Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the mandatory logo school items need to stop?

264 replies

BagelwithPhiladelphiaz · 15/08/2022 09:56

Exactly this.

I have just paid £76 for the mandatory PE kit for my DD’s senior school. Including items such as striped rugby socks, which are mandatory for some reason for all PE lessons, rugby or not.

This is before I spend £44 on a blazer, plus the uniform items that she actually needs as well as shoes, bag etc

Next I will order the mandatory items for my primary school children. Cheaper at £14 for a jumper (need a few though to wash, and they also tend to disappear in school despite being named) and £5 for PE t-shirt. This school isn’t so strict about it being mandatory but nearly all the DC have logo ones, so ones who don’t stand out, and they are needed for sports day/school photo day anyway.

None of these items are especially good quality. With secondary, we are restricted to one local supplier and the man who owns the shop is bloody rude, which adds insult to injury.

The blazer, perhaps fair enough I think as they look quite smart, but is £44 really the best price school could find? The other items.. especially the PE kits where we could easily buy very similar items without the logo, are they necessary? Especially as we have a winter coming where some people won’t be able to pay bills.

(The secondary did have a “free second hand clothes rail” for all, at some point, but when I phoned to ask they were very vague about when it would be. I have a friend whose children are on pupil premium- no subsided option for them -
and she managed to find out what day this was but went to find the second hand uniform she found some shabby items that weren’t in her DC’s size, and no PE items.)

OP posts:
dannydyerismydad · 17/08/2022 11:47

@InChocolateWeTrust we had fewer problems with school shoes when DS was smaller (aside from the fact we have never managed to get a pair of Clark's to fit his feet - his instep is freakishly high and the Velcro would never do up). Start Rite were always fine.

Unfortunately secondary school is another kettle of fish altogether. Plenty of Clark's and Start Rite styles which would have been acceptable at primary are deemed "too much like trainers". Different schools have different rules, and DS's secondary insists on the sort of stiff shoes a banker would wear with his suits. The only pair we could do up was 2 full sizes bigger than the size he measures at.

I don't complain about uniform for the sake of complaining. In general I'm happy that we don't have to think about what to put on when we get up in the morning. I do find it frustrating when the rules (and shoes) are so rigid a child is in pain.

Twizbe · 17/08/2022 11:18

I seriously have no issue with uniform but I think some rules around branded stuff would be good.

  1. anything branded must be unisex (exception for single sex schools)

  2. the school has to provide a second hand market place which must include a free swap shop

  3. quality has to match price. I have no issue paying £30 for a jumper IF that jumper lasts more than 1 year or can be donated / passed on in almost perfect condition

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 17/08/2022 10:35

our school has done deals with all uniforms suppliers to 75.00 for blazer, skirt, pet kit.

PuttingDownRoots · 17/08/2022 10:30

My DDs primary school is a shirt and tie uniform.

Except on PE days. Then its black leggings/shorts/joggers, white tshirt, black jumper. PE days include forest school, and after school sports club days. My DD wore pe kit three days a week. Every class ended up with a mix of pe kit and uniform sone days.

Why they don't change the uniform to black joggers/leggings, white tshirt/polo, then the school colour jumper is a mystery to me... it would actually be smarter than the random mix

Tohaveandtohold · 17/08/2022 10:17

Primary schools are doing this as well. In my friend’s child’s school, they wear branded tartan pinafore and branded cardigan in the early years and from y4, the girls wear branded tartan skirts, branded blazers and school tie. This makes things difficult for parents because it’s like an overall change from Y4 so one can’t even wear the same thing they had before. They only have one supplier as well. They’ve changed the branded and very expensive PE kit twice, it’s so ridiculous and they only have one supplier for all.
After covid, she said some parents complained about the cost of the uniform for girls especially and they held a poll for those that want the branded skirt and pinafore to be changed to just the normal grey supermarket trouser but still 85% of parents still said they prefer the expensive ones ( it always look good and smart when worn to be fair). The school then gave parents the option to wear grey trousers for their girls if they want and my friend bought her child one but almost everyone still wear the branded ones so she has decided to buy the branded one this year again. It’s as if even parents of children in state school like this one like the whole uniform look because it makes them look like private schools. I don’t even know where the balance is

gatehouseoffleet · 17/08/2022 10:15

For sure they will never wear blazers and logos again as adults unless they have to for employment purposes

I would hazard a guess that very very few current schoolkids will ever have to wear uniforms in the workplace unless they are in a public facing role eg in a shop or a guard on a train. And even then it will be provided for them, they won't have to buy it!

gatehouseoffleet · 17/08/2022 10:13

Quia · 17/08/2022 10:01

The only conceivably justification for school uniform is keeping costs down. As soon as expensive uniform with blazers and logos becomes compulsory, it totally negates that. The Department for Education really needs to toughen up on its guidance and make it clear that insisting on expensive uniform will lead to a crashing Ofsted fail.

I totally agree. There is no need for any of this and it takes away teacher and staff resources policing it.

You can look smart without having silly rules and expensive uniform. It is an abomination that parents have to invest in expensive and unnecessary uniform items for state schools (but it was ever thus, I remember my state school introducing a school skirt in the late 80s which cost £25 even then! Fortunately I was going into the sixth form which was more flexible).

Teaching isn't a really highly paid profession except for some "super-heads" so why do they think parents are so well off and can afford all of this?

Quia · 17/08/2022 10:09

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/08/2022 22:35

Can schools not state a colour and people can buy skirt/trousers/blazer in that colour from a shop of their choice/budget and a school tie?

Giving a choice like that invariably gets abused. You get the parents who insist little Johnny simply isn't comfortable unless he's in the scruffiest joggers going, the teenage girls who buy the shortest possible skirt in the right colour, the parents who don't like the unfashionable style of a plain sweatshirt & buy hugely variable fashion items instead.

The point of the uniform is for it to be uniform. I.e. all the kids look the same so appearance is no longer an issue. The more prescriptive, the less potential there is for variance to creep in and you have kids unhappy because they haven't got the trendiest hipster style trousers.

Plus it is supposed to be smart and tidy, both of which are positive attributes to encourage as they are widely appreciated in human society.

Nonsense. Plenty of schools simply prescribe something like grey skirts and trousers, white shirts and a plain dark coloured pullover, and make it clear the clothes are to be bought from any chain store's uniform range. It works fine. No-one gets worked up because some other child has a slightly hipster style of grey trousers, after all that is still hardly the height of fashion.

I can't see if it really matters if someone turns up in joggers - plenty of children with sensory difficulties cannot cope with rough material or something that is tight around their waste, so why make them wear it? It's not as if wearing joggers will affect their ability to learn, if anything the fact that they are comfortable is likely to enhance it.

Forcing children to wear uncomfortable blazers and ties doesn't make them smart and tidy, rather the reverse. They will always find a way to make the blazer look scruffy and tie the tie massively unevenly, and they will chuck the logoed stuff off as soon as they get home. For sure they will never wear blazers and logos again as adults unless they have to for employment purposes.

Quia · 17/08/2022 10:01

The only conceivably justification for school uniform is keeping costs down. As soon as expensive uniform with blazers and logos becomes compulsory, it totally negates that. The Department for Education really needs to toughen up on its guidance and make it clear that insisting on expensive uniform will lead to a crashing Ofsted fail.

Quia · 17/08/2022 09:57

londonmummy1966 · 16/08/2022 23:07

Whilst all the logod stuff annoys me the PE kit is the real annoyance - I seriously think that PE teachers like the power trip and kit is a way to get it over not just the kids but also the parents. They really have such inflated ideas about the importance of kit. DDs last kit list was -
stripey socks in an odd combination of colours for hockey
white socks with a multi couloured stripe around the top for tennis
Plain purple knee socks for netball (why couldn't they use the hockey ones.....)
black tracksuit bottoms with a green stripe
school logo'd track suit top
tracksuit only used to travel to sports ground on the mini bus and then removed to reveal
school logod polo shirt
school logod skort
above only used for net ball as for hockey they wore
school logod leggings
school logod midlayer and over that
school logoed football shorts
white school logo'd polo top for tennis
white school logod skirt for tennis
black leotard with purple trim for gym/dance
plain black shorts to wear over leotard for dance (why weren't the football shorts acceptable)
black swim suit with purple stripe
school logo swimming cap
school logod swimming bag
school logod sports bag
black trainers for hockey
white trainers for netball and tennis
a second pair of black trainers to be worn only to walk from the changing rooms to the hall for gym/dance

best part of £500.

I wrote a letter of complaint to the chair of governors who replied it was important for DDs representing the school to look smart but didn't bother to reply to my follow up to ask why this was necessary for all DC including mine who didn't play against other schools.....

I would be asking why having a logo makes them look any smarter. As well as referring the governor to the government guidance on uniform linked upthread.

