Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the mandatory logo school items need to stop?

264 replies

BagelwithPhiladelphiaz · 15/08/2022 09:56

Exactly this.

I have just paid £76 for the mandatory PE kit for my DD’s senior school. Including items such as striped rugby socks, which are mandatory for some reason for all PE lessons, rugby or not.

This is before I spend £44 on a blazer, plus the uniform items that she actually needs as well as shoes, bag etc

Next I will order the mandatory items for my primary school children. Cheaper at £14 for a jumper (need a few though to wash, and they also tend to disappear in school despite being named) and £5 for PE t-shirt. This school isn’t so strict about it being mandatory but nearly all the DC have logo ones, so ones who don’t stand out, and they are needed for sports day/school photo day anyway.

None of these items are especially good quality. With secondary, we are restricted to one local supplier and the man who owns the shop is bloody rude, which adds insult to injury.

The blazer, perhaps fair enough I think as they look quite smart, but is £44 really the best price school could find? The other items.. especially the PE kits where we could easily buy very similar items without the logo, are they necessary? Especially as we have a winter coming where some people won’t be able to pay bills.

(The secondary did have a “free second hand clothes rail” for all, at some point, but when I phoned to ask they were very vague about when it would be. I have a friend whose children are on pupil premium- no subsided option for them -
and she managed to find out what day this was but went to find the second hand uniform she found some shabby items that weren’t in her DC’s size, and no PE items.)

OP posts:
BewareTheBeardedDragon · 16/08/2022 08:36

Our primary school have just introduced mandatory branded PE sweatshirts. Previously the PE uniform included a plain navy sweatshirt. Apparently lots of children have been wearing non uniform coloured sweatshirts 'to keep warm' and for this reason they think introducing a light coloured branded one at £17.50 a pop will make uniform compliance better.

I genuinely don't understand why they couldn't just get tougher on expecting kids to actually wear plain navy sweatshirts - rather than requiring all to buy expensive branded ones which will not last as well because of their light colour. They will be stained with mud and so passing them on through families or through the second hand uniform store will be much harder.

Whatwouldscullydo · 16/08/2022 08:21

Cuck00soup · 16/08/2022 08:11

Those of you moaning about 4 pairs of shoes, what amateurs your schools must be in excluding the hoi poloi. The uniform list for DD’s school had school shoes, trainers, hockey trainers, football boots and astroturf trainers. Fortunately, I asked one of her friends older sisters if it was all necessary and she confirmed my suspicions. They need school shoes and one pair of trainers.

This is one of my fears actually. We have been asked to get non marking trainers, and football boots- hard ground and plastic studs as they need them for the AstroTurf. They won't be allowed on it with regular trainers.

also as the non marking trainers are presumably for the brand new sports hall, well I'm guessing by the "clean " instruction that they cant walk to school in them as they need to be kept clean. So her locker will be sat there full of shoes. She will be walking/cycling in trainers as they are more comfy for the distance she has to walk than the school shoes. So three pairs of shoes sat in her locker potentially not even being used. I'm thinking its gonna be like primary school where I just get returned a bag of barely used stuff thats all far to small now every few weeks that I have ti replace to again sit there unused

Cuck00soup · 16/08/2022 08:11

Those of you moaning about 4 pairs of shoes, what amateurs your schools must be in excluding the hoi poloi. The uniform list for DD’s school had school shoes, trainers, hockey trainers, football boots and astroturf trainers. Fortunately, I asked one of her friends older sisters if it was all necessary and she confirmed my suspicions. They need school shoes and one pair of trainers.

Thefruitbatdancer · 16/08/2022 07:57

A middle way has to be found in between logoed, exclusive uniform & own clothes. I was allowed to wear my own clothes at 6th form and that was a mistake imo & the school changed it after I left. It was easy to spot which students came from wealthier families. There were girls who were dressed in head to toe in designer labels & they regularly sneered at those who didn't. So the head introduced standard black skirt, blazer and white blouse without a logo for 6th formers.

For the reasons stated above, I believe in school uniform but not the ridiculously expensive logoed uniform of today.

pounchill · 16/08/2022 04:19

Our primary school started pushing being environmentally friendly ... week later have every child a plastic water bottle on sorts day to drink then bin. Hundreds of plastic waste when the whole school bring bottles to fill up daily! Such a poor message

sjxoxo · 16/08/2022 04:11

Mulling this over and wondered what would happen if all parents stuck together en mass and sent all kids to school in mon logo stuff. They wouldn’t be able to punish everyone.. begs the question to me who are the schools serving and on whose guidance? In the UK they are seen as high & mighty but they’re a public service funded by a tax paying nation for the tax paying nations kids..same as our other public services. I don’t see why they should be allowed to continue with blatantly outdated and unpopular policies? If you apply the facts here that you are all paying out for this stuff (for no real reason other than it’s compulsory) & compare it to the usage of other public services - if people were forced to pay these amounts they would be absolutely outraged. Schools should be at the cutting edge of education and that today means teaching sustainability and a more rounded approach to buying stuff. It’s actually really sh!t when you think about the bigger picture here. X

pounchill · 16/08/2022 03:49

Schools should support every background to afford a standard jumper, but also these clothes can be recycled etc. Badged jumpers get dumped constanlty, it's an absolute waste of money to me. We should be teaching our kids to be economical, not pay extortionate prices for soemthing to be thrown away

sjxoxo · 16/08/2022 03:27

dutysuite · 16/08/2022 02:59

My daughters school skirt is a thick heavy tartan skirt which is horrible in warm weather it costs £48, my sons have to have rugby shirts, games shirts, outdoor games jackets, shorts and jogging bottoms which all have to a logo, even their chrome book bags have to have a logo. This year to help with the cost the school (not private) stated that items such as games shorts and football socks didn’t need to come from the school uniform shop however, I found this quite unhelpful as I and many other parents had already stopped buying those from their supplier anyway as they are the only items that don’t have a logo. Trying to buy the uniform from the supplier is an absolute nightmare too as they have always been by appointment only during the school holidays and the uniform takes forever to arrive.

I find this quite shocking to be honest!! I would really consider this carefully when choosing a school - sounds v pretentious and also like they’re not focussing on bigger issues. What would happen if you sent them in with the same colour or style of item but not from the uniform shop? Or if you told the school you were unable to get an appointment or couldn’t afford it? Also what a lot of work for you to organise this!! Argh I’d tear my hair out x

sjxoxo · 16/08/2022 03:22

YADNBU and I would write to the head asking for iron on badges as can’t afford XYZ and what are they doing to comply with the government guidelines? Bloody joke. I am in france so no uniform here.. good in the sense of individualism BUT from July to October you get nothing but adverts for branded trainers & sweatshirts at ridiculous prices, all choreographed for the return to school. Uniform is definitely better IMO but they should just do iron on badges fgs!! That way everyone could buy a pack of 20 come September, iron them on to plain items and be done with it. If they want fancy blazers the school should provide them. X

dutysuite · 16/08/2022 02:59

My daughters school skirt is a thick heavy tartan skirt which is horrible in warm weather it costs £48, my sons have to have rugby shirts, games shirts, outdoor games jackets, shorts and jogging bottoms which all have to a logo, even their chrome book bags have to have a logo. This year to help with the cost the school (not private) stated that items such as games shorts and football socks didn’t need to come from the school uniform shop however, I found this quite unhelpful as I and many other parents had already stopped buying those from their supplier anyway as they are the only items that don’t have a logo. Trying to buy the uniform from the supplier is an absolute nightmare too as they have always been by appointment only during the school holidays and the uniform takes forever to arrive.

mathanxiety · 16/08/2022 02:56

Oh and the schools gave out chromebooks too.

mathanxiety · 16/08/2022 02:54

YANBU.

This is utterly appalling.

My kids went to a non uniform high school in the US. They wore school issued unisex basketball style PE shorts and Ts. The cost was under $10 and if you forgot your stuff you could rent a kit for 50 cents. The school also provided swimsuits for all students for swimming class and sanitized it all daily. This was free.

