Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools 3 day a week?

310 replies

Sunflowerkeep · 15/08/2022 09:51

Is this for real or just media again? Is it seriously being considered?

OP posts:
PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 14:36

One of the failing schools locally was forced into becoming an academy and employed a consultant to advise on a new name for their new start. They came up with "Name of Town Academy". 😆

I know the head of that school and when he first started they had a really harsh clear out of staff, due to cost savings needed, but actually, now their financial situation is quite strong and last year they gave teachers a pay award above that recommended.

They still don't get good results and they still have awful behaviour problems (their intake hasn't changed) but OFSTED seems to like them better now.

RancidOldHag · 15/08/2022 14:34

PriamFarrl · 15/08/2022 12:40

The problem with academy chains is that you are doubling up of staff.
Back in the days when all schools were under county control there was one set of advisors, HR, payroll etc. All schools were covered by this. With academies each chain has its own advisors, HR, middle management etc. So let’s say a town has 50 schools, previously all of those 50 schools would have everything managed centrally by county. One set of HR staff, for example, one set of advisors. Now those 50 schools might be run by 25 different Academy chains. Each of those is employing HR staff, advisors etc. and that’s before we get to managers creaming of money.
Academies are never going to save money. Also, the ownership of the building goes to the chain. They then have to manage the maintenance, which some don’t bother to do. Look at Bright Tribe for example.

Remember that back in the day, the LA took a slice of each school’s allocated budget to pay for those types of services.

With academisation, there was a new option as academies could continue to pay the LA. Or, if they preferred other suppliers of those services they could switch. Most switched, because the LA services in most areas were poor VFM.

So there might be more suppliers in the market, but the amount of money going on those services reduced after the LAs’ non-negotiable stranglehold on top-slicing was ended

Disneyblueeyes · 15/08/2022 14:33

The comment about pushing out experienced teachers is a very real one.
It's all well and good replacing all the experienced teachers for cheap ECTs, but these teachers still need support and mentoring, which is often what the experienced teachers do.
Standards of education will simply slip further.

neverbeenskiing · 15/08/2022 14:30

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 14:25

I'm not suggesting they teach. I'm saying that a lot of what teachers do, isn't teaching and maybe that's worth looking at.

I was confused by your phrasing. I assumed that when you said "core lessons should be delivered by qualified teachers, but not everything needs to be" I thought you were suggesting that anything outside of core could be delivered by pastoral staff. Sorry if I've misunderstood. So what is it you're saying pastoral staff should be delivering that they don't currently?

BungleandGeorge · 15/08/2022 14:29

There’s a fuel shortage. Surely basic common sense says that 30 kids and a teacher sharing a classroom is more efficient in terms of heating and power than having them in 31 individual homes with heating and electricity for laptops
etc

VerbenaGirl · 15/08/2022 14:28

ThrallsWife · 15/08/2022 10:25

Schools are already all forced into becoming academies (the new Schools Bill saw to that - there is no way out now). The issue is that MATs siphon any money off schools and line their own pockets and fancy offices with it (ours have spent a very large sum this year moving offices to a more fancy London location) and pay consultants huge fees to improve... absolutely nothing, because they know nothing about education. All of this while eroding the few things that made teachers' lives bearable when they were working directly for the LEA.

So academisation is likely to make finances worse, not better.

It does depend a lot on the MAT. I work at a small local MAT - no fancy head office or the like, and no syphoning off - just a small and very transparent recharge to cover the appropriate proportion of central functions like HR and Finance. We also have used staff moving between the two schools to provide cover when staff absence levels have been challenging and cover staff were too expensive. There is a world of difference between really healthy collaborations between local schools to best meet the needs in that area as efficiently as possible and huge national MATS being run in a very corporate way. The current storm of unfunded yet inadequate pay rises, massive utility costs and the impact of several years when there have been very limited funds for premises maintenance and improvement is bringing the sector to its knees, but no talk of a 3-day week as yet.

RoseAndRose · 15/08/2022 14:25

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 12:23

The money was spent on the worst school buildings or to replace them. The school I went to was knocked down and rebuilt during this time as the roof was falling apart and the repairs that were not happening were ultra expensive.
There are other old school buildings that were not in a bad enough state at the time to be prioritised, that have since deteriorated.

Oh, so the fine words about the extent of this flagship programme were just spin.

Disappointing, but unsurprising.

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 14:25

neverbeenskiing · 15/08/2022 14:21

Absolutely, core lessons should be delivered by qualified teachers, but not everything needs to be and actually, some unqualified pastoral staff are really very good at what they do.

Yes, many non-teaching pastoral staff are really very good at what they do, and would like to keep doing it. Why would they want to be roped into doing the job of a teacher instead for a lot less money? If they wanted to teach, they would train to be teachers. Also, who is going to do the job of the pastoral team if they're busy delivering lessons? Speak to any non-teaching member of staff with pastoral responsibility in a school and they will tell you that they are busier than they have ever been.

I'm not suggesting they teach. I'm saying that a lot of what teachers do, isn't teaching and maybe that's worth looking at.

Passtherioja · 15/08/2022 14:25

BeanieTeen · 15/08/2022 10:21

They’ve just extended the minimum hours for school days so I call bullshit.

They haven't extended them as such-they've said they need to be open for 32.5 hours per week which the majority of schools were already - 8:45-3:15, 9-3:30 kind of hours are pretty standard but some will have to have extended and some might actually reduce!

Badsox · 15/08/2022 14:24

I don't know about three days a week but I can envisage schools running a four day week and making some savings. Longer days with sports and creative subjects in the later afternoon and teachers all doing PPA and attending meetings online at home on the non teaching day could work really well. Child care for the day off would be no more expensive than after school and breakfast clubs which would not be needed due to earlier starts and later finishes. that set up could save some part time employees money because the length of a school day finally mirrored a working day. I believe a lot of schools in Scotland and France operate this system. The Secondary schools in my local area also have early finishes at 1.30pm on certain afternoons in the week. All that said, I do not agree with it but, recognise that it could become a sad reality due to chronic under investment in education and schools. We may need to adapt and this could be an option that we may need to become more used to!

BungleandGeorge · 15/08/2022 14:24

It’s absolutely crazy that pay increases for public sector come out of existing budgets. And not for the first time.

neverbeenskiing · 15/08/2022 14:21

Absolutely, core lessons should be delivered by qualified teachers, but not everything needs to be and actually, some unqualified pastoral staff are really very good at what they do.

Yes, many non-teaching pastoral staff are really very good at what they do, and would like to keep doing it. Why would they want to be roped into doing the job of a teacher instead for a lot less money? If they wanted to teach, they would train to be teachers. Also, who is going to do the job of the pastoral team if they're busy delivering lessons? Speak to any non-teaching member of staff with pastoral responsibility in a school and they will tell you that they are busier than they have ever been.

AchillesLastStand · 15/08/2022 14:20

Grumpybutfunny · 15/08/2022 10:50

Why not just A) ask the parents for help, I would rather pay a 1/210 of the energy bill increase (£142 based on a 30k increase) than have to find childcare for two days a week. Considering how popular the breakfast club is I imagine most parents will feel the same.
B) turn the temperature down even in November DS comes home in a polo shirt as it's been too hot to have his jumper on.
C) close the windows like every other winter COVID is everywhere we are all going to get it at least once a year.

Ask parents to pay? What a lovely middle class school your children must go to. At my DS’s school a lot of parents are so destitute that the headteacher doesn’t even ask for £1 charity donation for Children In Need or anything else.

The government created this mess, they can sort is out. They’ve got the money for a fucking high speed train that most people will never be able to afford to use. My DH is higher rate tax payer, the government need to have along hard think what they’re squandering tax payer’s money on.

Underanothersky · 15/08/2022 14:16

Everyone said the possibility of lockdown was scaremongering too.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/08/2022 14:13

MercurialMonday · 15/08/2022 14:08

But the problem is that after over a decade of this, the time when there is savings elsewhere to be made has long passed.

I have had the impression with both Tory candidates but especially Truss do not understand this.

Then she's not fit to be PM then. <talk about stating the obvious>

These are not complicated concepts and shouldn't be a surprise to anyone.

We've had over a decade of low inflation and a government that has squeezed funding of public services. So when there's a large increase in essential costs, funding must be increased to cover it. Otherwise the cost cannot be paid.

Maybe head teachers should send their unpaid utility bills to the chancellor of the exchequer when the bank account runs dry?

FarmerRefuted · 15/08/2022 14:12

The government need to get back in session and get an emergency budget in place that covers both support for households and funding for vital services such as schools, they also need to rein in the energy companies to mitigate these price rises.

DC school sent a letter out the week before last about this issue. Last year their energy costs were approx £120,000 (they're a federation with three schools across three sites for first, middle, and high), this year they're looking at approx £620,000 and they can't afford it. The letter was basically saying that they're looking at a range of options including condensing the schools/mothballing buildings so middle and high will share one site using portacabins for extra classrooms, cutting extra curriculars, cutting staff, cutting the school day by shortening the lunch break/breaktimes, closing the afterschool club/wraparound provision, or a combination of all of the above. They also made mention of one day a week remote learning where all but one building can be shut for day to save energy costs but said this was a last resort and not yet at the planning stages, it's the "not yet" that concerns me as its clearly being discussed as a possibility.

gatehouseoffleet · 15/08/2022 14:09

Superbabe64 · 15/08/2022 13:53

You need to step away from the Daily 'Fail' 🙄

This was on the BBC and in the Times as well. It's not the Heil making things up.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/08/2022 14:08

I know that. But they're not talking about putting teachers on reduced hours either.

But somehow the books need to be balanced. More money is needed to pay for the staff pay increase that has been agreed and higher utility bills.

But will that money be forthcoming? It can't be found from efficiency savings because there's no more cuts that can be made.

MercurialMonday · 15/08/2022 14:08

But the problem is that after over a decade of this, the time when there is savings elsewhere to be made has long passed.

I have had the impression with both Tory candidates but especially Truss do not understand this.

FrippEnos · 15/08/2022 14:07

It would probably mean asking a TA to go and help clear up, if there wasn't a safe way to get students to do it, or I'd go and do it myself, as I have in the school kitchen on a number of occasions.

That just shows a lack of knowledge about what goes on in a practical lesson.
And the lesson wouldn't be canceled it would be theory based inline with the curriculum.

FrippEnos · 15/08/2022 14:05

BarbaraofSeville

The problem with remote teaching is that it doesn't work. it might work if a lesson was online and the next face to face. bu7t even then there is no guarantee that the pupils will do the work at home.

PerfectRun · 15/08/2022 14:03

FrippEnos · 15/08/2022 13:57

As a technology teacher I would be refusing to allow children to move boiling water around a crowded room for the purpose of washing up.
You as the SLT would be signing off the risk assessment and taking responsibility for any accidents that happened because of your short sightedness.

and before you say 'no you wouldn't'

We have already stopped some practical lessons due to the room being overcrowded and unsafe.

Short sightedness? What would happen in practice is I'd meet with the food tech teacher and work out something that she was happy with. Neither of us would be looking to cancel the lesson. It would probably mean asking a TA to go and help clear up, if there wasn't a safe way to get students to do it, or I'd go and do it myself, as I have in the school kitchen on a number of occasions.

What I do known with absolute certainty, is that no one would be taking a position of there no way we can make this work.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/08/2022 14:02

Beautiful3 · 15/08/2022 13:57

I can't see this happening at all. How many teachers would continue to work, if they were reduced to part time hours and salary? It would be too difficult trying to work 2 jobs, for a full salary. They'd end up joining agencies, and working part time for more money. Schools would be forced to over pay for agency staff. It wouldn't work at all.

I don't think they're proposing that teachers are put on PT hours, or more that some teaching will be done remotely so they don't have to put the heating on every day.

That's the question that no-one seems to be answering. Schools need more money to pay for the staff pay rise and higher utility bills, but our government doesn't have a history of sufficiently funding schools (or other public sector organisations) and simply has a vague notion of increased costs being met by savings elsewhere. But the problem is that after over a decade of this, the time when there is savings elsewhere to be made has long passed.

BlackbirdsSinging · 15/08/2022 13:58

They could reduce down the salaries and the perks and second home funding from MPs and give it to schools instead. MPs earn way too much for what they do. It’s the civil servants who keep the country running. I think we need MPs but they really should not be paid so much. It’s a total disgrace.

Beautiful3 · 15/08/2022 13:57

I can't see this happening at all. How many teachers would continue to work, if they were reduced to part time hours and salary? It would be too difficult trying to work 2 jobs, for a full salary. They'd end up joining agencies, and working part time for more money. Schools would be forced to over pay for agency staff. It wouldn't work at all.

Swipe left for the next trending thread