Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing "cool girl" or "cool wife" used as an insult

313 replies

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 11:08

I have been on a few threads recently where some posters have been really quite cruel to other posters, including me, for having different boundaries and preferences than they do.

The terms "cool girl" or "cool wife" are slung at them, with the implication made (sometimes directly) that said "cool" person doesn't really do/feel/enjoy the way the say they do, and are just trying to be cool.

Everyone has different boundaries, experiences, cultural influences, relationships, ages, backgrounds, etc- why is it not okay for one person to find for example strippers okay within their marriage and others not to, without the former being accused of being part of the "cool wives brigade".

Is it really that hard for people to understand and accept that we all have different boundaries and lines in the sand?

It really makes me angry and I find it just another way in which woman choose to tear other women down, when what we need to do is support one another.

OP posts:
Marvellousmadness · 15/08/2022 15:30

The cool wife tends to be a woman with low standards though....

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 15/08/2022 15:29

Fluffymule · 15/08/2022 14:39

I think it’s interesting that some think the ‘cool wife’ label is only used as an insult to deride someone who simply trusts their husband, they are not bothered by him using porn or visiting strip clubs because it sits within their agreed and comfortable boundaries.

There’s an argument that some of the pushback they get may come from them ignoring the implications of what exactly they are not bothered about.

For example, that the majority of porn sites feature trafficked women, rape, torture, pedophilia, revenge content. Strips clubs are not universally staffed by enthusiastic students empowered to explore their sexuality whilst paying off their student loan as often portrayed, but many are trafficked women or being worked by a pimp who takes her nightly earnings as soon as she leaves.

So, people are entitled to their boundaries and choices in their relationships - and there is no need to use names to deny them of that - however people's opinions of them might be constructed because of wider context.

Cool that your husband likes that Porn Hub clip, not so cool the women he’s wanking over is actually 15 and doing it because otherwise she’ll get beaten or worse.

This.

Someone not wanting their partner to watch porn /get a lapdance may well be jealous or insecure yes. However they may simply realise what lies behind it all and want no part of it, and could not remain in a relationship with someone who refuses to see it for what it is.

I have no issue with my DH being friends with women, doing things on his own etc. I would have a problem with him treating women as objects for him to use at will for his own pleasure, with no thought of what circumstances have forced that woman into it.

It takes a special kind of stupid to believe the old 'student working their way through uni, making an empowered choice' nonsense.

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 15/08/2022 15:23

But you’re assuming it’s about trust or insecurity. I trust my DH (he has plenty of female friends who he spends time with without me, we sometimes holiday separately, both have a lot of independence, we have separate bank accounts and don’t use each other’s phones yada yada)

I wouldn’t be happy with him going to a strip club because then he’s supporting the sex industry which has a detrimental effect on women

Yes, yes, yes. You're describing my situation as well. Going to a strip club etc is cheating on a personal level and damaging on a societal level as well.

DeclineandFall · 15/08/2022 15:18

I think mumsnet needs a nuance corner and those using reductionist terms to provoke hostile discourse can fuck right off.
Tolerant of all but the intolerant.

PollyRockets · 15/08/2022 15:07

daisychain01 · 15/08/2022 14:55

In the context of Cool Wives, men having female friends is a red herring and nothing to do with being cool or permissive.

It becomes "Cool" if the woman says "I'm fine with my husband/partner having female friends. There's one he's particularly friendly to who insists on rubbing his back and tickling his neck when we're sitting there having a drink. I'm fine with that, bless he enjoys an ego boost and who am I to rain on his parade". Bragging about how tolerant you are with something that puts you in second place, to prioritise your man's needs at the expense of your own is the epitome of "Coolness".

But when has anyone ever posted anything like that?

On most of those threads someone just has to say I'm fine with my husband having female friends and they're a cool wife.

daisychain01 · 15/08/2022 14:55

In the context of Cool Wives, men having female friends is a red herring and nothing to do with being cool or permissive.

It becomes "Cool" if the woman says "I'm fine with my husband/partner having female friends. There's one he's particularly friendly to who insists on rubbing his back and tickling his neck when we're sitting there having a drink. I'm fine with that, bless he enjoys an ego boost and who am I to rain on his parade". Bragging about how tolerant you are with something that puts you in second place, to prioritise your man's needs at the expense of your own is the epitome of "Coolness".

