Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be annoyed the in-laws are unable to attend our sons first birthday?

132 replies

Sophie9090 · 13/08/2022 23:03

Hi

I feel a little annoyed but I am unsure if I’m being unreasonable. Our sons birthday is early November, I was trying to plan a party with my family and my husbands (we both have big family’s)

We asked my DH family if they would be able to attend, they all said they couldn’t make it for different reasons. They all live approx 1 hour 30 mins a away, most of them don’t drive, however there are train services, and most of them
would be able to car share.

They have never once came to visit us, we have always drove to them. I just feel they could make the effort to travel this one time, my DH is upset with them but I’m trying not to make him feel bad so I’m playing it down, however I feel it’s so selfish and I just don’t want to make to effort to see them.

Should I just let it go?

thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RobertaFirmino · 18/11/2022 20:20

What actually happens at a one year old's birthday party?

RealityTV · 18/11/2022 17:54

@Sophie9090, what you're really saying is that this isn't just about the birthday. You have extended yourself and embraced them by going to see them and you would like them to do the same. You know, deep down, that your kid won't remember this birthday, but this is just an example of how they don't treat you as well as you treat them. You feel like you two are doing all the work to maintain the relationship and they have NEVER come to see you, which makes things feel very one-sided. I get it and I understand. Does his family travel to the homes of other people? if so, you aren't being unreasonable, but continue to invite them to things and go to their events only if you feel like it. Sometimes people get stuck in their ways. Don't take it personally unless they visit other people who live as far away as you do and still won't come to see you.

I would also take the direct approach. ASK them why they never come to see you! Sometimes the direct approach gets you the answer you need! TRY IT!

Gymrabbit · 18/11/2022 11:13

NaomiGoldman

is this quote in reference to my post?

‘It's not "abuse" for people to not see the point of a big party for a one-year-old, and implying so is incredibly trivializing of actual abuse and insulting to actual abuse victims.’

NaomiGoldman · 18/11/2022 06:21

In the real world, people who make a fuss over a child's first birthday are usually the frivolous wealthy. Or people who are just plain frivolous with their money and overly concerned with appearances.

My family is very close and loving, but also largely working-class and down-to-earth. We don't measure love by how much money we got someone to spend on a gift or how far we got someone to travel for a holiday. A few pictures are taken, but we don't film every moment because we're busy enjoying the festivities and not so pretentious and up our own behinds that we think anyone would want to actually watch baby's-first-whatever. (Especially not the kids themselves; if they have their way, they'll probably destroy any and all tape at the first opportunity! 😄)

It's not "abuse" for people to not see the point of a big party for a one-year-old, and implying so is incredibly trivializing of actual abuse and insulting to actual abuse victims.

The only "miracle baby" worth travelling over a long distance to see was born and died over 2000 years ago. And even then, I'll bet there were relatives of Mary and Joseph who were like, "you know what, it's an awfully long slog even without the plague and the levies and all, we'll just send a card and some matzah for little Yeshua XO"

Gymrabbit · 16/11/2022 07:53

Don’t worry OP.
People love to be contrary on here - in the real world most people have 1st birthday gatherings for their kids and close relatives attend unless they have unavoidable other commitments.
they also see their families regularly.
obviously there are some families where people are abusive or just selfish arseholes but people normally know if their family are like this.
I feel sorry for your husband as it’s clear that his family don’t give a crap about him or his child.
like others posters said, enjoy your little family and your own parents and don’t worry about them. It’s their loss.

FiveMins · 16/11/2022 07:29

If it was just the party I would say YABU. It's the fact they never visit (which tbh is a blessing most likely!) means YANBU.

silverclock222 · 16/11/2022 07:26

The party has been and gone!

Topsyturvy78 · 16/11/2022 07:25

They're loss those that want to be there will be.

Jjones8 · 16/11/2022 07:23

I can understand you’re upset but I think you are overreacting a little. Perhaps you can celebrate your child’s birthday with them in another way? In my experience, first birthday parties are very dull for those attending. My children certainly don’t remember their first birthdays.

BeanieTeen · 16/11/2022 06:53

I don’t get the big deal at all about 1st birthday parties and wouldn’t travel more than about 15 minutes for one TBH

In my experience first birthdays aren’t special, just first birthdays for first borns. And I do understand the excitement around it for the parents. But no I know one has bothered doing parties for their second or third child.
I don’t blame people for not wanting to travel far for this kind of thing, especially if they don’t have a car.

Procrastination4 · 16/11/2022 06:43

OP, I don’t think that you are being unreasonable to be disappointed that your in-laws won’t make an effort to attend. I’m a bit surprised at the number of posters writing about how unimportant a first birthday, but can only assume that none of them are grandparents yet.

Our first grandson turns one next June. We have a wedding abroad that month and are going to add on an extra week or two to our stay as a holiday (ten hour flight away so want to make the most of it!) and our main concern was planning our trip so that we wouldn’t miss our grandson’s first birthday. He won’t know what’s going on but it’s a special day for my son and daughter-in-law, and we want to be there for them and mark the occasion.

Enjoy the day with you OH and family, and maybe let your in-laws make the effort to come to see you and your baby over the Christmas period rather than you having to travel to them.

BobbyBobbyBobby · 16/11/2022 06:18

Joystir59 · 16/11/2022 04:31

I wouldn't want to travel anywhere to attend a first birthday party either. I don't understand why you are even having one- your child won't care about it or remember it. You are making a huge fuss about nothing. Just quietly enjoy the day with your child.

I agree. I wouldn’t go on the ground that the op is filming it all. Forced Jolliness all round is not my cup of tea.

Joystir59 · 16/11/2022 04:31

I wouldn't want to travel anywhere to attend a first birthday party either. I don't understand why you are even having one- your child won't care about it or remember it. You are making a huge fuss about nothing. Just quietly enjoy the day with your child.

allboysherebutme · 16/11/2022 04:06

Don't ask them to anything again. X

junebirthdaygirl · 16/11/2022 04:03

Jacopo · 16/11/2022 02:33

The birthday was in August. In baby time this is effectively a zombie thread.

Well the birthday was in November so not that old.
Hope all went well.

Koppita · 16/11/2022 02:56

When DD1 turned 1, we tied balloons to her few presents, and met my mum for lunch at a farm cafe. It didn't cross my mind to have a party as such. Our family are very scattered, but it wouldn't cross my mind to think that people didn't care enough just because they don't want to attend a baby's birthday party!

I'm amazed at people taking 1.5 hour train journeys for this. There's no way I would have expected people to do that! It cuts both ways.

Love is love. It shows itself in so many tiny, vital, constant ways. It shouldn't be measured in parties, Instagram likes, or anything like that. If you don't believe that people truly care about your baby because they didn't want to go to a 1st birthday party, then you never believed they cared at all.

Jacopo · 16/11/2022 02:33

The birthday was in August. In baby time this is effectively a zombie thread.

LBFseBrom · 16/11/2022 02:10

It does sound as though a lot of travelling by train etc would be involved which is probably why they are not coming. It's a pity they don't drive.

I don't think a big fuss on first birthday is necessary, frankly; I had a party when mine was two and it was great fun but it was just us and a birthday cake at one year old, quite enough; we took photos. At that stage the party is more for the adults. However that's up to you.

Enjoy yourself anyway and congratulations on your miracle baby.

Cw112 · 16/11/2022 02:08

Could you do two smaller celebrations? I wouldn't plan a big party with lots of people for a 1 year old either. Just a little party in the house is perfectly fine and I'd suggest that if dhs family can't make it up to you do they want to do something near them the weekend after or whatever? Or just leave them to it. I don't think ds will mind as much as you mind even when he's older because they're unlikely to change so he'll grow up just accepting that he's not maybe as close to them. It's harder on you and especially your dh.

Dunnoburt · 16/11/2022 01:57

I can't even really remember what we did for my little ones first birthday 🙉.... but I know grandparent's weren't there ....wouldn't be a biggie for me I'm afraid...... definitely more important as they get older and learn disappointment!!

Fraaahnces · 16/11/2022 01:56

You can’t make people care unfortunately. When they are older and have COPD and/or diabetes, etc… I imagine they will want you & grandkids to drive to visit them in hospital/care homes. You can show them the videos of all the things they missed. Meanwhile, don’t bother driving or sharing.

Liorae · 16/11/2022 01:47

chatterbug22 · 13/08/2022 23:05

I understand why you’d be upset, have they given a reason? A first birthday is special.

It really isn't for anyone except the baby's parents.

HoppingPavlova · 16/11/2022 01:45

I understand our son won’t know now but we film everything for when he’s older, and I definitely will be filming his first birthday and he might ask when he’s older where his dads family is on his special day.

What age do you think your son will want/be forced to sit through these showings? Mine are are young adults and would not have been interested in sitting through shows of their birthdays at any point including the present. Really, the only people this is a big thing for is you and DH, the toddler doesn’t know/care and will likely never want to watch it and being honest first birthdays are not fun for most people so excuses tend to be made accordingly.

Calphurnia88 · 17/08/2022 12:45

EdgeOfACoin · 14/08/2022 07:39

Mumsnet is so weird.

Yes, generally people get together for children's first birthday parties. They are special. Furthermore, first birthday parties are much better for adults than other birthday parties, since they tend to be geared towards grown ups rather than endless rounds of Musical Chairs and Pass the Parcel.

As a general rule, family members like seeing their grandchildren and nieces and nephews. Furthermore, when one party frequently makes an effort to travel to see other members of the family, it is generally considered polite and kind to reciprocate once in a while.

And finally, this is clearly something that matters to the OP. She's provided three months' notice and is evidently looking forward to it. Her family are being extraordinarily selfish and I can understand why she is upset.

Couldn't have put it better.

And for the approx 42 people who've used the MN classic 'it's a party not a summons'... Yes, but it's a party to celebrate the first birthday of their GRANDCHILD, not a token invite to Brenda from work's 50th birthday bash.

Sweetener12 · 15/08/2022 09:34

Well, you definitely should let it go as there is nothing you can do about it. Looks to me, they just don't want to come, otherwise why say you can't make it in November while it's still August? Confused Hope they will be polite enough to acknowledge the birthday at least in a form of a phone call/smartshow 3d video card, but if not, it's their choice. Have a lovely party with those who actually want to be there for you and the baby, don't stress about those who dont.

Swipe left for the next trending thread