Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the mandatory logo school items need to stop?

264 replies

BagelwithPhiladelphiaz · 15/08/2022 09:56

Exactly this.

I have just paid £76 for the mandatory PE kit for my DD’s senior school. Including items such as striped rugby socks, which are mandatory for some reason for all PE lessons, rugby or not.

This is before I spend £44 on a blazer, plus the uniform items that she actually needs as well as shoes, bag etc

Next I will order the mandatory items for my primary school children. Cheaper at £14 for a jumper (need a few though to wash, and they also tend to disappear in school despite being named) and £5 for PE t-shirt. This school isn’t so strict about it being mandatory but nearly all the DC have logo ones, so ones who don’t stand out, and they are needed for sports day/school photo day anyway.

None of these items are especially good quality. With secondary, we are restricted to one local supplier and the man who owns the shop is bloody rude, which adds insult to injury.

The blazer, perhaps fair enough I think as they look quite smart, but is £44 really the best price school could find? The other items.. especially the PE kits where we could easily buy very similar items without the logo, are they necessary? Especially as we have a winter coming where some people won’t be able to pay bills.

(The secondary did have a “free second hand clothes rail” for all, at some point, but when I phoned to ask they were very vague about when it would be. I have a friend whose children are on pupil premium- no subsided option for them -
and she managed to find out what day this was but went to find the second hand uniform she found some shabby items that weren’t in her DC’s size, and no PE items.)

OP posts:
GettingOrganisedNow · 15/08/2022 21:27

I'd limit it to 1 logo item (and give the option of that being a sew-on badge), and ensure that all items can be bought in the supermarket, including PE kit. Unless they're playing in a school team, it should be plain colours.

Cuck00soup · 15/08/2022 21:19

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/08/2022 10:33

Expensive logo shit and make embroidery nonsense is how schools ensure that certain demographics don't even bother applying. If you are poor or have sensory issues and can't pick from.a selection you can actually tolerate wearing then you have been.priced out/deliberately excluded.

Parents love it becuase with a.logo theres no chance you will be mistaken for a " shithole high " student.

Theres nothing wrong with generic black/navy/grey jumpers from supermarkets and even aldi sell.white shirts and/or polo's.

Its not a mistake it costs you 400 to get through the door.

I've spent 250 so far on regulation items. Plus shirts and trousers. Which probably bring it up to 300 ish.

Also have had ti spend nearly 400 on a chrome book.

Still got 3 lots of footwear to buy.

And stationery/bag/pe bag.

I hope my kidneys are working im gonna have to sell 1.

This. Make your uniform expensive and you keep out the wrong sort of children parents. Keep out the wrong families and your exam grades stay high and you keep your place in the league tables.

DD's uniform isn't even nice and the single supplier is shockingly awful.

Want to say thanks for the thread though and Mewkin's link. I am going to write to the head and chair of Governors.

DimitriMendeleev · 15/08/2022 21:13

JustLyra · 15/08/2022 20:46

Some uniforms do the exact opposite of that.

in fact in some areas they are absolutely a tool to put poorer families off applying for certain schools.

No idea if this will reply properly.

I agree, the idea that 'they all look the same' is there, however there is still a huge inequality with uniform. I teach in a secondary school and despite having a uniform, the people with money are still obvious, with the coats, shoes, bags etc that they have.

TeacupDrama · 15/08/2022 21:13

there should be a limit of one logoed item plus tie if the school has logoed blazer the jumper and shirt underneath can be generic from anywhere, if no blazer the jumper or sweatshirt have a logo this still provides huge numbers of combinations
if you have

  1. either black or grey for trousers /skirts
  2. either white or pale blue shirts
  3. black, grey, navy, burgundy , red, royal blue or green jumpers that is 28 combinations before you add in ties etc quite enough variety without needing striped or checked shirts or kilts even in a crowded conurbation like London 28 different high schools would still be a pretty large area and all of the above apart from tie and badge can be bought in ASDA or John Lewis or whatever in between no state school should have a PE uniform, just PE shorts/leggings/ joggers a t shirt ( maybe in school or house colour) and a pair of trainers is perfectly adequate teams can be easily done with coloured tabards all school children should wear plainish black flat shoes or trainers there is no need for any rules on bags and coats apart from no offensive words or symbols and that coats need to be suitable for bad weather and bags big enough to hold what you need and the school will not consider any item to be worth more than £50 maybe £70 for children that wear adult sizes regardless of purchase price so any damage or theft is limited to that

how Finland get such good results with no uniform and virtually no homework should perhaps be explained by expensive uniform fanatics

user1471447863 · 15/08/2022 21:10

Sod this 'looks smart' business. Children should be comfortable as a starting point.
Being hot, sweaty, uncomfortable or cold does not help learning.
Offices up and down the country cast off the tie and suit years if not decades ago.

