Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Has the work life balance shifted and I didn't notice?

94 replies

forinborin · 15/08/2022 09:18

A very first world problem, interested in your experiences.

All my friends seem to have an incredible amount of flexibility in their working schedules. For example, if we're meeting for a lunch during the week, they often offer to do something in the afternoon as well (shopping, cinema, some art exhibition or drinks etc). They are able to attend all school events, volunteer somewhere during the office hours, take their parents to medical appointments, have long weekends with leaving early on Friday or starting late on Monday, never mind mid-day gym, or dentist, or vet, or physio appointments.

I am very happy for them (genuinely), but I just can't understand how on earth it is possible. We are roughly at the same level of seniority (and not at the level where our working hours are timetabled), different industries though. All of us working full time, but all my days are usually back to back, I can't even carve out more than 30 mins for lunch without playing tetris with meetings and deadlines, and if I do make some space for personal needs, I have then to work late or super-late, or catch up over the weekend. Posting on mn is pretty much the only leisure thing I can fit in 5 mins here or there that are under occupied for some reason (mainly when travelling between offices).

Am I doing something wrong? Has the working culture just shifted and I am terribly out of date?

OP posts:
rarelyontime · 15/08/2022 13:52

Fhuukccssghkkb · 15/08/2022 12:38

When you get to a certain level, the employer is paying for your scarce skills, knowledge and risk management/ decision making capabilities. They are not paying for your time, but your impact. Some people are able to deliver impactful outputs very quickly.

Its the 80/20 rule in action.

You can’t walk into these roles, you need to climb up and spend a lot of hours getting there. Many won’t get there.

Insightful comments.

I agree with all of this.

MerlinsButler · 15/08/2022 13:44

@Sandinmyknickers this is a really good point. The majority of my projects are very technical and I am therefore in my own silo so can be completely flexible.

Where others are also working on a project then obviously I don't have that same degree of flexibility although in reality most queries I can answer from my phone so it isn't too restrictive and I'm always happy to answer calls / texts / emails when I'm out and about. But it is difficult to make sure more junior staff don't feel like they have to also be "on" constantly.

I think as it becomes more of a norm it will work itself out but it is a balancing act.

Sandinmyknickers · 15/08/2022 13:33

I find it interesting when people bring up presenteeism as the only reason an employer might want you to work between certain hours and use phrases like "as long as the work gets done".

I guess that is true for jobs where you are really in a silo, maybe something very technical.

But in the majority of jobs, having people work super flexibly (not just running the odd errand or having a run in the middle of the day, but taking entire afternoons off to then work late evening or weird hours) slows everything down. I work across multiple disciplinary project teams and if I had to wait a 24 hr Window for every answer to a question or couldn't just call someone up or schedule a quick call to go through something or a technical matter because they'd swanned off for the afternoon and would "get it done in the evening or weekend", the projects and industry would grind so slowly. Or, worse, it puts pressure on people to also reply at odd hours and never be able to switch their phone off and we all become way more reactionary in the moment rather than just waiting for the next working day.

DillAte · 15/08/2022 13:29

@forinborin
mainly when travelling between offices

Apart from all of the obvious WFH stuff, I think it's also things like this.
A lot of meetings that would have required inter-office collaboration have been teams-based now.

I've got a 4 hour train journey, followed by a plane flight back on the same day.
That's almost a standard working day of travelling for a meeting of a few hours that genuinely has no value-added by not being on Teams.

SatelliteFish · 15/08/2022 13:17

My job is like this I just have to get the work done and done to a high standard.

I couldn’t pop out for half the day or anything but could attend a school event or run an errand or go for a run during the working day and make up the time in the evening.

tenterden · 15/08/2022 13:16

I also have that degree of flexibility. I wfh most of the time and also visit client premises, but that tends to be very early morning visits so I often start work at 6am and finish at 1 (work a 35 hour week) I love going to local indie cinema. Tickets are a few pounds, and I can have a nice walk on the beach after. A lot of my friends retired in late fifties so there's always someone to hang with if I don't fancy going alone.

If I am actually wfh and not going out, I start at 8 and can have two hours for lunch if I fancy, and still be finished by 5.

Bobbybobbins · 15/08/2022 13:08

Such an interesting thread! I'm a teacher so no flexibility - but that is ok. What does piss me off is that my school contracts us to stay til 4.30. This is obviously fine on the days when we have a meeting or training but really irritating when we don't!

