Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the mandatory logo school items need to stop?

264 replies

BagelwithPhiladelphiaz · 15/08/2022 09:56

Exactly this.

I have just paid £76 for the mandatory PE kit for my DD’s senior school. Including items such as striped rugby socks, which are mandatory for some reason for all PE lessons, rugby or not.

This is before I spend £44 on a blazer, plus the uniform items that she actually needs as well as shoes, bag etc

Next I will order the mandatory items for my primary school children. Cheaper at £14 for a jumper (need a few though to wash, and they also tend to disappear in school despite being named) and £5 for PE t-shirt. This school isn’t so strict about it being mandatory but nearly all the DC have logo ones, so ones who don’t stand out, and they are needed for sports day/school photo day anyway.

None of these items are especially good quality. With secondary, we are restricted to one local supplier and the man who owns the shop is bloody rude, which adds insult to injury.

The blazer, perhaps fair enough I think as they look quite smart, but is £44 really the best price school could find? The other items.. especially the PE kits where we could easily buy very similar items without the logo, are they necessary? Especially as we have a winter coming where some people won’t be able to pay bills.

(The secondary did have a “free second hand clothes rail” for all, at some point, but when I phoned to ask they were very vague about when it would be. I have a friend whose children are on pupil premium- no subsided option for them -
and she managed to find out what day this was but went to find the second hand uniform she found some shabby items that weren’t in her DC’s size, and no PE items.)

OP posts:
Twizbe · 17/08/2022 22:45

@ItsSnowJokes thing is that £2.50 jumper lasts 5 mins.

My friend has gone through 3 supermarket cardigans in 1 year.

The £20 jumper I had to buy still looks brand new and still fits DS he will wear it when he goes back and then his sister will wear it. Then we will give it to the PTA to hand on somewhere else.

Fizbosshoes · 17/08/2022 22:39

The school my ds attends stipulated generic navy uniform from any shop. So I buy it from M&S and ASDA, it's great that there's no logo.

Exactly, it can be done without being stupidly expensive. Simply the fact that chain stores and supermarkets sell school uniform suggests that the choice doesn't have to be compulsory branded uniform or no uniform at all.

cyclamenqueen · 17/08/2022 22:38

LockAqua · 17/08/2022 22:30

I think what the anti-uniform posters are forgetting is that DC would need clothes to wear to school even if uniform does not exist. Clearly more casual clothes are going to be required for 7 days a week as opposed to 2- 250% more in fact.

For that money, why not have smart uniform clothing that keeps everyone equal?

Because what child wants to wear school uniform out of school? Whereas general clothes are interchangeable and can be worn at any time. They are also cheaper. .

LockAqua · 17/08/2022 22:30

I think what the anti-uniform posters are forgetting is that DC would need clothes to wear to school even if uniform does not exist. Clearly more casual clothes are going to be required for 7 days a week as opposed to 2- 250% more in fact.

For that money, why not have smart uniform clothing that keeps everyone equal?

ItsSnowJokes · 17/08/2022 16:25

Twizbe · 17/08/2022 15:17

Tbf though, you have to clothe your children in something.

They wear uniform 5 days a week so if you're really struggling that much what else will they wear?

I can clothe them in a £2.50 supermarket school sweatshirt rather than a £20-30 school jumper. This is what people are getting at. Arsehole schools who rip parents off for absolutely no reason.

Thefruitbatdancer · 17/08/2022 16:08

Fizbosshoes · 16/08/2022 13:37

But the choice doesn't have to be compulsory logo-ed uniform or no uniform?

Can schools not state a colour and people can buy skirt/trousers/blazer in that colour from a shop of their choice/budget and a school tie? It's obviously an earner for schools who get a% from the suppliers but uniform can be done without having to have branded or logoed stuff.

When I was at school the uniform was black. There was a school supplier but it wasn't compulsory to buy uniform there. The wealthier kids bought their blazers and uniforms there, my parents bought uniform from bhs which was cheaper (I'm pretty sure supermarkets generally didn't do clothes/uniforms in the 1990s) The tie and school badge we could get from school and then everything else could be bought where you wanted.

The school my ds attends stipulated generic navy uniform from any shop. So I buy it from M&S and ASDA, it's great that there's no logo.

CoffeeWithCheese · 17/08/2022 16:03

Sirzy · 17/08/2022 14:44

I don’t see why more schools/parents don’t organise swap shops for uniform. Especially when younger often it is outgrown before the condition goes in it.

thankfully Ds secondary school is very realistic in the costings for the few logod bits of uniform - blazer, shorts and t shirt cost less than £50 for all three if needed new at the same time.

Round here they try to (including our PTA running a Christmas jumper bank for funds before Christmas) - however the biggest local school is forever fucking about with its logo meaning that the uniforms can only be passed about for a year or so until the school clamps down on the "obsolete" stuff. It's incredibly annoying to see happen.

