Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum broke leg, now SIL furious

393 replies

RoversEnd · 13/08/2022 09:14

So long story short my Mum broke her leg and we were meant to be dog sitting SIL’s dog this week as they are on holiday. We had to say we can’t do it as my Mum needs care. She’s on her own. I’m an only child and there is no-one else to help. We’ve got her a basic wheelchair and in cooking and caring for her. The response to this was that they are ‘furious’.

DH’s parents actually offered to look after the dog but apparently they can’t give ‘the dog what it needs’ for a week. There has been no concern for my Mum’s situation at all. SIL even said ‘I’m sorry to hear that RoversEnd and RoversEnd’s mum can’t handle this situation by themselves’.

AIBU to feel really hurt? I don’t have any siblings so I tried to make this relationship work for my DD’s sake so she has cousins to spend time with. DD is also an only child due to our secondary infertility. I feel like I’ve made a major effort trying to build this relationship and actually there’s nothing there. DH says he’s so disappointed that there’s no feeling or care for our situation whatsoever. I know she’s disappointed we can’t look after her dog, but her own parents offered to look after it too and sure they wouldn’t be able to take it for ten mile walks but they are very fit and healthy and could do a lot more than us, given we are in hospital every other day. In the end she said ‘she’s sorted something out’ and has now continued to talk on the family chat like nothings happened. I feel like removing myself from the group.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 13/08/2022 17:05

Mamamia7962 · 13/08/2022 09:32

Agree with PPs that you could have still looked after the dog.

How, exactly, as SiL wanted it at her house and the OP's mum is now wheelchair bound?

It's not as if SiL didn't have other offers

7eleven · 13/08/2022 16:55

Oh sweetheart. Friends can be family. Focus on friendships. You’re not going to get what you want from your sil.

LondonJax · 13/08/2022 16:50

Well SIL and her DP will have to rethink holidays in future.

If they don't want the dog in kennels then they'll have to get a professional sitter lined up. Because asking someone to travel one and a half hours just to dog sit is utterly ridiculous.

Relying on family or friends isn't a good idea - things happen. What if it had been the OP who had broken her leg? How would she then manage, with young children, to cover a dog which is a three hour round trip away? Would SIL honestly have expected OP's DH to drop everything, including the care of his family, for a dog? Seriously some people need to get a grip.

Either add in the cost of kennels or a professional sitter to your holiday or do own country holidays and take the dog. That's what having a pet means, make sacrifices in terms of where you holiday, pay for professionals or don't expect to call the shots in what happens to the animal in terms of where it's cared for.

Nocutenamesleft · 13/08/2022 16:43

VioletInsolence · 13/08/2022 15:47

What type of person is that? Sounds like me and I’m autistic/adhd/autistic/chronically fatigued. Sounds like you’re missing an empathy chip.

I don’t really understand why so many people are saying that the OP could manage to look after her mother with a broken leg plus doing ten mile walks. And I also don’t understand why they should go out of their way to help when the SIL hasn’t even asked how the OP’s mum is.

Do people just follow what other people say on here? Just that it’s usually ‘No is a complete sentence’ and everyone hates dogs anyway🙄

Agree. Thought the original comment was very passive aggressive!

Nocutenamesleft · 13/08/2022 16:42

I’d do exactly as you did

my mum is 70 and couldn’t cope with a broken leg. Not on top then of the fact that she’s be in someone else’s house that means you can’t properly rest with a dog jumping over you all the time!!

no you did the right thing there.

HannahSternDefoe · 13/08/2022 16:41

DangerouslyBored · 13/08/2022 16:19

I would rather not go on holiday than put my dogs through the trauma of boarding. Highly
doubt your dog ‘loved’ it. Boarding goes against everything that makes a dog feel secure and loved.

But surely that's the point...

You either go on holiday and board the dog, or take it with you and fit your holiday around it.

You don't know how well the friend or family member will treat it - but the kennels will have a set standard.

DangerouslyBored · 13/08/2022 16:19

BellePeppa · 13/08/2022 15:34

Why don’t they put the dog in boarding. My dog has been several times and seems to love it (I checked their credentials thoroughly).

I would rather not go on holiday than put my dogs through the trauma of boarding. Highly
doubt your dog ‘loved’ it. Boarding goes against everything that makes a dog feel secure and loved.