Ponderingwindow · 15/08/2022 14:55

I mostly seen it used when women come into a thread and tell a woman whose own boundaries have been violated that her boundaries are abnormal. It’s just unnecessary.

If a woman has a problem with strippers, or drinking, or endless golf, or whistling, or wearing the color green then those are her boundaries. She gets to have them and she gets to negotiate them with her partner. It’s not up to outsiders to decide if those boundaries are acceptable.

we should be supporting women in standing up for themselves. Instead we have posters coming on and telling them that they are controlling or no fun.

waterlego · 15/08/2022 14:50

Ah, @Sallyh87, that’s a nice post, thank you 😀 Yes, Twitter certainly is an education but can be horribly depressing if one spends too much time on there 😫

gnilliwdog · 15/08/2022 14:43

Yes@Fluffymule I have heard many strip clubs are also linked to money laundering from vice - so prostitution, drugs, trafficking. Nothing fun about that industry at all.

BeautPomiander · 15/08/2022 14:43

Totally agree about the "Be Kind" having elements of manipulation. It can be used as a foil to encourage you to ignore your true feelings. It's subtle, it's nuanced and it can be really unsettling and make you question your own absolutely reasonable feelings. And all under the guise of improving society.

It shouldn't be like this. But it is.

Sallyh87 · 15/08/2022 14:42

@waterlego, I totally understand what you are saying and absolutely agree! You explained it to me in a rationale and dare I say ‘kind’ manner 😬. However, sometimes on Mumsnet posters are so passionate about a topic that they neglect the time to do that. I think we should be aware of the impact of our words etc.

That being said you are completely right and a quick look at Twitter is an education!

Meraas · 15/08/2022 14:41

*used to describe women who make other women feel bad for not enjoying anal etc

Meraas · 15/08/2022 14:41

But when I see it in practice, it's normally just someone stating preferences.

This is confirmation bias in your part, OP.

I could easily say I’ve seen it normally used to make women feel bad for not enjoying anal, rough sex etc

Fluffymule · 15/08/2022 14:39

I think it’s interesting that some think the ‘cool wife’ label is only used as an insult to deride someone who simply trusts their husband, they are not bothered by him using porn or visiting strip clubs because it sits within their agreed and comfortable boundaries.

There’s an argument that some of the pushback they get may come from them ignoring the implications of what exactly they are not bothered about.

For example, that the majority of porn sites feature trafficked women, rape, torture, pedophilia, revenge content. Strips clubs are not universally staffed by enthusiastic students empowered to explore their sexuality whilst paying off their student loan as often portrayed, but many are trafficked women or being worked by a pimp who takes her nightly earnings as soon as she leaves.

So, people are entitled to their boundaries and choices in their relationships - and there is no need to use names to deny them of that - however people's opinions of them might be constructed because of wider context.

Cool that your husband likes that Porn Hub clip, not so cool the women he’s wanking over is actually 15 and doing it because otherwise she’ll get beaten or worse.

waterlego · 15/08/2022 14:36

@Sallyh87, yes it is very annoying. And it’s crafty because it sound so reasonable. Of course we all want to be seen as being kind. So if we object to a bald middle aged man playing on a young women’s soccer team, there are plenty of misogynists queuing up to tell us to just ‘be kind’. And then we’re the ones being made to look unreasonable. It’s so manipulative!

Sallyh87 · 15/08/2022 14:30

waterlego · 15/08/2022 14:27

@Sallyh87 Yes, on the surface ‘be kind’ is of course a nice thing to strive for. The vast majority of people want to be kind to others (and want others to be kind to them) but this phrase is increasingly being used to try and get women to shut up. You only have to spend a few hours on Twitter to see it.

Fair enough, I didn’t understand the context and to be honest I am slightly annoyed that something as simple as ‘be kind’ is being hijacked. Anyway, everyday is a school day and have learned something!

Brefugee · 15/08/2022 14:28

in and of itself #BeKind doesn't mean STFU in the same way that "cool girl" isn't just a girl who likes beer and football.

It is the way they are used, and corrupted, by the very people who are making women's lives difficult. Don't like, say, men in women's changing rooms? #BeKind and let people do things that make you feel uncomfortable. Where #BeKind = STFU

So Cool Girl/Wife wouldn't be one whose husband felt uncomfortable at a strip club and waited outside - it would be one whose husband went to the strip club, shoved 5 dollar bills in the stripper's G-string and paid for a lapdance and then said "i don't know why anyone would have a problem with that, you're all insecure prudes, I'm cool with it [inference: and all other women should too]".