Fhuukccssghkkb · 15/08/2022 12:49

In a weird way, we’re going back to how our ancestors lived.

Pre industrial revolution, people didn’t tend to work long hours each day, perhaps just 4 max. There was a lot of rest time and this is true of hunter gatherer societies today.

But during the industrial revolution employers exploited the workforce making them work 6 days of 12 plus hour days.

It wasn’t until Ford created the concept of 2 days continuous rest and the 40 hour week, that western society fell into a pattern of the working week we know today. His motivation was to create leisure time and demand for motor cars!

This article is super interesting as it compares the hours humans have worked in different societies during history:

www.lovemoney.com/galleries/amp/84600/how-many-hours-did-people-really-work-across-human-history

Fhuukccssghkkb · 15/08/2022 12:38

When you get to a certain level, the employer is paying for your scarce skills, knowledge and risk management/ decision making capabilities. They are not paying for your time, but your impact. Some people are able to deliver impactful outputs very quickly.

Its the 80/20 rule in action.

You can’t walk into these roles, you need to climb up and spend a lot of hours getting there. Many won’t get there.

rarelyontime · 15/08/2022 12:34

I control my own diary and my own annual leave, so I can be flexible around things like appointments.

The flip side is that I will work late in the evenings if necessary because there's a big deadline. It's about give and take.

PeloAddict · 15/08/2022 12:05

I'm the opposite - WFH but no flexibility at all

MaryMcCarthy · 15/08/2022 12:04

In my industry it seems to have been established that as long as you're fulfilling objectives and producing work of a good standard, you don't need to be at your desk at every moment of every day.

I realise I'm in an envious position, but I love it. The work life balance is great and I've never been so productive. I like working on Sunday nights, for example, so I know if I work plenty on Sunday night I can have a much easier Monday. It's been great for my mental health and I wish this kind of attitude was present across more industries.

It's not about being at work. It's about the work you do. That's logical, surely?

Scepticalwotsits · 15/08/2022 12:04

Roominmyhouse · 15/08/2022 11:15

Not everyone has meetings all day. If you don’t and either just need to do a set amount of hours or a set amount of work, it’s much easier to be flexible and take longer lunches or pop out to things but starting earlier or finishing later.

Meetings all day are often a sign of lack of control, whether this is by the business or by the individual not being able to say no.

some people though make a career out of being professional meeting attenders.

dont get sucked into having a meeting about a meeting, and then have a meeting why you are not getting enough done and another meeting about how you will claw back time.

Also don’t feel you have to attend every meeting if there is someone else you can get the summary from and there isn’t something being discussed that is relevant to you

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 15/08/2022 12:03

I think WFH has really shown how much time people waste in the office. Many can get through the same amount in half the time at home because they're not dragging stuff out to fit in with their rigid working hours, or sitting through meetings that have little relevance to their work, or getting caught up in politics and drama, and of course there's also not the long soul destroying commutes.

Absolutely - working from home made us realise just how many of those meetings could actually have been an email. My work gets done (plus additional projects so it's not like I'm doing as little as possible!), I'm available during core hours, so what does it matter if I use my breaks to pop to the shops, have a shower or flex my hours to finish early?

If Covid spelled the end presenteeism, it will be one of the few silver linings to come out of the whole shit show.

ColonelCarter · 15/08/2022 11:58

I think with more WFH we can be much more flexible with when we work. Certainly DH and I can. It's great.

I'm still in the office 3 days a week but can come in late, finish, early, work evenings or weekends to catch up etc. I still have the same workload (more actually due to staffing issues) but work are much more flexible about when we do it. At DHs male dominated environment, they don't schedule meetings between 8.30&9 and 3-4 because most of the dad's do the school run.

PollyRockets · 15/08/2022 11:55

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 15/08/2022 11:27

I can't do what your friends do for the most part, certainly can't go out for lunch then go to the cinema, or the gym.

I might start the day putting washing on, then start work, put the washing out at lunch time and do some housework. Then work again until I finish then do hobbies. It's so much easier not having a commute. Like insanely easier. I get flexi time and can use that time for an afternoon off for a vet or whatever, but dentist etc is all taken in hours. Personal appointments are not, it's not a health need to cut your hair obviously.

Your friends are taking the piss and are in jobs that clearly aren't actually needed. It's one of those ones made up to give someone a job. Maybe they aren't good at anything else. I'd be embarrassed by that, not pleased.