A school logo'd jumper or polo shirt at most is all that is needed, if at all. School colours is adequate in most cases (blue top, grey trousers etc).
Primary schools in particular are more into active learning, outside or not sat at desks any more so clothing choices should better reflect this. There is absolutely nothing wrong in kids going dressed in a polo shirt and leggings etc. And as for preparing them for the workplace - news flash this is likely what they will be wearing there too.

Blazers are frankly shit as an item of clothing serving no useful purpose that cannot be done much better by modern items of clothing such as a jacket or a jumper. They should have been left in the 1950's where they belong.
They are shit as a jumper, either too hot or too open, and shit as a jacket as not waterproof or warm enough and still requires a waterproof jacket on top.
A modern fleece or soft shell jacket is a much more intelligent item of outerwear. If kids are going to wear blazers then the teachers damn well better be wearing tweed jackets with leather elbow patches on them.
Parents should be engaging more with the schools when it comes to uniform changes and making their expectations very clear. Much of the rest of the world manages fine with no formal uniform in schools.

Hurdling · 15/08/2022 21:07

Agree, but it’s also easy to get good as new 2nd hand high school uniform on Facebook market place. So pay £15 for a blazer instead of over 40 etc

RainbowsMoonbeams · 15/08/2022 21:02

YANBU. My DC’s school have just changed the logo for the second time in 3 years! Now everyone is required to buy all the new clothing all over again. And it is of course overpriced.

Thefruitbatdancer · 15/08/2022 20:59

When I was at secondary many moons ago, the uniform was a generic black & grey. The logo badges were available from the PTA for a few quid to sew on at home. This kept the cost down for many families, why can't schools do this again?

I've just spent £150 on dd's Yr 7 sports kit alone & another £3 per clothing item for her name to be embroidered on the front. Ordinary sew on labels won't do, you have to have it embroidered on the front. I haven't calculated the price for the whole uniform yet. I think it will come in at around £500 - £600 including trainers, shoes & coat.

JustLyra · 15/08/2022 20:46

DimitriMendeleev · 15/08/2022 20:45

I have ambivalent opinions on uniform and uniform policies

I have no idea why having pink hair or a nose ring, or wearing jeans would have any impact on your ability to learn. I think the idea of uniform is ridiculous in ways, and a dress code (as in don't have your arse on show and no one wants to see your underwear) would suffice.

But, I also think that uniform is a way of ensuring that there is no obvious divide between the haves and have nots. The price of it is fucking ridiculous though.

Some uniforms do the exact opposite of that.

in fact in some areas they are absolutely a tool to put poorer families off applying for certain schools.

DimitriMendeleev · 15/08/2022 20:45

I have ambivalent opinions on uniform and uniform policies

I have no idea why having pink hair or a nose ring, or wearing jeans would have any impact on your ability to learn. I think the idea of uniform is ridiculous in ways, and a dress code (as in don't have your arse on show and no one wants to see your underwear) would suffice.

But, I also think that uniform is a way of ensuring that there is no obvious divide between the haves and have nots. The price of it is fucking ridiculous though.

JustLyra · 15/08/2022 20:39

LockAqua · 15/08/2022 19:36

The DCs’ school is very strict on uniform and requires everything to be ligues including coats and bags.

They are also very strict on how uniform is worn- top buttons done up, shirts tucked in and blazers on at all times unless permission is granted in exceptionally warm weather.

It’s no coincidence that the school is outstanding and has excellent results and behaviour. Parents who want low standards and low expectations are welcome to them, but many parents want outstanding schools with rules and standards.

The outstanding school locally here has a uniform of black skirt or trousers, black jumper or card, white shirt or polo shirt. No logos visible.

They have rules and high standards. They have gone from requires improvement 10/12 years ago (when they had a stupidly expensive uniform) to outstanding at their last inspection. Despite a simple uniform.