Quia · 17/08/2022 09:56

mewkins · 15/08/2022 10:07

You are not unseasonable and government guidance agrees with you. I think you could email the head and ask what they are doing to comply with this.

www.gov.uk/government/publications/cost-of-school-uniforms/cost-of-school-uniforms#requirements-for-schools

This! Also contact each and every governor and ask about it.

UndertheCedartree · 17/08/2022 09:54

londonmummy1966 · 16/08/2022 23:07

Whilst all the logod stuff annoys me the PE kit is the real annoyance - I seriously think that PE teachers like the power trip and kit is a way to get it over not just the kids but also the parents. They really have such inflated ideas about the importance of kit. DDs last kit list was -
stripey socks in an odd combination of colours for hockey
white socks with a multi couloured stripe around the top for tennis
Plain purple knee socks for netball (why couldn't they use the hockey ones.....)
black tracksuit bottoms with a green stripe
school logo'd track suit top
tracksuit only used to travel to sports ground on the mini bus and then removed to reveal
school logod polo shirt
school logod skort
above only used for net ball as for hockey they wore
school logod leggings
school logod midlayer and over that
school logoed football shorts
white school logo'd polo top for tennis
white school logod skirt for tennis
black leotard with purple trim for gym/dance
plain black shorts to wear over leotard for dance (why weren't the football shorts acceptable)
black swim suit with purple stripe
school logo swimming cap
school logod swimming bag
school logod sports bag
black trainers for hockey
white trainers for netball and tennis
a second pair of black trainers to be worn only to walk from the changing rooms to the hall for gym/dance

best part of £500.

I wrote a letter of complaint to the chair of governors who replied it was important for DDs representing the school to look smart but didn't bother to reply to my follow up to ask why this was necessary for all DC including mine who didn't play against other schools.....

That is completely ridiculous! I went to a Grammar for secondary which was in to looking smart etc. We still managed to wear the same kit for hockey, netball and tennis - polo, netball skirt and sweatshirt and gym knickers and polo for dance/gymnastics. Those who competed also had a tracksuit, but not needed for those who didn't.

londonmummy1966 · 16/08/2022 23:07

Whilst all the logod stuff annoys me the PE kit is the real annoyance - I seriously think that PE teachers like the power trip and kit is a way to get it over not just the kids but also the parents. They really have such inflated ideas about the importance of kit. DDs last kit list was -
stripey socks in an odd combination of colours for hockey
white socks with a multi couloured stripe around the top for tennis
Plain purple knee socks for netball (why couldn't they use the hockey ones.....)
black tracksuit bottoms with a green stripe
school logo'd track suit top
tracksuit only used to travel to sports ground on the mini bus and then removed to reveal
school logod polo shirt
school logod skort
above only used for net ball as for hockey they wore
school logod leggings
school logod midlayer and over that
school logoed football shorts
white school logo'd polo top for tennis
white school logod skirt for tennis
black leotard with purple trim for gym/dance
plain black shorts to wear over leotard for dance (why weren't the football shorts acceptable)
black swim suit with purple stripe
school logo swimming cap
school logod swimming bag
school logod sports bag
black trainers for hockey
white trainers for netball and tennis
a second pair of black trainers to be worn only to walk from the changing rooms to the hall for gym/dance

best part of £500.

I wrote a letter of complaint to the chair of governors who replied it was important for DDs representing the school to look smart but didn't bother to reply to my follow up to ask why this was necessary for all DC including mine who didn't play against other schools.....

UndertheCedartree · 16/08/2022 22:51

LockAqua · 16/08/2022 21:05

@UndertheCedartree

Clearly there are exceptions but it’s no coincidence that the vast majority of outstanding schools, including top private schools, have very strict uniforms.

The DCs’ school are very strict on uniform and how it is worn and they believe this is a huge part of the school’s success.

’Sweating the small stuff’- i.e. top buttons undone, blazers off without permission improves overall behaviour and prevents bigger behavioural problems.

I honestly doubt that. More likely it is just because the poorer DC and those with SEND are excluded.

Fizbosshoes · 16/08/2022 22:48

The point of the uniform is for it to be uniform. I.e. all the kids look the same so appearance is no longer an issue. The more prescriptive, the less potential there is for variance to creep in and you have kids unhappy because they haven't got the trendiest hipster style trousers.

...so tough luck if youre a low income family and the blazer is £80+, the skirts are £30 each, and there are multiple PE kits to buy for each child?

UndertheCedartree · 16/08/2022 22:41

acorntotree · 16/08/2022 12:09

My son's school has an amazing second hand store which is run by a parent where every item is £1 and most is barely worn and in great condition. It would be good if this was the case at all schools. I've looked at the uniform for the local secondary schools and the blazer at the school my dd will probably go to is £99!

My DD's school has this too, 50p an item, run by the PTA. It can be dipped into by the school for any DC that needs it for free. My DD benefitted when I sent her to school in a Summer dress on the day it snowed 😳(it was beautifully sunny in the morning!) They found her a nice thick cardi to go over her dress and even put an extra in her bag too.

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/08/2022 22:35

Can schools not state a colour and people can buy skirt/trousers/blazer in that colour from a shop of their choice/budget and a school tie?

Giving a choice like that invariably gets abused. You get the parents who insist little Johnny simply isn't comfortable unless he's in the scruffiest joggers going, the teenage girls who buy the shortest possible skirt in the right colour, the parents who don't like the unfashionable style of a plain sweatshirt & buy hugely variable fashion items instead.

The point of the uniform is for it to be uniform. I.e. all the kids look the same so appearance is no longer an issue. The more prescriptive, the less potential there is for variance to creep in and you have kids unhappy because they haven't got the trendiest hipster style trousers.

Plus it is supposed to be smart and tidy, both of which are positive attributes to encourage as they are widely appreciated in human society.

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/08/2022 22:14

Since when are Clark's shoes stiff?
They are soft leather with rubber soles, they are functionally near identical to leather trainers they simply look smarter and can polished to look smart.

My DS has wide feet and high in steps and we had zero problem getting big standard clarks that he found comfortable.

I think some people just hate the look and idea of smart uniform clothing even when its functionally no different to what would be worn otherwise. Modern primary school wear is flexible, elasticated waist band, comfy polo shirts & sweatshirts.

Fine if you idealistically dislike it but don't make it out it's not comfortable clothing.

InChocolateWeTrust · 16/08/2022 22:08

I'm amazed there isnt more second hand trade going?

I live in an affluent area where people can comfortably afford the uniforms, nonetheless there is a roaring second hand trade going. The pta do £1 an item sales and there's always piles of school jumpers, trousers, shirts, polos. Plus theres this class list app and people offer up all sorts for free, plus there's a local buy sell group where people regularly offer up good condition uniform items for free. I've only this week passed only DC logo tops to a neighbour for free, I had DC tie and 2 jumpers free off a different neighbour. Secondary stuff is regularly given away too, everything from blazers, pe stuff, ties, the works.

UndertheCedartree · 16/08/2022 21:57

dannydyerismydad · 15/08/2022 22:19

It's the shoe thing that gives me the biggest rage.

People complain kids are lazy and don't walk enough. They complain about pollution and traffic around schools as parents drop their offspring at the door.

Meanwhile schools are forcing horrible, stiff formal shoes onto kids feet. Encourage them to wear trainers and walk/run to school.

DS has the most awkward shaped feet. He's worn cheap black non flashy trainers to primary school for the last 2 years.

I've just spent : full days trying every pair of Clarks, Start Rite, M&S, supermarket shoes. Most of them won't even get on his foot due to his ridiculously high instep.

Completely agree. School shoes are not practical at all. My DD's Primary allows trainers to be worn and isn't fussy about the colour, thankfully.

Parker231 · 16/08/2022 21:44

Due to the financial crisis I imagine a larger number than previous years won’t be going back to school in the regulatory uniform. Their families won’t have the cash available.

UndertheCedartree · 16/08/2022 21:21

Florenz · 15/08/2022 21:49

Is £500 a year really too much to spend on sending your child to a good school?

Whether it is or isn't, the point is some families can't afford that. And should lower income DC be excluded from good schools?

2anddonefornow · 16/08/2022 21:17

For us as well as cost we have a sizing issue. Need much larger size for length but they go wider much quicker so looks frankly ridiculous.

LockAqua · 16/08/2022 21:05

@UndertheCedartree

Clearly there are exceptions but it’s no coincidence that the vast majority of outstanding schools, including top private schools, have very strict uniforms.

The DCs’ school are very strict on uniform and how it is worn and they believe this is a huge part of the school’s success.

’Sweating the small stuff’- i.e. top buttons undone, blazers off without permission improves overall behaviour and prevents bigger behavioural problems.

Snoozer11 · 16/08/2022 20:30

It always amazes me how we always hear about teachers being overly stretched and having to work into the small hours 7 days a week, and yet they same to spend an awful lot of time clutching their pearls and sending letters home about an undone top button.

Swipe left for the next trending thread