Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools 3 day a week?

310 replies

Sunflowerkeep · 15/08/2022 09:51

Is this for real or just media again? Is it seriously being considered?

OP posts:
blameitonthecaffeine · 15/08/2022 13:57

Most parents WFH these days, so how hard can it be to sit a 5yo in front of the TV with Peppa Pig (on mute) and a bag of crisps for 8hrs?

No they don't?! Most healthcare, teachers, retail, hospitality, transport, sports, arts, animal care, emergency services, lots of social care, prisons/probations/courts and dozens of other professions I haven't thought of all work full time out of the home. Plus lots of people in offices. It's only a majority of office workers who work from home a majority of the time.

FrippEnos · 15/08/2022 13:57

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 12:59

As it happens I'm SLT in an LA school where we have recently used exactly this action plan (on the advice of the LA). Why would the answer be to cancel lessons or close the school?

As a technology teacher I would be refusing to allow children to move boiling water around a crowded room for the purpose of washing up.
You as the SLT would be signing off the risk assessment and taking responsibility for any accidents that happened because of your short sightedness.

and before you say 'no you wouldn't'

We have already stopped some practical lessons due to the room being overcrowded and unsafe.

Dancingwithhyenas · 15/08/2022 13:54

I doubt it but budgets are in an extreme situation.

Probably schools will make redundant even more TAs and/or reduce SENCO hours, so children with SEN will be even less well supported and then parents of NT children will go on mumsnet understandbly outraged that their child has got hurt but in many cases still flipping willing to vote Tory.

Meanwhile my autistic child has been signed off from all services because they now will only provide OT or EP for children where they have an ECHP… and LA are blanket refusing to access for ECHPs - their policy is to delay, deny, obfuscate and delay some more to balance the books. My child is lucky that they won the lottery of having middle class parents who will advocate and go to tribunal and write to PALs etc. But how many children are not in this situation? How many parents just can’t write legal letters when their child is put on 3 year waiting lists for any kind of medical service? I hate that advocating for my child potentially delays another child. It’s terrible.

I feel deeply sorry for support staff and teachers (I was a SENCO and got out to charitable sector), for children who are in a class with an unsupported child/ren and I’m beyond angry for my child and others like them.

Superbabe64 · 15/08/2022 13:53

You need to step away from the Daily 'Fail' 🙄

Youaremysunshine14 · 15/08/2022 13:51

MajorCarolDanvers · 15/08/2022 13:41

Media/unions/head teachers/local authorities whipping up a storm to force the government to increase their budgets.

Schools will NOT go to 3 days a week.

Good. I hope it works. It's criminal that our schools are being run on shoestrings. We should all want better for our kids.

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 13:45

PriamFarrl · 15/08/2022 13:32

I don’t understand how it will save money though. Children will still be entitled to the same number of hours of schooling so surely if they aren’t being taught in school then they are being taught online. As we know this isn’t an option for all children and I expect we would be in a position where, for example, pupil premium children will be able to come into school and do online lessons from the classroom. So if the building is open for them then it’ll be lit and heated. No money saved there. The teacher will still be paid as they are teaching and also you can’t just suddenly reduce hours. So where is the saving?

I don't think it will happen, but I don't think anyone is proposed 3 days in school and 2 days online. Some academy chains heads are threatening that they can only provide 3 days in an attempt to get better funding. Which is needed, but also those execs are on 6 figure salaries! My nearest secondary academy reports a salary for the highest paid memebr of staff of £135k -£140k plus £40k pension contributions. There's a few teachers there and there will be other senior salaries on high salaries too (they only need to report over £100k)

I do think some schools could make savings by looking at who is delivering what. Absolutely, core lessons should be delivered by qualified teachers, but not everything needs to be and actually, some unqualified pastoral staff are really very good at what they do.

Festoonlights · 15/08/2022 13:42

Legally schools and teachers are contractually required to cover the bare minimum. It’s not possible to simply decide mid stream to knock off 2days!

The source is unnamed unsurprisingly. Either created to pressure government into more funds or causing more problems

MajorCarolDanvers · 15/08/2022 13:41

Media/unions/head teachers/local authorities whipping up a storm to force the government to increase their budgets.

