Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the mandatory logo school items need to stop?

264 replies

BagelwithPhiladelphiaz · 15/08/2022 09:56

Exactly this.

I have just paid £76 for the mandatory PE kit for my DD’s senior school. Including items such as striped rugby socks, which are mandatory for some reason for all PE lessons, rugby or not.

This is before I spend £44 on a blazer, plus the uniform items that she actually needs as well as shoes, bag etc

Next I will order the mandatory items for my primary school children. Cheaper at £14 for a jumper (need a few though to wash, and they also tend to disappear in school despite being named) and £5 for PE t-shirt. This school isn’t so strict about it being mandatory but nearly all the DC have logo ones, so ones who don’t stand out, and they are needed for sports day/school photo day anyway.

None of these items are especially good quality. With secondary, we are restricted to one local supplier and the man who owns the shop is bloody rude, which adds insult to injury.

The blazer, perhaps fair enough I think as they look quite smart, but is £44 really the best price school could find? The other items.. especially the PE kits where we could easily buy very similar items without the logo, are they necessary? Especially as we have a winter coming where some people won’t be able to pay bills.

(The secondary did have a “free second hand clothes rail” for all, at some point, but when I phoned to ask they were very vague about when it would be. I have a friend whose children are on pupil premium- no subsided option for them -
and she managed to find out what day this was but went to find the second hand uniform she found some shabby items that weren’t in her DC’s size, and no PE items.)

OP posts:
HighlandPony · 16/08/2022 19:54

I’m a firm believer that uniform is merely an extra tax on parents

UndertheCedartree · 16/08/2022 19:49

LockAqua · 15/08/2022 19:11

@tithead22

The whole point of a uniform is that everyone looks smart and the same. Blazers are part of the uniform and should therefore be worn at all times.

Good schools have high standards and expectations in all areas, including uniform.

Not at my DD's outstanding Primary or my DS's non-uniform school. At DD's school they are inclusive to all (why should only the wealthy get to go to outstanding schools?) Uniform can be bought from the supermarket and looks perfectly smart enough. At DS's school they all wear jeans, t-shirts and hoodies with no effect on the high achievement. In fact both schools focus on that rather than if Ella is wearing the right shoes or if Leo's tie is the right length. All that nonsense - not for me, thanks.

Parker231 · 16/08/2022 15:27

UndertheCedartree · 16/08/2022 14:52

My DS doesn't wear uniform. He wears jeans, t-shirts and hoodies from Primark. He would think any 'one up manship' very immature and in poor taste.

Same with DT’s - private, expensive but non uniform school. Regular jeans, shorts etc were the norm - non branded. No one cared about where your clothes came from - also no bullying about what items of clothing you had. Worked out much cheaper as they wore for school the same clothes they would have done after school, weekends and holidays

UndertheCedartree · 16/08/2022 14:52

Pinklady245612 · 15/08/2022 16:09

I can imagine my son's friends all trying to one up each other. Plain shirts and trackies won't cut it, they'd want named stuff which becomes just as costly. My point to OP was that the school is taking the p*ss as our school logo pe kit is half the price of hers

My DS doesn't wear uniform. He wears jeans, t-shirts and hoodies from Primark. He would think any 'one up manship' very immature and in poor taste.

Fizbosshoes · 16/08/2022 13:37

But the choice doesn't have to be compulsory logo-ed uniform or no uniform?

Can schools not state a colour and people can buy skirt/trousers/blazer in that colour from a shop of their choice/budget and a school tie? It's obviously an earner for schools who get a% from the suppliers but uniform can be done without having to have branded or logoed stuff.

When I was at school the uniform was black. There was a school supplier but it wasn't compulsory to buy uniform there. The wealthier kids bought their blazers and uniforms there, my parents bought uniform from bhs which was cheaper (I'm pretty sure supermarkets generally didn't do clothes/uniforms in the 1990s) The tie and school badge we could get from school and then everything else could be bought where you wanted.

PerrinAybara · 16/08/2022 13:33

YANBU. DC1 is just about to start secondary and I've spent a fortune on various compulsory logoed bits (but not as much as some posters).

What worries me more is that the school is super-strict with uniform rules being followed - blazers on at all times, no coats indoors, punishment for uniform infringements, etc. So I am not sure DC2 will be able to attend the school when the time comes, despite it being close and all his friends likely to be going, as he has ASD and lots of sensory issues around uniform. I know I can request reasonable adjustments on the EHCP but they would be obvious and make him stand out as being different. Hardly inclusive.

UndertheCedartree · 16/08/2022 13:13

I agree. All school uniform should be able to be bought from a supermarket.

I'm lucky in that although there are logoed items for my DD's Primary none of them are compulsory so I've been able to order plain items from a supermarket. Still expensive as she's outgrown everything!

The Secondary she will be going to will require specific items for everything - so shirt, skirt and jumper plus P.E kit all not able to be bought from the supermarket, but at least no blazer!

Parker231 · 16/08/2022 13:06

School uniform in the UK is ridiculous - it adds nothing to their education and the majority is expensive and impractical. Really is time it was abandoned. DT’s school was non uniform - they wore jeans, T-shirt and hoodie which they had anyway.

Louise0701 · 16/08/2022 13:04

@ThePumpkinPatch DS needs black school shoes, black plimsolls, wellingtons, football / rugby boots & black trainers for games.

Louise0701 · 16/08/2022 13:02

YANBU. I’ve just spent £620 on 2 DC, still need DC3s preschool uniform and shoes, coats & wellingtons.

user1471447863 · 16/08/2022 13:01

HighlandPony · 16/08/2022 02:16

Not unreasonable at all. I hate uniform. If you want them in uniform you provide it. Any workplace that wants staff in uniform provides it so schools should be no different. All this rubbish about how it stops bullying etc it doesn’t. You can spot the kid wearing a jumper that’s been through four other siblings first a mile off.

Exactly this.
A workplace may have a dress code but the moment it turns into uniform/logo's/branded/corporate styling or PPE then they supply.
If schools had to do the same they would quickly sort out their ideas.

And as for the nonsense about bullying - what stops bullying is proper schooling, teaching children appropriate behaviour and tackling inappropriate ones promptly and effectively. Not uniforms.

gogohmm · 16/08/2022 12:24

My DD's school has sew on badges for the blazer - I bought hers from M&S then a £4 badge (which you could remove and sew onto the bigger size!)

ChocolateCakeYum · 16/08/2022 12:20

School uniform is ridiculous.

Ds’s blazer alone costs £70!

acorntotree · 16/08/2022 12:09

My son's school has an amazing second hand store which is run by a parent where every item is £1 and most is barely worn and in great condition. It would be good if this was the case at all schools. I've looked at the uniform for the local secondary schools and the blazer at the school my dd will probably go to is £99!

cyclamenqueen · 16/08/2022 11:58

Hopeandlove · 16/08/2022 11:45

If your children are FSM ask the school for a voucher for uniform

In many schools the voucher doesn’t even cover the cost of a blazer and skirt . Also some academies have banned second hand uniform sales/Facebook sites ( obviously they can’t stop parents privately selling union yo each other ) ostensibly to stop tatty uniform but also to preserve their control and supplier monopoly .

Hopeandlove · 16/08/2022 11:45

If your children are FSM ask the school for a voucher for uniform

AnnPerkins · 16/08/2022 11:43

YADNBU DS is starting at upper school in September where they have to wear blazers with house-specific badges AND ties with house-specific logos (£10.99 each). So if you have a younger sibling who is put into a different house you can't hand down older sibling's. And of course they are only available from a single supplier. There are also logoed skirts and trousers but we can buy elsewhere and sew on a logo (£5) if we prefer Hmm

For PE they have to have as minimum shorts, polo shirt, rugby top, hoodie and socks - that of course can only be bought from the same supplier.

I bought just one of everything (2 trousers) and have spent £150 already. I still need to get jumper, shirts, footwear and schoolbag.

There is a thriving Facebook page for buying and selling used stuff but why go so overboard with their uniform requirements in the first place? Who wears blazers or even shirts and ties in the workplace any more?

And making them keep blazers on in the summer term? That is frankly psychotic Angry.

BigFatLiar · 16/08/2022 11:38

spanieleyes · 15/08/2022 10:16

We have a logo jumper/cardigan and that's it, nothing else. And even that isn't compulsory and we say so! As long as pupils have roughly the correct colour( blue jumper and grey/black skirts and trousers) that's fine!

It's ages (or seems like it) since we had this problem fortunately like you they were pretty basic requirements plus the allowed a couple of shops (sewing supplies) that had the capability to embroider the design onto clothes so you could buy a plain top in the correct colour and take it along and have the logo added.

Stripeydragon · 16/08/2022 11:27

A lot of the children at my son's special school wear uniform on non uniform days because that is what you wear at school. For ds putting it on in the morning tells him that is where he is going that day. It also means he only has one set of clothes always covered in paint stains etc. There are other reasons other than anti bullying for having a uniform.

LeevMarie · 16/08/2022 11:19

@miserablecat totally agree! It upsets me, too. DS will still be 3 when he starts the nursery - surely the anti-bullying argument in favour of uniform isn't a valid one when we're talking about kids that young.

It amounts to nothing more than a money-spinner for the school.

PowerPack · 16/08/2022 11:13

I work in a PRU with the most deprived children in the county. We don't have a uniform, but it's something that comes up repeatedly with the Student Council. They want branded stuff. Most them are wearing branded clothing in one form or another (even if it's Primark) , that marks out their social status, they'd prefer it was school branding.

miserablecat · 16/08/2022 11:10

I was really upset when they brought in uniform (branded polo shirts) when DS was at nursery. They've got the rest of their school lives to wear identical uniform - what's wrong with going to nursery wearing a tutu or a spiderman suit (if weather appropriate!)

LeevMarie · 16/08/2022 11:01

Agreed, op. It's ridiculous. I've just handed over nearly £60 for nursery uniform. Nursery!! That's before I've bought the mandatory two pairs of shoes, trousers and PE shorts.

I've never understood the UK's obsession with uniform either. The nursery/school I'm sending DS to is a high performing academy in a rank average part of the north of England. I certainly don't live in a wealthy part of the country.

The argument put forward by the school in favour of this nonsense is that the children look, "very smart". I despair.

Aworldofmyown · 16/08/2022 10:22

Our secondary school uniform consists of:
Logo blazer
Logo Jumper
Specific check skirt only sold at school supplier.
Logo tie.
Long and short sleeved Logo PE top
Logo PE shorts.
Logo PE socks.
2x trainers (astro and outdoor)
They get round government guidelines by telling us some of the uniform is optional ie jumpers but kids cannot wear an alternative, so if you want them to be warm it will cost you. Makes me fucking furious.
We can afford it but we live in a very split area of wealthy and poor. No choice of school as they are all seriously over subscribed.
They issue uniform report cards, I want to cry for the kids who's parents can't afford it.
We do have a Facebook uniform page so I put outgrown stuff on there for free I the hope it helps someone - it's crazy unfair though.

Smorgasbordbaby · 16/08/2022 10:04

LockAqua · 15/08/2022 19:07

I strongly disagree. A uniform is meant to be err, uniform. I believe uniforms shouid be strict and smart with all items logoed so that everyone is the same.

Ime the best schools all have strict uniforms with logos being expected. Schools with low uniform standards tend to have cultures of low expectations and poor discipline. Not for me, thanks.

I strongly disagree. I went to private school for most of my schooling and the ridiculous uniforms I had to wear made no difference to how I learnt. I now live in a country that doesn't have school uniforms and consistently ranks in the top 10 worldwide for education. My children's learning is affected by their teachers, the school, the support and the environment. The fact that they're comfortable, in decent clothes and good quality comfortable shoes seems much more beneficial to their learning than stuffed into wool blazers or uncomfortable kilts like I was.