case age and experience has changed my view.

I also think it's fine to have your own boundaries that are different to mine, but not to belittle those boundaries.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 15/08/2022 13:20

There are some women on Mumsnet who seem to think that you are some sort of 'Cool Wife' who desperately wants men to like her if:

You don't hate porn
You don't mind your partner having female friends
You don't think it's a big deal if your partner goes to a strip club
You share your partner's keen interest in football
You don't expect your partner to keep in constant contact with you on a stag weekend

Never seen the football one and of course husbandd can have female friends.

However I personally think porn , strip clubs , the "sex industry" harms all women. I won't call women who think these are fun / "empowering" "a choice" , insert cliché of choice -"cool girls".

I will however criticise such misguided and dangerous views and certainly won't support women who hold these views just because they are women.

waterlego · 15/08/2022 13:20

Chubarubrub · 15/08/2022 13:17

I think it’s gender stereotyping. You can’t honestly like football? You’re just pretending to appease your man and be seen as a ‘cool girl’ I think it’s quite regressive actually.

I’ve never seen it used against a woman who likes football. I agree it’s ridiculous in that context.

It is less ridiculous when it’s used against a woman who appears to accept all manner of bad behaviour from her partner.

foxlover47 · 15/08/2022 13:19

@waterlego thank you :) x