Schools will NOT go to 3 days a week.

thebellagio · 15/08/2022 13:41

You know what this really shows tho? The governments complete and utter disdain for state education. No one could ever say that this government has prioritised our children's education over the past 12 years.

I've said so many times on other threads that this energy crisis isn't just about the poorest people being able to pay the gas bills. If schools/hospitals cant run their heating, then we then start to see the breakdown of society.

If they go to 3 or 4 day weeks, who looks after the children when the parents are working? The BBC has an article today about the chronic lack of childcare available because nurseries are shutting because they can't afford to remain open. If that forces parents into part time work, who covers their bills? Because with no disposable income, that means shops/gyms/hairdresses and our entire service sector collapses.

This is a monumental crisis and no one seems to be getting the urgency other than Martin Lewis

Our school building isn't fit for purpose. The windows are so rotten that in the winter, ice is INSIDE the windows. The wooden frames are so derelict that quite frankly you would only need to push them with a small shove and the whole frame would fall out. The government has let these buildings become so derelict that I'm not surprised that they are costing a bomb to run.

In an ideal scenario, I'd love to see the government putting the money into solar panels for every single school. Yes it would be a huge infrastructure investment - but for the long term, it would save hundreds of thousands of pounds in energy costs. The more we can make our buildings more efficient, the better for everyone!

wonderstuff · 15/08/2022 13:36

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 13:20

TAs have been really hard to recruit this year, but actually for the first time in ages we've had plenty of teaching applications for our vacancies. We've even had situations where the decision was quite difficult!

We do employ quite a few unqualified teachers, but they're usually people with significant industry experience in their subject or specialist coaches, not TAs. They're paid as unqualified teachers not TAs too and the scale overlaps a bit with the qualified teacher pay scale.

We have some TAs who are pt as TA and pt as UT as they do some teaching, they are very experienced and run small groups or foundation level qualifications. Would make excellent teachers but don’t want to do a degree.
We’re outside outer London weighting but in an expensive part of the UK struggling to recruit across the board.

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 13:34

Sirzy · 15/08/2022 13:28

Given how many schools are stuck with ancient ineffeicnt heating systems that are expensive to run then this winter is going to be a nightmare for them to try to juggle the books. I doubt it will come to closures but something has to give.

thankfully Ds school is having a new system fitted over the holidays so that should help them a bit

We've just moved into a new building purpose built for us by the LA. It's supposed to be energy efficient and we shall see what savings there are there, but the increase in running costs for everything else is huge. There's so much highly technical kit that needs servicing annually by specialist companies. Before we could use a local plumbing company and shop around. Now there's much less choice and they all seem to think they're quids in when quoting for public sector work.
.

PriamFarrl · 15/08/2022 13:32

I don’t understand how it will save money though. Children will still be entitled to the same number of hours of schooling so surely if they aren’t being taught in school then they are being taught online. As we know this isn’t an option for all children and I expect we would be in a position where, for example, pupil premium children will be able to come into school and do online lessons from the classroom. So if the building is open for them then it’ll be lit and heated. No money saved there. The teacher will still be paid as they are teaching and also you can’t just suddenly reduce hours. So where is the saving?

YomAsalYomBasal · 15/08/2022 13:31

It's already happening slowly. Most schools where I am close at lunchtime on a Wednesday or Friday. It'll happen bit by bit.

OhTheLeetleHandsAndFeetle · 15/08/2022 13:28

I am very worried about this. I am worried about how schools will fund heating and the impact on students, but from a personal perspective I am very concerned about my job. I am an old experienced teacher - have been teaching for over 20 years. I am therefore very expensive. I work part time and currently have no management responsibilities (through choice - I used to be SLT but stepped down due to family commitments). If I were managing my school budget, I’d be looking at me and thinking, ‘If we can squeeze out OhTheLeetle, we can employ a full time NQT or even two qualified cover supervisors.’

There are lots of us old workhorses who have kept plodding along through the years, including providing cover for key worker kids during Covid and quietly getting on with it whilst the virus raged through classrooms and staff rooms and who are about to be rewarded with being ‘managed out’. I imagine they won’t want the cost of redundancy payments, so the narrative will be that the old workhorses have suddenly become incompetent teachers, and we’ll have our professional integrity, reputations and mental health trashed with ‘competency’ procedures before being unceremoniously tipped out onto the street.

