Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have gotten annoyed with someone commenting on what I eat?

40 replies

CuriousityMe · 14/08/2022 15:51

So a few years ago I was 3.5 stone heavier than I am now. I've maintained a healty BMI and weight since and do eat a lot healthier now, while still enjoying an occasional treat. A family member said to me I need a more varied diet, I'm too rigid in what I eat. In fact I'm not - there's very little I don't like and never leave food behind me on the plate. This person doesn't live with me so has no idea how varied my diet actually is; I think maybe they think I'm too healthy, which I'm not. I never skip meals either but look forward to my food. I got annoyed with them and said I have a varied diet. This has upset me - but I think it's the fact of the words exchanged. AIBU to have put them right?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
10HailMarys · 15/08/2022 16:08

ManateeFair · 14/08/2022 18:12

I lost a few stone a while back and a couple of people were weird about it and kept commenting on my eating - ironically, one of them kept suggesting I wasn’t eating enough (invariably just because I’d said no to a cake or something at work) and the other said “Ooh, are you allowed that?” or “That’ll wreck the diet!” every time I ate anything that wasn’t a vegetable, so I couldn’t win.

The thing was, I ate loads, didn’t cut out any food groups, nothing. I just set a calorie limit to stick to on most days, and it wasn’t actually even a very low one because I was very active with exercise and walking.

Yeah, this is bit like my experience at work although in my case it was one person who just kept making snide remarks about me not eating cakes/sweets etc in the office and commented on literally every lunch she saw me eat, and one who was part of some kind of fat-positive movement who believed that all consciousness of food or weight is a form of eating disorder and that anyone who deliberately loses weight is committing an act of hatred and erasure against other fat people. That led to some 'interesting' conversations.

(To be clear, I wasn't one of those people who constantly goes on about weight and diets in the office. The only times I ever mentioned it were on a couple of occasions when people who hadn't seen me for a while actually asked me outright if I'd lost weight.)

Essexgalttc · 15/08/2022 15:51

CuriousityMe · 15/08/2022 15:39

Feel a bit guilty today about saying something back to her but hopefully I won't need to say any more!

Unless someone has a genuine reason to be concerned for example if you was rapidly losing weight and never ate them no commenting on someone’s weight or what they eat is not needed

I personally found that others comments about what I ate contributed to my disordered eating.

You did right putting her in her place

It’s about time people stopped this

Personally, I’d never tell a friend they were eating too little or too much.

CuriousityMe · 15/08/2022 15:39

Feel a bit guilty today about saying something back to her but hopefully I won't need to say any more!

OP posts:
BMW6 · 14/08/2022 23:03

"Rest assured, when I want your opinion on my food choices I'll ask for it. In the meantime keep your opinion to yourself"

Deliver with a hard stare. No smile.

BronzeSage · 14/08/2022 22:58

People like others to do the same as them. They find it comforting and validating. Not your problem.

CuriousityMe · 14/08/2022 20:57

@Anxietyandwine I wonder why her comment struck such a cord with you?

It just irritated me, I suppose, because I'm a grown adult and can make my own food choices.

OP posts:
SuperCamp · 14/08/2022 20:14

@Pebble55* *
they're baby boomers anyway so most of what comes out of their mouths is utter drivel

Stupidity comes in many forms. E.g ludicrous ageist generalisations.

SuperCamp · 14/08/2022 19:55

midsomermurderess · 14/08/2022 17:07

How do I know? I don’t know these people. No one here does. But it’s astonishing how much jealousy comes up on this site. I think it’s stunted emotional development. And there’s no need to write an essay about it.

Yeah, but I just knew from the OP that it was going to be from someone criticising her for not eating cake or dessert.

Pebble55 · 14/08/2022 19:18

Yeh I get the same stupid comments from the PIL. Because I usually
only eat two meals a day (just like my father, brother, ma and pa) and refuse to partake in having lunch at 12:00 while I'm still digesting breakfast that finished at 10, I cop a whole load of shit from them. I've learned to just ignore their idiocy, they're baby boomers anyway so most of what comes out of their mouths is utter drivel

HumourReplacementTherapy · 14/08/2022 19:17

One of the benefits of WFH is I no longer get the constant comments on what I'm eating. When I was doing 5:2 it was a nightmare. If I wasn't eating lunch I'd be questioned. If I was I'd be questioned.... it was 2013 when I started it so nobody had really heard much about it yet .... I still used to have fasting days as maintenance after I'd lost the weight and so it went on for bloody years. 😩
I would never comment on someone's diet and would only comment on the food they were eating to say it looked nice or something along those lines.

drkpl · 14/08/2022 19:09

She’s probably jealous that you’ve lost weight

carefullycourageous · 14/08/2022 19:08

I'd just say 'I eat what I want to eat, thanks' and shut it down. Do not explain yourself or even discuss it.

