Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools 3 day a week?

310 replies

Sunflowerkeep · 15/08/2022 09:51

Is this for real or just media again? Is it seriously being considered?

OP posts:
overitall1 · 15/08/2022 18:18

Schools could save huge amounts of money by closing for 6 weeks in the winter to save on heating. In fact why not have the school year Jan - Dec with the 6 weeks hols in Nov - Dec? Then parents could go off on holiday to somewhere warm in the winter.

You're welcome 😉

Shinyandnew1 · 15/08/2022 18:09

so the HT now works from home 2 days a week

I’m not sure that’s the way to go. Some would argue that head might be better wearing a coat and hat and be at school every day-to support their staff.

Mammyloveswine · 15/08/2022 18:06

PriamFarrl · 15/08/2022 12:40

The problem with academy chains is that you are doubling up of staff.
Back in the days when all schools were under county control there was one set of advisors, HR, payroll etc. All schools were covered by this. With academies each chain has its own advisors, HR, middle management etc. So let’s say a town has 50 schools, previously all of those 50 schools would have everything managed centrally by county. One set of HR staff, for example, one set of advisors. Now those 50 schools might be run by 25 different Academy chains. Each of those is employing HR staff, advisors etc. and that’s before we get to managers creaming of money.
Academies are never going to save money. Also, the ownership of the building goes to the chain. They then have to manage the maintenance, which some don’t bother to do. Look at Bright Tribe for example.

This!! It's ludicrous academy trusts having "CEOs"! The central team in my academy trust probably earn twice as much as my actual schools staff earns and there are a lot more bodies in our school than the central team!!

I won't even mention the amount spent on ridiculous stuff for example changing our entire email system from google classroom to office outlook and teams (meaning hours spent on IT!)... whole trust training days whereby everyone is given a fancy outsourced lunch... banners and planners and diaries and pens all with the academy logo on... promotional videos made professionally for the trust... every child given a branded trust water bottle instead of bringing their own in.. non-class based senior leaders whilst employing intervention teachers/ppa teachers (but i imagine that might be the first change as a very quick way to save money! Can imagine some members of the senior team being annoyed at actually having to teach for a day or so a week though!).

Fre · 15/08/2022 18:04

FacebookPhotos · 15/08/2022 11:57

It won't happen, but I can easily see more schools dropping Friday afternoons. Having that time as everyone's PPA so you don't need to pay an extra staff member as PPA cover and turn the heating off early too.

It'd be rubbish for most of the kids. Well motivated upper secondary age could benefit though, they never seem to have enough time for independent study.

It'd be shit for working parents of primary aged children, as they'd need to pay for childcare for that time.

@FacebookPhotos I'm a governor at DDs primary, we already do Friday PPA, it made a minor difference to the budget as we send TAs home at lunchtime Friday but we already only had enough to cover 1-1, so the HT now works from home 2 days a week (is on call if we need her) so her office doesn't have to be heated which saves money, a small amount but it was enough.

We're considering no hot meals at all, even for those on PP to save money. We're not the only school locally considering this, we also already supply two other schools who don't have kitchens with food.

We hire out our buildings 4 nights a week, but just break even when energy costs are taken into account. We have had a permenant FT teaching position advertised for over a year and can't fill it, so we have two upper KS2 classes with 35 kids in each, yet application numbers are going up every year, we have two Reception classes in September both with 32 in (Council made us take the extra 4 children).

And we're one of the larger primaries in the borough most round us are single or even half form entry, have no idea how they're going to manage.

LargeLegoHaul · 15/08/2022 18:01

itsgettingweird · 15/08/2022 17:50

Agree.

The education bill that's currently going through makes this all to clear.

And they won't be able to cut school days as all schools now have to have 32.5 hours a week over the 39 weeks (well 40 but you get 5 inset days)

The expectation schools will have 32.5 hour weeks isn’t until September 2023. For mainstream schools, although most follow the same rules the 190 days only applies to maintained schools. See the government guidance here.

itsgettingweird · 15/08/2022 17:50

Droughtpout · 15/08/2022 10:13

This will never happen. It is more likely that the (current) government will just continue to run schools into the ground until they all become academies.

Agree.

The education bill that's currently going through makes this all to clear.

And they won't be able to cut school days as all schools now have to have 32.5 hours a week over the 39 weeks (well 40 but you get 5 inset days)

Shinyandnew1 · 15/08/2022 17:08

toomuchlaundry · 15/08/2022 16:43

I wonder if schools will have to go down the route of sharing teachers, so a teacher teaches a number of classes at the same time using remote provision, and having a cheaper member of staff in the classroom for crowd control. Save money on the qualified staff as won't need as many. Not saying this will be effective from a teaching point of view but will save money.

Being held responsible for the progress and assessment for not only my own class of 30+, but a class of 30+ somewhere else in the school would be hideous! Our wifi and IT equipment at school is also so dreadful, I can’t see that it would actually even work.

notanothertakeaway · 15/08/2022 17:08

FacebookPhotos · 15/08/2022 11:57

It won't happen, but I can easily see more schools dropping Friday afternoons. Having that time as everyone's PPA so you don't need to pay an extra staff member as PPA cover and turn the heating off early too.

It'd be rubbish for most of the kids. Well motivated upper secondary age could benefit though, they never seem to have enough time for independent study.

It'd be shit for working parents of primary aged children, as they'd need to pay for childcare for that time.

@FacebookPhotos Around here, pupils have longer days Monday to Thursday, but finish at 12.15pm on Fridays. Most people like it that way

toomuchlaundry · 15/08/2022 17:08

Who gets £7,000 per pupil?

FredGarland · 15/08/2022 17:06

jcyclops · 15/08/2022 16:03

School managers (whether head teachers or academy executives) have again shown their lack of common sense and how inept they can be when discussing their budget squeeze - especially considering energy costs.

Shorter working days will make so little difference as to be worthless. A 4-day or 3-day week would save more, especially if combined with longer days. An even bigger saving would come by extending the Christmas break by 3 weeks and cut the breaks in late spring and summer.

Commenting on plans for education spending per pupil to increase to 2010 levels by 2024, the IFS claimed spending per pupil will remain three per cent below 2010 levels after factoring in a number of rises including teacher's salaries. Are teachers salaries not classed as education spending, and if not WTF is the £6000 - £7000 per pupil spent on?

Would love £6 -7,000 per pupil! Would make a big difference.
What we'll be getting this year is £4170, down from £4194 last year.

ChilledAngelDelight · 15/08/2022 17:04

Shinyandnew1 · 15/08/2022 11:34

Teacher should get the booster

That is a very sensible suggestion.

Even though it won't prevent them from getting covid?

bigfootisreal · 15/08/2022 16:48

rongon · 15/08/2022 16:18

it was hailed at the time as an ‘every school’ success story - more ‘sexing up’ I suppose

The Building School Fund would have been an every school success if Michael Gove hadn't pulled it. He originally wanted to scrap it altogether, but was forced to just half the funding himself. Years of budget cuts followed that decision.
Personally, the schools I know are not in as bad a way as they were prior to 1997, but give it a few more years!

One near me has closed completely. New building standing empty all down to shocking back handers to do with money and 2 schools merged into one and completely ruined.

toomuchlaundry · 15/08/2022 16:43

I wonder if schools will have to go down the route of sharing teachers, so a teacher teaches a number of classes at the same time using remote provision, and having a cheaper member of staff in the classroom for crowd control. Save money on the qualified staff as won't need as many. Not saying this will be effective from a teaching point of view but will save money.

rongon · 15/08/2022 16:18

it was hailed at the time as an ‘every school’ success story - more ‘sexing up’ I suppose

The Building School Fund would have been an every school success if Michael Gove hadn't pulled it. He originally wanted to scrap it altogether, but was forced to just half the funding himself. Years of budget cuts followed that decision.
Personally, the schools I know are not in as bad a way as they were prior to 1997, but give it a few more years!

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 15/08/2022 16:16

Whitehorsegirl · 15/08/2022 10:32

How would that work anyway?

Parents are not suddenly going to magically be able to switch their jobs to part-time hours and pick up the slack two days a week.

The government seriously needs to get its act together, realise that utility companies are creating a national emergency and it is time to re-nationalise the lot...Because schools, hospitals, small businesses and individuals can no longer afford their bills and that is simply is going to bring everything crashing down in term of the economy and society in general.

I believe neither Johnson or Truss are up to the challenge though and we also should have a temporary government that brings all the parties together to fix this mess and then have a general election.

It wouldn't. Pre pandemic a lot of schools in our borough switched to early finishes two days a week to cut down on support staff costs and utilities. All staff PPA was crammed into these times and they were encouraged to work from home to save on costs to schools. Everyone hated it; staff but especially parents. TAs were suddenly being paid less as they'd had their hours cut, teachers were teaching all day on the full days (often the schools did Tues-Thurs as the full days, so they'd not have a feee period between Monday and Friday in order to tweak lesson plans or do any of that stuff within the school days) but more than anything parents were up in arms.

No primary schools doing it lasted more than a year because of the childcare implications and how much parents were against it. A few secondaries have carried it on. I'm not sure how much difference it's made financially, presumably some otherwise they wouldn't have continued it. It's not very popular though (I do some work for the education department of the local council, hence my knowledge of this).

RoseAndRose · 15/08/2022 16:12

“But public buildings need ongoing investment, not one off injections every few decades”

Of course. But it’s still disappointing that is seems that for some schools the rebuilds are no longer fit for purpose after as little as a decade (those where work started just before the end of the 00s) because windows don’t open and there is lots of glass, and they’re also difficult to heat.

also that, as pp pointed out, the programme was less than it was held up to be - it was hailed at the time as an ‘every school’ success story - more ‘sexing up’ I suppose

jcyclops · 15/08/2022 16:03

School managers (whether head teachers or academy executives) have again shown their lack of common sense and how inept they can be when discussing their budget squeeze - especially considering energy costs.

Shorter working days will make so little difference as to be worthless. A 4-day or 3-day week would save more, especially if combined with longer days. An even bigger saving would come by extending the Christmas break by 3 weeks and cut the breaks in late spring and summer.

Commenting on plans for education spending per pupil to increase to 2010 levels by 2024, the IFS claimed spending per pupil will remain three per cent below 2010 levels after factoring in a number of rises including teacher's salaries. Are teachers salaries not classed as education spending, and if not WTF is the £6000 - £7000 per pupil spent on?

rongon · 15/08/2022 16:00

*There was a massive schools rebuilding project - it was a government flagship policy - in the 00s.

Has all that spending really gone on works that we’re so shorty that a mere 10-20 years on, school buildings are again not fit for use?*

I remember the state schools were in by the end of the Major government after decades of underfunding. It was dire. We had leaks everywhere, on a day of heavy rain I had to squeeze my class into half the room so they wouldn't get dripped on. Half the floor tiles had come up and couldn't be replaced.
Our school building was open plan, which didn't work - even the toilets were open plan!
Our buildings funding went on repairing roofs, new flooring, building walls to separate classrooms. Schools also spent money on money on IT infrastructure. Our playground also needed investment and we were able to make our school wheel chair friendly (when I started we had a child with limited mobility who used to have to bump himself up and down the numerous stairs in the building!)
We were one of the lucky schools that got the funding before it was pulled (not everyone did!). But public buildings need ongoing investment, not one off injections every few decades.

JanglyBeads · 15/08/2022 15:55

@EllaB22 what kind of school/area, may I ask? You have (had) Sat morning sessions and many dependent on school meals?

EllaB22 · 15/08/2022 15:45

I would not cope if schools went to 3 days a week. As a teacher it is near impossible to to get through the curriculum / exam specs as it is with the knowledge gaps due to covid. We need to be in school five days a week.

We got a letter out for the new year last week - school will now open at 8.20 and we must be off site by 4.30 ( last year you could go in from 7am and lock up was 6.30 pm so alot of staff came in either 7am - 4ish and worked before school or some do 8.45 - 6ish). Ultimately we are going to have to take work home now. Lunch is down to 35 minutes. Saturday morning school is no longer approved for this year with a review in Febuary half term. Our afterschool clubs must end at 4.15 ( last year this was up to 5.30 for the homework club). Afterschools will be voluntary and no funding for specialists coming in. We are being told if we wish to park onsite we must now buy a parking permit for the year. This has never been the case !!! Parking as always been free although the car park is not big enough so some people end up having to park elsewhere.

Our school is cold even with the heat on - last year students were permitted a hoody under the blazer if v cold and a scarf on in lessons. We could ask them to wear coats too but a school jumper / hoody / blazer and then a coat over this is not going to be comfortable. Even pre covid when there was no windows guidance our school was cold.

I am also concerned about the food - so many of our students depend on school for a proper meal. I complained last year that the quality of canteen food was unaccpetable and I got told off for this basically and told it was the canteen operating within their budget. But really the kids were getting pizza and chips most days or some other sort of colourless food with a big biscuit as this was apparently cost effective.

BarbaraofSeville · 15/08/2022 15:40

There was also the winter of discontent which feels a lot like what we're going into now.

'The Winter of Discontent was the period between November 1978 and February 1979 in the United Kingdom characterised by widespread strikes by private, and later public, sector trade unions demanding pay rises greater than the limits Prime Minister James Callaghan and his Labour Party government had been imposing, against Trades Union Congress (TUC) opposition, to control inflation'

2bazookas · 15/08/2022 15:31

We had three-day weeks back in the 1970's, to ration and share the limited power available.

Hellothere54 · 15/08/2022 15:28

RoseAndRose · 15/08/2022 12:09

I was saddened by this post because it rings so true.

There was a massive schools rebuilding project - it was a government flagship policy - in the 00s.

Has all that spending really gone on works that we’re so shorty that a mere 10-20 years on, school buildings are again not fit for use?

Essentially yes. My secondary was a mix of 30s buildings (which were solid) and 60s building (which were full of asbestos and falling down). They decided to rebuild our school as part of academising in the mid 00s. They gave the contract to a French company as they wouldn’t pay the price quoted by a local company and they built a cardboard school, which, within its first few years, had sinks pulling away from walls and walls so thin lessons were being disturbed by noise from the class next door. It was an absolute shambles!

bigfootisreal · 15/08/2022 15:25

Disneyblueeyes · 15/08/2022 14:33

The comment about pushing out experienced teachers is a very real one.
It's all well and good replacing all the experienced teachers for cheap ECTs, but these teachers still need support and mentoring, which is often what the experienced teachers do.
Standards of education will simply slip further.

This has happened for the past few years for a lot of upper pay scale teachers. It has become a common way to cut costs. Put the higher paid teacher on a support plan with targets they are unable to meet or tell them they are not meeting them. They jump before they are pushed and then in their place is a fresh off the line ECT.

Nat6999 · 15/08/2022 14:52

The government need to listen to what Keir Starmer has announced today & make it happen, it's the only way to keep energy prices down.

Swipe left for the next trending thread