Sirzy · 15/08/2022 13:28

Given how many schools are stuck with ancient ineffeicnt heating systems that are expensive to run then this winter is going to be a nightmare for them to try to juggle the books. I doubt it will come to closures but something has to give.

thankfully Ds school is having a new system fitted over the holidays so that should help them a bit

maddy68 · 15/08/2022 13:25

Schools have limited budgets and these have been decreasing year on year since the Tories got in.

Heads have to manage the books. While costs are increasing.

Stop bloody voting Tory !

Youaremysunshine14 · 15/08/2022 13:25

QuebecBagnet · 15/08/2022 12:06

There’s another option though, that the government give the schools more money?

THIS! ^

Instead of trying to work out how schools can run on a shoestring and coming up with ideas about boiling kettles and not paying teachers, as parents we should be protesting about getting them funded properly! If the Govt can waste billions on test and trace they can find more cash for schools.

blameitonthecaffeine · 15/08/2022 13:24

I can't imagine there's any way the government would let this happen. It would put our provision near the lowest in the world which is ... well, unimaginable.

I've worked in schools in two much poorer countries than ours, one of them an extremely poor, developing country. The poorer but okay country had 2 school sessions a day, one from 7 - 11 and one from 1 - 5 (I think, can't remember the exact timings). Basically all children only got 4 hours schooling a day and lots of homework. But they all got to go every day. The very poor country had classes off up to 120 children in one room. It was extreme and, if the child was ahead or behind the average pace of a class they weren't progressing. Yet they still all got to go every day. We can't possibly go below those terrible standards.

Other reasons it wouldn't be possible are, of course:
working parents
children with needs that can't be catered for online
subjects that are difficult or impossible to teach online
children who are vulnerable at home
private schools will stay at 5 days a week and everyone who can scrape together the money for them will use them resulting in even more a 2 tier system than we currently have.

Sleepyblueocean · 15/08/2022 13:23

"I hope the government aren’t thinking that actual teaching would be over 3 days and expect the TAs to pick up the slack the other 2 days."

Most TAs are there for children with EHCPs. There aren't many class TAs these days.

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 13:20

wonderstuff · 15/08/2022 13:12

Academies don’t legally have to employ qualified teachers with the exception of the SENCO! My school is struggling to recruit teaching assistants at the moment, I suspect there aren’t many people keen on working as an unqualified teacher. If unemployment increases it may be different obviously.

TAs have been really hard to recruit this year, but actually for the first time in ages we've had plenty of teaching applications for our vacancies. We've even had situations where the decision was quite difficult!

We do employ quite a few unqualified teachers, but they're usually people with significant industry experience in their subject or specialist coaches, not TAs. They're paid as unqualified teachers not TAs too and the scale overlaps a bit with the qualified teacher pay scale.

DreamingofItaly2023 · 15/08/2022 13:20

It couldn’t happen in Wales imo as it would kill Welsh medium education. Children from English speaking families need more than 3 days a week immersion in the language.

Itisasecret · 15/08/2022 13:19

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 13:15

Well you can think what you like, but I am and have been for nearly 10 years.

When I see threads like this I do worry for education because so many school staff seem determined that there is no solution to the challenges we face. However, that's not my experience in the schools I've worked in, where the vast majority of staff are very ready and willing to find solutions and do whatever it takes to make things work.

In that case you’d know it’s perfectly fine for schools to run at 4.5 days.

Youaremysunshine14 · 15/08/2022 13:18

Milkand2sugarsplease · 15/08/2022 12:57

@Droughtpout ALL schools are becoming academies within the next 5 years anyway. Most already are, the rest are being made to.

Only if the Tories stay in power at the next election, which they hopefully won't.

There would be uproar if schools went to a three-day week and the knock-on effect on the economy from parents not being able to work would be too great. The Govt would have to find the budget to keep them open.

RainOnMySkin · 15/08/2022 13:16

We should all move to a 4 day week, much more sustainable.

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 13:15

Itisasecret · 15/08/2022 13:08

Of course you are.

Well you can think what you like, but I am and have been for nearly 10 years.

When I see threads like this I do worry for education because so many school staff seem determined that there is no solution to the challenges we face. However, that's not my experience in the schools I've worked in, where the vast majority of staff are very ready and willing to find solutions and do whatever it takes to make things work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread