Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum broke leg, now SIL furious

393 replies

RoversEnd · 13/08/2022 09:14

So long story short my Mum broke her leg and we were meant to be dog sitting SIL’s dog this week as they are on holiday. We had to say we can’t do it as my Mum needs care. She’s on her own. I’m an only child and there is no-one else to help. We’ve got her a basic wheelchair and in cooking and caring for her. The response to this was that they are ‘furious’.

DH’s parents actually offered to look after the dog but apparently they can’t give ‘the dog what it needs’ for a week. There has been no concern for my Mum’s situation at all. SIL even said ‘I’m sorry to hear that RoversEnd and RoversEnd’s mum can’t handle this situation by themselves’.

AIBU to feel really hurt? I don’t have any siblings so I tried to make this relationship work for my DD’s sake so she has cousins to spend time with. DD is also an only child due to our secondary infertility. I feel like I’ve made a major effort trying to build this relationship and actually there’s nothing there. DH says he’s so disappointed that there’s no feeling or care for our situation whatsoever. I know she’s disappointed we can’t look after her dog, but her own parents offered to look after it too and sure they wouldn’t be able to take it for ten mile walks but they are very fit and healthy and could do a lot more than us, given we are in hospital every other day. In the end she said ‘she’s sorted something out’ and has now continued to talk on the family chat like nothings happened. I feel like removing myself from the group.

OP posts:
Highfivemum · 13/08/2022 11:27

Appalling behaviour from you SIL. I would def remove myself from chat. She sounds a spoilt entitled person with no empathy.
in future don’t offer you help if she then is so rude when your situation changes

Phineyj · 13/08/2022 11:26

I've just visited some elderly inlaws. They are currently cat sitting for BIL and SIL for two weeks. It is quite a bit of work for them in the hot weather being vigilant about open doors and windows (indoor cat, house on main road), plus extra mess from food and litter.

I pay a cat sitter to come to the house daily if we're away. I consider it part of budgeting the holiday.

If you're having your pets cared for as a favour and something serious comes up for the person - tough shit! You get what you pay for!9

2pinkginsplease · 13/08/2022 11:26

Id be pissed off too if I were your sister in law, they made arrangements to enable them to go on holiday and now you’ve pulled the plug.

plenty of people look after their own dogs when they have broken their leg or not long out of hospital. I’m not understanding why you can’t do both, many people do.

SoupDragon · 13/08/2022 11:25

Dogs are like children. You don't just leave them with anyone.

of course they aren't like children. If they were you wouldn't be leaving them at home when you go on holiday. You don't usually do that with children or leave them in kennels.

Entjfigbr · 13/08/2022 11:25

OP, clearly no need to invest any more energy into this relationship. All one way, and no care towards you or your mum.

itsgettingweird · 13/08/2022 11:24

Scianel · 13/08/2022 11:20

As I said, my mum's broken leg heralded the last few painful, distressing weeks of her life. I'm rather glad I didn't shut her away in a room to look after someone's dog so that it's owner could fuck off on holiday.

Sorry to hear about your mum.

Flowers

My own mum died earlier this year of cancer and I'm so glad that people were nice and accepted me pulling out of long-standing weekly car sharing arrangements at the time and even took on extra duties to take ds for me.

People can be such dicks about expecting things and expecting others to give up their life to cater for them.

stuntbubbles · 13/08/2022 11:23

Could you take the dog to the Highlands wedding with you. R could drive.

ApplesandBunions · 13/08/2022 11:22

itsgettingweird · 13/08/2022 11:20

And it is hard to understand why a couple cannot look after a dog because one of their mothers broke a leg. People break their legs all the time, it doesn’t mean the family pet has to be ferried off to the kennels because the family need to devote all their attention to the broken leg.

But they could look after the dog in a way that worked for them.

But the sil didn't want her dog ceres for in a way that suited the person doing a favour. She wanted it on her terms which didn't work for those caring for the dog.

If you won't compromise when you want a favour then you don't get the favour.

Exactly. And if you want to be able to dictate how your pet is cared for, you pay a professional to do it.

Scianel · 13/08/2022 11:20

As I said, my mum's broken leg heralded the last few painful, distressing weeks of her life. I'm rather glad I didn't shut her away in a room to look after someone's dog so that it's owner could fuck off on holiday.

itsgettingweird · 13/08/2022 11:20

And it is hard to understand why a couple cannot look after a dog because one of their mothers broke a leg. People break their legs all the time, it doesn’t mean the family pet has to be ferried off to the kennels because the family need to devote all their attention to the broken leg.

But they could look after the dog in a way that worked for them.

But the sil didn't want her dog ceres for in a way that suited the person doing a favour. She wanted it on her terms which didn't work for those caring for the dog.

If you won't compromise when you want a favour then you don't get the favour.

Scianel · 13/08/2022 11:19

I don't see how your mother breaking her leg had anything to do with it

Oh dear. Well I suppose it's not your fault if thinking isn't your strong point.

Stravaig · 13/08/2022 11:19

So many PP here so excited about the chance to give OP an undeserved kicking & not letting the facts get in the way of their bullying!

Yes, this is weird. Is it because there's a dog involved? Brits are often grotesquely sentimental about pets, in a way which has little to do with their actual wellbeing. After all, if SIL and family truly cared about DDog, they'd have chosen a holiday which included them.

SunnyD44 · 13/08/2022 11:19

& I'm not sure why you're foisting 'solutions' on OP when she's capable of deciding for herself what help she is prepared to give her selfish SiL.

@KettrickenSmiled OP started a thread asking for advice.
Giving a potential solution to her problem is what she wants.

Not making up random scenarios like you keep doing.
Which is not helpful and frankly a pretty odd thing to do.

