Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing "cool girl" or "cool wife" used as an insult

313 replies

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 11:08

I have been on a few threads recently where some posters have been really quite cruel to other posters, including me, for having different boundaries and preferences than they do.

The terms "cool girl" or "cool wife" are slung at them, with the implication made (sometimes directly) that said "cool" person doesn't really do/feel/enjoy the way the say they do, and are just trying to be cool.

Everyone has different boundaries, experiences, cultural influences, relationships, ages, backgrounds, etc- why is it not okay for one person to find for example strippers okay within their marriage and others not to, without the former being accused of being part of the "cool wives brigade".

Is it really that hard for people to understand and accept that we all have different boundaries and lines in the sand?

It really makes me angry and I find it just another way in which woman choose to tear other women down, when what we need to do is support one another.

OP posts:
WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 14:14

Just to add

Framing it as 'infidelity' rather than 'abusive and repulsive exploitation of disempowered women' is just as anti-feminist/pro-patriarchy as cool wife-ness. It's a distraction with an agenda.

Topgub · 15/08/2022 14:13

@DixonD

What does that even mean?

I know I'm not like other women?

Are all other women except you the same?

NCHammer2022 · 15/08/2022 14:12

In fact “you’re insecure” seems to be the new “you’re jealous”. Not everything is about a woman being insecure, some things are objectively detrimental to society and to women in particular and women who object to that shouldn’t be dismissed as “insecure”.

DixonD · 15/08/2022 14:10

Actually, I will add my husband has only once been in a strip club in the 16 years we’ve been together. It was my brother’s stag do and he felt so uncomfortable about looking at other women that he stood outside and waited for them to come out. I don’t describe myself as a cool wife or whatever, I’ve just got no time or inclination to get wound up about such things.

Maybe I’m not like other women? In fact I know I’m not. I’m ok with that. If you’re not…🖕

PixiePirate · 15/08/2022 14:10

I try not to call people names or trample over other people’s boundaries but I also inwardly eye roll and tbh feel really frustrated at times when some women’s views and standards have an impact on me and my life. I realise that’s my problem and my issue to deal with but I don’t have to like it.

A prime example is partners or wives who don’t have a problem with / don’t dare speak up about / pretend they don’t care when their husband pays a woman to dance naked inches from their face for the purpose of sexually arousing them. I believe that has a direct impact on my life because I work with lots of men and i believe it helps inform how much they value and respect women in the workplace and in society in general.

Yes the responsibility lies with those men and i know I can’t hold their wives and girlfriends responsible for their misogyny. However, I can’t help but feel every bit as frustrated with those women who take the ‘men will be boys’ line as you seem to feel frustrated that some other women choose not to support you in being cool with it.

At the end of the day the only ones winning here are the men.

NCHammer2022 · 15/08/2022 14:10

DixonD · 15/08/2022 14:03

Why are you being such a dick?

I genuinely do not care if my husband looks at porn. Or sees a stripper. I trust him. I’ve never looked at his phone. I’m not insecure in the slightest. I do not pander to him. We disagree over lots of things and I am not afraid to stand up to him. I was happy single, and he knows it. I don’t control him and he doesn’t control me. Cheating is a different thing. But looking at porn in my opinion, is no where near that boundary.

But you’re assuming it’s about trust or insecurity. I trust my DH (he has plenty of female friends who he spends time with without me, we sometimes holiday separately, both have a lot of independence, we have separate bank accounts and don’t use each other’s phones yada yada).

I wouldn’t be happy with him going to a strip club because then he’s supporting the sex industry which has a detrimental effect on women.

WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 14:09

Sallyh87 · 15/08/2022 13:57

I think I struggle a bit with how posters don’t recognise the impact that their words (so easily typed) might have on the person reading it. Yes, by all means disagree, it is a discussion forum, but words do have a real impact. There is a person on the other side.

Would they say such things in person?

What are people getting out of insulting someone anonymously?

The trouble is that, after millennia of this shit, feminists know that 'thinking about individuals' prevents women from seeing ourselves as a class, and from seeing the massive system under which we all are all crushed. In fact, that this is precisely the intention - what do you think 'Be Kind' is all about? It means 'STFU'.

