Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if this is actively dying? Cancer related

55 replies

Neverendingdust · 14/08/2022 18:42

I originally put this on a quieter board with no response so I’ve added it here instead for broader perspective.

Posted before about this (66 yr old) family member with stage 4 Oesophageal cancer with lung mets, treatment was refused after receiving 6 month prognosis (at almost 4 months now). I’m just wondering how others who have experienced this or work in the field would evaluate his current condition.

He had an infection a few weeks ago which has since been seemingly controlled by antibiotics. This last 2 weeks he has started sleeping between 20-22 hours of the day, shutting himself away from others, has minimal urine output, barely eating or drinking anything even in this heat (1-2 Ensures per day, 2 cups of tea at most and very little interest in anything more, the odd ice lolly every other day) His pain was under control using a patch but is now showing signs the dosage may need to increase.

He sleeps very still, you could be forgiven for thinking he had died by the way he looks, his mouth remains open and breathing is very subtle, he no longer snores too which is strange. His hands and feet are pale but not mottled although his overall complexion is a greyish tone.

What is odd is during the few hours he is awake (spread throughout the day in 30 min blocks, at most) he can appear relatively normal, chatting and making jokes for brief moments but soon becomes fatigued again. He is mobile to a point albeit very wobbly.

Hospice at home team are visiting in the mornings but without any regular medical assessment it’s difficult to place where we are in terms of progression.

My question is how long can people survive on just 1-2 Ensures and minimal fluids? He is extremely thin and is essentially wasting away, is this just the gradual decline? Previous cancer death experiences I had were very different situations and not based around malnutrition.

What other signs should we look out for and at what point would you request hospice admission?

OP posts:
SueSaid · 14/08/2022 20:21

It is awful to watch someone die like this. As you say it is so very protracted and sometimes you just want it to be be over. The point when things become fairly imminent is usually when more analgesia is needed in the form of a syringe driver and bowels stop working but of course it can vary enormously.

If his relatives are coping at home fine, ime the time to consider hospice inpatient care is when home life becomes intolerable for family members for example if the patient becomes distressed or agitated, but if sleeping for hours just take it in turns to sit with him, read a book listen to his favourite music Flowers.

autocollantes · 14/08/2022 20:14

I'm so sorry OP that you and your family are going through this and that the family member with cancer too is going through this.

I have no advice for you, but I feel it's extremely important that people feel able to speak about death. I wanted to counter what was said above.

So, YANBU to ask, no.

I wish you, your family and the relative with cancer, peace, even if can only be only in little moments.

NeelyOHara1 · 14/08/2022 20:10

I wish choosing ones own timing of end of life was made easier, at the very least for those already diagnosed as such. The drawn out pain and chaotic nature of timing just puts the dying person and their loved ones under unnecessary further trauma IMHO.

Biscuitandacuppa · 14/08/2022 20:07

I lost my dad to oesophageal cancer with liver mets. He was declining at home until he had a fall which led to internal bleeding. He went into hospital and was put on a driver. When I went in to see him he was semi aware, he roused enough to hug me but then went back to sleep. I was reassured by the macmillan team that this would be the situation for the next few days and it was ok to go home, shower, sleep and come back the following morning. He died before I had driven home. I suspect he needed to say his goodbyes and then let go.

Prior to his fall he had stopped eating, was sleepy, he was dark yellow and had fluid build up (ascites) in his stomach and oedema in his legs. But he was still shuffling about and chatty when awake.

WorriedMillie · 14/08/2022 20:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

The OP is struggling with such a horrendous time, seriously, just scroll on by.

just horrible

Member869894 · 14/08/2022 20:01

no advice I just wanted to pop in and wish you strength and courage - I lost my mum to cancer last year. Its such a strange and stressful time xx

5YearsLeft · 14/08/2022 19:59

As far as I know, and maybe this would ease his mind or yours, you are allowed to ask for medical assessments while on end of life care where I am, such as bloods and minimal scans; these are not considered active treatment, but necessary to help you understand the speed of progression of the disease, so the patient and their family aren’t unduly stressed by the unknown. I don’t see any reason why they couldn’t take a few bloods and see if his liver/kidneys/etc are starting to shut down or if his bloods show the heart is starting to show damage, etc? Because that’s what all the symptoms you’re looking for are meant to tell you (mottled skin, grey appearance, decreased urine output).

In answer to your question, I would say you have maybe a few weeks to a month, as a random guess from working in hospice as a spiritual advisor, and now dying myself, so being hyper-aware of all these things. He is showing all the signs of imminent death, but active dying will be once he no longer has those “normal talkative” phases you mention. He will no longer probably be able to use the toilet normally, and may be in a semi-coma. There may be absolutely no food or fluid intake. This can last for a week or so before actual death. Those who are very lucky simply die at the stage your relative is in now - their breathing becomes too labored while sleeping, they have no time to be afraid, and they’re gone. The rest will go through the process I’ve mentioned of losing their ability to recognize this world (semi-coma) or interact with it (eat, move, toilet) before they leave it.

I’m so sorry you and your relative are facing this. Cancer is incredibly awful and unfair, and I wish you the best. Hopefully, he will be able to pass soon, before the pain worsens much more.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 14/08/2022 19:58

My dad died of Oesophageal Cancer. His last week was in a hospice where he was lucid when he was awake until the final day. He was in for a week. His feet swelled and he wasn't able to walk after about day 2. He was head back mouth open for maybe 12 hours before he died. He knew we were there. They used the pump in the last 24 hours

My sympathies OP x

Welshgal78 · 14/08/2022 19:55

My brother was like this when he diedof the same cancer in April. On his last day he seemed to be awake most of the day but he couldn't move or talk and his breathing was laboured with his mouth open all the time. We all sat with him on his last day taking it in turns to hood his hand. He died on his wife's birthday when his son was only 9 weeks old. It was so sad because he had wanted to be a dad for a very long time and would have been a great dad. I'm so sorry you and you relatives are going through this. I hope you get all the support you need in their final days and afterwards.

Hugasauras · 14/08/2022 19:54

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What a horrible comment. You must be so proud of yourself.

Sorry you're going through this, OP Flowers

I've posted this on here a few times before, but maybe you'll find something helpful in it. I can't remember where it's from now. I am likely to be in the same situation in the not too distant future as my mum has stage 4 cancer, and I find a comfort in reading it.

'When someone dies, the first thing to do is nothing. Don't run out and call the nurse. Don't pick up the phone. Take a deep breath and be present to the magnitude of the moment.

There's a grace to being at the bedside of someone you love as they make their transition out of this world. At the moment they take their last breath, there's an incredible sacredness in the space. The veil between the worlds opens.

We're so unprepared and untrained in how to deal with death that sometimes a kind of panic response kicks in. "They're dead!"

We knew they were going to die, so their being dead is not a surprise. It's not a problem to be solved. It's very sad, but it's not cause to panic.

If anything, their death is cause to take a deep breath, to stop, and be really present to what's happening. If you're at home, maybe put on the kettle and make a cup of tea.

Sit at the bedside and just be present to the experience in the room. What's happening for you? What might be happening for them? What other presences are here that might be supporting them on their way? Tune into all the beauty and magic.

Pausing gives your soul a chance to adjust, because no matter how prepared we are, a death is still a shock. If we kick right into "do" mode, and call 911, or call the hospice, we never get a chance to absorb the enormity of the event.

Give yourself five minutes or 10 minutes, or 15 minutes just to be. You'll never get that time back again if you don't take it now.

After that, do the smallest thing you can. Call the one person who needs to be called. Engage whatever systems need to be engaged, but engage them at the very most minimal level. Move really, really, really, slowly, because this is a period where it's easy for body and soul to get separated.

Our bodies can gallop forwards, but sometimes our souls haven't caught up. If you have an opportunity to be quiet and be present, take it. Accept and acclimatize and adjust to what's happening. Then, as the train starts rolling, and all the things that happen after a death kick in, you'll be better prepared.

You won't get a chance to catch your breath later on. You need to do it now.

Being present in the moments after death is an incredible gift to yourself, it's a gift to the people you're with, and it's a gift to the person who's just died. They're just a hair's breath away. They're just starting their new journey in the world without a body. If you keep a calm space around their body, and in the room, they're launched in a more beautiful way. It's a service to both sides of the veil.'

Neverendingdust · 14/08/2022 19:52

@KentuckyCriedFricken sorry to read about your BIL. I know all cancer is nasty but I’m sure you’ll agree this one really does have an incredibly sinister edge to it. The malnutrition and lack of proper hydration is a big concern for me because he hasn’t been eating much for weeks now and that’s on top of the initial months long huge weight loss from swallowing difficulties. Was there any signs in the days before your BIL passed that you think were indicators of dying?

I just hope it doesn’t go on much longer simply because I’m petrified of how he will look at the end for his family to see.

OP posts:
123ROLO · 14/08/2022 19:51

Sounds like it's approaching but not quite there yet.

I recently lost someone close to me to esophagus cancer who was 60, he had mets to the area around his lungs but not the lungs themselves so kind of simular.

The last week, he was sleeping a lot, but able to get up and transfer, he communicated very short sentences or one word responses, spoke with a whisper, very drowsy. Ate maybe a few spoons of yoghurt and a fortisip.

Final 48 hours, mostly asleep with mouth open, opened his eyes occasionally for one or two sips of drink.

Once he started declining liquids all together, he went to sleep, mouth open, started turning a bit grey, started the 'death' rattle, and was gone in about 6 hours.

Felt queasy writing this.

But before he died I went on lots of forums to read what to expect, and I knew he was in his last week, then last 24 hours, then last few hours, it did help somewhat to know what to expect, and helped to control the situation, for example a relative kept pushing for him to drink even though he said he couldn't, I explained that he can't drink as he is too weak to swallow and his body is rejecting it for a reason. And I was able to explain what the rattle noise was as it alarmed some people. So it did help to learn about it first.