Sounds like you’re projecting alot on this thread.
Let me guess you have an issue with your own SIL.

itsgettingweird · 13/08/2022 11:17

AlexandriasWindmill · 13/08/2022 10:20

Lots of people break their leg and have a dog so I can understand why SIL was bemused that your DM having a broken leg means you and your DH can't keep a prior arrangement.
I also think it's fair for them not to want your ILs to stay in their house or watch their dog. Dogs are like children. You don't just leave them with anyone.

And lots of people break their leg and can't 🤷‍♀️

But point is this isn't the dog owner who has broken their leg or the person caring for the injured persons dog.

Neither is responsible for the dog and affected alternatives that were turned down.

The SIL is within her rights to coin the Mn phrase "that doesn't work for me" as much as OP was and has.

stuntbubbles · 13/08/2022 11:16

You agreed to look after their dog so they could go on holiday and you have pulled out. I don't see how your mother breaking her leg had anything to do with it.
Bloody hell the inside of your head must be a lovely place to be.

GucciBear · 13/08/2022 11:13

Tell her that if the dog had good manners = i.e. properly trained, you could manage both. Too many people have dogs and do not give even basic training.

AclowncalledAlice · 13/08/2022 11:12

amylou8 · 13/08/2022 10:52

You committed to looking after the dog. It's still possible for you to look after the dog even though it may no longer be convenient. You're unreasonable to let her down at such short notice because it no longer suits you. I'd be pissed off too.

Maybe the OP should have consulted a crystal ball before agreeing to dog sit, then she would have known her mum was going to break her leg. 🙄

Poppins2016 · 13/08/2022 11:12

Doidontimmm · 13/08/2022 09:23

It can’t be jumping every minute? If your mum wanted to sleep she could go to her bedroom? Dogs not going to hurt a foot in a cast and she will be ok left for an hour if you take the dog out?

My grandmother had leg ulcers and was in a lot of pain towards the end of her life. Our (active, bouncy) dog had to be kept in a separate room at all times, because dogs are unpredictable and even the slightest knock would cause immense pain. To confine a dog (or a person) to one room for a whole week in these circumstances would be rather impractical and unfair.

KettrickenSmiled · 13/08/2022 11:12

You agreed to look after their dog so they could go on holiday and you have pulled out.
Go & read the OP again @Lovethemarsbars.
OP did not "pull out" - she simply offered a change of venue, ie the dog to come to her house, so that she can manage the situation with her mum as well.

I don't see how your mother breaking her leg had anything to do with it.
You don't see how having an immobile person to help with their wheelchair, loo breaks, dressing, washing & every-other-day hospital appointments would impact on the arrangement?
How dense (or eager to bully OP) do you need to be not see that?

And you have not done her a favour by offering to look after her dog as you didn't actually look after her dog.
OP did not withdraw her offer to look after the dog.
SiL petulantly refused the alternative offer OP was able to make.

You don't have to look after her dog but you offered and then you withdrew the offer so yabu.
READ THE EFFING THREAD. This did not happen.

So many PP here so excited about the chance to give OP an undeserved kicking & not letting the facts get in the way of their bullying!

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 13/08/2022 11:09

RoversEnd · 13/08/2022 09:21

@Doidontimmm Mum is staying with us and the dog is really active. We said we could mainly keep let DD play with the dog in the garden and take it for walks so my mum can rest. Otherwise it’s jumping up and down on people all the time. But there was no response to that. I think they wanted the dog sitting on their terms or not at all.

To everyone saying they should have just looked after the dog anyway.
They did offer to in a way that would accommodate OP's Mum's needs as well, but SIL was too rude to respond. it was on SILs terms or not at all.
The Mum's leg situation warranted a wheelchair
The OP said they had to be at the hospital every other day - what would they do with a visiting boisterous dog then?
The DH was probably at work.
I think the SIL is Ok to be disappointed but she had other options readily available - she sounds selfish.
I don't think I'd want to look after the dog next time.

Isyesterdaytomorrowtoday · 13/08/2022 11:08

Can’t your DH look after the dog?

Abraxan · 13/08/2022 11:07

Lovethemarsbars · 13/08/2022 11:02

You agreed to look after their dog so they could go on holiday and you have pulled out. I don't see how your mother breaking her leg had anything to do with it.

And you have not done her a favour by offering to look after her dog as you didn't actually look after her dog.

You don't have to look after her dog but you offered and then you withdrew the offer so yabu.

You really can't see why the OP can no longer decamp to another house to care for a very active dog whilst she also needs to care for her mum, who is currently wheelchair bound and needing to go to the hospital every other day?

Really?

It's very very clear why that arrangement can no longer happen.

Stravaig · 13/08/2022 11:06

No is a complete sentence.
An essential tool for dealing with selfish, entitled, toxic people.

Festoonlights · 13/08/2022 11:06

Op I would stop relying on sil to be the sibling you wish for. It’s the dependence on your relationship with her that is allowing her to take advantage of you and call the shots.
Look for decent friendships that can provide reciprocal, healthy support.

ddl1 · 13/08/2022 11:06

If there were no alternatives but to cancel the holiday or put the dog into a kennel, I could understand the SIL being disappointed; but this is not the case. There are some possible solutions- the PILs could look after the dog; the dog could come to stay with you and your DH rather than your DH going there- but apparently the SIL won't entertain anything but her original plan.

Is this a case of what might be called 'precious pooch syndrome', where the dog trumps everyone else, or is the SIL jealous that her brother might be prioritizing his wife and MIL over doing everything that she wants? In any case, you should not be expected to neglect your Mum or to drag her with a broken leg to an unfamiliar house, when there are other solutions available.

Swipe left for the next trending thread