They wore uniform in their elementary school, but I could buy DS' anywhere, and the DDs' blouses too, up to 5th grade. The DDs wore pinafores to 4th grade and a skirt after that to 8th grade. The pinafore and skirts were easy to alter to fit though only available from the uniform shop. The blouses for 5th to 8th grade were only available at the uniform supply shop. PE gear was a shorts you could buy anywhere and a white t-shirt.

Kids in public elementary schools don't wear uniforms.

Somehow or other, all these kids who get through school wearing their own choice of clothing, with no logo in sight, go to university or into jobs and figure out what's appropriate to wear to whatever workplace they end up in.

LemonMuffins · 16/08/2022 02:43

We have twins entering year 10 and also had a huge list of art supplies requested for gcse art (they're both doing it).

We even have to supply acrylic paint, paint brushes and a bloody tool box with padlock?! It would surely be more economical for school to bulk buy and have parents contribute to that? We also have to pay a separate amount for their sketch books and portfolios.

I did gcse art in the mid 2000s and all I remember having of my own was some graphite pencils and colouring pencils. We had a fully stocked supply cupboard in our bog standard state school.

I refuse to buy the full PE kit - they have some tshirts and shorts that still fit so they'll do. I won't buy any rugby jerseys, socks or hoodies and they'll get by in their mildly scruffy blazers until they no longer fit. Shirts I only buy from asda as they destroy them anyway. I also refuse to buy football boots or mouthguards as they never get used.

If school ever get arsey about any of this I'll tell them to provide it themselves

Parents were also essentially forced to buy laptops, as school want to implement laptop learning. It's nuts.

I dread to think what will be demanded of the child doing food tech 😩

RedToothBrush · 16/08/2022 02:21

Florenz · 15/08/2022 21:49

Is £500 a year really too much to spend on sending your child to a good school?

Well Jacob. They could just use their other money. On a pointless excuse to satisfy the egos of a few parents and teachers.

HighlandPony · 16/08/2022 02:16

Not unreasonable at all. I hate uniform. If you want them in uniform you provide it. Any workplace that wants staff in uniform provides it so schools should be no different. All this rubbish about how it stops bullying etc it doesn’t. You can spot the kid wearing a jumper that’s been through four other siblings first a mile off.

RedToothBrush · 16/08/2022 02:15

Twizbe · 15/08/2022 22:29

I just don't see the fuss.

I spent less over all on clothes for DS since he's started school as he doesn't need so much. Being in uniform 5 days a week is a huge help for that.

I'd be more pissed off if I had to buy expensive but bad quality. But as it is, when DD starts she just needs a bag and a tie from the branded bits.

I've got friends who are at schools with more lax uniform and they have to buy way more uniform because a lot of the unbranded stuff from supermarkets just falls apart or fades.

DS can wear either logoed or unlogoed tops to school. I buy both - partly because he is self conscious about it and partly because I can't afford to fork out on just the branded stuff with the state he comes home in after school.

The supermarket polos and jumpers last longer and don't fade as much as the logoed stuff which he wears in equal measure. Thats the thing that really pisses me off. The logoed stuff really isn't better quality and is extortionate. If you were getting the quality to match it wouldn't be so gaulling.

RedToothBrush · 16/08/2022 02:08

Twizbe · 15/08/2022 22:18

I think school uniform teaches an important lesson.

There are loads of jobs and professions where you have to wear certain clothes. Either for safety, cleanliness or branding. Sometimes you have to wear certain things in certain situations.

God. How do people in countries without uniform cope when they grow up and have to wear safety equipment or uniform? It must blow their unprepared minds and cause psychological trauma.

Some people come up with some right bullshit to justify uniform. Its either a tool to use on a power trip over kids or a tool to stop the riff raff applying.

Thefruitbatdancer · 15/08/2022 22:44

When my dc were at primary I always bought their grey uniform from M&S. Superb quality that would often last 2 academic years if I bought a size up. The logo jumper I bought from the PTA shop for £16 bobbled after a few washes.

Twizbe · 15/08/2022 22:29

I just don't see the fuss.

I spent less over all on clothes for DS since he's started school as he doesn't need so much. Being in uniform 5 days a week is a huge help for that.

I'd be more pissed off if I had to buy expensive but bad quality. But as it is, when DD starts she just needs a bag and a tie from the branded bits.

I've got friends who are at schools with more lax uniform and they have to buy way more uniform because a lot of the unbranded stuff from supermarkets just falls apart or fades.

TeacupDrama · 15/08/2022 22:28

very few countries in the EU have any school uniform at all though there are some dress codes and requirements in Scandinavia children go outside unless below -25C so they need proper warm and waterproof clothing and footwear, in france there are rules about religious attire, Germany, Austria and Italy has been anti uniform of any type for schools since WWII,
we really do not need anything at all other than a colour scheme and sensible dress code

miserablecat · 15/08/2022 22:25

Florenz · 15/08/2022 21:49

Is £500 a year really too much to spend on sending your child to a good school?

...but the £500 isn't to ensure the quality of the school , or the education your child receives.

If you choose to pay for private school you pay for (often, but not necessarily) smaller classes, or better ratio of staff: pupils, better range of clubs etc, newer or better range of facilities and (probably) networking opportunities.

With state school you are often allocated the nearest school without it being an active choice. A state education is free that is why its not OK to effectively exclude some lower income families by having unnecessarily expensive uniform.

And whilst it's good that lots of schools have 2nd hand sales or sell on fb market place, that should not be a family's only choice of affording a uniform. It's often pot luck (and time consuming) to find each item needed, in the right size, from a place that you are able to get to, to collect from....when it would be a lot easier to pick up a correct size pair of trousers or polo shirt from matalan or the supermarket.

Thefruitbatdancer · 15/08/2022 22:24

dannydyerismydad · 15/08/2022 22:19

It's the shoe thing that gives me the biggest rage.

People complain kids are lazy and don't walk enough. They complain about pollution and traffic around schools as parents drop their offspring at the door.

Meanwhile schools are forcing horrible, stiff formal shoes onto kids feet. Encourage them to wear trainers and walk/run to school.

DS has the most awkward shaped feet. He's worn cheap black non flashy trainers to primary school for the last 2 years.

I've just spent : full days trying every pair of Clarks, Start Rite, M&S, supermarket shoes. Most of them won't even get on his foot due to his ridiculously high instep.

Try Geox shoes for awkward feet

Whatwouldscullydo · 15/08/2022 22:24

I've just spent : full days trying every pair of Clarks, Start Rite, M&S, supermarket shoes. Most of them won't even get on his foot due to his ridiculously high instep

I hear you. Dd2 inherited my wonky feet. She does better ( we all do) in ankle boots. More support. Less chance if ankles rolling so much. I'm secretly hoping that when we get our referral to the physio therapist they will suggest boots might be better and we can tell school where to stick their shoe rules.

Although I doubt I'd be that lucky. We are a family with awkward feet. Who fare much better in ankle boots than shoes.

LeChienAMangeMesDevoirs · 15/08/2022 22:23

@Twizbe I don't buy that line of thinking.

DH, who grew up without uniform overseas and now works in a profession that requires a uniform, has managed to adapt without problems.

Often professions that require a uniform require a number of years of university study. Said students do not wear uniform except on placement perhaps.

It's a ludicrous, outdated concept. I cannot see any advantages. Children know who has money with or without uniform.

dannydyerismydad · 15/08/2022 22:19

It's the shoe thing that gives me the biggest rage.

People complain kids are lazy and don't walk enough. They complain about pollution and traffic around schools as parents drop their offspring at the door.

Meanwhile schools are forcing horrible, stiff formal shoes onto kids feet. Encourage them to wear trainers and walk/run to school.

DS has the most awkward shaped feet. He's worn cheap black non flashy trainers to primary school for the last 2 years.

I've just spent : full days trying every pair of Clarks, Start Rite, M&S, supermarket shoes. Most of them won't even get on his foot due to his ridiculously high instep.