Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to be annoyed to change how I speak

67 replies

Passedmybedtime · 14/08/2022 18:19

I have a strong accent and like others in my area we talk faster than others, a new colleague has started work and English isn't that persons first language, I have already changed how I speak to help the person understand and I was barked at by management to speak slower, and that annoyed me, I was offended if I'm honest. I can't help how I speak and I thought I was speaking more clearer and slower for the other person to understand. I dont know what else I can do?? I feel I'm being unreasonable asking this and I tried my best to acdondate the new start esp since it was the person's first day and trying to show the ropes even with a language barrier. I can't go into much details of my work but I feel a annoyed and upset to get into trouble at work when I was trying my hardest to help the person

Am I wrong to feel annoyed?

OP posts:
FrangipaniBlue · 14/08/2022 20:43

From your last post it sounds like your colleague may not speak much English at all OP?

If that's the case then I would be tempted to suggest to management that while you will try to speak slower to help, perhaps they could also help further by the company footing the cost of English lessons for your new colleague.....

user1234560480 · 14/08/2022 20:42

If i go much slower speaking I'd be spelling it out, and that's patronising, unhelpful and rude imho.

Not really. That's what one girl at my work does - it sounds like she's speaking to them like they're stupid (to us)but the person who doesn't speak much English loves her and says she's so easy to understand because she doesn't have a Glasgow accent 😂the lassie is from Springburn and her normal accent is about as strong as you get. She only does it for this one person.

girlmom21 · 14/08/2022 20:42

MajorCarolDanvers · 14/08/2022 20:08

Aberdonians, folk from the Western Isles, Devon and Cornwall, Birmingham and Northern Ireland are far harder to understand than Glaswegians. Glaswegian is easy.

OP you need to be inclusive of your colleague and adapt your speech.

Are you from Glasgow?

thebeesknees123 · 14/08/2022 20:39

Yes, because even if you are speaking clearly, vowel sounds and intonation will be completely different to what they have learnt, even assuming it's at a high level - it might not be. The majority of communication is non verbal so a good approach might be keeping sentences very concise while doing a lot of showing- i.e. visual/hands on training . It is rotten of your boss to shout at you as this is not exactly a situation you've been trained for

Passedmybedtime · 14/08/2022 20:37

thebeesknees123 · 14/08/2022 20:16

How good is her English? Maybe you need to drop in some gestures, too? I can sympathise, having learnt another language then having you contend with dialects, too. It's not easy in the beginning.

Now my hearing is deteriorating, too, so I struggle with different voices - not just accents but voices at a certain pitch. I know I am really annoying with it.

I would actually start at the me Tarzan, you Jane stage and work your way up, following her lead

I'm actually not sure, the person barely spoke, but due to person being just off plane from their own country, probably a rabbit caught in headlights and getting over a culture shock as well as leaving family and friends behind.

OP posts:
cushioncovers · 14/08/2022 20:36

Are you in Glasgow op? If the newcomer has come to work in Glasgow then yanbu.
I take phone calls from clients in Glasgow and find it incredibly hard to catch what they are saying. There's no way I could live there 😁

Phoebesgift · 14/08/2022 20:33

I can't understand the most people from Glasgow either.

Passedmybedtime · 14/08/2022 20:33

TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 14/08/2022 20:20

@Passedmybedtime How dare you have a Glasgow accent! Totally unacceptable and xenophobic of you not to change for one person.

I have a Glasgow accent and know how you feel it's frustrating.

If i go much slower speaking I'd be spelling it out, and that's patronising, unhelpful and rude imho.

OP posts:
PenOrPencil · 14/08/2022 20:21

Non-native speakers will have learned RP (Received Pronunciation). It used to be referred to as Oxford, BBC or The Queen’s English, so a very Southern, sanitised English.

When you learn a language you also learn at a slower speed. Anything other than super clear news reader English will be incomprehensible to the untrained ear. Nobody should shout at you to modify how you talk, but your new colleague will need some time to tune their ears into Glaswegian.
There are some very funny clips online of American guests on the Graham Norton Show who are meeting people with regional accents.

Passedmybedtime · 14/08/2022 20:20

Not everything is xenophobe or ulterior motive. I work with a wide range of people from the 4 corners, and we all get on great and understand each other, nor do I mind on breaks when they chat amongst themselves in their native languages, i dont expect them to not talk their first language, if im on a break with colleagues who are indians I never expect them to chat in English, as at that moment I'd be odd one out, its break time and whatever they chat about is not about work and doesn't concern me.So to call me a xenophobe is ridiculous and also a lie.

OP posts:
TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 14/08/2022 20:20

@Passedmybedtime How dare you have a Glasgow accent! Totally unacceptable and xenophobic of you not to change for one person.

I have a Glasgow accent and know how you feel it's frustrating.

thebeesknees123 · 14/08/2022 20:16

How good is her English? Maybe you need to drop in some gestures, too? I can sympathise, having learnt another language then having you contend with dialects, too. It's not easy in the beginning.

Now my hearing is deteriorating, too, so I struggle with different voices - not just accents but voices at a certain pitch. I know I am really annoying with it.

I would actually start at the me Tarzan, you Jane stage and work your way up, following her lead

Passedmybedtime · 14/08/2022 20:15

It's like when I call up a call centre based in England and have to repeat myself over and over even in a slower accent, does that make the call handler xenophobic because he or she hasn't accommodated to my needs? I'm response to the person calling me a xenophobe.

OP posts:
Brawsome · 14/08/2022 20:11

Stone of Destiny is bang on re lazy listeners. I’ve had this too - lost count of the number of times the reaction to me opening my mouth is greeted by an immediate look of irritation. Just because my accent is from somewhere else. Not far from Glasgow.

incidentally, if the Glasgow accent is such a problem, why was that city one of the more favoured call centre locations?

jayho · 14/08/2022 20:09

Are you in Glasgow and has this person chosen to come and work in Glasgow? If so, YANBU at all. You're already trying to accommodate them. They'll pick it up soon enough. I've worked in different parts of France and there are strong regional accents (except in Paris where they speak French 'properly' as they'll tell you themselves at the drop of a hat). I've usually found it fascinating to try and understand the vernacular.

your manager is a knob and if you wanted to get technical, you cannot be discriminated against because of your accent - ie you can't be told to modify your speech.

catandcoffee · 14/08/2022 20:08

My favourite accent reminds me of my Dad.

God I loved Rab C Nesbit.😂

MajorCarolDanvers · 14/08/2022 20:08

Aberdonians, folk from the Western Isles, Devon and Cornwall, Birmingham and Northern Ireland are far harder to understand than Glaswegians. Glaswegian is easy.

OP you need to be inclusive of your colleague and adapt your speech.

Andromachehadabadday · 14/08/2022 20:05

Loics · 14/08/2022 19:48

Xenophobic? I find the majority of accents around the Midlands a nightmare, is it everyone's responsibility to speak slower to accommodate me? No, I live and work in England so I've grown to understand.
I can ask people to slow down if needed, I'd be furious if someone was "barked at" on my behalf.

If you part of your job is to train someone (and communicate with them) and that someone needs to slow down further, then yes, it’s your responsibility to slow down.

it’s bizarre that anyone thinks it isn’t. Can’t imagine ever saying to a colleague ‘oh you don’t understand me. Tough shit. That’s your responsibility.’ I just don’t get people who have never changed how they communicate depending on who they are communicating with. We all communicate with different people, differently.

some of my closest colleagues are Glaswegian. I can understand them, but colloquialisms means somethings are lost, so I don’t use them like I would with friends who live here. And vice Versa. And where some just slip out, we explain them.

op doesn’t seem that bothered that she was barked at, which isn’t ok. She is bothered that she is being expected to change how she speaks. That’s the title and the main part of the op.

and the Op does come across as xenophobic to me. To me it has a whiff of ‘not my problem if that person who isn’t a native English speaker can’t understand me’.

the only resolutions here are

Op slows down

Op tells her bosses she simply will not put more effort in to slow down and training needs to be done by someone else

New employee is let go, because op is offended by having to change how they communicate.

That’s the 3 outcomes. I wonder which one op wants.

Drywhitefruitycidergin · 14/08/2022 20:04

I voted yabu - it's the responsibility of the speaker to ensure that the listener has heard & understood.
It might be annoying & frustrating at first but new colleague will probably adapt over time.
I lived with a lovely girl from Northern Ireland once and she spoke so fast & was so strongly accepted that at first I couldn't even understand her name when she said it!

Jewel1968 · 14/08/2022 20:03

I have an accent and a way of speaking that I had to alter to be understood. I revert back to the old ways when drunk or angry etc... I find that I struggle with some accents but the longer I am exposed to it the easier it is. It's not just accent, it is the words themselves that can confuse.

Nobody should bark at you though.

GoodThinkingMax · 14/08/2022 19:58

The OP mentioned she is working with someone whose first language is not English. She sounds pretty intolerant of this.

Loics · 14/08/2022 19:48

GoodThinkingMax · 14/08/2022 19:31

I can't help how I speak and I thought I was speaking more clearer and slower for the other person to understand.

Yes, you can.

YABU

The point of speaking to someone is to communicate to them & be understood by them. So you have a choice here: behave like a considerate communicating adult, or stay in your (frankly xenophobic) childish mindset.

Xenophobic? I find the majority of accents around the Midlands a nightmare, is it everyone's responsibility to speak slower to accommodate me? No, I live and work in England so I've grown to understand.
I can ask people to slow down if needed, I'd be furious if someone was "barked at" on my behalf.

PurpleMarie · 14/08/2022 19:43

To the other person I'm not being oversensitive though, asking me to try an change something impossible about myself is what annoys me

Speaking slower isn’t impossible.

Why wouldn’t you want to be better understood by a colleague?

GoodThinkingMax · 14/08/2022 19:31

I can't help how I speak and I thought I was speaking more clearer and slower for the other person to understand.

Yes, you can.

YABU

The point of speaking to someone is to communicate to them & be understood by them. So you have a choice here: behave like a considerate communicating adult, or stay in your (frankly xenophobic) childish mindset.

Hont1986 · 14/08/2022 18:45

Another one here that doesn't find Glaswegian accents a problem. Maybe I have a poor sample size because I've never lived there, but I can follow Limmy's Show with no problem at least.

That said, it is one of the harder accents to follow if you're expecting textbook-style 'RP' English pronunciation and grammar.

Swipe left for the next trending thread