Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Man stalking woman, excused by saying he must be autistic..

397 replies

AutismIsStigmatised · 13/08/2022 14:11

I came across this video on TikTok today, I'll post the link below but in summary an unknown man posed as an amazon delivery person to get access to a block of flats this woman lives in. He was behaving strangely and wanted to give her a 'gift' which was some sort of cup / candle holder. She confronted him and he left, then came back up again, left again then came back up a third time with his hood up as though he was about to do something sinister. Very bloody creepy.

vm.tiktok.com/ZMNsQfG2W/

The comments are littered with people saying that he's 'clearly autistic'

Take a look and tell me what you think but as the parent of an autistic boy (and wife of an autistic adult) it really upsets me when people assume scary/criminal behaviour is due to autism. I know many people with autism and not one has ever behaved like that..

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 22:21

VeganPesto · 13/08/2022 22:16

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet I do agree with you actually. The carers are just trying to do their job and shouldn’t be at risk themselves. I’m not sure what the solution is other than keeping the man indoors 24/7 and I don’t know that that’s fair. The outdoors is so beneficial to my mental health and I’m sure it helps him too

Yes I certainly don’t agree with the ‘lock em
up’ mentality - I still remember the ‘long stay hospitals’ that disabled people had to suffer in in subhuman conditions <shudder> - and I don’t think 3 carers could restrain anyone aggressive except maybe a child. I don’t know if more needs to be done to protect people or if it’s just a case that you’re one of those 1 in a million victims who just happened to be in this man’s beeline!

VeganPesto · 13/08/2022 22:16

@LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet I do agree with you actually. The carers are just trying to do their job and shouldn’t be at risk themselves. I’m not sure what the solution is other than keeping the man indoors 24/7 and I don’t know that that’s fair. The outdoors is so beneficial to my mental health and I’m sure it helps him too

VeganPesto · 13/08/2022 22:13

@HailAdrian As far as I know his carers weren’t even questioned by the police. My dog had to go through a full behaviour/temperament test and my parents were questioned too as I wasn’t old enough to be his legal owner at the time. He passed with flying colours and the policemen said they thought he was lovely.

The disabled man still isn’t supervised properly although I’ve only seen him in the village a few times since. The last time was 2 months ago, at the other end of the village to the care facility where the man lives. I only noticed him as my dog growled, hackles up terrified when he started to approach. My poor lad remembers almost 10 years on he’s never reacted like that to anyone else.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 22:10

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 22:01

Sorry that happened to you. His carers should have been held accountable, anyone who requires 3 people to supervise them should be very much supervised.

I really don’t know how 3 people could restrain a man of that size who was on an aggressive mission to hurt someone.

I feel this thread is descending into carer bashing. Caters are just human beings, they can’t control their patients, they can only mind and assist them

AutismIsStigmatised · 13/08/2022 22:05

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 21:58

What do you think that should mean in terms of consequences for him? Bearing in mind that the woman was so incredibly scared that she called the police

In this case as the young man was capable of holding down a full time job he would seemingly have the capacity to understand what the police are telling him, I feel that a very clear instruction to leave her alone and not approach her again would be sufficient as a first intervention.

I certainly don't think he should be hauled down the police station after the first report, then again even neurotypical men aren't hauled down the police station for stalking until they do something extreme. That was my experience anyway.

OP posts:
HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 22:01

VeganPesto · 13/08/2022 21:52

A large (6ft+ and stocky) disabled man ran up to me on a field when I was 14 and placed his hand across my throat and squeezed. My dog bit him. He was with 3 carers at the time who should have been watching him yet our door was the one that the police came to.

I honestly think if my dog hadn’t bitten him (one single bite on the leg that created a puncture but no excessive injury) he could have killed me.

I am autistic and have ADHD. I’ve also been raped by a stranger. Lots of men terrify me, even some disabled men.

Sorry that happened to you. His carers should have been held accountable, anyone who requires 3 people to supervise them should be very much supervised.

Cyclemarine · 13/08/2022 21:59

VeganPesto · 13/08/2022 21:52

A large (6ft+ and stocky) disabled man ran up to me on a field when I was 14 and placed his hand across my throat and squeezed. My dog bit him. He was with 3 carers at the time who should have been watching him yet our door was the one that the police came to.

I honestly think if my dog hadn’t bitten him (one single bite on the leg that created a puncture but no excessive injury) he could have killed me.

I am autistic and have ADHD. I’ve also been raped by a stranger. Lots of men terrify me, even some disabled men.

That’s horrendous and kind of an example of what I meant by sometimes delivering a short sharp pain is necessary to escape the grip of someone assaulting you… regardless of their mental capacity.

I hope nothing happened to your brave dog and the police also spoke to the carers about their extreme carelessness which nearly proved fatal!

