Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Finding out something controversial about family member

162 replies

Howtofeelnow · 15/08/2022 00:12

Nc in case they’re on here considering this was a conversation today

Found out today a family member used to do something in the past that I believe is fairly controversial. I had no idea. I’m very strongly against the thing they did, and tbh think most (decent) people are.

no real indication they were aware I might be anti the thing they did. no indication of whether they’d ever do it again.

I’m really shocked and disappointed. I love this person but somehow can’t see them in the same way. I know people disagree about things obviously but I really, really feel like this is a conflict in core values…probably not making sense still just a bit 😨

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/08/2022 09:10

Voted Tory?

ThePollutedShadesOfPemberley · 15/08/2022 09:10

Maybe this person has a similar attitude to people with entrenched views on things?

PonyPatter44 · 15/08/2022 09:06

Were they screaming in the Sistine Chapel?

Its fox-hunting or beagling, isn't it?

mam0918 · 15/08/2022 09:03

I mean without saying what it is its impossible to say.

There is a huge sliding scale between someone who parked in parents and child without a kid once and someone who was a nazi who gassed people in the genocide.

The fact you say its not illegal but have strong personal moral objections would indicate its something like abortion, which would explain why your not posting what it is because lots of pro people would swarm the attack which would mean you know its not classed by most as 'right' vs 'wrong'.

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 09:02

Howtofeelnow · 15/08/2022 07:56

ha some of these made me laugh!

It would be too outing to have said what they revealed, I thought that much would be obvious. Some of the responses have helped me think through what I’m feeling tho so thank you

to answer some questions, it wasn’t criminal. I have no idea whether they’d do it again because I was so shocked I moved the conversation on swiftly as I didn’t know what to say

it’s nothing to do with religion or politics -
I think they do actually vote Tory, which I personally think is unforgivable but hey, I knew that about them and understand we’re all different etc etc

i think the cruz of it is I don’t think you can support this and be a ‘good’ person which I know is probably too black and white of me but is my honest gut reaction

If you think it’s unforgivable that they don’t vote the same way as you then it suggests that you have some issues to work through about how you judge others, and it’s possible that the other thing they did is fine too.

WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 15/08/2022 09:01

Darked on the washing?
These threads are so annoying- obviously having affairs - but the whole point of MN being anonymous is so people down get outed.

ManateeFair · 15/08/2022 08:50

I think it’s very difficult to know if YABU without knowing what the thing is, as others have said, because doing something you consider unpleasant or immoral but which is not ultimately harmful is one thing, but doing something you feel is actively harmful and cruel and exploitative is a lot harder to put aside.

For example, if it was dogging then YABU but if it was badger-baiting or burning £50 notes in front of homeless people YANBU.

Whitehorsegirl · 15/08/2022 08:44

If you want an actual useful advice you would have to disclose what they did...

if did something illegal (bank robbing, drug dealing, beating someone up) but were never caught then I would struggle to maintain a relationship.

If they did something silly when they were young and naive from moonlighting as a stripper to acting in porn films, using prostitutes or being a drug addict but then realised they were on the wrong path and changed their life then it would not bother me.

If they disclosed they once voted for Farage, supported fox hunting or were part of a racist group that would change my view of them and I would again struggle to stay in touch with them.

If it is a conflict with your values, ask yourself if the person regrets what they did, is open about realising they made a mistake and are clear they would not repeat what they did. People can do stupid things but they can also change and become better human beings.

But if the person sees nothing wrong in their action and what they did completely clashes with your values then maybe you have to accept your relationship/friendship with them is over.

CeratopsofthePharoahs · 15/08/2022 08:44

Did they say they actually prefer the Star Wars prequels to the original films? Perhaps they actually like Jajar Binks.

rainbowstardrops · 15/08/2022 08:42

So you still won't say what it is, even though you said you've name changed, so what exactly would be outing to you.

Also, if you're not going to say what it is then how can people give their opinions on what they would think and what was the point of your post???

Crazy.

leicestermare · 15/08/2022 08:38

What an annoying thread.

Either tell us what the thing is, so that we can tell you whether YABU in your reaction or not (which as you've posted in AIBU is presumably your intention?) or don't bother asking.

I don't understand how the the 'thing' can be outing unless it's something that so few people have ever done, and publicised so widely in the news / internet that we'd be able to attach a name to it. Which clearly it wasn't since the OP didn't know anything about it until the family member told her!

So this just doesn't add up OP. Try harder next time!

x2boys · 15/08/2022 08:34

NRogers · 15/08/2022 07:50

Cheese and then beans is so much better. Cheese melts way faster.

I put the cheese in the pan of beans and mix together .

Georgeskitchen · 15/08/2022 08:32

Is this mysterious 'activity " still legal?
Is it some sort of cult/religion?
If you can tell us what it is then we can judge whether or not you're being precious

Dalaidramailama · 15/08/2022 08:29

yep I’ve got adult siblings who sell drugs for a living. Makes it really really hard to maintain relationships. They try harder than me to be honest. It’s difficult when the values are SO SO SO different. The space between us gets wider with every passing year now.

Sunnyqueen · 15/08/2022 08:28

No one can possibly give you an opinion without knowing what you're talking about. I would have thought that was obvious. On the whole though unless it involved illegally hurting people it probably wouldn't make me think bad of them.

loislovesstewie · 15/08/2022 08:24

One of my ancestors was sentenced to death for bestiality with a sheep ( true, BTW). Perhaps I am guilty by association?

SnoozyLucy7 · 15/08/2022 08:23

Howtofeelnow · 15/08/2022 07:56

ha some of these made me laugh!

It would be too outing to have said what they revealed, I thought that much would be obvious. Some of the responses have helped me think through what I’m feeling tho so thank you

to answer some questions, it wasn’t criminal. I have no idea whether they’d do it again because I was so shocked I moved the conversation on swiftly as I didn’t know what to say

it’s nothing to do with religion or politics -
I think they do actually vote Tory, which I personally think is unforgivable but hey, I knew that about them and understand we’re all different etc etc

i think the cruz of it is I don’t think you can support this and be a ‘good’ person which I know is probably too black and white of me but is my honest gut reaction

You say it wasn’t criminal but you can’t support this, what ever it is, and be a “good” person, and yet this is in the past, it’s just history. You weren’t there, obviously you didn’t get an explanation because you moved the conversation along. I know that you are entitled to your gut reaction, but I think this comes off as unnecessarily judgmental.

Good people are capable of bad things, equally bad people are capable of good things, and all the shades in between.

larkstar · 15/08/2022 08:15

Perhaps you need to understand the reasons behind their choices - their circumstances etc - it's easy to say lock up all shoplifters until you find a desperate mother stealing nappies for her newborn. Life is full of grey areas where decisions are influenced by many conflicting factors.

Northernparent68 · 15/08/2022 08:06

Too outing ? So they are the only person in the country who does this activity? It’s likely they don’t need or want your judgment or approval, I expect they’ve already picked up your attitude.

SuePerdupa · 15/08/2022 08:05

Did he used to bum pigs in an abattoir? Or wear women's pants to church? Both odd, one slightly more. However, I could forgive one, but always picture home doing the other around Christmas time when our paths would meet
HTH

notanothertakeaway · 15/08/2022 08:02

They use toilet brushes?

Howtofeelnow · 15/08/2022 07:56

ha some of these made me laugh!

It would be too outing to have said what they revealed, I thought that much would be obvious. Some of the responses have helped me think through what I’m feeling tho so thank you

to answer some questions, it wasn’t criminal. I have no idea whether they’d do it again because I was so shocked I moved the conversation on swiftly as I didn’t know what to say

it’s nothing to do with religion or politics -
I think they do actually vote Tory, which I personally think is unforgivable but hey, I knew that about them and understand we’re all different etc etc

i think the cruz of it is I don’t think you can support this and be a ‘good’ person which I know is probably too black and white of me but is my honest gut reaction

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 15/08/2022 07:56

There's a vast difference between torturing kittens and being a lap dancer. The former I'd struggle to come to terms with, the other I might raise an eyebrow but that's it. But you might think lap dancing is the root of all evil.
Regardless, give it time to sink in and look
at who the person is today. Many of us have don't something we'd never do now. Is there nothing in your past?

SeasonFinale · 15/08/2022 07:53

If it was "cream first" it's fully understandable that you can never view them the same again!

FizzyNeko · 15/08/2022 07:50

Why are there so many replies about fox hunting, is it a really common thing?

Swipe left for the next trending thread