Both cases are about encouraging/telling women to stomp on their own boundaries.

As for "wimmin". Well i grew up in the 70s/80s and it was a thing then to draw attention to the fact that no, women aren't a subset of men - they are a class in their own right. So there was a lot of (IMO misguided) tabloid talk about "personhole covers" and "chairperson" when actually the suggestions had been "Actually, not all people who use 'manhole' covers are men, so let's be inclusive in our language and acknowledge that" (but the suggestion wasn't usually "person hole" covers it was things like "street drain covers" or whatever) And mostly "chairman" was replaced with "Chair" rather than "chairperson" or whatever. But the frothing by the tabloids back then was damaging to the greater picture and a lot of women, Spare Rib i think? was prominent, in saying "righty ho, chaps, we'll be wimmin just so you notice the difference"

In the end i think it was only Private Eye who ran with it.

Fairislefandango · 15/08/2022 14:27

However, saying that ‘be kind’ is the same as STFU, I don’t agree with. Having empathy for people and understanding how they feel should not be seen as a weakness. Being kind should not become a negative thing.

Being kind of your own volition because you're a nice person is a very good thing. Being instructed to 'Be kind' as a way of minimising or deflecting your concerns is not. Neither is being told to 'Be kind' because you belong to a particular group which has traditionally been expected to prioritise kindness to others at the expense of their own rights and needs.

waterlego · 15/08/2022 14:27

@Sallyh87 Yes, on the surface ‘be kind’ is of course a nice thing to strive for. The vast majority of people want to be kind to others (and want others to be kind to them) but this phrase is increasingly being used to try and get women to shut up. You only have to spend a few hours on Twitter to see it.

Topgub · 15/08/2022 14:20

@Sallyh87

Be kind and support women absolutely as ways to silence women.

Sallyh87 · 15/08/2022 14:17

WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 14:09

The trouble is that, after millennia of this shit, feminists know that 'thinking about individuals' prevents women from seeing ourselves as a class, and from seeing the massive system under which we all are all crushed. In fact, that this is precisely the intention - what do you think 'Be Kind' is all about? It means 'STFU'.

We are socialised to care about the feelings of individuals so that we don't unite. Other forces like consumerist individualism and queer theory do the same thing - frame society as consisting of individuals, each with their own 'journey', their own struggle, their own truth, in order to distract from the fact that society is actually a system in which one large group exploits and oppresses another large group along the axes of race, class, and sex.

It really is that simple.

You make some very interesting points and I do take them onboard. I personally would class myself as a feminist and would happily tell anyone that and try to support women in work etc.

However, saying that ‘be kind’ is the same as STFU, I don’t agree with. Having empathy for people and understanding how they feel should not be seen as a weakness. Being kind should not become a negative thing. Men, women and children should always strive to be kind. If we don’t life just becomes a miserable event with everyone upsetting and being horrible to each other .

sunglassesonthetable · 15/08/2022 14:17

In fact “you’re insecure” seems to be the new “you’re jealous”. Not everything is about a woman being insecure, some things are objectively detrimental to society and to women in particular and women who object to that shouldn’t be dismissed as “insecure”.

add to that list

cool girl
pearl clutcher
vanilla
hand maiden
Karen

Oh I forgot it's not ok to say Karen

my bad @WinterDeWinter I thought DARVO was a specialist MN one. will google next time👍🏻

Thelnebriati · 15/08/2022 14:16

Insecure, jealous, controlling (and vanilla) But sure, its 'cool wives' thats the terrible insult.

WinterDeWinter · 15/08/2022 14:16

A prime example is partners or wives who don’t have a problem with / don’t dare speak up about / pretend they don’t care when their husband pays a woman to dance naked inches from their face for the purpose of sexually arousing them. I believe that has a direct impact on my life because I work with lots of men and i believe it helps inform how much they value and respect women in the workplace and in society in general.

Exactly @PixiePirate . These women are aiding and abetting and it impacts all women (including themselves and their daughters). It is our business.

NCHammer2022 · 15/08/2022 14:14

Topgub · 15/08/2022 14:13

@DixonD

What does that even mean?

I know I'm not like other women?

Are all other women except you the same?

She’s special. We’re just insecure and don’t trust our husbands.