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 21:58

AutismIsStigmatised · 13/08/2022 21:54

He will have known what he was doing as far as making a decision to approach and talk to the woman on the train every day, what he likely didn't realise was that he was scaring her and that his behaviour would get him into trouble with the police.

In his mind it was seemingly as simple as "I like this person, I enjoy speaking to her, I'm going to keep speaking to her" and he completely missed any and all social cues that indicate that she wanted him to leave.

What do you think that should mean in terms of consequences for him? Bearing in mind that the woman was so incredibly scared that she called the police

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:57

AutismIsStigmatised · 13/08/2022 21:54

He will have known what he was doing as far as making a decision to approach and talk to the woman on the train every day, what he likely didn't realise was that he was scaring her and that his behaviour would get him into trouble with the police.

In his mind it was seemingly as simple as "I like this person, I enjoy speaking to her, I'm going to keep speaking to her" and he completely missed any and all social cues that indicate that she wanted him to leave.

More eloquent than anything I would have typed, I blame the heat of course.

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:55

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 21:46

So to be clear - it’s not all autistic people you think k should be immune from any prosecution, just your perception of what is ‘severely autistic’?

Yes, which is why I've overused the words 'severely' and 'profoundly.'

I agree that it's a 'male' issue but not an 'autism' one. I believe that autistic men and women are often misjudged but I don't believe a man who is clearly intent on intimidating and hurting a woman can be misjudged. Autistic men and 'NT' men intimidate and hurt women frequently, it's definitely a male problem. Like i say, social media is full of armchair psychologists who see disturbing behaviour and blame it on autism and mental health issues. The simple truth is more straightforward.

AutismIsStigmatised · 13/08/2022 21:54

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 21:47

Oh no, we do realise that - we are very simply saying it doesn’t mean that, if they DO assault someone, they should be excused from any consequences.

Given you think that only ‘severely autistic’ people don’t know what they’re doing, I’m amazed you felt sorry for the very high functioning man who scared a woman on the bus upthread to the point she got the police involved. He is clearly not severely autistic so he must know what he was doing?

He will have known what he was doing as far as making a decision to approach and talk to the woman on the train every day, what he likely didn't realise was that he was scaring her and that his behaviour would get him into trouble with the police.

In his mind it was seemingly as simple as "I like this person, I enjoy speaking to her, I'm going to keep speaking to her" and he completely missed any and all social cues that indicate that she wanted him to leave.

OP posts:
VeganPesto · 13/08/2022 21:52

A large (6ft+ and stocky) disabled man ran up to me on a field when I was 14 and placed his hand across my throat and squeezed. My dog bit him. He was with 3 carers at the time who should have been watching him yet our door was the one that the police came to.

I honestly think if my dog hadn’t bitten him (one single bite on the leg that created a puncture but no excessive injury) he could have killed me.

I am autistic and have ADHD. I’ve also been raped by a stranger. Lots of men terrify me, even some disabled men.

AutismIsStigmatised · 13/08/2022 21:50

For those who haven't seen the young ladies updates on tiktok, she had a second man approach her door this evening and he was making crude comments about wanting to see her with her top off.

She explained in the comments that this second incident wasn't the same man she caught on camera initially, but somebody she vaguely knows of from the area who seems to have some mental health problems.

So that's two separate men coming to her flat within 24hrs.

She suspects its something to do with a drug dealing ex as in him sending people to scare her and that is, I assume, why she hasn't mentioned getting the police involved. She's probably scared of repercussions from the ex.

I was shocked when she said she's only 19, that poor girl having to deal with all of this shit.

OP posts:
LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 21:49

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:34

But more to the point, it's not a feminist issue, at least not in my eyes. Women are vulnerable members of society because (mostly neurotypical) men and so are severely disabled people.

The feminist aspect is that these things always seem to happen to women and they are usually not nearly as strong as the men who hurt/bother/damage them

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 21:47

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:28

I think people struggle to get their heads around the idea that some autistic people literally have no idea whatsoever what is good behaviour and what is bad. That doesn't apply to the guy in the video because he used deception, suggesting he knows he is wrong, in order to harm someone.

Oh no, we do realise that - we are very simply saying it doesn’t mean that, if they DO assault someone, they should be excused from any consequences.

Given you think that only ‘severely autistic’ people don’t know what they’re doing, I’m amazed you felt sorry for the very high functioning man who scared a woman on the bus upthread to the point she got the police involved. He is clearly not severely autistic so he must know what he was doing?

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 13/08/2022 21:46

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:26

I can tell you that he is not severely autistic. Anyone with any experience of severely autistic people will agree. He may be 'high functioning' but he is absolutely not profoundly autistic.

So to be clear - it’s not all autistic people you think k should be immune from any prosecution, just your perception of what is ‘severely autistic’?

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:40

PonyPatter44 · 13/08/2022 21:38

There are dozens (maybe hundreds) of severely autistic men in prison. Many of them bounce back and forth between prison and medium-secure psychiatric units. It is blindingly obvious to everyone who comes into contact with these men in prison that they are in the wrong place - but sometimes the system gets it wrong and sends these men to prison instead of MSU.

I would think that someone whose disability was so profound that they could not even walk down the street alone would realistically never be in a position to commit serious crimes. The problem lies with people who are a little higher functioning and can live semi-independently, but who still struggle with normal social mores.

I agree but when I say 'profoundly autistic' I mean someone who doesn't have a hope in hell of ever being independent. Like, possibly not even toilet trained.

Cyclemarine · 13/08/2022 21:39

Cyclemarine · 13/08/2022 21:36

and btw, for all we know some of these men who have a thing for breasts may grab hold of them tight and it would cause extreme pain/be impossible to move away from them if you don’t want your breast tissue torn.

if they are beyond understand verbal and social communication ( or even if not) the best course of action for me to quickly end this is to issue a short sharp shock.
For eg. many years ago a man tried to assault me after a party (tried to forcibly kiss me out the blue) and a friend intervened to poke him in the eyes and because of the short sharp pain caused my fingers in his eyes, he instinctively dropped his arms from the back of my head and backed off having for the message.

We learned later he has some mental health issues but my friend definitely did the right thing. I’m so grateful for her quick thinking.

oops typos galore

I meant : ‘caused by fingers in his eyes’ and ‘backed of having got the message’.

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:39

and btw, for all we know some of these men who have a thing for breasts may grab hold of them tight and it would cause extreme pain/be impossible to move away from them if you don’t want your breast tissue torn.

Not disagreeing with that. It's not just autistic men who are prone to grabbing other people's body parts though, autistic women can be violent too. Hence my opinion that it's not a 'man vs woman' issue.

PonyPatter44 · 13/08/2022 21:38

There are dozens (maybe hundreds) of severely autistic men in prison. Many of them bounce back and forth between prison and medium-secure psychiatric units. It is blindingly obvious to everyone who comes into contact with these men in prison that they are in the wrong place - but sometimes the system gets it wrong and sends these men to prison instead of MSU.

I would think that someone whose disability was so profound that they could not even walk down the street alone would realistically never be in a position to commit serious crimes. The problem lies with people who are a little higher functioning and can live semi-independently, but who still struggle with normal social mores.

Cyclemarine · 13/08/2022 21:36

and btw, for all we know some of these men who have a thing for breasts may grab hold of them tight and it would cause extreme pain/be impossible to move away from them if you don’t want your breast tissue torn.

if they are beyond understand verbal and social communication ( or even if not) the best course of action for me to quickly end this is to issue a short sharp shock.
For eg. many years ago a man tried to assault me after a party (tried to forcibly kiss me out the blue) and a friend intervened to poke him in the eyes and because of the short sharp pain caused my fingers in his eyes, he instinctively dropped his arms from the back of my head and backed off having for the message.

We learned later he has some mental health issues but my friend definitely did the right thing. I’m so grateful for her quick thinking.

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:34

But more to the point, it's not a feminist issue, at least not in my eyes. Women are vulnerable members of society because (mostly neurotypical) men and so are severely disabled people.

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:31

Cyclemarine · 13/08/2022 21:29

You think it’s easy to stop abuse from just moving away when it’s an older teen/ young man/grown man who can outrun you? As I said my instinct - and others - would be to defend myself if I’m being assaulted whether it was a hard shove or a slap or a knee to the groin.

These are all proportionate measures to sexual abuse, I’m not talking about taking a knife to someone or anything deadly of course.

That's fair but I don't doubt most people would describe that as a really shitty situation for all involved.

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:29

secular39 · 13/08/2022 21:28

Why has the topic moved onto 'severely Autistic'? The boy in the video is no way profound/severely Autistic.

It started with another posters story about a guy and a woman on a train.

But no, the one in the video is not profoundly autistic.

Cyclemarine · 13/08/2022 21:29

HailAdrian · 13/08/2022 21:24

That's a bizarre assumption. I think he should remove himself from the situation if the disabled person's carer isn't dealing with it. It's not ok to hurt anyone but even less so if you do it intentionally. I'd assume the disabled person couldn't handle the noise/people/small space so it'd be crazy to even have them on the train in the first place.

You think it’s easy to stop abuse from just moving away when it’s an older teen/ young man/grown man who can outrun you? As I said my instinct - and others - would be to defend myself if I’m being assaulted whether it was a hard shove or a slap or a knee to the groin.

These are all proportionate measures to sexual abuse, I’m not talking about taking a knife to someone or anything deadly of course.