Someone sounds jealous

APurpleSquirrel · 15/08/2022 11:51

I have quite a bit of flexibility in my job - I work in marketing & since Covid am permanently Wfh now (office was closed last year).
I can do most of the school pick ups & drop offs, can attend school events - I just make my hours up later.
Although I have roughly set hours it is more about getting the work done rather than being sat behind my laptop between x-x. That means some days I finish early as there isn't anything to do or staying online till past 6pm as something needs to be completed.
No commute is great & I can do bits round the house when I have a break.
The greater flexibility works both ways - so before I was much more of a clock watcher, & resented staying past my hours, now I accept it as give & take on my working week & finish earlier or take a longer lunch another day.

brookstar · 15/08/2022 11:36

Your friends are taking the piss and are in jobs that clearly aren't actually needed. It's one of those ones made up to give someone a job. Maybe they aren't good at anything else. I'd be embarrassed by that, not pleased.

Not all jobs are the same though.
I don't fill out time sheets or have core hours. As long as my work gets done then nobody cares when I do it.

I have no meetings or commitments today. I've done a few hours of work this morning but this afternoon I'm taking DS out for a couple of hours. I'll do some more work this evening.
That doesn't mean I work in a made up job and I'm not embarrassed!

SleeplessInEngland · 15/08/2022 11:30

What industries are your friends in? I suspect that answers your question.

SpeckledlyHen · 15/08/2022 11:29

stuntbubbles · 15/08/2022 10:10

Ooh, I want one of these roles. I could get so much done if it weren’t for my job! Sadly I have to log my minutes to charge them back to clients so I’m largely tied to my laptop.

I am guessing you are a solicitor? Beholden to the 6 minute unit.. I am chargeable too, I am not a solicitor but work in IT for the legal sector and charge clients for my time. Whilst I don't have to account for units I do about 60% of my working week chargeable and have to log timesheets for it. It does make you bound to your laptop but of course there is a little bit of wriggle room unlike I can imagine you would have.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 15/08/2022 11:27

I can't do what your friends do for the most part, certainly can't go out for lunch then go to the cinema, or the gym.

I might start the day putting washing on, then start work, put the washing out at lunch time and do some housework. Then work again until I finish then do hobbies. It's so much easier not having a commute. Like insanely easier. I get flexi time and can use that time for an afternoon off for a vet or whatever, but dentist etc is all taken in hours. Personal appointments are not, it's not a health need to cut your hair obviously.

Your friends are taking the piss and are in jobs that clearly aren't actually needed. It's one of those ones made up to give someone a job. Maybe they aren't good at anything else. I'd be embarrassed by that, not pleased.

DoDisDenDoDat · 15/08/2022 11:17

I think its not just a "work/life" balance, but when in work, a "work/meeting" balance. I see so many people around me spending so much time on Teams/Zoom meetings, meaning that it's hard finding the time to actually do real measurable work. I actively try to avoid as many meetings as possible - if my input can be summed up in a email then that's what I do rather than spend 1 or 2 hours on Teams. This means I have much more time to do the "real" work and therefore gives me more flexibility in terms of when I do the work. Some places have a culture of "must be seen" so you find people actively looking for more meetings to attend to increase their visibility.

Roominmyhouse · 15/08/2022 11:15

Not everyone has meetings all day. If you don’t and either just need to do a set amount of hours or a set amount of work, it’s much easier to be flexible and take longer lunches or pop out to things but starting earlier or finishing later.

MerlinsButler · 15/08/2022 10:48

I think that a lot depends on the role and /or the company.

I work on specific projects with set deadlines. I can manage my own time as long as I meet that non-negotiable deadline. As I have overall responsibility and once the initial phase of the project is complete it needs no input from anyone else, so I can work when I choose.

I will often work early mornings - take the afternoon and then do some hours in the evening particularly if working on overseas projects.

It may look like I'm skiving but in reality I'm working 50hours plus per week just not a typical 9-5. Everyone else is doing the same as we are fully remote.

I'm currently doing a business plan for a new team recruitment and hopefully the flexible working hours / get the job done well mentality will continue. I have no desire to micromanage people's day.

Scepticalwotsits · 15/08/2022 10:45

Cinnabomb · 15/08/2022 10:20

For those in these flexible roles - what do you do?

BA/Citizen Developer for a multinational