We are socialised to care about the feelings of individuals so that we don't unite. Other forces like consumerist individualism and queer theory do the same thing - frame society as consisting of individuals, each with their own 'journey', their own struggle, their own truth, in order to distract from the fact that society is actually a system in which one large group exploits and oppresses another large group along the axes of race, class, and sex.

It really is that simple.

Thatswhyimacat · 15/08/2022 14:06

The irony is that a lot of the posters who sling 'cool wife' as an insult on these threads seem to spend a lot more time thinking about men than I do.

DixonD · 15/08/2022 14:03

UglyNameChange · 15/08/2022 11:18

Nah, YABU.

It’s a good and usefull description of certain kind of women who pander to men.

It’s goob, because we have a very long history of women having to just go along with what men want / to be okey with hiw men behave / tolerate all kinds of bullshit.
It’s really good that at least some women have woken the fuck up.

If you are talking about the lap dance thread, you can perfectly see hiw many are there right now, trying to errode women’s boundaries.
That you have to be okey with a man going into a stip club, apperently women who don’t like it are now ” conservative”.

If you are confused, read the Gone Girl monologue, it’s perfect.

Why are you being such a dick?

I genuinely do not care if my husband looks at porn. Or sees a stripper. I trust him. I’ve never looked at his phone. I’m not insecure in the slightest. I do not pander to him. We disagree over lots of things and I am not afraid to stand up to him. I was happy single, and he knows it. I don’t control him and he doesn’t control me. Cheating is a different thing. But looking at porn in my opinion, is no where near that boundary.

WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 13:59

And actually, it goes beyond DARVO because it claims not that those with power are being abused by the accusation that they abuse their power, but that those with less power are being abused by having that fact pointed out.

Teddletime · 15/08/2022 13:58

Example of the Feminist use of 'wimmin' taken from Feminist Chat,

'Today, I really needed someone by my side. I was challenging in person some pretty dubious characters in respect of speaking truth in a difficult situation (think what you like). Sent a call out for "wimmin" to stand with me what did I find? Resounding echoes of silence.......'.

Sallyh87 · 15/08/2022 13:57

I think I struggle a bit with how posters don’t recognise the impact that their words (so easily typed) might have on the person reading it. Yes, by all means disagree, it is a discussion forum, but words do have a real impact. There is a person on the other side.

Would they say such things in person?

What are people getting out of insulting someone anonymously?

Meseekslookatme · 15/08/2022 13:56

Topgub · 15/08/2022 11:12

I disagree with both cool girl as an insult and the idea that women should unilaterally support other women's choices

So much this.
I say this as someone that's been accused of "cool girl" because I enjoy masculine hobbies and anal
🙄

WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 13:56

Quick to google @sunglassesonthetable but from Wikipedia
DARVO is an acronym for "deny, attack, and reverse victim and offender". It refers to a reaction that alleged perpetrators of wrongdoing, particularly sexual offenders, may display in response to being held accountable for their behavior.[1] Some researchers and advocates have indicated that it can be as a common manipulation strategy of psychological abusers.[2][3][4] An abuser (or alleged abuser) denies the abuse ever took place, attacks the person that alleged abuse (often the victim) for attempting to hold the abuser (or alleged abuser) accountable for their actions, and claims that they are actually the victim in the situation, thus reversing what may be a reality of victim and offender.[2][4] It often involves not just "playing the victim" but also victim blaming.[3]

Thelnebriati · 15/08/2022 13:56

DARVO is an acronym - deny, accuse, reverse victim and offender. Its something abusers do when called out.

gnilliwdog · 15/08/2022 13:55

In the grand scheme of things, calling someone a cool girl is a lot less hurtful than defending choking, rough sex, trafficking, rape as those who 'enjoy' those activities, or don't mind porn, would like to do.

Teddletime · 15/08/2022 13:54

At this point I add as I always do, that I hate the fondness posters on the Feminist Boards have for the words 'wimmin' and 'menz'. They are incredibly patronising and you don't really see these terms anywhere else but on there.
As in, 'Wimmin wanting the vote '. They are clearly being sarcastic and think they are being edgy referring to 'wimmin'.
I don't get it.

OneTC · 15/08/2022 13:54

Judging people that avail themselves of the sex industry as it currently stands is a perfectly valid position. As is judging those who are bystanders to it

sunglassesonthetable · 15/08/2022 13:53

What do you mean by DARVO?

AdamRyan · 15/08/2022 13:53

BeautPomiander · 15/08/2022 13:50

This

The thread I have seen where "cool wives" comes in seem to go along these lines. But say you were to use another example:

OP - Am I unreasonable for not liking ice cream.

Poster 2 - I don't like ice cream either

Poster 3 - I'm not bothered either way, I have it occasionally when I'm in the mood, but you're not being unreasonable not to like it.

Poster 4 - I love ice cream! I don't know why you have a problem with ice cream!

Poster 4 is missing the point of the thread and seems to be have some sort of underlying motive in marketing the positives of ice-cream. The OP doesn't care about that. Other posters notice, feel that the OPs boundaries are being ignored and sweep in to fix it. That's what I see anyway a lot of the time. Poster 4 believes that they are being insulted for given their opinion/sharing their lifestyle and counter attacks. Others join in. The OP gets ignored.

If we all just took more time to listen and less time to defend what doesn't need to be defending, then Mumsnet would be a hell of a lot nicer.

Excellent post

WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 13:52

@sunglassesonthetable
"All those phrases, including 'Cool Girl', are ways to enforce orthodoxy. There's a faction here that are preoccupied with keeping everyone's toes firmly on the line.

Of course, they drew the line."

sunglassesonthetable · 15/08/2022 13:51

What's DARVO? @WinterDeWinter

Which comment did you mean?

BeautPomiander · 15/08/2022 13:50

MangoBiscuit · 15/08/2022 13:27

I've only seen the phrase used on MN, and I've only seen it used on threads where the OP has asked if they're UR for being upset with their partners behaviour.

It's usually along the lines of:
AIBU to be upset that DP went to a strip club?
Several posters saying no, that would be a deal breaker for me.
Some posters saying they'd have problem with it, it isn't cheating, so the OP should relax.
Those posters then get called "cool wives" etc

In that context, I'm ok with it being used. You don't get to imply that someone else's boundaries are wrong, then get huffy when your own get challenged.

Fact is, neither boundary is wrong. They're personal.

This

The thread I have seen where "cool wives" comes in seem to go along these lines. But say you were to use another example:

OP - Am I unreasonable for not liking ice cream.

Poster 2 - I don't like ice cream either

Poster 3 - I'm not bothered either way, I have it occasionally when I'm in the mood, but you're not being unreasonable not to like it.

Poster 4 - I love ice cream! I don't know why you have a problem with ice cream!

Poster 4 is missing the point of the thread and seems to be have some sort of underlying motive in marketing the positives of ice-cream. The OP doesn't care about that. Other posters notice, feel that the OPs boundaries are being ignored and sweep in to fix it. That's what I see anyway a lot of the time. Poster 4 believes that they are being insulted for given their opinion/sharing their lifestyle and counter attacks. Others join in. The OP gets ignored.

If we all just took more time to listen and less time to defend what doesn't need to be defending, then Mumsnet would be a hell of a lot nicer.

For · 15/08/2022 13:48

Yanbu to not want to be insulted by strangers on the internet, but yabvu to want others to never use these terms at all. They’re very useful. The first time I read the term ‘cool wife’ was in Gone Girl and I recognised so much of what she was saying. I’ve been a cool girl - in my teens / early twenties I was up for anything and would insist I loved it! As I got older I realised how often I’d done stuff I didn’t really want to do because I was lonely, insecure, and trying desperately to please men. From drinking beer (yuk), to anal sex, to body piercing, to being ‘cool’ about porn despite its exploitation and consequences, to wearing ‘sexy’ underwear that’s uncomfortable and actually turns me off… As I’ve matured I’m sad about what the young woman I was thought she ought to do, and the self delusion involved. ‘Cool girl’ as a label helps me understand what was happening to me.

Thelnebriati · 15/08/2022 13:47

In pretty much any discussion about harm to women, some random woman will pop up to announce she doesn't see a problem. If you don't like the term 'cool wives' feel free to think of an alternative you can stomach.

But we don't have to support everything women do, and a thing is not feminist just because its a woman doing it.