Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comedians defending Jerry Sadowitz

467 replies

FenlandFuckwit · 13/08/2022 20:37

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-62533592

His latest gig has been cancelled after he told racist jokes and got his dick out. Why are other comedians defending his right to do this? This behaviour is not ok, AIBU to think this is indecent and disgusting behaviour and the venue were correct in cancelling him.

OP posts:
Floisme · 15/08/2022 17:46

Warren Mitchell used to tell stories about bigots coming up to him and hailing him as a hero who was telling it like it was. He told them as if they were hilarious stories showing how the stupid racist had been fooled and he never seemed to understand why this wasn't a good thing.
That's not how I remember it at all. I may be wrong but, from what I can recall, both Mitchell and Johnny Speight stood by their work but also talked about how uncomfortable they felt when that kind of thing happened and didn't have any easy answers.
The difference for me is that, as I remember, 'Till Death do us Part' was screened before the watershed - I'm not even sure the watershed existed then. I can see the problem with that but I don't think it's the same thing as an all adult theatre show where there are warnings about the content.
I agree that this shouldn't be a mainstream show and, from what I've read, Sadowitz is very careful to control content e.g. not to release it onto You Tube.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 17:45

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 17:36

But it doesn’t, so that’d be silly.

You don't think an exposed penis counts as nudity?

oviraptor21 · 15/08/2022 17:42

As @hotdiggetydog was there, maybe they can clear up whether there were any references that might be considered transphobic in the show?

Saucery · 15/08/2022 17:41

Also, from what I’ve heard about it, I wouldn’t book tickets for Shannon Matthews:The Musical (another thread running about this). Wouldn’t want it shut down, though, because some people do want to see it.
I have a friend who went to see Chubby Brown in Blackpool. I would honestly rather jump off the North Pier than go inside the building and see him. Boys in my 6th Form used to put his live show recordings on the communal record player and it was horrible and oppressive. I don’t know why the staff didn’t step in tbh, but the early 80s was prime era for his sort of comedy. I still don’t think he should be cancelled either and the line between “character saying offensive things to reflect back the audience’s prejudices “ is much more hazy than Sadowitz’s imo.

BaronMunchausen · 15/08/2022 17:39

It seems unlikely that JS broke off from his comedy act to seriously call Sunak a p* - and more probable that he was satirising the attitudes of others, including the racist Tory members who "aren't ready for a brown one".

Re Graham Linehan - it also seems unlikely that the theatre trust would have omitted transphobia from the list of alleged sins, had it been a factor in the cancellation.

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 17:36

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 17:35

Then the show page should mention that it might contain nudity. Period.

But it doesn’t, so that’d be silly.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 17:35

Then the show page should mention that it might contain nudity. Period.

Saucery · 15/08/2022 17:34

I don’t want to see animals killed so I don’t work in an abbatoir.
I don’t want to deal with teeth so I’m not a dental nurse.
I’m needlephobic so I don’t work as a phlebotomist.
I don’t want to work with the public behaving at their worst so I’m not a police officer.
I get claustrophobic in breathing apparatus so I don’t work in the frontline of the fire service.

Get the gist?

MrsTerryPratchett · 15/08/2022 17:29

But what about staff? They dont get a choice in what they hear. Should you have to listen to Frankie Boyle night after night whilst on minimum wage? That is trickier.

I can't watch certain films because of violence. I don't work in a cinema.

I have worked for social services so heard and saw some things but would give an average person PTSD.

If you work in the arts, you are going to see some edgy things. You either want the job or not, with the attendant issues.

OneTC · 15/08/2022 17:28

cariadlet · 15/08/2022 17:15

The character of Alf Garnett was supposed to be racist. Neither the writer nor the actor who played him were racist. Quite the opposite.

The audience was supposed to laugh AT him. Unfortunately, many people watching at home were racist and laughed WITH him. Children would go into school the next day and use the character's racist comments to racially abuse their classmates.

The intention was good, the results weren't.

People really struggle with this as a concept. Catherine Tate trod a very similar line with some of her characters and it's uncomfortable knowing that a significant portion of people watching are laughing for different reasons

CredibilityProblem · 15/08/2022 17:28

Warren Mitchell used to tell stories about bigots coming up to him and hailing him as a hero who was telling it like it was. He told them as if they were hilarious stories showing how the stupid racist had been fooled and he never seemed to understand why this wasn't a good thing.

It's a no win situation tbh: if you make your satire obvious enough that even the dimmest racist can't think that their views are being validated on prime time TV then it's never going to be the sophisticated political comedy your friends would value.

And this is why Sadowitz couldn't and shouldn't go mainstream and I think an influx of "anti-snowflakes" to his shows can only end in tears one way or another.

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 17:26

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 16:25

Sounds like Alf Garnett.
Say racist stuff and claim it is against the racism.

Well yes. It takes quite a special kind of person to think that 12 Years a Slave was condoning slavery.

SheeWeee · 15/08/2022 17:25

Office247 · 15/08/2022 16:07

forgive me because I can see the majority think it’s unreasonable that his show has been cancelled, and I’m trying to understand hence me reading here.

I just don’t see the point in a man whipping his dick out like this. It seems completely unnecessary, regardless of any warnings. I’m sure there’s plenty the guy can do for laughs that doesn’t resort to this. It’s a bit grim. I don’t think being a comedian or being part of a Fringe show is a free pass - unless the theme is literally nudity, then there is the risk of random tourists just grabbing tickets to shows without being fully informed. The strip clubs up the road have stricter restrictions. I’m actually surprised it’s been accepted for this man do do this for decades.

Ok so you don't see the point, you don't like the sound of it, you're surprised its a thing.

That's all fine, but what makes you think your opinion has any relevance to anyone but you? You don't like the sound of it, so don't book a ticket. Don't go. Why would you or anyone else think your dislike of it means that it shouldn't exist at all?

cariadlet · 15/08/2022 17:15

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 16:25

Sounds like Alf Garnett.
Say racist stuff and claim it is against the racism.

The character of Alf Garnett was supposed to be racist. Neither the writer nor the actor who played him were racist. Quite the opposite.

The audience was supposed to laugh AT him. Unfortunately, many people watching at home were racist and laughed WITH him. Children would go into school the next day and use the character's racist comments to racially abuse their classmates.

The intention was good, the results weren't.

GrabbyGabby · 15/08/2022 17:10

Office247 · 15/08/2022 16:07

forgive me because I can see the majority think it’s unreasonable that his show has been cancelled, and I’m trying to understand hence me reading here.

I just don’t see the point in a man whipping his dick out like this. It seems completely unnecessary, regardless of any warnings. I’m sure there’s plenty the guy can do for laughs that doesn’t resort to this. It’s a bit grim. I don’t think being a comedian or being part of a Fringe show is a free pass - unless the theme is literally nudity, then there is the risk of random tourists just grabbing tickets to shows without being fully informed. The strip clubs up the road have stricter restrictions. I’m actually surprised it’s been accepted for this man do do this for decades.

Knob gags are usually shite. But in one of his shows, he does a sketch about being at the self service tills in tesco, and it keeps beeping "unexpected item in the packing area" So he says "Ill give you unexpected" and he lobs his knob out.

That is a worthy knob gag.

Finding this debate so interesting. Agree, offensive comedy should have its place, and come with the appropriate warnings, so people can vote with their feet.

But what about staff? They dont get a choice in what they hear. Should you have to listen to Frankie Boyle night after night whilst on minimum wage? That is trickier.

I suspect this will go all The Crucible, with staff at venues across the city feeling unsafe and demanding the witches are burnt.

Then when the festival is utterly bland and ticket sales have tanked someone with a bit of sense will tell them to wind their necks in.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 17:05

CatsandFish · 15/08/2022 14:41

@JemimaPuddlegoose 'anti-trans', or, pro-women? It's so easy to label everyone who is pro-womens human rights as 'anti-trans'. In fact, it says so much that being pro womens human rights is now anti-trans. That should tell you something, if you really think about it.

This is exactly my point, there's a huge difference between being "pro women" and being "anti-trans." I'm very, very concerned that you're twisting what I said, which is that people who are actively anti-women's rights are using the fact that they are also anti-trans to pretend they somehow pro-women when they are not.

Think of all the far right wing politicians who want to ban abortion, treat women who have miscarriages or stillbirths as potential criminals, outlaw essential epilepsy medication because it could hypothetically be used to induce an abortion, ban birth control. Even certain male politicians who have been accused of rape and wife beating have been given the "gender critwashing" treatment. People with a right wing agenda and people who hate women and want to steal our rights are exploiting us GC women's legitimate concerns over gender ID as a way of making deeply misogynistic beliefs and political policies that actively hurt or could kill women more palatable, and try to brainwash us into supporting men who hate us and want to reduce us to chattel on the grounds "at least they know what a woman is."

NO. I will never ever support a rapist, a wife-beater, or someone who wants to ban abortion, just because they're against self-ID. I will never ever stop standing up against the gaslighting and attempts to convince GC women that we should support abusive misogynistic men.

This Jerry Sadowitz thing is an excellent example. By all accounts he went out of his way to not make any jokes about trans people, trans people are apparently the ONLY group he didn't target (why oh why do so-called "edgy" comedians treat trans people as some special group on a pedestal?) There's not a single report, review, tweet anywhere that says his act even mentions trans people; I've seen tweets and reviews from people who attended the show confirming that he doesn't mention trans people once in his act; and "transphobia" is suspiciously missing from the list of things he's accused of, which is weird since everyone and their aunt gets accused of transphobia nowadays.

Female audience members have been harassed and subject to verbal abuse and even groping by fellow audience members (I have a friend who went to see one of his shows, and he directed a stream of racial slurs to her directly when she was the only non-white person in the audience). The audience are encouraged to get wasted. You really think an audience of drunk rowdy blokes who have been ramped up and egged on to think that women are just holes are going to understand the difference between "ironic racism" (or "satirical misogyny") and actual racism/misogyny?

The content warning says this: “strong language and themes some may find distressing." Where in that warning does it say "you might be called a racial slur and have a dick shoved in your face"?

AlexandriasWindmill · 15/08/2022 16:46

I think the point about films showing racism or violence or nudity was related to safe feeling unsafe. If racism/violence/nudity are depicted in art in any form does it make staff 'unsafe'? They are at no more practical or physical risk from a film depiction than a theatre depiction than a comedy performance.

So the risk they're referring to must be emotional? In which case, where are the limits. Is it fine when it has a multi-billion dollar Hollywood industry behind it but not when it's a fringe show? Is it funding that makes it more 'safe'? Is it the politics of consumerism that denotes risk?

With the caveat that no-one has to work in a theatre (movie or traditional) and everyone has the right to determine their own level of risk and act accordingly.

Censorship is always political. Doesn't matter how you dress it up, trying to restrict creative freedom whether attacking authors, poets, dancers, artists or comedians - is a right-wing position. As someone put it during the week, discussing Rushdie, now people are trying to create a culture where we've internalised the fatwa - where publishers, theatres, agents, etc, are supposed to bow to pressure and be silent rather than risk offence. That is terrifying.

SerendipityJane · 15/08/2022 16:32

Say racist stuff and claim it is against the racism.

That way you can play both sides of the room ... (courtesy S. Lee) ...

Scianel · 15/08/2022 16:30

antelopevalley have you been to a JS show, out of interest?

Floisme · 15/08/2022 16:28

I think that’s totally fair
🙂

antelopevalley · 15/08/2022 16:25

Scianel · 15/08/2022 16:12

12 Years a Slave was not - come and laugh at the racism

Nor was this show. It was come and laugh at the racists.

I just don’t see the point in a man whipping his dick out like this

Then it's not the show for you, and that's fine. There are plenty of stage productions and films that have full frontal male nudity. The performer clearly feels that exposing himself adds to his show and is in context.
People - adults - really do need to take a bit of responsibility. It's the Fringe, it's an 18+ show as many are, the tickets warn of the nudity.

It's all starting to remind me of that poor sodding walrus who was put down because people were too stupid to stay away from it.

Sounds like Alf Garnett.
Say racist stuff and claim it is against the racism.

Office247 · 15/08/2022 16:23

Floisme · 15/08/2022 16:16

I find it a bit of a stretch to imagine even the most random tourist buying a ticket for that particular show without having any inkling of they were about to see. But if that were the case, then I think they'd be entitled to ask for and get a refund. What I don't think they're entitled to do is to prevent other adults from seeing the show because they couldn't be bothered to check.

I think that’s totally fair

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 16:23

Office247 · 15/08/2022 16:07

forgive me because I can see the majority think it’s unreasonable that his show has been cancelled, and I’m trying to understand hence me reading here.

I just don’t see the point in a man whipping his dick out like this. It seems completely unnecessary, regardless of any warnings. I’m sure there’s plenty the guy can do for laughs that doesn’t resort to this. It’s a bit grim. I don’t think being a comedian or being part of a Fringe show is a free pass - unless the theme is literally nudity, then there is the risk of random tourists just grabbing tickets to shows without being fully informed. The strip clubs up the road have stricter restrictions. I’m actually surprised it’s been accepted for this man do do this for decades.

I’m not sure if you know, but there are shows where women show off quite a lot too.

Mainly though, what has whether it’s necessary got to do with banning it?

RoseAndRose · 15/08/2022 16:23

CredibilityProblem · 15/08/2022 16:12

No of course not, but the PP said you wouldn't get extreme racism passed by the BBFC, and of course you would....in a context which clearly condemns it.

I agree that racism can be shown, and 12 Years a Slave was passed with no cuts, though caveated for strong violence, injury detail, sex, nudity and racist terms

Other films have cuts made for extreme racism: BBFC’s statement when explaining the certification for Love + Hate: “Works which actively encourage and endorse racist attitudes and behaviour have been placed at the adult category, cut or rejected in the past”. but, as in this case, they can stand when the film as a whole shows adequate mitigation.

I think what counts as “extreme” might be the crux here.

And of course a BBFC approved film, which contains adequate mitigation (both in story arc and in cuts to the most excessive passages) does not compare to quick-fire live sets

Fancydancer1934 · 15/08/2022 16:22

PlanetNormal · 14/08/2022 11:20

It’s Jerry Sadowitz, FFS. Everyone who knows anything about comedy is well aware that he has been offending censorious pearl-clutchers for decades. That’s his act. It always has been. Those of delicate sensibilities can avoid being offended by the simple strategy of not buying a ticket for his show and going to see Michael fucking Macintyre instead.

This country is going backwards on issues of free speech and decades of anti censorship progress are being reversed. This climate ends in books being burned and septuagenarian authors being stabbed on stage at literary festivals by religious nutters.

Hear hear! A voice of reason amongst the faux offended brigade.