Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Comedians defending Jerry Sadowitz

467 replies

FenlandFuckwit · 13/08/2022 20:37

www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-62533592

His latest gig has been cancelled after he told racist jokes and got his dick out. Why are other comedians defending his right to do this? This behaviour is not ok, AIBU to think this is indecent and disgusting behaviour and the venue were correct in cancelling him.

OP posts:
NippyWoowoo · 15/08/2022 10:21

It’s been mentioned by 2 separate posters a few posts above mine.

Oh and one below.

NippyWoowoo · 15/08/2022 10:19

AlisonDonut · 15/08/2022 09:26

It was mentioned by someone earlier on, as being a reason.

That's why it was spoken about.

But there is no evidence of this at all.

So people stopped talking about it.

Apart from the people that keep moaning that people are talking about it.

It’s been mentioned by 2 separate posters a few posts above mine.

EverythingHeadinSouth · 15/08/2022 10:14

But he went well beyond what an experienced venue was prepared to tolerate.

It's not as simple as that. The "venue" did not make the decision. Ultimately, one individual within the organisation that runs the venue made the final call. That's how organisation's work. So all those people who had booked tickets had their plans for a night out trashed, and JS presumably lost earnings, down to the opinion of one person. You have no idea how much experience that one person has either. If we tolerate this sort of censorship then where does it end? We might as well cut to the chase and invite the Taliban to come and govern us.

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 10:08

CredibilityProblem · 15/08/2022 09:55

The staff issue is a problem. Audience can vote with their wallets or their feet, but staff can't. What is it OK to expect people to put up with watching if it's their job?

It's a whole can of worms. I dimly recall that there have been previous problems with BAME ushers at more straightforwardly racist comedy shows feeling victimised.

Yes, it’s fine to expect staff in a comedy venue to put up with hearing offensive comedy. If anyone has serious enough issues that they actually suffer harm through hearing offensive comedy then this is not the job for them.

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 10:01

RoseAndRose · 15/08/2022 07:59

but I'm completely mystified as to why The Pleasance didn't know what kind of show he was going to deliver

That’ll be because they did know - they’ve had him there before.

But he went well beyond what an experienced venue was prepared to tolerate.

Ah, it sounds like at last we have someone who knows exactly what was said.

Could you give the details please?

TinySophie · 15/08/2022 09:59

doce · 15/08/2022 06:49

I'm still unaware of what Sadowitz actually said, but I can't imagine anything that could be more offensive - and dangerous to society - than the highly corrosive Daily Mail!

Well there’s the Guardian for starters.

Tractorcrisis · 15/08/2022 09:55

I guess many entertainment venues, post Covid - are struggling. So keeping audiences happy, and not showing content that might result in a financially damaging lawsuit is a priority.

I think I’m on the fence with this one! I didn’t see the act, so don’t know how the joke came across. If it was laughing at a race or reinforcing racial stereotypes than I think the decision was correct. If it was challenging prejudice - than the show should have not been cancelled.

CredibilityProblem · 15/08/2022 09:55

The staff issue is a problem. Audience can vote with their wallets or their feet, but staff can't. What is it OK to expect people to put up with watching if it's their job?

It's a whole can of worms. I dimly recall that there have been previous problems with BAME ushers at more straightforwardly racist comedy shows feeling victimised.

ThinkingaboutLangClegosaurus · 15/08/2022 09:50

WolverineBluey · 14/08/2022 10:59

No he didn't pickle. Glinner waded in early before that detail was revealed, mentioned something about 'men in wigs' or something iirc. Had a feeling he was jumping the gun a bit before the facts were known. But don't pretend the point of what he wrote was defending JS exposing himself.

Viv Goskropp has defended JS, as has Al Murray, Henning Wehn, Leo Kerse for some examples I've seen.

The venue could do more to explain themselves here. From what we know of modern 'cancel culture', on the surface it does seem extreme and quite a shocking case of censorship.

The context of what JS is supposed to have said and done is also unknown. He himself mentions no walk outs that night. I don't like the sound of his material and will not rush to defend him as at this point it's really still quite unclear what has gone on.

I read that Sadowitz made a joke about men in wigs.
Graham Lineham has long been known for defending women’s right to single-sex spaces.
In the UK at present, censorship is most often imposed on feminists or their supporters by transactivists.
Therefore I presume Sadowitz has offended the transactivists.

Brefugee · 15/08/2022 09:40

@Tractorcrisis

So I think my point is : censorship SHOULD exist if an art form causes harm. And I think that’s particularly apparent if you think of age restrictions/classifications. But that definition of ‘what is harmful’ if a very grey area. Clearly if it is unlawful - that’s wrong, but there are various moral areas perhaps not covered by law.

That was the point i was making though - state censorship does already exist in that we have laws, and we also have certification for films (and music?) which could be adopted by all publishing and theatres i think.

We also have content warnings on some things, and it wouldn't take much to expand that into box offices/online ticket sales.

I do worry that we are all moving into echo chambers. We have the thread about unis removing some books, and taking them off reading lists, because they are too shocking now. But at the same time we have games like GTA which seem to get more extreme with every release (from what i can gather, i don't play and i don't know anyone who plays). So in the end you have people who, for eg, play GTA and people who have to be protected from reading One Flew Over the Cuckoo's nest and there is nothing in between. Also personal responsibility (to stop reading, to research shows you go to etc) exists, alongside the law and content classifications (over 18, etc).

I know lots of people who grew up in countries where wongspeak could land you in jail, out of work and in re-education camps. Frankly? I'd rather a few people be shocked over a foul-mouthed comedian or a dick on stage than have that.

Scianel · 15/08/2022 09:35

The suggestions I'm seeing on twitter is that it's venue staff who objected. People who were there are saying there weren't any walkouts, just one couple who left a bit early but waved at the stage, and some movement up and down to the bar and toilet. Which agrees with the JS statement.

AlisonDonut · 15/08/2022 09:31

It used to be that as long as it didn't hurt animals or kids, pretty much anything goes. Particularly if it is adults only.

However, younger adults seem to have a bit of a 'you can say what you want as long as I agree' thing going on.

So in the past, if you don't like Jerry S then don't buy tickets. Now it is if you don't like Jerry S then buy tickets, complain and get him cancelled.

He's not my cup of tea in the slightest but he does warn people before hand and he is playing a character, a character this is not supposed to be liked.

Where does it all end, that we all have to have the same likes, dislikes, opinions and there is literally no comedy any more?

Shortpoet · 15/08/2022 09:28

It's about audience expectation. It might cause an uproar if Michael McIntyre or Eddie Izzard got their wee man out in an act because no one would have gone along to one of their shows expecting that.

Approx of nothing, I was at a performance in about 1999 where Eddie Izzard did get his wee man out. But the context was that it was a play about Lenny Bruce who died naked on a bathroom floor and Eddie was playing Lenny. And the full frontal male nudity was signposted very very clearly when purchasing tickets. Obviously if he did it in the middle of “cake or death, or “le singe et dans l'arbre” it would be a different story.

AlisonDonut · 15/08/2022 09:26

NippyWoowoo · 15/08/2022 09:14

And they're bending over backwards to say no no it MUST have been the transphobia!

But everything else is ok, it's just those pesky TRAs causing trouble that there is no mention of Confused

It was mentioned by someone earlier on, as being a reason.

That's why it was spoken about.

But there is no evidence of this at all.

So people stopped talking about it.

Apart from the people that keep moaning that people are talking about it.

Tractorcrisis · 15/08/2022 09:24

@Brefugee

Yes, I remember Jaws! So therefore taking film as an art form - there would be less censorship on that particular film today than in the 70’s, yet there are cries that we are becoming ‘too woke’, we are losing our right to free speech…

Depicting a shark eating a human isn’t illegal, yet there is censorship involved. If my daughter’s primary school decided to show it to the class, I think majority opinion would be that it wouldn’t be ‘right’ but not necessarily illegal?? I don’t know enough about the law here.

So I think it’s too broad a statement to say “I don’t think art should be censored”. I guess what is allowed by law - legal/illegal - those laws exist to protect others from harm.

So I think my point is : censorship SHOULD exist if an art form causes harm. And I think that’s particularly apparent if you think of age restrictions/classifications. But that definition of ‘what is harmful’ if a very grey area. Clearly if it is unlawful - that’s wrong, but there are various moral areas perhaps not covered by law.

NippyWoowoo · 15/08/2022 09:14

AllPowerfulLizardPerson · 15/08/2022 07:35

Discussions on comedy and festival themed subreddits are all about the racism.

It’s only on MN that trans issues feature - is this based on actual accounts of the show or use assumption?

And they're bending over backwards to say no no it MUST have been the transphobia!

But everything else is ok, it's just those pesky TRAs causing trouble that there is no mention of Confused

ResisterRex · 15/08/2022 09:00

Some comedians did discuss this in public and they make a compelling case for free speech as well as giving context to why JS is an important figure to comedians, and why they should defend him:

twitter.com/andrewdoyle_com/status/1558915426624610310?s=21&t=F5bUC-nSYwZ7Pl3oHVW-pA

Scianel · 15/08/2022 08:48

And I hasten to add, the recent outrage about onstage nudity on MN was specifically because the show was aimed at a family audience, not 18+ as this was.

RoseAndRose · 15/08/2022 08:46

WolverineBluey · 15/08/2022 08:29

Sorry Rose, I meant the nature of the act in general rather than just performing the exact same show.

Like others I'm still not sure where transphobia comes into it.

”shock” acts have to keep getting more extreme, or they no longer shock

so level of offence rises, and may well tip in to absolutely unacceptable hate speech

”I was only joking” and “can’t you see it’s a joke” already cover a wide range of offensive utterances, that are tolerated in some circumstances, but it’s not an exemption for everything always. If it was a venue other than The Pleasance, I’d e rather more sceptical of the assessment. But they’re not naive, host some real eye-openers, and yet found this too much

(I too am baffled by the trans comments on this thread, and agree they could fairly be seen as arising from transphobia)

Scianel · 15/08/2022 08:46

There are plenty of Fringe acts involving full nudity. I mean you're told when you buy the ticket so presumably if you don't want to see a knob you don't go and see JS or Puppetry of the Penis.

BobMortimersPocketMeat · 15/08/2022 08:46

FrancescaContini · 15/08/2022 08:41

Erm, it is public. Agree that this is very grim.

The cast of the recent revival of the stage musical Hair
Daniel Radcliffe (and a number of earlier actors) in Peter Schaffer’s Equus
Benedict Cumberbatch in the National Theatre’s award winning adaptation of Frankenstein

Three examples I know off the top of my head where there is full frontal male nudity.

None of these have resulted in the shows being cancelled.

FrancescaContini · 15/08/2022 08:41

AllyCatTown · 13/08/2022 20:59

Is getting your dick out in a public place acceptable to them?

If he regularly does it on stage I don’t see any issue with that and it’s well known what to expect. I assume it’s adults only. It’s not public like getting your dick out on the street it’s a performance.

Erm, it is public. Agree that this is very grim.

AllPowerfulLizardPerson · 15/08/2022 08:37

Like others I'm still not sure where transphobia comes into it

Transphobia in relation to this seems to come only from those who assume the issue must be trans related.

That is not the working assumption on other sites, such as comedy and Fringe subreddits

CredibilityProblem · 15/08/2022 08:33

Sadly I think this might be disastrous for Sadowitz. He has an audience who knows the score, shares his view of life and politics and appreciates what he's saying.

If this makes him a hero of the "you can't say anything nowadays, I'll buy a ticket, that'll show the snowflakes!" Daily Mail tendency then it could get nasty. As per a PP's anecdote he can deal with one person actually agreeing with some of the terrible things he says, but what if it was half the audience? And what if hundreds of people expecting Jim Davidson turn up to each show, have a conniption at the actual content, demand refunds and complain to the local paper in unmanageable numbers. I'm not sure all publicity is good publicity in this case.

ResisterRex · 15/08/2022 08:32

The point is that we still don't know. I still find it odd that there is no detail at all, which makes whatever is said, increasingly hard not to look at from all angles and with a lot of "what ifs" and "but what do they mean by this".

Whoever complained hasn't come forward (and I'd expect that to be anonymous to a newspaper or some other means like a new Twitter account or whatever) and that also seems really unusual especially by this point in the proceedings.

As to definitions and their statement, some schools of thought ie CRT, would have quite a different take on the definition of "racism" so given there is still no detail - and because I don't want to live in a totalitarian state - I would prefer to remain curious about this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread