Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comedians defending Jerry Sadowitz

467 replies

FenlandFuckwit · 13/08/2022 20:37

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-62533592

His latest gig has been cancelled after he told racist jokes and got his dick out. Why are other comedians defending his right to do this? This behaviour is not ok, AIBU to think this is indecent and disgusting behaviour and the venue were correct in cancelling him.

OP posts:
Floisme · 15/08/2022 18:54

No I've not been before but, given the reputation the Fringe has for edginess and how much the whole shebang costs, hell yes, I'd do as much research as I could and, if I didn't, I think that would be on me.

If the issue is that venue didn't provide sufficient information to anyone who did do some research - it's not clear to me whether they did or not - then yes, that's a fault and I think they should have rectified it and offered a refund to anyone who had bought a ticket unawares. I don't see it as a reason to cancel the show.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 18:51

The Pleasance didn't mention any complaints about indecent exposure or nudity when they contacted JS to tell him his show was cancelled.

Every single press report has mentioned the exposed penis as (one of) the reasons the show was cancelled.

Audience members are directly quoted in several of these press articles.

JS' own statement confirms that he exposed his penis.

balalake · 15/08/2022 18:50

I was very surprised that Jerry Sadowitz was even booked to perform there in the first place.

BoredofthisCrap7 · 15/08/2022 18:48

"That is literally what the entire incident behind this thread is about: that a SPECIFIC female audience member complained about JS shoving his naked penis in his thread. Other audience members have confirmed it. Plenty of press coverage have included this detail, and JS does not deny exposing his penis to her."

Nope.
What's her name?
I've seen countless other threads on as many forums saying it was NOT about the nudity, that STAFF members were the ones to complain.
Why is your information better than theirs?
Where did other audience members confirm it?
Press coverage may have included this detail, it doesn't mean its true and that they have not all just jumped on and re-reported the original story.

JS does not deny exposing his penis, but he does not say he "shoved it" in anyone's literal face.
Not sure what "shoving his naked penis in his thread" means?

AlexandriasWindmill · 15/08/2022 18:47

The Pleasance didn't mention any complaints about indecent exposure or nudity when they contacted JS to tell him his show was cancelled.

The Fringe has never once run a programme where every show is for every person. That's anathema to its reason d'etre. It's also why lots of locals decamp during the Fringe rather than going to see stuff (the money from renting out apartments helps too).

All the large comedy venues are being pressured to cancel comedians and shows. But the others are resisting so far. This isn't just about JS. It's much bigger than one person and one show. That's why comedians are being so vocal about it.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 18:47

Floisme · 15/08/2022 18:37

Damn right I'd do some research first if I were going to a festival that cost insane amounts of money and that had a reputation for edginess and rule breaking.

If the venue gave insufficient warning - and there seems to be disagreement over that so I can't tell from this thread - then that's a fault in my opinion, and one that the venue should correct, e.g. re-issuing more comprehensive information, offering refunds to anyone who was not aware of what they were going to see. It still doesn't justify their banning the show.

The "research" is visiting the edfringe.com website, which contains comprehensive event description and content warnings submitted by each act.

Acts are explicitly told that they MUST include any and all relevant content warning in the information they upload.

Again: the information is submitted by THE ACTS THEMSELVES (or their team); the Edfringe.com web staff simply copy and paste it into the live website.

On a typical EdFringe visit you see perhaps half a dozen, perhaps as many as 10 shows a day. It's completely ludicrous to expect people to diligently painstakingly research that number of shows (and painstakingly watch every youtube video) just in case an act has deliberately lied (by omission) in the listing page they submitted.

People have clearly never been to Edinburgh before.

Floisme · 15/08/2022 18:47

Who is your latest post addressed at Jemima?

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 18:42

It's very telling that the MRA trolls have launched a concerted and what appears to be coordinated attack on any woman who pushes back on male entitlement, or who supports women's rights.

Sorry, not going to let you derail the thread by attacking women.

If you have specific information about a specific woman who had a penis actually shoved in her face

That is literally what the entire incident behind this thread is about: that a SPECIFIC female audience member complained about JS shoving his naked penis in his thread. Other audience members have confirmed it. Plenty of press coverage have included this detail, and JS does not deny exposing his penis to her.

*His own promotional video says he'll get his dick out - your complaint there appears to be with the Fringe website who failed to mention this?
The tour also appears to be called 'Not For Anyone'. Sadowitz appears to have done his job in flagging the unsuitability of the content."

So you expect women to go to the individual website of every act they see, and watch every single video on that website? You think that's a reasonable thing to expect?

Why did JS refuse to include "may contain nudity" in the show listing description HE submitted?? Edfringe has no involvement in what info the many thousands of acts they host choose to submit or not submit in their event listing.

*No, it counts as exposing his penis."

"Exposing your penis doesn't count as nudity" takes the absolute fucking biscuit of all the MRA shite I've read online.

Floisme · 15/08/2022 18:37

Damn right I'd do some research first if I were going to a festival that cost insane amounts of money and that had a reputation for edginess and rule breaking.

If the venue gave insufficient warning - and there seems to be disagreement over that so I can't tell from this thread - then that's a fault in my opinion, and one that the venue should correct, e.g. re-issuing more comprehensive information, offering refunds to anyone who was not aware of what they were going to see. It still doesn't justify their banning the show.

noblegiraffe · 15/08/2022 18:31

Not a single word about nudity or potential nudity, and the only content warning is this: "This show contains strong language and themes some may find distressing" which hardly gives an accurate description. I don't see any "VERY OFFENSIVE" anywhere there, do you? No.

His own promotional video says he'll get his dick out - your complaint there appears to be with the Fringe website who failed to mention this?

The tour also appears to be called 'Not For Anyone'. Sadowitz appears to have done his job in flagging the unsuitability of the content.

BoredofthisCrap7 · 15/08/2022 18:30

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 18:23

That is simply untrue and how fucking dare you accuse the women in question of being liars.

The actual show listings page is right here: tickets.edfringe.com/whats-on/jerry-sadowitz-not-for-anyone

Not a single word about nudity or potential nudity, and the only content warning is this: "This show contains strong language and themes some may find distressing" which hardly gives an accurate description. I don't see any "VERY OFFENSIVE" anywhere there, do you? No.

Oh and I can't even watch the video you've linked, as it comes up with an error message saying "this video is restricted and can only be watched on YouTube."

It's totally beyond the pale to suggest that women should take on the responsibility of thoroughly researching every act they see ahead of time (in Edinburgh, where it's the norm to see ten shows a day), just on the off-chance that there's nudity that the act refused to mention in the show description or content warning, even though that's literally what the content warning is for.

That's all in your own head unfortunately.
I didn't accuse anyone of anything.
Or suggest anyone research anything.

If you have specific information about a specific woman who had a penis actually shoved in her face, I'm sure we'd all love to see it, and not a second hand story on a forum.

You seem to have a lot of info no-one else has access to.

MarmadukeSpillageEsquire · 15/08/2022 18:28

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 14:00

Yes, I understand that one. You got your head around the hooves one yet?

Clip clop!

Comedians defending Jerry Sadowitz
AlexandriasWindmill · 15/08/2022 18:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ResisterRex · 15/08/2022 18:27

it comes up with an error message saying "this video is restricted and can only be watched on YouTube."

Gosh if only there were internet-enabled apps to help.

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 18:26

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 18:23

That is simply untrue and how fucking dare you accuse the women in question of being liars.

The actual show listings page is right here: tickets.edfringe.com/whats-on/jerry-sadowitz-not-for-anyone

Not a single word about nudity or potential nudity, and the only content warning is this: "This show contains strong language and themes some may find distressing" which hardly gives an accurate description. I don't see any "VERY OFFENSIVE" anywhere there, do you? No.

Oh and I can't even watch the video you've linked, as it comes up with an error message saying "this video is restricted and can only be watched on YouTube."

It's totally beyond the pale to suggest that women should take on the responsibility of thoroughly researching every act they see ahead of time (in Edinburgh, where it's the norm to see ten shows a day), just on the off-chance that there's nudity that the act refused to mention in the show description or content warning, even though that's literally what the content warning is for.

