Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing "cool girl" or "cool wife" used as an insult

313 replies

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 11:08

I have been on a few threads recently where some posters have been really quite cruel to other posters, including me, for having different boundaries and preferences than they do.

The terms "cool girl" or "cool wife" are slung at them, with the implication made (sometimes directly) that said "cool" person doesn't really do/feel/enjoy the way the say they do, and are just trying to be cool.

Everyone has different boundaries, experiences, cultural influences, relationships, ages, backgrounds, etc- why is it not okay for one person to find for example strippers okay within their marriage and others not to, without the former being accused of being part of the "cool wives brigade".

Is it really that hard for people to understand and accept that we all have different boundaries and lines in the sand?

It really makes me angry and I find it just another way in which woman choose to tear other women down, when what we need to do is support one another.

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 16/08/2022 19:29

I watched a Louis Theroux programme years ago where he spent time in the industry. As I remember he did bring a bit of wry humour to it. Still, the overwhelming impression was of a seriously disturbed culture preying on people who had a number of psychological problems. The simulated rape porn was just horrific.

AdamRyan · 16/08/2022 18:51

So 2 things, would you describe me as a "cool girl" because I don't take issue with my husband watching porn but would fully respect you not being ok with yours doing it?

No I wouldn't describe you as a cool girl. Its not a phrase I use. However I did not like the "many many many" part of your post as it implies women who don't like their husbands looking at porn are somehow strange. You generally seem quite annoyed that some women wouldn't be ok with their husbands watching porn, I don't know why.

Secondly. What about the huge amount of women who watch porn to look at men, surely they are benefitting themselves?
2 things: 1) I don't care what people I don't know do, if they choose to watch porn that's their business but 2) men in porn are far less likely to be coerced and then degraded or treated violently than women, so I don't think its comparable. And far fewer women than men watch porn on a regular basis.

In my opinion most porn aimed at men is misogynistic, degrading/humiliating to rhe actresses, and you could be watching a filmed rape. It would put me off a man if they were ok with that (and yes it seems most are).

Also personally having my marriage break down due to porn, I'd be wary of a man who happily admitted they watched it now. Before I was a bit more laissez-faire.

I'd suggest you watch "Hot girls wanted" and see what you think after that.

shazzybazzy34 · 16/08/2022 16:32

AdamRyan · 16/08/2022 16:17

This is the thing though

Literally noone cares if you are OK with your husband watching porn. It's totally irrelevant to the world, or any question apart things like from "AIBU to think women should be fine with their husbands watching porn". In which case knock yourself out with your "porn's fine".

But what happens (like on the thread in question) is it will be a thread like "AIBU to think porn damages relationships" and someone will pop up to go "I don't care, my husband watches, all men watch it, in fact sometimes i watch it too. It definitely doesn't harms relationships and people who say it does are old/prudes/out of touch/normal MN porn haters.

Then if anyone posts to say "well, thats not really relevant, does porn damage relationships in general" they get told it's shaming and policing other womens behaviour.

That's cool girl behaviour. Putting other women down or insulting them for not being fully on board with activities that damage women and benefit men.

It definitely doesn't harms relationships and people who say it does are old/prudes/out of touch/normal MN porn haters

I don't agree with anyone saying that. I respect both sides of the coin but I have noticed time and time again on here IF you are ok with your husband watching porn you care called a "cool girl" which is meant in a derogatory manner. Also I have seen people pull women down who are NOT ok with their partners watching porn and that is wrong too.

So 2 things, would you describe me as a "cool girl" because I don't take issue with my husband watching porn but would fully respect you not being ok with yours doing it?
Secondly. What about the huge amount of women who watch porn to look at men, surely they are benefitting themselves?

AdamRyan · 16/08/2022 16:17

shazzybazzy34 · 16/08/2022 16:04

Ha ha I am like a lot of other women, many, many, many women do not have a problem with their partners watching porn.

Many many women watch porn including some, but not all of my girlfriends, I am not one of them, I don't like it. I don't enjoy watching it at all. I also have friends who would hit the roof at the thought of their DH watching porn. I respect and "see" all of them. I "see" you too.

Guess that makes me a "cool, not cool girl". I'll take that.

You do you too Boo.

This is the thing though

Literally noone cares if you are OK with your husband watching porn. It's totally irrelevant to the world, or any question apart things like from "AIBU to think women should be fine with their husbands watching porn". In which case knock yourself out with your "porn's fine".

But what happens (like on the thread in question) is it will be a thread like "AIBU to think porn damages relationships" and someone will pop up to go "I don't care, my husband watches, all men watch it, in fact sometimes i watch it too. It definitely doesn't harms relationships and people who say it does are old/prudes/out of touch/normal MN porn haters.

Then if anyone posts to say "well, thats not really relevant, does porn damage relationships in general" they get told it's shaming and policing other womens behaviour.

That's cool girl behaviour. Putting other women down or insulting them for not being fully on board with activities that damage women and benefit men.

shazzybazzy34 · 16/08/2022 16:04

Brefugee · 16/08/2022 15:32

Ohhh yawn.

zzzzzz right backatcha. Let me guess: You're not like other girls.

You KNOW the harmful shit the Cool Wives put up with and think that everyone else is an uptight prude for not putting up with it themselves.
So you carry on. You do you. Whatever.
But we see you.

Ha ha I am like a lot of other women, many, many, many women do not have a problem with their partners watching porn.

Many many women watch porn including some, but not all of my girlfriends, I am not one of them, I don't like it. I don't enjoy watching it at all. I also have friends who would hit the roof at the thought of their DH watching porn. I respect and "see" all of them. I "see" you too.

Guess that makes me a "cool, not cool girl". I'll take that.

You do you too Boo.

Brefugee · 16/08/2022 15:37

I have said it probably a dozen times now but it bears repeating.

a) i don't generally use the term, but sometimes it is the apt description. It saves writing out whole paragraphs

  1. people use it wrongly? yes they do. Either correct them or move on and ignore. (see also Gaslighting and Narcissist)

iii) What people will accept in their own lives can wildly differ from what other people accept. Let's put it on a continuum with Cool Girls at the "permits anything" and the Controlling Harridan at the "jealous of everything allows nothing" at the other.
Most people will be somewhere along that line - and at different times they may move closer to one end or the other.

I'm happy to call someone who obsessively checks their partner's phone, has a hissy fit if he even goes for lunch with women from work etc a control freak. It's the internet YMMV

Brefugee · 16/08/2022 15:32

Ohhh yawn.

zzzzzz right backatcha. Let me guess: You're not like other girls.

You KNOW the harmful shit the Cool Wives put up with and think that everyone else is an uptight prude for not putting up with it themselves.
So you carry on. You do you. Whatever.
But we see you.

WinterDeWinter · 16/08/2022 14:38

Gah, you have to click 'show quote history' to see the quote I was talking about - it's this from @sunshineandstrawberryjam

sunshineandstrawberryjam · Yesterday 11:23

It's a deeply misogynistic term that is basically used to deny women agency or the ability to make their own decisions or analysis of a situation. At this point I tend to just switch off if someone uses it and refuse to pay them any attention from that point onwards as it's such a twatty term to use.

WinterDeWinter · 16/08/2022 14:37

Tandora · 16/08/2022 14:11

Agree with this. YANBU OP

This is DARVO - Deny, Attack, Reverse Victim and Offender. As I mentioned above, it co-opts the language of 'progressiveness' (developed by feminists and the broad left) to claim that pointing out oppression is actually an act of oppression - that the victim is the offender.

It's insane, makes no sense, and utterly transparent once you've had it pointed out. I'd feel excruciated if I had to sink that low in a debate. But women are heavily programmed not to make others feel bad, especially men, so it's often quite effective. So panicked at breaking the Be Kind rule that their critical thinking is temporarily disabled.

You've got to be a shameless, Trump-level MRA (or an actual narcissist - see the Relationships board for many examples) to deploy it though, so I guess that limits the field a little.

See also the trans extremist narrative, lots of crossover tactically.

Tandora · 16/08/2022 14:11

sunshineandstrawberryjam · 15/08/2022 11:23

It's a deeply misogynistic term that is basically used to deny women agency or the ability to make their own decisions or analysis of a situation. At this point I tend to just switch off if someone uses it and refuse to pay them any attention from that point onwards as it's such a twatty term to use.

Agree with this. YANBU OP

category12 · 16/08/2022 14:06

sst1234 · 16/08/2022 13:56

This forum is called…..AIBU. Why post if you’re not prepared to hear another person’s opinion that you are AIBU?

In that example, the OP wouldn't be asking for an opinion, they're asking for advice on the situation.

Eg. if you post saying "I hate fish, but my host is only supplying fish-based meals, what should I do" - it's pointless to post "Oh I love fish".

It's adding bugger all. Which is a choice, but it's not a great one.

DuckDuckNo · 16/08/2022 14:02

Brefugee · 15/08/2022 11:19

YABU. I'm sick of the Cool-Girls (or Cool Wives, or I'm Not Like Other Girls/Women or Pick Me Girls/women) showing up to defend indefensible behaviour by men.

This is the internet so YMMV. But maybe you might want to think about why this shorthand is used so often.

This. Okay, you're fine with your husband blowing money on hookers, going to lap dances, having "special friends" or wtf ever. Doesn't make you more enlightened and there's no reason to evangelise your lack of boundaries on other people's threads.

sst1234 · 16/08/2022 13:56

ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler · 15/08/2022 11:14

I haven't seen this tbh but if the conversation goes something like:

OP:
"I have just found out my partner has been looking at porn and this upsets me greatly what should I do?"

reply:
"why are you so bothered I have zero issues with my partner looking at porn, you need to relax"

Then the second person is being a twat, not appreciating the OP's boundaries and perhaps deserves a not so nice response.

Plus there really are some women who will put up with anything to please their partner/DH etc. and will pretend to be fine with it. Not saying that is the case for everyone before you jump down my throat but it will be the case for some.

This forum is called…..AIBU. Why post if you’re not prepared to hear another person’s opinion that you are AIBU?

sunglassesonthetable · 16/08/2022 13:54

a) ignore it, they are obviously not speaking to you or point out that it's not cool girl stuff
or
b) have a quick look at what you wrote, is it cool girl stuff? then either own it or carry on

I'm fine with how to react tbh.

But my argument is it's just a knee jerk reaction now.
and a way to "other" as in
" they are always unpleasant, brainwashed etc" on this thread.

sunglassesonthetable · 16/08/2022 13:43

It is not abusing someone as such to call out their Cool Girl behaviour. That is a very clear phenomenon reported on by enough sociologists that people understand what the shorthand means. Quite the opposite: the cool girls are indulging in misogynistic behaviour.

I understand that there is this sociological phenomenon. And that refers to cool girls indulging in misogynistic behaviour.

But It's used repeatedly on MN to refer to posters who step outside another posters OWN personal boundaries. And we know boundaries are fluid.

The cool girl boundaries are very very blurred on MN. So it has become abuse.

shazzybazzy34 · 16/08/2022 13:37

Brefugee · 16/08/2022 13:08

What i meant is that if you make a comment and someone comes back with "oh the Cool Girls are here" and you're not indulging in Cool Girl behaviour you can
a) ignore it, they are obviously not speaking to you or point out that it's not cool girl stuff
or
b) have a quick look at what you wrote, is it cool girl stuff? then either own it or carry on

It is not abusing someone as such to call out their Cool Girl behaviour. That is a very clear phenomenon reported on by enough sociologists that people understand what the shorthand means. Quite the opposite: the cool girls are indulging in misogynistic behaviour.

Ohhh yawn.

WHO gets to say what constitutes as "cool girl stuff"? Me not minding my DH watching porn doesn't make me "cool", nor does it mean I am indulging in mysogynistic behaviour...what absolute clap trap. Same way as the fact I don't watch porn and think anal sex is gross doesn't make me a pearl clutcher.

Have a look at what you wrote...it is cool girl stuff..then own it?

Get a GRIP!

So sick at tired of being called a "cool girl" in a derogatory way because I am ok with my husband having a hand shuffle and watching a bit of porn by woman who find it abhorrent that I am ok with it whilst their husbands are more than likely doing the same behind their backs.

I would never tell a woman she is wrong for not allowing her husband to watch porn. I would not judge her for that. They are her boundaries, Her rules for HER marriage.

None of my business.