Thankfully my kids go to a different school which does have a fancy jumper with logos and coloured bands through the waist and cuffs - but it's not compulsory and DD1 is in year 6 this year (when the hell did that sneak up on me) and doesn't want the fancy jumpers this year - so I've passed her old ones down to DD2 and she's just got some supermarket cheapies that she's happier in. We get periodic requests to not go over the top with hair accessories, sensible shoes and boots and for the love of god send them in with a sensible coat - but that's about it uniform wise.

CoffeeWithCheese · 17/08/2022 15:59

RainbowsMoonbeams · 15/08/2022 21:02

YANBU. My DC’s school have just changed the logo for the second time in 3 years! Now everyone is required to buy all the new clothing all over again. And it is of course overpriced.

This is what happens round here - and funnily the big academy chain are much keener on playing musical logos with schools in their trust that are in more "deprived" areas, than the one in the yummy mummy belt whose children look much "scruffier" going to school and are able to hand down uniform so much easier. Meanwhile the kids from tougher backgrounds are onto their 5th logo change in the time I've lived near the school and the changeover period is running out now so there are a lot of desperate parents trying to find second hand in the required logo.

Annoyingly the area is well served with second hand uniform banks - all rendered somewhat useless because of the damn logo changing.

CecilyP · 17/08/2022 15:42

Tbf though, you have to clothe your children in something.

The clothes they already have! DS started school in age 3-4 of which he had plenty that lasted for another year. Thankfully only had to buy shoes and a jacket. Starting secondary, he could still wear the clothes he was wearing 6 weeks earlier before the summer holidays. School uniform would only work out cheaper if they just eased into it as they outgrew your their old clothes, and if they continued to wear the uniform at weekends and during the holidays.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 17/08/2022 15:33

Twizbe, I love school uniform as it does save buying clothes but I get mine from supermarkets and at 2.50 for 4 white shirts etc. it doesnt leave me out of pocket (in fact saves me buying so many clothes) but logo'd shirts, blazers, trousers ETC. do

cyclamenqueen · 17/08/2022 15:30

The clothes they already have , hand me downs from siblings. Multipacks as stated by pp , and my teenagers never wanted anything new it’s all ‘vintage’ aka charity shop or de pop .

Whatwouldscullydo · 17/08/2022 15:22

Twizbe · 17/08/2022 15:17

Tbf though, you have to clothe your children in something.

They wear uniform 5 days a week so if you're really struggling that much what else will they wear?

Clothes bought in charity shops.

Multipack t shirts. I got 2 tops fir a tenner in tesco. If I bought 3 I'd have 6 tops and still it would have cost less than a blazer.

Clothes family and friends pass down.

Sales. I rarely pay full price for any of my clothes.

Ebay sell bundles if Clothes in pretty much any size.

All of which wouod cost less than school uniform

Twizbe · 17/08/2022 15:17

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 17/08/2022 14:37

What happens if you literally can't afford uniform (which is likely to happen over the next year) and just buy not branded items? Will they exclude your child? Our primary just has specific colours to wear and even that is not mandatory - it is an excellent school with great results.

Tbf though, you have to clothe your children in something.

They wear uniform 5 days a week so if you're really struggling that much what else will they wear?

Twizbe · 17/08/2022 15:16

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 17/08/2022 14:37

What happens if you literally can't afford uniform (which is likely to happen over the next year) and just buy not branded items? Will they exclude your child? Our primary just has specific colours to wear and even that is not mandatory - it is an excellent school with great results.

Our school has a collection of school uniform that can be given for free to anyone who needs it.

Topseyt123 · 17/08/2022 15:07

SwordToFlamethrower · 17/08/2022 14:25

I 100% agree as well. It is a huge con. Poor kids will always be identified because their shoes wear out and don't get replaced. They grow out of their uniforms and keep having to wear them, they become thread bare.

The costs of uniforms are exorbitant and completely unnecessary as it just gives teachers more ways to tell kids off and give out detentions.

Don't get me started on girls being excluded for skirts being too short!

Just let kids wear the clothes they want, bought from wherever they choose.

I absolutely agree with this, and I started out being a big supporter of school uniform.

The ridiculous expense of logoed items, massive long lists of "essential" stuff which then hardly ever gets used and silly rules enforced to silly levels have combined to turn me against it. Long before my daughters left school I had begun to feel that school uniform should be abolish and the daft British fetish with it brought to an end.

It isn't a leveller. It is a needless set of extra rules and expense. School uniform should be consigned to the bin of history.

Sirzy · 17/08/2022 14:44

I don’t see why more schools/parents don’t organise swap shops for uniform. Especially when younger often it is outgrown before the condition goes in it.

thankfully Ds secondary school is very realistic in the costings for the few logod bits of uniform - blazer, shorts and t shirt cost less than £50 for all three if needed new at the same time.

Noodles1234 · 17/08/2022 14:43

Contact the School, PTA or local FB groups, they are usually donated away for free or around £1 per item. I have collated all uniform for free or £1 per item. So much cheaper!

TheBeardedVulture · 17/08/2022 14:41

Our shite local secondary is the local state school that has the fanciest uniform. I think they think it instills discipline and makes the school look better. It’s like slapping a plaster on a shotgun wound.

QueenoftheNimbleFlyingCat · 17/08/2022 14:37

What happens if you literally can't afford uniform (which is likely to happen over the next year) and just buy not branded items? Will they exclude your child? Our primary just has specific colours to wear and even that is not mandatory - it is an excellent school with great results.

SwordToFlamethrower · 17/08/2022 14:25

Fairislefandango · 15/08/2022 10:41

I don't support uniform full stop. I don't believe it's the leveller it's claimed to be, and given that kids need clothes for the holidays it's all just extra expense. Most other countries manage fine without.

100% this. I've no idea why people fall for the idea that uniform equates to better behaviour. It absolutely doesn't. It just creates more things for teachers to have to tell kids off for. It's a waste of time and efforts, and devalues the rules which are actually important, because kids are very well aware that wearing the right colour socks has zero effect on their education!

I 100% agree as well. It is a huge con. Poor kids will always be identified because their shoes wear out and don't get replaced. They grow out of their uniforms and keep having to wear them, they become thread bare.

The costs of uniforms are exorbitant and completely unnecessary as it just gives teachers more ways to tell kids off and give out detentions.

Don't get me started on girls being excluded for skirts being too short!

Just let kids wear the clothes they want, bought from wherever they choose.

singingintheshower · 17/08/2022 14:18

YANBU @BagelwithPhiladelphiaz ! £44 for a blazer seems a lot. I bought my DS one yesterday & it was £28. He'll be going into yr 10 so I'm hoping that'll last 2 more years. Apart from new shirts & one new tie I'm not buying him anything else atm (I bought new trousers last term). His school isn't fancy though - just a regular, non-selective secondary).
I'm also buying stuff for my DD to take to Uni in a month & the amount I'm spending on that is shocking tbh!

HowManyTurtles · 17/08/2022 14:17

YANBU.
I think schools should say school colours. I.e. a blue blouse/shirt (or polo!), and a navy jumper and black trousers/skirts/pinifores. Yes to the smart ones, i.e. not joggers, leggings or jeans but they shouldn't be able to dictate they are logod or specific brands.

StinkerTroll · 17/08/2022 14:14

Our local high school have allowed girls to wear non logoed trousers this year due to the cost of uniform..... interestingly the boys have never had to wear logoed trousers! Consequently neither of my dds have ever worn the trousers with logos (they've always been tailored trousers, not leggings or jeans), I've been DYING to be called into school over them.... I would have loved that fight! The trousers with logos approx £24 per pair, tailored black trousers £8 from asda. I'm all for uniform, but the only branded item should be the ties and badges (sew or iron on - this could apply to pe kit as well)

Whatwouldscullydo · 17/08/2022 11:57

Ironically i think a shoe dress code would probably be the easiest one to police. No knee highs. No spike heels. Full foot coverage. No ballet flats. Then let everyone just wear trainers/walking boots/dms or other ankle boots. Footwear should be comfortable and functional and weather appropriate to encourage walking/cycling to school.

We need to get kids moving more . It's OK on primary because many are basically trainers. But high schools are more fussy. To the detriment of the kids tbh. It's ridiculous a flimsy flat slip on shoe would be allowed but a sturdy pair of kickers wouldn't be.

Its nonsense

FunsizedandFabulous · 17/08/2022 11:57

londonmummy1966 · 16/08/2022 23:07

Whilst all the logod stuff annoys me the PE kit is the real annoyance - I seriously think that PE teachers like the power trip and kit is a way to get it over not just the kids but also the parents. They really have such inflated ideas about the importance of kit. DDs last kit list was -
stripey socks in an odd combination of colours for hockey
white socks with a multi couloured stripe around the top for tennis
Plain purple knee socks for netball (why couldn't they use the hockey ones.....)
black tracksuit bottoms with a green stripe
school logo'd track suit top
tracksuit only used to travel to sports ground on the mini bus and then removed to reveal
school logod polo shirt
school logod skort
above only used for net ball as for hockey they wore
school logod leggings
school logod midlayer and over that
school logoed football shorts
white school logo'd polo top for tennis
white school logod skirt for tennis
black leotard with purple trim for gym/dance
plain black shorts to wear over leotard for dance (why weren't the football shorts acceptable)
black swim suit with purple stripe
school logo swimming cap
school logod swimming bag
school logod sports bag
black trainers for hockey
white trainers for netball and tennis
a second pair of black trainers to be worn only to walk from the changing rooms to the hall for gym/dance

best part of £500.

I wrote a letter of complaint to the chair of governors who replied it was important for DDs representing the school to look smart but didn't bother to reply to my follow up to ask why this was necessary for all DC including mine who didn't play against other schools.....

This is much more ridiculous than my DD's first round of uniform. For swimming stuff etc, I bet they only do it for a term. Same with tennis & football and all the other sports kit. My DD is not sporty at all and so from my POV this is a poor investment. At my DD's school there's a tracksuit, a t-shirt, a pair of shorts and leggings and we buy white trainers from Spirts Direct.

Swipe left for the next trending thread