Anxietyandwine · 14/08/2022 19:06

I don’t think anyone should really be commenting on other peoples food choices unless it’s in a supportive manner. This would upset me. But I have an eating disorder and am currently in therapy and working with a dietician. I wonder why her comment struck such a cord with you?

I remember someone at work (very tall, willowy, competitive under-eater) saying to me ‘my goodness that is a huge salad!’ (It was in a repurposed takeaway plastic tub and was pure salad with no meat etc and a spoon of hummus I was around 9 stone.)

It really upset me and I struggled to eat at work from then on which didn’t help matters, so YANBU as she has no idea what your diet is or why and people should mind their business.

WhereYouLeftIt · 14/08/2022 18:59

CuriousityMe · 14/08/2022 16:29

It's brother's wife. Twice recently I declined dessert when out for a meal with them. Two courses was enough for me.

So your brother's wife "said to me I need a more varied diet, I'm too rigid in what I eat" - on the basis that you chose not to have a dessert?

She's batshit.

I very rarely have dessert, I just don't particularly like 'restaurant' desserts. She'd love me.

Ignore, ignore, ignore. She should be grateful you confined yourself to 'I do have a varied diet' rather than 'what's it got to do with you, who made you the Food Police?'.

LidFlipper · 14/08/2022 18:25

My family are like this. Surprise surprise I have bulimia. It wasn’t until I met my husband that I realised it wasn’t normal to comment on peoples food.

Tiani4 · 14/08/2022 18:23

"Dear SIL, hi please don't comment on what I eat again, I'm an adult and I eat a varied healthy diet.

Regardless I'm sure you weren't trying to body shame as that would be unkind,

Thank-you , Curiosity

BurgerQueen23 · 14/08/2022 18:15

I lost weight and lots of people started to comment on what I ate or didn’t eat. It’s jealousy. A lot of people don’t like it when others get slim and especially not slimmer than them. Hi

FangsForTheMemory · 14/08/2022 18:13

It's the height of bad manners to criticise what someone else is eating.

Would really like to know how you lost 3.5 st and kept them off though?

ddl1 · 14/08/2022 18:13

It may not be jealousy in the strict sense, but she may take your not eating dessert as an implied criticism of her doing so. In any case, she shouldn't be commenting.

ManateeFair · 14/08/2022 18:12

I lost a few stone a while back and a couple of people were weird about it and kept commenting on my eating - ironically, one of them kept suggesting I wasn’t eating enough (invariably just because I’d said no to a cake or something at work) and the other said “Ooh, are you allowed that?” or “That’ll wreck the diet!” every time I ate anything that wasn’t a vegetable, so I couldn’t win.

The thing was, I ate loads, didn’t cut out any food groups, nothing. I just set a calorie limit to stick to on most days, and it wasn’t actually even a very low one because I was very active with exercise and walking.

CuriousityMe · 14/08/2022 18:07

Good to hear I'm (mostly!) not being unreasonable to have said something.

OP posts:
EnjoythemoneyJane · 14/08/2022 17:47

Yeah, jealousy (despite the eye rolls that answer clearly engenders in some). If you’ve lost loads of weight and someone keeps trying to make you eat pudding under the guise of being concerned for your health, they’re fucked off about it. Ignore her. Congratulations, btw.

KohlaParasaurus · 14/08/2022 17:36

A former colleague of mine, a charming woman, faced with a similar comment, said, "I eat MY food. I don't eat YOUR food." It's difficult to find a response that isn't defensive, doesn't sound rude or snappy, and doesn't encourage further intrusion into your food choices, but that's the closest I've heard.

Shoxfordian · 14/08/2022 17:33

Is she overweight herself? Ignore her

NotApplicable · 14/08/2022 17:33

My in laws are like this to the extent I've nearly stopped contact, because the constant personal digs at my perceived lack of food consumption (their family revolves around food and all have weight issilues) was making every family event stressful. It was giving me anxiety attacks where I felt I HAD to eat the same ain't as them so as not to cause offence or provoke comments, but made myself ill and my IBS flare up.

They know I come from a genetically slim small family who don't generally eat big meals. Dessert has never been a thing for me. And I have digestive issues. But they don't give a damn, because food and eating is the be all and end all.

But the last time my MIL got snarky with me and I ended up (secretively) in tears because I wouldn't eat 3 people's left over Indian takeaway along with a freshly cooked quiche and salad, with a dessert to finish, despite the rest of the family only eating quiche and salad, made me realise I had to stop trying to keep them happy at the cost of my own physical and mental health.

Now I only eat what I want, I decline and refuse what I don't want and I just completely ignore any comments. I don't explain, I don't justify, I don't reason. I just blankly ignore. Any attempts to get ne to eat what I don't want are just met with a straight forward and consistent 'No thank you'

They dont bother any more

Swipe left for the next trending thread