Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of seeing "cool girl" or "cool wife" used as an insult

313 replies

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 11:08

I have been on a few threads recently where some posters have been really quite cruel to other posters, including me, for having different boundaries and preferences than they do.

The terms "cool girl" or "cool wife" are slung at them, with the implication made (sometimes directly) that said "cool" person doesn't really do/feel/enjoy the way the say they do, and are just trying to be cool.

Everyone has different boundaries, experiences, cultural influences, relationships, ages, backgrounds, etc- why is it not okay for one person to find for example strippers okay within their marriage and others not to, without the former being accused of being part of the "cool wives brigade".

Is it really that hard for people to understand and accept that we all have different boundaries and lines in the sand?

It really makes me angry and I find it just another way in which woman choose to tear other women down, when what we need to do is support one another.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 15/08/2022 12:28

I'll use pearl-clutcher when someone is being ridiculous (eg about someone using a towel for a week) because that seems to be a regular amount of time for people to use towels for? (not that I've done a poll)

As i said i don't use Cool Girl often, but when i do I'm aiming it straight between the eyes of someone who will come in and tell someone that their boundaries are far too tight and they should relax and let someone do what they like with/to them because they'er ok with that and everyone who isn't is a prude.

We spend so long supporting women to make different choices to us (but valid choices to them so why not support it?) but also warning them to be sure and secure in themselves and their boundary setting. And i see the results of years of this in a lot of the young women i know now and it makes me really happy, and pleased that we worked so hard at it. So in that respect, of course, i also support the Cool Girls in their own decisions (insofar as they have made them independently, as pp said we don't grow up in a vacuum) right up to the point they try to persuade women with healthy (personal) boundaries that they are wrong.

Fairislefandango · 15/08/2022 12:27

It's pretty baffling when people accuse MN en masse of having a particular attitude or of being really for or against something. Firstly MNers are all individuals. Secondly any remotely controversial view on here generally has a large camp vehemently agreeing and a large camp vehemently disagreeing.

I don't really believe in unilaterally supporting any view just because it's been expressed by a woman (or by a member of any other group that one happens to belong to). Any view should be judged on its individual merits.

AdamRyan · 15/08/2022 12:27

Fluffymule · 15/08/2022 12:19

I’ve been following the ‘Porn culture has led to women suffering injuries during sex’ thread over the weekend. The conversation had a number of running themes and points, but a key one was about young women experiencing a dating scene where acts, such as anal sex, are now considered ‘normal’, that many men now expect anal as commonly as PIV and some don’t seek consent or even broker a conversation around boundaries.

This immediately attracted a cohort of posters who came on to say how much they enjoyed anal sex and how others shouldn’t judge.

Fair enough, their opinion (although I’d ague the discussion wasn’t judging women who enjoy anal, they were judging the men who demand it or push consent boundaries to get it).

It was not enough just to make a point, these posters continued to tilt at windmills insisting they were being ‘judged’, whilst feeling it necessary to prove they were nothing like the uptight judgers on the thread, by describing how and why they like it so much. Repeatedly.

So, inevitably other posters became irritated and the discussion started to narrow into an argument around ‘prudes’ and ‘cool girls’ rather than the important issue of women being assaulted and injured under the label of sexual activity, motivated by porn. Which is never ‘cool’ and even less ‘cool’ to activity minimise.

Thank you - just came on to post that kind of thing

I'm kinda meh about it. "Cool girl" is not a term I'd use. However on many of these threads it also seems fine to call people "vanilla"; "pearl clutchers"; "prudish" or allege they are stupid or have poor comprehension skills.

I think those kind of responses are just as bad.

Play the ball, not the man

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 12:26

NellyNothing · 15/08/2022 11:30

YABU and yanbu - the phrase is unkind and only twats would call someone that. However there is nothing wrong with kindly pointing out that you shouldn't pander to someone.

You can disagree with other posters without being nasty. It's not difficult.

Completely agree!!!

OP posts:
DeclineandFall · 15/08/2022 12:26

This thread is interesting. It could be about whether using insults like cool girl add to a conversation or whether as an insult they just derail it.
Instead it's just veered off into another slag fest. Plus ca change.

ReneBumsWombats · 15/08/2022 12:26

The terms "cool girl" or "cool wife" are slung at them, with the implication made (sometimes directly) that said "cool" person doesn't really do/feel/enjoy the way the say they do, and are just trying to be cool.

Yes, that's exactly what the implication is supposed to be. It's from Gone Girl.

I don't think name calling is a great way to debate but yes, this is what they're saying. Although it's not about trying to be cool as much as trying to pander to men.

