Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my friend is wrong and this can't be classed as stealing?

331 replies

Keyansier · 14/08/2022 11:06

Whenever I order a home delivery from Tesco I always get a refund on stuff that they have substituted in exchange for what I originally ordered to get money back and to keep the food, sometimes when I genuinely dislike their substitute choice or sometimes when I just want some money back.

My friend said "that is what is known as stealing". I replied "HOW can it be stealing when I call up and ask for a refund and it's at their discretion if they give one or not?" Also, I used to work in a few call centres and so probably speak to people who work at call centres politer than most other people, so that might factor their decision to give me refunds.

Unless someone tells me that they work for Tesco on the call centres and they are obliged to give everyone a refund that asks for one but they will later be punished or sacked for it if they say yes, then I can't see what the issue is if they say yes? I don't shout, or threaten or rant. I ask nicely and they say yes. If they were to ever say no, I'd simply say "okay then" and that would be that. So how is it stealing?

I just can't believe in this day and age someone would begrudge someone free food. Their tagline is "Every Little Helps". This is helping me. If they didn't want to help, they can easily say no. Or AIBU and out of touch?

OP posts:
DownNative · 14/08/2022 17:59

Keyansier · 14/08/2022 11:06

Whenever I order a home delivery from Tesco I always get a refund on stuff that they have substituted in exchange for what I originally ordered to get money back and to keep the food, sometimes when I genuinely dislike their substitute choice or sometimes when I just want some money back.

My friend said "that is what is known as stealing". I replied "HOW can it be stealing when I call up and ask for a refund and it's at their discretion if they give one or not?" Also, I used to work in a few call centres and so probably speak to people who work at call centres politer than most other people, so that might factor their decision to give me refunds.

Unless someone tells me that they work for Tesco on the call centres and they are obliged to give everyone a refund that asks for one but they will later be punished or sacked for it if they say yes, then I can't see what the issue is if they say yes? I don't shout, or threaten or rant. I ask nicely and they say yes. If they were to ever say no, I'd simply say "okay then" and that would be that. So how is it stealing?

I just can't believe in this day and age someone would begrudge someone free food. Their tagline is "Every Little Helps". This is helping me. If they didn't want to help, they can easily say no. Or AIBU and out of touch?

If you're asking each driver at the door to refund your unwanted substitutions AND let you keep the food...those drivers are costing their Tesco store a lot of money altogether.

And they need retraining.

If you're calling up the Tesco line, whoever is refunding you for food you're keeping IS costing Tesco a lot of money altogether.

That Tesco call employee needs retraining! Additionally, driver at the door IS meant to ask you if you're happy with your substitutions.

If you're lying to the driver by saying you're happy with them and then calling Tesco up to get them for free.....I'm afraid your friend is correct and you're stealing as you weren't honest with Tesco's driver at door OR employee on the telephone.

Effectively, you're manipulating them. A customer at my store did the same thing as you. Result? They were eventually blocked from getting substitutions for free AND had to speak to the Dotcom Manager who knew exactly what that customer was doing.

This is NOT Tesco's policy and they've been cracking down on this for the last few years. Before the pandemic.

The Tesco policy is if your fresh item goes out of date the day after delivery, you can keep it AND get a refund. Driver does this at the door.

Nothing else.

Whatkindoflifeisthis · 14/08/2022 17:56

Keyansier · 14/08/2022 11:48

I didn't ask if people thought what I was doing was "right" I asked if people agreed with my friend and classed it as stealing. I also asked if anyone that worked for Tesco get penalised by issuing refunds and you've just confirmed they don't so if it means someone in a callcentre somewhere shakes their head and refunds £20 quid or so from the 2.6 billion pound profits Tesco acquired last year, then all I could say is: "Oh".

Well no, I didn't confirm nor deny if staff get penalised for giving out refunds. They actually can. Although it would have to be an unreasonably high amount. Your stats are collated weekly and they can see everything; cumulative total of refunds given, how many 'goodwill' vouchers are issued, length of time spent on each call. Everything. I was pulled up now and again for various stats ie too many vouchers issued, refunding willy nilly when I probably shouldn't have. I didn't really care tbh, I was a student at the time and hated the job, I didn't really care if they put me on performance management/sacked me. But yes, staff can be pulled up if they are too blasé with the refunds.

I did some across people like you whereby the store manager from where the groceries were coming from used to personally check the shop of certain known customers before it was delivered. Or refuse to provide substitutions. Or whatever fitting action based on what the customer was guilty of. Make sure you don't become one of these 'blacklisted' customers, that would be very embarrassing indeed.

But whatever, it's not my money, I don't really care. If your conscience is OK with your behaviour though then crack on.

LittleBearPad · 14/08/2022 17:49

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:39

If you say so! I don't have experience of this exact industry but supermarkets have ridiculous amounts of data and people looking at it day in day out, and are extremely good at using it. So if my industry does it, supermarkets can do it 1000x as well. It just seems incredible that they wouldn't.
But if you address my actual points maybe you can educate me.
Anyway I'm off to play a game with my son

But your points aren’t relevant as you simply don’t understand what you’re talking about.

AMIAMIBU · 14/08/2022 17:47

@johnd2 bore off! Tesco lose money from theft, OP is a thief....

It's not rocket science is it?

Iwantmyoldnameback · 14/08/2022 17:43

OP.
Tesco will increase prices to cover losses so other shoppers will ultimately pay for your free food.

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:39

LittleBearPad · 14/08/2022 17:31

You have absolutely no idea what you’re talking about do you.

If you say so! I don't have experience of this exact industry but supermarkets have ridiculous amounts of data and people looking at it day in day out, and are extremely good at using it. So if my industry does it, supermarkets can do it 1000x as well. It just seems incredible that they wouldn't.
But if you address my actual points maybe you can educate me.
Anyway I'm off to play a game with my son

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:34

LittleBearPad · 14/08/2022 17:28

You weren’t in the finance function were you Hmm.

No finance are basically recording what we are doing financially, but honestly we have to be well ahead of the finance team on what the trends are, so my team would be doing something about it based on metrics visible well before the actual revenue is recorded.
But yes if we are struggling, the finance would not lie about what happened!

LittleBearPad · 14/08/2022 17:31

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:30

I said let's not argue about who lacks understanding, the point of my post was Tesco's profits are not a reason to steal as in reality the money isn't ultimately coming from where you think it is.
And this is because there are loads of people working there whose job it is to make them have more profits.
I'm trying to avoid to turn it into a personal argument.

You have absolutely no idea what you’re talking about do you.

SpidersAreShitheads · 14/08/2022 17:31

Oh. The thief is back. Only flounced for a couple of hours. Was probably on hold to the Tesco call centre getting a bit more cash through dishonesty.

Threads like these you hope that someone with a bit of clout who works at Tesco is reading and manages to track down the account from clues on their MN posts. Would be amazing 👌

Mountainpika · 14/08/2022 17:30

Theft by deliberate deception. Shameful behaviour.

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:30

AMIAMIBU · 14/08/2022 17:23

@johnd2 why say let's not argue, then bang on about I'm being right?

Are you mansplaining for a reason?

I said let's not argue about who lacks understanding, the point of my post was Tesco's profits are not a reason to steal as in reality the money isn't ultimately coming from where you think it is.
And this is because there are loads of people working there whose job it is to make them have more profits.
I'm trying to avoid to turn it into a personal argument.

LimeTwists · 14/08/2022 17:30

It’s not theft because they offer you the option. However, they do it to be helpful in the hope that people will try and like the substitution, not so cheeky people like you can take the piss by deliberately choosing to keep the food knowing full well they plan to pretend to dislike it and pocket the refund. What you are doing is unpleasant.

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 14/08/2022 17:30

Just out of interest OP, do you ever make 'pairing suggestions' toTesco? Chips, drinks, that sort of thing...?

LittleBearPad · 14/08/2022 17:28

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:21

Let's not argue about who lacks understanding, as you are right on a theoretical level, but not in a practical level.,

every business I've ever worked in, this kind of stuff is budgeted and carefully monitored with targets or key results. Any deviation would be noticed and reported and action taken ages before it became significant.
So yes if it were ignored or insignificant, literally speaking it would come out of profits, but any business poorly managed enough for that to happen by default would be out of business extremely quickly(or bailed out by the government)

You weren’t in the finance function were you Hmm.

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:26

AMIAMIBU · 14/08/2022 17:20

Don't be ridiculous!

Stolen food comes out of profit, so you're saying that if food wasn't stolen that profits wouldn't be more?

How can you actually think that?

Actually working in a business where theft is common can be more profitable. This is why banks had to be regulated by government to have chip and PIN and the new online payment regulations. Because the theft was ridiculous but the profits were greater.
If it weren't profitable due to the theft then the business would go under, and if it were more profitable there would be more competition. (Whether the big supermarkets form a monopoly is another question admittedly!)

TheDuck2018 · 14/08/2022 17:25

Op, you're coming across as a total thief aswell as a massive dickhead. Hope that helps 😃

AMIAMIBU · 14/08/2022 17:23

@johnd2 why say let's not argue, then bang on about I'm being right?

Are you mansplaining for a reason?

Hobnobswantshernameback · 14/08/2022 17:22

Shit flouncer
stupid auto correct

rwalker · 14/08/2022 17:22

LittleBearPad · 14/08/2022 17:14

Of course it comes out of their profit! Such a fundamental lack of understanding.

Profit is revenue less costs. For each item the OP gets refunded Tesco’s lose the revenue. They don’t get the item back to resell but still have to pay the supplier. They lose their profit margin on it - reducing their profit before and after tax.

They factor cost of this into there cost still keep same profit margins
they just up the price of the goods so it’s cost us the consumer not Tescos profit

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:21

LittleBearPad · 14/08/2022 17:14

Of course it comes out of their profit! Such a fundamental lack of understanding.

Profit is revenue less costs. For each item the OP gets refunded Tesco’s lose the revenue. They don’t get the item back to resell but still have to pay the supplier. They lose their profit margin on it - reducing their profit before and after tax.

Let's not argue about who lacks understanding, as you are right on a theoretical level, but not in a practical level.,

every business I've ever worked in, this kind of stuff is budgeted and carefully monitored with targets or key results. Any deviation would be noticed and reported and action taken ages before it became significant.
So yes if it were ignored or insignificant, literally speaking it would come out of profits, but any business poorly managed enough for that to happen by default would be out of business extremely quickly(or bailed out by the government)

Hobnobswantshernameback · 14/08/2022 17:21

Aaaannnnndddd
he's back in the room
maybe as well as "looks young enough to be mistaken for a foetus" "drama llama" and "goady chancer" you could add "shit flounced" to your CV

AMIAMIBU · 14/08/2022 17:20

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:10

For all those who think it comes out of their profits directly, that's not how businesses are run otherwise if it happened too much, am otherwise viable business would go under.
What actually happens is it comes out of the budget or target for this. As the budget is monitored any change or spike would be noted and action taken.
The action might be banning certain customers, reallocating the budget, changing the scheme, or something else from their imagination.
Most of those things would ultimately come from customers one way or another.
Only things that actually discourage profits would reduce the profits directly, eg a tax on profits.

Don't be ridiculous!

Stolen food comes out of profit, so you're saying that if food wasn't stolen that profits wouldn't be more?

How can you actually think that?

LittleBearPad · 14/08/2022 17:14

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:10

For all those who think it comes out of their profits directly, that's not how businesses are run otherwise if it happened too much, am otherwise viable business would go under.
What actually happens is it comes out of the budget or target for this. As the budget is monitored any change or spike would be noted and action taken.
The action might be banning certain customers, reallocating the budget, changing the scheme, or something else from their imagination.
Most of those things would ultimately come from customers one way or another.
Only things that actually discourage profits would reduce the profits directly, eg a tax on profits.

Of course it comes out of their profit! Such a fundamental lack of understanding.

Profit is revenue less costs. For each item the OP gets refunded Tesco’s lose the revenue. They don’t get the item back to resell but still have to pay the supplier. They lose their profit margin on it - reducing their profit before and after tax.

johnd2 · 14/08/2022 17:10

For all those who think it comes out of their profits directly, that's not how businesses are run otherwise if it happened too much, am otherwise viable business would go under.
What actually happens is it comes out of the budget or target for this. As the budget is monitored any change or spike would be noted and action taken.
The action might be banning certain customers, reallocating the budget, changing the scheme, or something else from their imagination.
Most of those things would ultimately come from customers one way or another.
Only things that actually discourage profits would reduce the profits directly, eg a tax on profits.

PuzzledObserver · 14/08/2022 17:09

It’s obtaining money by deception, is what it is.

If you want free food, visit the local food bank or community larder. You might find a lot of the stuff there has been donated by Tesco. That doesn’t mean anyone can turn up at the shop and help themselves.

Swipe left for the next trending thread