5zeds · 14/08/2022 19:45

I think good mouth care can make it very much better if you can’t swallow. I wish we’d focused entirely on comfort.

GiselleRose · 14/08/2022 19:45

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Not kind.

bloodywhitecat · 14/08/2022 19:44

DH died from bile duct cancer with liver mets after having a stroke which put paid to further chemo, he didn't eat much for the last few weeks probably from just before Christmas until his death in late Feb. He refused Ensures or anything similar and his pain ramped up rapidly in the last few days. He didn't have the mottled extremities but did sleep for increasing amounts of time towards the end. He went on to a syringe driver late on the Friday afternoon and died early on Sunday morning. When he was discharged from hospital after the stroke we were told six to twelve months but I knew that was bollocks, he was discharged the week before Christmas and lasted two months.

Can you ask for an assessment from the hospice? They will help to guide you on whether you need to be thinking about admission.

It's an awful thing to watch Flowers

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 14/08/2022 19:44

Sorry, where I said '1-2 weeks' I meant that the end of life signs don't often last longer than that, so if he's been like this for more than a week it likely isn't the last stage.

Neverendingdust · 14/08/2022 19:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Thanks for popping by A5, real classy of you.

OP posts:
KentuckyCriedFricken · 14/08/2022 19:41

OP, I could have written this exact post recently. My BIL died of the same cancer in June. What you have described is exactly how he was in his final weeks. I am sorry to say that from the stage you have described until his death was less than 2 weeks. Even the day before he died he was sitting up and talking. Even joking with people. He also slept very still and we often had to “check” to see if he was still alive or not in the night. In fact, the morning he died and my niece said “he’s died” we even said to her “no that’s just how he sleeps”.

He was the third family member we have lost to the same cancer but the first that I have been so involved with in the final weeks. The hospice at home arrangement was in our home as his home wasn’t suitable. So he moved in with us.

GiselleRose · 14/08/2022 19:41

Lost my mum to pancreatic cancer and this was how it went with her. We were informed she’d most likely die in her sleep but she suffered a drop in blood pressure in the end and died over a few hours (don’t think she was aware of it after the bp drop as she had a kind of seizure). She died at home.

A580Hojas · 14/08/2022 19:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Neverendingdust · 14/08/2022 19:35

Thank you all for sharing 💐 it’s a fucking hideous disease isn’t it. The worst part of oesophageal cancer is the being unable to swallow anything at all towards the end. He’s virtually skin and bones, it’s incredibly sad to see and you just feel so helpless watching from the sidelines.

@JumpingPiglets Sorry to hear about your father. In this instance he wants to go to hospice at the end to make things easier for his wife who has her own health issues to deal with. In an ideal world staying at home would be the best option but in this case it really isn’t unless he dies peacefully in his sleep before it gets to that stage (which would no doubt be a blessing in disguise).

@Wilkolampshade Sadly your mums passing sounds similar to my mums, we had to endure a week of sedation before she eventually passed on a gloriously sunny day, the sheer relief it was over was palpable.

@MatildaTheCat I fear we are not at the end yet too. Sorry to read your story.

@RocketPanda hopefully he does the same as your mum and goes without having to endure the grim drawn out alternative.

OP posts:
Elieza · 14/08/2022 19:34

Sorry to hear about your situation and your relatives cancer.

My relative couldn’t go into a hospice as there were no places left as it was full (way prior to covid).

So you might need to remember that. If your relative is happy at home I hope he can stay there.

Marie Curie nurses are great. Hopefully you can get the support you need from them. I’d be getting extra pain meds for him arranged asap. I hope his passing is peaceful.

bloodyplanes · 14/08/2022 19:28

Yes it sounds to me like the process has begun.

Carrieonmywaywardsun · 14/08/2022 19:22

It doesn't sound like the very end IME. But it does sound like he is nearing it. The end usually last 1-2 weeks where he'll be drinking even less, skin will be mottled etc. Mobility and speaking suggests he has some energy so is taking in enough, towards the end he won't take in as much because his body won't need it.

N0tfinished · 14/08/2022 19:21

My dad died at home, he didn't have cancer but died of pulmonary fibrosis, therefore pneumonia, so I'd imagine the final stages are similar. I'd agree with a previous pp, you're probably not at the very final stages, based on our experience. We had home hospice care & they were very good at making sure we were aware when he was reaching his final days. I feel that the syringe driver is a sign that the end is approaching.

We definitely didn't regret having dad at home. It made everything so natural. The kids wandered in & out to him, we put the match on & sat there with him chatting. We had a night nurse from hospice service for his last 2 Nights. We were well supported & dad wasn't in pain or distressed. There were 5 of us between siblings & my mum, plus partners etc for comfort & help. We had familiar carers coming & going. That all made a huge difference.

If you feel differently & are concerned about your loved ones comfort, then that's a whole different ballgame. Everyone's situation is unique. If you feel frightened or concerned you won't cope, then I'd say make the decision before it becomes an emergency.

Swipe left for the next trending thread