JustLyra · 15/08/2022 20:36

LockAqua · 15/08/2022 19:11

@tithead22

The whole point of a uniform is that everyone looks smart and the same. Blazers are part of the uniform and should therefore be worn at all times.

Good schools have high standards and expectations in all areas, including uniform.

So how do you explain schools on the continent outperforming UK schools despite uniform not being a big factor?

Good standards and expectations can still be in place without expensive uniforms.

troppibambini6 · 15/08/2022 20:22

Totally agree. Everything at my daughters school has to be brought through the school supplier even shirts as they are a horrible mustard yellow. It's costs £500 to completely kits them out. Ridiculous.

FunsizedandFabulous · 15/08/2022 20:22

I remember parting with £300 on "official" uniform at the designated uniform shop four years ago. Even the bag was logoed. Since then we've tried to get the most wear out of everything. I have bought three bags in four years, and she needs a new one for Y11. There is a particular trousers that she has to wear at school for £25 a pair but we managed to find two pairs for £17 in M&S this year. We just hope the HT doesn't notice. She can just about still squeeze into her old PE kit and other stuff still fits so we haven't had to lay out too much this summer.

WhiteFire · 15/08/2022 20:17

I am incredibly fortunate that out of all the schools in the area my kids school is the one with the least requirements. Blazer, jumper, tie and pe top and everything else can be from anywhere.

A friend's DD goes to one of the other local schools where everything is logo's, however she is very tall and in year 8 had already grown out of the school regulation trousers. The school which is part of a very large academy chain pretty much shrugged their shoulders. We were on a mission together to find trousers to fit tall, slim girls. I at least had the advantage of just being black, while for her the style had to match, (and then needed to get the embroidery done)

PuttingDownRoots · 15/08/2022 20:13

And its not just the uniform. Even the stationery adds up. (£15 for the calculator for example).

Hateyo · 15/08/2022 20:10

The school my DD’s went to both ended up in special measures and both changed the uniform to special logo everything. Including the bloody awful pleated skirts and blazers.
My DD’s we’re in the year bands that could continue to wear old stock.
Even so I ended up putting 5 sweaters in rag bag as couldn’t even give away ( was only last two years of school)

ZenNudist · 15/08/2022 19:58

Typo! £800 FFS

ZenNudist · 15/08/2022 19:57

Actually just added up. It was £80 and I've not bought winter coats yet.

ZenNudist · 15/08/2022 19:54

At my friends sons grammar school she is paying £4 per item for mandatory initial s which is ridiculous.

We had to pay £56 for a rugby shirt with ds name on it in house and school colours reversible. £56!!! Can't be reused!

I have spent about £500 kitting out ds1 for new secondary and ds2 for primary. I'm comfortable but it's stupid to have to spend so much.

Clarks charges £50 for declining quality size 1 school shoes. Might order £35 m&s ones and send clarkes back

I think ds1 ones cost £70 because he's Size 9...

purplecorkheart · 15/08/2022 19:43

100% agree. One of the school here has an almost invisible gold thread in their female trousers. The quality of said trousers is way poorer than the most basic supermarket trousers but the price is ++++. The majority of familes in the school cannot afford to purchase a second pair. The male trousers in the school in contrast are plain grey and can be purchased in any supermarket. Tracksuits, Jumpers and School Jackets are all branded and crazy prices available from one shop.

LockAqua · 15/08/2022 19:38

*logoed

LockAqua · 15/08/2022 19:36

The DCs’ school is very strict on uniform and requires everything to be ligues including coats and bags.

They are also very strict on how uniform is worn- top buttons done up, shirts tucked in and blazers on at all times unless permission is granted in exceptionally warm weather.

It’s no coincidence that the school is outstanding and has excellent results and behaviour. Parents who want low standards and low expectations are welcome to them, but many parents want outstanding schools with rules and standards.

cyclamenqueen · 15/08/2022 19:24

Schools aren't allowed to make any profit from school uniform

@PerfectRun the way around this is that the school places exclusive rights with a supplier who then makes a ‘voluntary’ donation to the school. Sadly this is now widespread

tithead22 · 15/08/2022 19:14

@LockAqua hello, yes, I’m perfectly aware of that. The reality is that the more ridiculous of these rules take a lot of time in lessons to enforce. The more ridiculous the rule, the more it impacts the efficacy of school-wide efforts to implement important rules.