Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comedians defending Jerry Sadowitz

467 replies

FenlandFuckwit · 13/08/2022 20:37

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-62533592

His latest gig has been cancelled after he told racist jokes and got his dick out. Why are other comedians defending his right to do this? This behaviour is not ok, AIBU to think this is indecent and disgusting behaviour and the venue were correct in cancelling him.

OP posts:
LovinglifeAF · 17/08/2022 09:23

I’d be surprised if it was that joke either; undoubtedly offensive as it is. Did the statement from the Pleasance mention ableism?

SmallPiecesOfGlitterAreSomehowEverywhere · 17/08/2022 09:12

RoseAndRose · 17/08/2022 08:30

Well that lame joke doesn’t cause trouble. It’s not particularly funny or though-provoking for starters, and I find it hard to believe that’s the one.

Also interested to note that pp felt the need to add an asterisk to the word ‘spastic’ - Scope did not rename from The Spastic Society until 1994, so it’s a not such a perjorative term for those of us who were beyond the playground by then.

it’s a not such a perjorative term for those of us who were beyond the playground by then.

I beg to differ.

SequinsandStilettos · 17/08/2022 09:06

I shall rephrase. The asterix is used because that word along with its diminutives is considered disablist, precisely because in the preceding years (pre 94) it was being used as a playground slur. Kids, who have picked it up from their parents, still use it. Lizzo and Beyonce were criticised for using a diminutive, as they were unaware the word is a slur in the UK.

BagelwithPhiladelphiaz · 17/08/2022 09:04

vera99 · 16/08/2022 20:22

The Tories make me feel fucking unsafe - the sooner we cancel them the better.

😂

FrancescaContini · 17/08/2022 09:02

picklemewalnuts · 17/08/2022 08:18

Prophets, jesters, fools, were traditionally people who speak truth to power. People who say the unsayable.
People who challenge and subvert the official story.
It's uncomfortable and unpleasant to be around. They cause trouble.

Jerry fits neatly in that category.

This is an excellent point - thank you for making it.

FrancescaContini · 17/08/2022 09:01

SheeWeee · 16/08/2022 14:37

But literally any show can make anyone feel "unsafe" (can they not simply be upset anymore?) for any reason, so by that logic we need to cancel literally everything. Even the bullshit with the therapist.

Quite. One woman’s meat is another woman’s poison etc…

SequinsandStilettos · 17/08/2022 09:00

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

vera99 · 17/08/2022 08:39

This reply has been hidden

This reply has been hidden until the MNHQ team can have a look at it.

RoseAndRose · 17/08/2022 08:30

Well that lame joke doesn’t cause trouble. It’s not particularly funny or though-provoking for starters, and I find it hard to believe that’s the one.

Also interested to note that pp felt the need to add an asterisk to the word ‘spastic’ - Scope did not rename from The Spastic Society until 1994, so it’s a not such a perjorative term for those of us who were beyond the playground by then.

picklemewalnuts · 17/08/2022 08:18

Prophets, jesters, fools, were traditionally people who speak truth to power. People who say the unsayable.
People who challenge and subvert the official story.
It's uncomfortable and unpleasant to be around. They cause trouble.

Jerry fits neatly in that category.

Saucery · 17/08/2022 08:18

So that’s the joke from his night at The Pleasance? Offensive, undoubtedly. But not any different from the rest of his set. If I went to his show, I’d expect exactly that sort of thing (which is why I wouldn’t go to his show, although I might have done when I was younger). It’s a very retro joke too. There used to be books you could buy ‘100 Jokes About Dead Babies’, where that sort of thing was passed around at school. Pre social media, of course.
It’s a case of reflecting on yourself and your values when you listen to that sort of material. You really check your thinking when you laugh along at a set and then BAM, something comes up on a subject that hits you personally. I experienced that when I went to see Frankie Boyle. That’s what a decent offensive comedian should do - and early on, FB was good at it, not so much now.
Some of Ricky Gervais’s stuff makes me squirm. It’s meant to and choosing to watch it means you sign up for that particular flavour of offence.
Now, if that material hit home to an individual and it’s their personal line they don’t want crossing then I do sympathise to an extent. Especially if it was a member of staff who couldn’t walk out. However, that is their job and the venue’s responsibility is to staff that show with people who can deal with it.

picklemewalnuts · 17/08/2022 08:17

To be fair with that flag business- I'm not a fan of LF- the whole sharp lines and angles of that flag, and the overkill flagging up of that london street, was reminiscent of something really scary.

It was like a scene from a dystopian movie, without anyone messing with it at all. I actually assumed it was photoshopped at first. LF was making explicit something I was subconsciously uncomfortable about.

CredibilityProblem · 17/08/2022 07:56

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/08/2022 01:51

GC but also Jewish and disagree with using the Swastika as a GC symbol

i must have missed this one? WTF?

Laurence Fox posted a "witty" remake of the Pride flag into swastika form.

vera99 · 17/08/2022 07:44

His 'joke' apparently is;

Q: "How do you crucify a sp*stic?" A: "On a swastika."

The liberal in me trying to justify that is

a) he is Jewish b) he wants the racists in the audience to laugh c) there is an implied callback to the fact that the Nazis exterminated disabled people along with minorities and the Jews. d) figuratively it invoked an awful picture that it could be true and makes us imagine that horrific preposition e) he wishes to use taboo language to break boundaries, establish his otherness and status as an outsider f) he personally thinks it funny. as a 'straight' simple "joke".

Who knows what goes on inside his head - he has eschewed fame and fortune for just making do and from comments, I have read elsewhere pushes friends and people away from him so cuts a lonely figure but is very pleasant by all accounts on one to ones.

I would no longer go to see him not least at 61 most comedians are no longer funny just blathering about shit and I would rather avoid an uneasy hour in a darkened room watching him work out his demons. In earlier centuries it would be like going to lunatic asylums to laugh at the inmates.

ResisterRex · 17/08/2022 06:27

This thread is a dumpster fire.

Do you mean this one, or the FWR one where you made similarly weak and unpersuasive points that lacked evidence and with which people disagreed?

MrsTerryPratchett · 17/08/2022 01:51

GC but also Jewish and disagree with using the Swastika as a GC symbol

i must have missed this one? WTF?

MarmadukeSpillageEsquire · 17/08/2022 01:30

JemimaPuddlegoose · 17/08/2022 00:05

This thread is a dumpster fire.

Implying child rape victims with PTSD are entirely to blame and stupid and oversensitive if they get upset at seeing an exposed penis without warning.

Black women who dislike being called n***r are responsible for dystopian levels of censorship and need to be relentlessly attacked in order to silence them.

Mocking those with PTSD.

Referring to anyone who objects to racism as "the terminally offended".

People who take the time to diligently research and read the show listing and content warning being attacked as being babies with lies about them refusing to take responsibility, because they should have psychically guessed that Jerry gave inaccurate show description and in refusing to provide the content warnings he was asked for. Because women are always responsible for male behaviour!

Meanwhile any stage show, TV series or book that features drag queens, any opinion about gender that differs from the One Accepted Opinion, anything about race or critical race theory, gets attacked and smeared. Anyone who defends those shows or books gets a hundred personally abusive comments and basically a pile-on with the aim of bullying them into silence. Remember, personal opinion is banned on Mumsnet! All wrongthink will be punished!!

You have to hold the "right" opinions about drag (bad and evil), gender (nonsense), racism (doesn't exist) banning racism (evil censorship) and if you differ from the Correct Ideology, or if you're found to be not Ideologically Pure enough, you're BAD and WRONG.

Even other gender critical posters are attacked and bullied into silence if they're found to be not ideologically pure enough (for example, if you're GC but don't mind adult drag shows, or GC but also Jewish and disagree with using the Swastika as a GC symbol. Sorry those are wrongthink!)

And the same posters who try their level best to bully anyone with a different opinion from them, are the ones claiming to be anti-censorship! So it's fine to relentlessly attack and bully anyone found guilty of wrongthink, but if someone says they personally find the N word unacceptable, or suggest that comedians should mention if their shows contain nudity, and there are howls of outrage and accusations of censorship. Simply for having an opinion that differs from your own.

Is being offended a threat to our safety these days?

Yeah, we see you. I know exactly what you're playing at in attempting to reframe black women who object to racial slurs, or women who object to misogynistic abuse, as "terminally offended" and over sensitive.

More dog whistles than Crufts this thread.

👏👏👏👏

LovinglifeAF · 17/08/2022 00:39

GinnyJelly · 17/08/2022 00:30

Thanks for posting, I didn’t think it was particularly funny, the only positive thing I would say is that I love his accent. I guess this wasn’t the routine that got him cancelled so still can’t say if he deserved that still.

It wasn’t to my taste either. But, I’d never support it being censored.

LovinglifeAF · 17/08/2022 00:38

JemimaPuddlegoose · 17/08/2022 00:05

This thread is a dumpster fire.

Implying child rape victims with PTSD are entirely to blame and stupid and oversensitive if they get upset at seeing an exposed penis without warning.

Black women who dislike being called n***r are responsible for dystopian levels of censorship and need to be relentlessly attacked in order to silence them.

Mocking those with PTSD.

Referring to anyone who objects to racism as "the terminally offended".

People who take the time to diligently research and read the show listing and content warning being attacked as being babies with lies about them refusing to take responsibility, because they should have psychically guessed that Jerry gave inaccurate show description and in refusing to provide the content warnings he was asked for. Because women are always responsible for male behaviour!

Meanwhile any stage show, TV series or book that features drag queens, any opinion about gender that differs from the One Accepted Opinion, anything about race or critical race theory, gets attacked and smeared. Anyone who defends those shows or books gets a hundred personally abusive comments and basically a pile-on with the aim of bullying them into silence. Remember, personal opinion is banned on Mumsnet! All wrongthink will be punished!!