BoredofthisCrap7 · 15/08/2022 18:12

He doesn't "shove his dick" in anyone's face.
That's hyperbole of the highest order.

Also, he DOES say he will get his penis out, in his OWN video promotion of the tour.

Again. This is an act that has been running for nearly four decades. He has done it since the very beginning. I saw him nearly 30 years ago and he was doing it then.

The show is labelled as VERY OFFENSIVE with strong themes that people may find distressing.

Don't book a damn ticket if you are of a sensitive nature.
Simple.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 15/08/2022 18:07

If the fringe fails to stage the random, the chaotic, the crass, the weird, the edgy it's no longer the fringe.

I've worked Edinburgh Fringe several times. I've seen a million shows there. One of my best friends is one of the heads of programming.

Exposing your penis without warning and calling people racial slurs is not "random, chaotic, weird and edgy."

Floisme · 15/08/2022 18:03

CredibilityProblem · 15/08/2022 17:55

I'm sure I remember Warren Mitchell telling that story the light hearted way floisme, but it was a long time ago and of course it's possible he told it both ways over time depending on context.

Yes that's possible. It was a long time ago and probably pre-Internet so can't be checked but my impression was that he was a very thoughtful guy who was proud of his role but acknowledged the discomfort and the risk. Or maybe he changed his mind.

hotdiggetydog · 15/08/2022 18:03

oviraptor21 · 15/08/2022 17:42

As @hotdiggetydog was there, maybe they can clear up whether there were any references that might be considered transphobic in the show?

Absolutely everyone and everything was fair game to be honest. He wasn't discriminatory in that sense.

Bouledeneige · 15/08/2022 17:59

The Pleasance knew exactly who they were booking and knew everything about his act - he's been playing Edinburgh for ever. And the Pleasance is a bastion of the festival - in many ways it's the symbol of the fringe (which was always counter cultural, anarchic and anti high art). Its impossible to imagine that they've suddenly discovered he's offensive to some people. It's on them that they decided to cancel the show and completely understandable that comedians would hate it. It makes a mockery of the whole festival and its ethos that suddenly acts can be pulled after a few complaints. If the fringe fails to stage the random, the chaotic, the crass, the weird, the edgy it's no longer the fringe.

Scianel · 15/08/2022 17:57

JemimaPuddlegoose I have seen Sadowitz live and nothing like that happened. Most of the audience got it just fine. There was one group of guys that were laughing for the wrong reasons and they massively stood out as the minority. And no-one groped anyone, we were seated in a theatre.

CredibilityProblem · 15/08/2022 17:55

I'm sure I remember Warren Mitchell telling that story the light hearted way floisme, but it was a long time ago and of course it's possible he told it both ways over time depending on context.

ResisterRex · 15/08/2022 17:55

One of the comedians who was on the Andrew Doyle show last night discussing this, has said:

twitter.com/leokearse/status/1559130847101460480?s=21&t=8pHdhcfwxBvJnBqGLkt0WQ

"I was supposed to discuss Jerry Sadowitz's cancellation from the Edinburgh Fringe on BBC Scotland this morning but they decided just DISCUSSING the issue would contravene their hate speech rules.
Hate speech rules aren't there to help us. They exist to silence us."

So not only do we have no confirmation as to what was said, now the country's broadcaster won't even discuss it.

Scianel · 15/08/2022 17:54

But what about staff? They dont get a choice in what they hear. Should you have to listen to Frankie Boyle night after night whilst on minimum wage? That is trickier

It's not tricky at all. If you are a vegan you can't expect to go and work in an abbatoir and demand that they cease slaughtering animals. If you're scared of heights you can't work as a rigger and insist on not going above the ground. If you're short, plain and dumpy you can't insist that an agency hires you as a model (although some people seem to find even that a problem now). If you have a medical condition that doesn't allow you to drive, you can't work as a truck driver.
And so on. Where did this idea come from that anyone is entitled to any job and that the company must make the necessary adjustments? It doesn't work like that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread