Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have ‘defaced’ this photograph??

818 replies

Boobsakimboo · 14/08/2022 09:39

We have lockers at work, in our break room where everyone goes and one co-worker,
Jim, has a photo of a famous, topless page 3 girl on the inside of his door.
the girl in the photo was 16 when it was taken, and he’s had it since around the same age - he wrote into The Sun and got a signed one sent- so it’s very precious to him.

several women have mentioned to Jim that they’d rather he didn’t have it there as the locker door is often left open and we can see it. Jim thinks we’re prudes, because it’s famous page 3 girls, and IN his locker it’s not an issue.

Anyway, cut to last week. I was alone in break room. Locker door was open so I’m looking at this picture. There were Sharpie pens sitting on the table. So I gave the child in the photo quite a substantial bikini top with the permanent marker.

shit has hit the fan! Management don’t quite know what to do. Jim is furious, and the workforce divided into those who think it’s funny and those who think it was wrong.
no-one know who did it… Jim
his suspicions …

So MN, was AIBU??

OP posts:
Musmerian · 14/08/2022 10:48

@badgerstink - you should have put up an atheist quote on your own desk. Nietzsche’s ‘God is dead.’ perhaps?

Starrystarrynight456 · 14/08/2022 10:48

@SunnyD44 have you read what I said above about the employer potentially in breach of the 2010 Equality Act. Op absolutely has a leg to stand on. She could quite easily create a defence about the management allowing sexual harassment and a hostile work environment by allowing Jim to display a photo others raised was offensive and made them uncomfortable. Yes OP should have raised it with HR but OP could easily argue she had no faith they would do anything either given management had been so ineffective. I'm a HR professional of 20 plus years and no way would I be recommending anything other than minor action against the OP - allowing Jim to display that photo is an employment tribunal waiting to happen.

Ryah76 · 14/08/2022 10:48

The poster was inappropriate for display in the workplace, no question about it. Personally I wouldn’t have defaced it, I would have removed , posted it to HR with a letter outlining the problem and managements piss poor response to the complaints raised about it.

Hopefully your colleague would be notified that it was not acceptable for display within the work place and his property would be returned to his home address.

Headbandheart · 14/08/2022 10:47

Boobsakimboo · 14/08/2022 09:50

‘What have management said in the past when you've brought to their attention that many of you are offended by Jim's photo?’

management are 3 blokes in their 40s and saw no harm as it was in his locker. Plus it was ‘ arty’ apparently. When I said - you know she was famously 16 in that picture, the answer was ‘it was different back then! And 16!is the age of consent.

In most reputable companies no one would be allowed to have nude, or never scantily “pin up” pictures on site anywhere whether inside lockers or not.
the locker is company property - a decent company would say images like this are not allowed on or within company property.

a decent company would say that such pictures must not be viewed in company time and therefore not displayed anywhere that others could see including in a desk, on a desk, etc.
If he kept it in his personal bag and did not take it out then maybe ok.
There was a bit of a issue at work as some of the women had photos of famous football players - all in their kit not nude. Some toys were saying they should be taken down as they were “pin up” shots the women were goggling and lusting at, the women claimed they were just supporting their favourite team.

in the end the company got out of it because they imposed a complete no photo of humans ban anywhere - their main concern was people having pictures of family out on desks- there had been a security scare at one of our sites with protestors coming into the office. Lists of names and addresses were taken and so it became a complete Clear desk policy. 🤷🏼‍♀️ That meant they never did have to determine if the women were fans or lusting 🤣.

CloudCatz · 14/08/2022 10:47

There is nothing wrong with one 16 year old fancying another 16 year old.

Yes, but he's 50 now. Do you watch films you used to watch when you were 16, and still find those 16 year old actors fuckable at your age now?

SunnyD44 · 14/08/2022 10:47

@Onandupw so you think we should just destroy everything that offends us?
Do you not think something like this should be taken higher?

Randomthoughts992 · 14/08/2022 10:47

no matter what, it isn't appropriate to have a topless child photo on your locker in the workplace. It isn't appropriate anywhere, he may have got it when he was that age but he isn't now so needs to move on from the interest in a child. He should have taken it home if it was Soooo important to him and i would have been complaining to management every week til it was removed as child porn.

Onandupw · 14/08/2022 10:47

@Crazycrazylady sexual image of a sixteen year old
girl is the same as a piece of meat according to you?

well indeed. I think that makes the point very well.

titchy · 14/08/2022 10:46

Antarcticant · 14/08/2022 10:42

It would be perfectly legal for 50-year-old Jim to have sex with or even marry a 16 year old.

And? Your point being...?

KatherineJaneway · 14/08/2022 10:46

bizarrely because I didn’t want to get him in trouble!

But you think so little of him you destroyed something that is precious to him.

100% that picture had no place in a workplace environment however there were other options than destroying his picture. You clearly enjoyed what you did which is a very unpleasant trait.

CloudCatz · 14/08/2022 10:46

It would be perfectly legal for 50-year-old Jim to have sex with or even marry a 16 year old.

Yes, but illegal for him to receive sexy photos or videos from her.

Onandupw · 14/08/2022 10:45

@SunnyD44 not really like a handbag though is it? It’s a naked sixteen year old girl. What do you think are some of the issues with you equating a naked sixteen year old girl with a handbag?

LondonWolf · 14/08/2022 10:45

The OP says Jim was 16 when he acquired the image, and so was the model. There is nothing wrong with one 16 year old fancying another 16 year old. The image shouldn't have been out there, by today's standards, but you can't re-write history.

This.

Sparklingbrook · 14/08/2022 10:44

whalleyt · 14/08/2022 10:43

@Sparklingbrook I would have gone to HR but I still think it's funny and I think any tribunal would come down harder on the person with said photo then the person who defaced it.

The main thing is that HR would have sorted all this out and decided who was in the wrong etc without all this.

Teddletime · 14/08/2022 10:44

I think the 'tide turned' in terms of Renaissance Art almost immediately.
'In November 1545 Pietro Aretino — himself a known homosexual — viciously attacked Michelangelo's "godlessness" displayed in the naked youths of the Sistine Chapel and said quite explicitly: "Even if you are divine, you don't disdain male consorts." He went on to identify two of these boyfriends, Gherardo Perini and Tommaso Cavalieri, nicknamed "Tomai'
and the Sistine Chapel was a church and workplace for many.
The Victorian era was famously responsible for covering up or knocked off the genitalia on many statues

whalleyt · 14/08/2022 10:44

Are sexual images of children okay?

apparently 16 is not a child or it's ok as she chose to do it & got rich 🤷🏻‍♀️

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 14/08/2022 10:44

Bornin1989 · 14/08/2022 10:36

If Jim had a hard drive full of pictures of topless 16 year old girls that you "accidentally" spilled a cup of tea on, would people seriously be saying you were wrong for destroying his property? Even if he'd been a teenager when he saved the photos, even if the photos were taken at a time when the sexualization of 16 year olds was more accepted? I don't understand how people are being so accepting of Jim and his child porn.

Why on earth would you do that when you could report him? Unless you were more bothered about making a point than you were about the actual material (or just wanted a funny story for MN that didn’t get quite the universal approval you expected)?

Crazycrazylady · 14/08/2022 10:44

To be fair it wasn't on display in his desk . It was in his locker which you got a flash of occasionally. You knew it was precious to him and totally defaced it.
I think there is something really creepy about you feeling it's appropriate to destroy something you don't agree with in someone else's locker. Should atheists be able to destroy something religious in your locker .what a bout vegetation's upset my meat somewhere . Is it all fair game. I think you were very spiteful actually .

CloudCatz · 14/08/2022 10:44

If she was 16 when it was taken, then it's CP/CSAM surely.

It's very weird to have naked women in public places. Why does he want to become aroused every time he uses his locker? Surely they belong at home in the bedroom? Men can be so very weird.

PurpleCatCuddles · 14/08/2022 10:43

oakleaffy · 14/08/2022 10:39

Topless modelling at 16 must have been what she wanted to do, don't know how long ago this would have been but people left home at 16/17 at the end of the last Century, they weren't considered ''Children'' as one could marry at 16.

.... what?

I've really heard it all now.

I left home at 16 and did sex work. It was what I 'wanted' to do at the time. I look back now and see I was exploited. Because I was a child.

Jesus christ.

whalleyt · 14/08/2022 10:43

@Sparklingbrook I would have gone to HR but I still think it's funny and I think any tribunal would come down harder on the person with said photo then the person who defaced it.

Onandupw · 14/08/2022 10:43

Are sexual images of children okay?

Are sexual images of children okay if they are important to a middle aged man because he’s been sexually aroused by them since he was himself sixteen?

Does the fact that someone paid for an image of the sexual image of a child and therefore it is his property make it okay for him to have a sexual image of a child? in other words - why is ownership relevant to whether a sexual image of a child is okay (displayed or not)?

Does a sixteen year old girl, under pressure from adults, have the capacity to decide that she is comfortable with sexual images of her being taken that can then be displayed for the rest of her life?

Is it really annoying when men just want to have a bit of a bantz about child sexual images? Are the needs of men to display their sexual needs more important than children who are exploited for sexual images and those that wish to protect them?

Child safeguarding and protecting girls is all just soooo hysterical and boring isn’t it.

bluberries · 14/08/2022 10:43

Antarcticant · 14/08/2022 10:42

It would be perfectly legal for 50-year-old Jim to have sex with or even marry a 16 year old.

Doesn't make it ok to have her picture up in the workplace

Maireas · 14/08/2022 10:43

Boobsakimboo · 14/08/2022 10:38

‘Just out of interest, how about a copy of Michelangelo's David on display?’

😅😅😅😅at the comparison of this with Page 3 Girls! I’ve seen the light, thank you. Shall we start a campaign to get Page 3 topless models back?

I think we can imagine the level of abuse Clare Short got when she tried to get Page 3 banned.
I don't know if the Vatican was mentioned, though 🤔

FOJN · 14/08/2022 10:42

It never seems to be a problem when women are ogling at half naked oiled hunks in suggestive poses. Remember the Chippendales

That's not acceptable either, I would be no more comfortable with pictures of near naked men than pictures of near naked women. I would have some serious concerns about any middle aged woman with a picture of a near naked 16 year old boy displayed at work, well anywhere for that matter.

The diet coke ad used to make me cringe.