You have to hold the "right" opinions about drag (bad and evil), gender (nonsense), racism (doesn't exist) banning racism (evil censorship) and if you differ from the Correct Ideology, or if you're found to be not Ideologically Pure enough, you're BAD and WRONG.

Even other gender critical posters are attacked and bullied into silence if they're found to be not ideologically pure enough (for example, if you're GC but don't mind adult drag shows, or GC but also Jewish and disagree with using the Swastika as a GC symbol. Sorry those are wrongthink!)

And the same posters who try their level best to bully anyone with a different opinion from them, are the ones claiming to be anti-censorship! So it's fine to relentlessly attack and bully anyone found guilty of wrongthink, but if someone says they personally find the N word unacceptable, or suggest that comedians should mention if their shows contain nudity, and there are howls of outrage and accusations of censorship. Simply for having an opinion that differs from your own.

Is being offended a threat to our safety these days?

Yeah, we see you. I know exactly what you're playing at in attempting to reframe black women who object to racial slurs, or women who object to misogynistic abuse, as "terminally offended" and over sensitive.

More dog whistles than Crufts this thread.

are you quite well?

GinnyJelly · 17/08/2022 00:30

Thanks for posting, I didn’t think it was particularly funny, the only positive thing I would say is that I love his accent. I guess this wasn’t the routine that got him cancelled so still can’t say if he deserved that still.

JemimaPuddlegoose · 17/08/2022 00:05

beastlyslumber · 16/08/2022 14:01

If you're someone likely to be triggered by certain jokes or references, surely you account for that in the kinds of shows you decide to go and see?

Adults need to take responsibility for themselves. The idea that a show needs an on-site therapist to make everyone feel safe is so fucking Brave New World it terrifies me.

This thread is a dumpster fire.

Implying child rape victims with PTSD are entirely to blame and stupid and oversensitive if they get upset at seeing an exposed penis without warning.

Black women who dislike being called n***r are responsible for dystopian levels of censorship and need to be relentlessly attacked in order to silence them.

Mocking those with PTSD.

Referring to anyone who objects to racism as "the terminally offended".

People who take the time to diligently research and read the show listing and content warning being attacked as being babies with lies about them refusing to take responsibility, because they should have psychically guessed that Jerry gave inaccurate show description and in refusing to provide the content warnings he was asked for. Because women are always responsible for male behaviour!

Meanwhile any stage show, TV series or book that features drag queens, any opinion about gender that differs from the One Accepted Opinion, anything about race or critical race theory, gets attacked and smeared. Anyone who defends those shows or books gets a hundred personally abusive comments and basically a pile-on with the aim of bullying them into silence. Remember, personal opinion is banned on Mumsnet! All wrongthink will be punished!!

You have to hold the "right" opinions about drag (bad and evil), gender (nonsense), racism (doesn't exist) banning racism (evil censorship) and if you differ from the Correct Ideology, or if you're found to be not Ideologically Pure enough, you're BAD and WRONG.

Even other gender critical posters are attacked and bullied into silence if they're found to be not ideologically pure enough (for example, if you're GC but don't mind adult drag shows, or GC but also Jewish and disagree with using the Swastika as a GC symbol. Sorry those are wrongthink!)

And the same posters who try their level best to bully anyone with a different opinion from them, are the ones claiming to be anti-censorship! So it's fine to relentlessly attack and bully anyone found guilty of wrongthink, but if someone says they personally find the N word unacceptable, or suggest that comedians should mention if their shows contain nudity, and there are howls of outrage and accusations of censorship. Simply for having an opinion that differs from your own.

Is being offended a threat to our safety these days?

Yeah, we see you. I know exactly what you're playing at in attempting to reframe black women who object to racial slurs, or women who object to misogynistic abuse, as "terminally offended" and over sensitive.

More dog whistles than Crufts this thread.

DeadButDelicious · 16/08/2022 22:23

vera99 · 16/08/2022 22:22

Glad to be of help grab it while you can...

Watching it right now!

vera99 · 16/08/2022 22:22

Glad to be of help grab it while you can...

DeadButDelicious · 16/08/2022 22:13

vera99 · 16/08/2022 20:16

Not a miracle but I have the files from torrent sites and have uploaded them to a YT account that I have as unlisted so virtually invisible. I tried to upload his show Total Abuse with no text or names but the YouTube AI copped it was full of abuse so rejected it.

If anyone is curious to see a whole show Gobshite here it is. He almost belongs to another era now and is no longer to my taste but I'm glad he exists and ploughs his fairly lonely furrow. It's words to a paying audience in a closed room that can never be as obscene as so much else that goes on in the world.

drive.google.com/file/d/1Ep6knMBjW8lpB549-ddJe5hJOD0LaZhA/view?usp=sharing

THANK YOU! I've been looking for that for AGES! You've made my night!

SerendipityJane · 16/08/2022 22:00

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/08/2022 20:59

The Venn diagram of people who spoke about Saville and people who get cancelled is worryingly circular.

I'm not normally for the tin foils hats but even I raise an eyebrow.

#justsayin'