Topgub · 15/08/2022 12:26

@SleeplessInEngland

During your mother's time?!

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 12:26

For those who think I am referring specifically to the lap dance thread, I'm not.

I am actually not comfortable with my partner having a lap dance, a) because I'd be jealous and b) because it just crosses a line of what I'd feel is okay. Oddly I wouldn't mind if someone went to a strip club though!

I just think the insults when people don't have the same opinion are so horrible. A PP made a good point though about calling people Pearl Clutchers, etc, is just as damaging a trope, which I take on board.

OP posts:
waterlego · 15/08/2022 12:25

Fluffymule · 15/08/2022 12:19

I’ve been following the ‘Porn culture has led to women suffering injuries during sex’ thread over the weekend. The conversation had a number of running themes and points, but a key one was about young women experiencing a dating scene where acts, such as anal sex, are now considered ‘normal’, that many men now expect anal as commonly as PIV and some don’t seek consent or even broker a conversation around boundaries.

This immediately attracted a cohort of posters who came on to say how much they enjoyed anal sex and how others shouldn’t judge.

Fair enough, their opinion (although I’d ague the discussion wasn’t judging women who enjoy anal, they were judging the men who demand it or push consent boundaries to get it).

It was not enough just to make a point, these posters continued to tilt at windmills insisting they were being ‘judged’, whilst feeling it necessary to prove they were nothing like the uptight judgers on the thread, by describing how and why they like it so much. Repeatedly.

So, inevitably other posters became irritated and the discussion started to narrow into an argument around ‘prudes’ and ‘cool girls’ rather than the important issue of women being assaulted and injured under the label of sexual activity, motivated by porn. Which is never ‘cool’ and even less ‘cool’ to activity minimise.

Good post.

Divebar2021 · 15/08/2022 12:24

It's used as an insult by people who can't either cope or fathom other people having different reactions to a situation than them. Go straight to the insult and high five yourself for being so right and so on point

Amen.

waterlego · 15/08/2022 12:24

@SunnyD44 Why do you think that women who have certain boundaries have ‘miserable lives’?

SunnyD44 · 15/08/2022 12:22

YANBU but it’s often used by certain types of women who I pity.

If saying it makes their miserable lives better for one second then let them
crack on and don’t take it personally.

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 12:21

Catriona898 · 15/08/2022 11:22

Well it's not like mumsnet generally support women who make different choices is it? There aren't many long threads that I have read recently that haven't turned into a bun fight when it comes to attitudes about sexual fidelity. Should you be able to go onto a website and say "I would be fine with my partner going to a stripper", absolutely. But it's a forum and people can and do disagree. The "cool wives" thing is annoying I agree, but not any more annoying than the many and varied insults that people use to describe women. The people saying "I wouldn't be fine with my husband going to a stripper" aren't getting unilateral support either. Getting angry about hearing about the "cool girl brigade" , while not mentioning the other, many and varied misogynistic terms to describe women is unreasonable. It seems you are only concerned with a comment that affects your lifestyle. That's not really supporting women as a whole is it?

That is a really good point actually. I have been guilty of referring to pearl clutching etc, which is I suppose just as ignorant as people insulting cool girls.

You're very right.

OP posts:
Topgub · 15/08/2022 12:21

@11GrumpsaGrumping

We live in a sexist, patriarchal society.

Women don't grow up in a vacuum.

Of course women have their own likes and dislikes but many of them are through mysoginist conditioning.

SleeplessInEngland · 15/08/2022 12:21

What "cool wife/girlfriend" really means is "I have a permissive attitude to men's sexual pecadillos / perversions". If enough women adopt this attitude then what you find is a wholesale degeneration in the behaviour and quality of men. Leading us to the depressing dating scene that most under 40s women are now having to endure.

Depressing compared to when? During my mother's time when a woman wanting to be a working parent was a novelty and, in some cases, frowned upon?

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 12:19

@UglyNameChange I see your point. But, can it not be possible that some woman choose to do things for themselves/have their own opinions/are behaving in ways that are comfortable to them without also pandering to men?

I find it very misogynistic that some women don't accept that other women like or accept things because of themselves, not because of the men in their lives!

OP posts:
Fluffymule · 15/08/2022 12:19

I’ve been following the ‘Porn culture has led to women suffering injuries during sex’ thread over the weekend. The conversation had a number of running themes and points, but a key one was about young women experiencing a dating scene where acts, such as anal sex, are now considered ‘normal’, that many men now expect anal as commonly as PIV and some don’t seek consent or even broker a conversation around boundaries.

This immediately attracted a cohort of posters who came on to say how much they enjoyed anal sex and how others shouldn’t judge.

Fair enough, their opinion (although I’d ague the discussion wasn’t judging women who enjoy anal, they were judging the men who demand it or push consent boundaries to get it).

It was not enough just to make a point, these posters continued to tilt at windmills insisting they were being ‘judged’, whilst feeling it necessary to prove they were nothing like the uptight judgers on the thread, by describing how and why they like it so much. Repeatedly.

So, inevitably other posters became irritated and the discussion started to narrow into an argument around ‘prudes’ and ‘cool girls’ rather than the important issue of women being assaulted and injured under the label of sexual activity, motivated by porn. Which is never ‘cool’ and even less ‘cool’ to activity minimise.

Brefugee · 15/08/2022 12:18

Poster: They're just friends. You can't ban him from having friendships; it's controlling.
Other poster: Well you might be a COOL WIFE but my husband isn't allowed to talk to women!

I think @TrashPandas also put their finger on it (thanks also to @WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps for the compliment).

There is a wide spectrum between "anything goes, whatever my man wants to do is fine by me" and "he isn't allowed even to think about looking at another woman or I'll LTB" and most posters, i daresay most women, move along the central part of the sliding scale at various times and under various circumstances.

I'm finding a couple of threads on MN today very interesting. The lapdance one is a bit of an eye opener. (don't want this thread to get zapped as a TAAT because it is a really an interesting discussion) but also the one about the stepmum returning the child to his home at the agreed time. And the reason is that people really do extrapolate and make up scenarios in their heads that indicate to me they have had serious issues around these topics and are projecting.

In the step-mum one it was a throwaway comment by OP about the mum not often asking the step-dad to step in - turned into him practically being accused of being a paedophile. And the lapdance one has people saying everything from "fine" through "he only told you so you wouldn't find out another way" (which seems reasonable to me - no matter what you think of what he actually did) to him being a serial abuser of prostitutes and LTB.

What a time to be alive!

11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 12:17

@ScarlettOHaraHamiltonKennedyButler ah yes I can see that actually.

Like a more helpful response, which I have also seen on here (with the cool girl insult), is "I am okay with porn in my relationship, but that might not be for you. What are your boundaries, etc" to help the op work through where they are at.

OP posts:
11GrumpsaGrumping · 15/08/2022 12:15

@Harridan1981 I see your point. But when I see it in practice, it's normally just someone stating preferences. I have never sensed an "I'm trying to be cooler than you" undertone, but the statement itself seems so triggering.

OP posts:
Honestlyeyeroll · 15/08/2022 12:15

I’ve been called Cool Girl because i don’t care that my husband has female friends. I’ve also been called cool girl because I don’t care that he’s bisexual.

(No-one has called me cool girl because he has male friends)

It’s used as a phrase by others to hide their own insecurities.

Maireas · 15/08/2022 12:15

Oh dear lord, like those posters supporting that man having a "glamour" image on view at work!
"They're only breasts" "you see more at the beach" !
It just gives a pass for sleazy and exploitative behaviour.

scatterolight · 15/08/2022 12:14

What "cool wife/girlfriend" really means is "I have a permissive attitude to men's sexual pecadillos / perversions". If enough women adopt this attitude then what you find is a wholesale degeneration in the behaviour and quality of men. Leading us to the depressing dating scene that most under 40s women are now having to endure.

If women were a little more conscious of how their own standards and behaviour could play a part in shaping the men around them we might live in a society more conducive to respectful loving relationships.

sunglassesonthetable · 15/08/2022 12:14

I agree totally. I think the way these 'cool girls' try to mock and criticize women who will NOT accept certain behaviours from their men, actually illustrates that they've been brainwashed by the men. It's a huge defence mechanism IMO. Sad thing is, I don't think they realise it.

🙄 here we go. Nuance.

OneTC · 15/08/2022 12:11

I think the term cool-girl ends up being about as pointless as it sounds. One person's cool girl is another person's conservative and it's used by a variety of people many of whom you'd be happy to live without their approval. In the same way some people would call you woke cos you don't actively hate brown people

However your choice of example, strippers really? I think there are women doing it willingly, but I also know there are women doing it unwillingly, or as a last resort, or because they're trafficked, or multiple other problems. Willfully ignoring that part of the industry is weird for both men and women. I don't think it's necessarily indicative of trying to be cool as it is a lack of consideration generally for other people and their situation

Swipe left for the next trending thread