Brefugee · 16/08/2022 13:08

What i meant is that if you make a comment and someone comes back with "oh the Cool Girls are here" and you're not indulging in Cool Girl behaviour you can
a) ignore it, they are obviously not speaking to you or point out that it's not cool girl stuff
or
b) have a quick look at what you wrote, is it cool girl stuff? then either own it or carry on

It is not abusing someone as such to call out their Cool Girl behaviour. That is a very clear phenomenon reported on by enough sociologists that people understand what the shorthand means. Quite the opposite: the cool girls are indulging in misogynistic behaviour.

sunglassesonthetable · 16/08/2022 12:28

I'm not trying to rebut anything tbh.

i'm genuinely trying to understand how there is so much abuse of other women around this word.

Which wouldn't be tolerated in another context.

Brefugee · 16/08/2022 12:22

It's very easy though to successfully rebut claims of being the Cool Wife by pointing out what a Cool Wife is.

Like all the people who use the term gaslighting when it isn't.

sunglassesonthetable · 16/08/2022 12:19

I get that these tropes are very useful as a sort of 'shorthand ' for something. And what Cool Girl is shorthand for has been explained on here. And the implications. Very well .

But has no one noticed that the definition already on this thread has been pushed past that?

"They" are unpleasant to those that disagree
"They " are brainwashed
"They" will put up with anything

What all of them ? all the time? As a definitive?

Then what is that definitive Cool Girl line? Someone needs to lay it out.

But in reality As @Brefugee says there is probably a sliding scale of what people tolerate.

And using Cool Girl/wife etc has just slipped into abuse like Pearl Clutcher. Cool Girl is chucked about indiscriminately on MN, Regardless of the boundary being breached. I think it's come to mean mean something very different to the Gone Girl thing.

sunglassesonthetable · 16/08/2022 11:35

Then you haven't seen many MN threads. Referring to the Cool Wives/Girls isn't name calling. It is identifying a phenomenon. And as previous pp here and elsewhere have said, giving it a name caused them to realise their own internalised misogyny and work on that.

No I realise people say "I'm cool with that" on other threads. I thought the poster was referring to what's been said on this thread.

I don't like Cool Girl personally but neither do I like Pearl Clutcher etc. Or any name that just reduces the discussion and polarises talk into a tit for tat war.

Brefugee · 16/08/2022 11:23

The whole thread is about 'cool wives' and 'cool girls' I have never seen anyone on here say they are 'cool' with stripping etc. They may say they have no problem with it. It's used as an insult and so my point still stands- name calling is not on.

Then you haven't seen many MN threads. Referring to the Cool Wives/Girls isn't name calling. It is identifying a phenomenon. And as previous pp here and elsewhere have said, giving it a name caused them to realise their own internalised misogyny and work on that.

shazzybazzy34 · 16/08/2022 11:09

sunglassesonthetable · 16/08/2022 09:36

*Think about the wider picture?

The possibility these women she is gawping at for cheap kicks aren't doing it voluntarily?

Even if were, the wider societal implications for all women of normalising the idea that women's bodies can be bought to use as a masturbation tool?*

No she doesn't watch porn.

But her OH/ friends might. That's what she said.

So knowing the wider picture. What should she do? In your mind? That's what I don't understand.

And 'cool girl' has only been used as a negative on this thread. Even by posters describing how they used to be 'cool girls'.

Thank you.

I would be interested in what Lassie suggests I do?

shazzybazzy34 · 16/08/2022 11:08

DeclineandFall · 16/08/2022 09:26

I put quotes round "cool" as it isn't a word I personally would use. However,there are posters on here who have adopted it to describe themselves and/ or say they are "cool" with porn, stripping etc. I was using their own term.

That's very disingenuous. The whole thread is about 'cool wives' and 'cool girls' I have never seen anyone on here say they are 'cool' with stripping etc. They may say they have no problem with it. It's used as an insult and so my point still stands- name calling is not on.

Exactly this.

shazzybazzy34 · 16/08/2022 11:07

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 16/08/2022 09:16

Think about the wider picture?

The possibility these women she is gawping at for cheap kicks aren't doing it voluntarily?

Even if were, the wider societal implications for all women of normalising the idea that women's bodies can be bought to use as a masturbation tool?

The only woman I gawp at is meself in the mirror and curse the shed load of choc I ate the week before.

I don't watch porn in any form.

My friends that do watch porn watch it for the men so the same could be said for buying men's bodies as a masturbation tool.

Swipe left for the next trending thread