SimonaRazowska · 13/08/2022 16:11

Out of curiosity, what breed is this 10-mile walk needing dog?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 13/08/2022 16:06

So much of the usual MN faux-confusion on this thread. This one example doesn't mean they are codepedent either.

Indeed. It's disingenuous and completely transparent.

TheGraceFace · 13/08/2022 16:03

OP, you did right to put your mom’s needs before a dog. Unless anyone on here’s going to take it seeing as they’re all so keen on you still doing it, tell SIL to put it in the kennels.

Drivebye · 13/08/2022 16:02

Honestly let your DH deal with it. His family, he organises. You yours. Why don't people do this. Men never get all the stress that goes along with these things.

Women just continue to put themselves in these situations.

EmmaH2022 · 13/08/2022 15:54

Whimsical what do you think a "simple leg break" would be like, just out if interest?

Loics · 13/08/2022 15:52

MRex · 13/08/2022 15:27

Not quite. SIL thought her brother would have still looked after the dog, while OP looked after her mother. But OP decided she can't look after her mother on her own and needs DH there, while the DH thinks he can't look after a dog on his own while working from home. We can agree the SIL was being unreasonable to lay out demands instead of being flexible once the situation changed. Many of us though feel a bit baffled as to why one adult can't look after a dog when working from home, and another adult can't assist her mum on her own. There may be reasons that haven't been given about why both are so codependent, but it seems odd to those of us who are used to being a bit more capable individually.

Would those super cabaple and independent posters really be sitting there "baffled" at why they aren't dog-sitting? So much of the usual MN faux-confusion on this thread. This one example doesn't mean they are codepedent either...

If there really is confusion over it - I'm not sure what OP's husband does, but if the dog is non-stop as the OP seems to have indicated, I wouldn't and probably couldn't work from home alongside it. We have a family member with a "very active" dog -
she would literally be running over me, jumping up and barking throughout the day, including meetings. She also requires long walks at specific times - if you happen to have something else on at that time she'll simply sit and bark until she's taken out. I would never dog sit without someone else who could accommodate her needs when I couldn't.

If DP was in OP's situation and was worried sick about his elderly mum while caring for her (as OP mentioned the fall has made her think of other things such as her mum's health and a fear of losing her), the last thing I would do is bugger off to dog sit an hour and a half away, especially if the dog owner was as rude and entitled as SIL has been.

VioletInsolence · 13/08/2022 15:47

Wickywickyyow · 13/08/2022 09:29

Are you the type if people that can only cope with one thing at a time? We have friends like that, they all go to children's parties together, they share email accounts, they don't do anything by themselves. Anything more that one thing to do at once is just too much.

What type of person is that? Sounds like me and I’m autistic/adhd/autistic/chronically fatigued. Sounds like you’re missing an empathy chip.

I don’t really understand why so many people are saying that the OP could manage to look after her mother with a broken leg plus doing ten mile walks. And I also don’t understand why they should go out of their way to help when the SIL hasn’t even asked how the OP’s mum is.

Do people just follow what other people say on here? Just that it’s usually ‘No is a complete sentence’ and everyone hates dogs anyway🙄

Hoppinggreen · 13/08/2022 15:36

Round here if you haven’t booked 6-12 months in advance you are unlikely to find a homeboarder and a lot of people don’t like kennels

Seaweed42 · 13/08/2022 15:35

Maybe you have inadvertently taken over the family relationship with SIL for the reasons you already mentioned. Therefore your DH is able to take a step back.
He could easily have stepped in and said 'back off SIL, my wife has her sick mother staying, ask our parents to mind the dog. You are punishing us for offering to do you a favour'.

Why are you taking on this guilt and self blame? Are you usually so hard on yourself yet making everything nice for others?
Please be nicer to yourself and let this go. You've done absolutely nothing wrong. The SIL is good at guilt tripping.
People with poor boundaries (I'm one too!) get easily triggered when our defence mechanism of 'rescuing' is called into into question.
We pride ourselves on being nice, and lovely. Women are socialised to be the 'good girl' who helps everyone, so very very difficult emotions of blame and self hatred are aroused in us when we cannot make ourselves available to others in ways we intended.
Please let this go and concentrate on your own family. You could also get a book on boundaries. I've just ordered one call Boundaries Boss by Terri Cole. I listened to her podcast and it was an eye opener for me because it's me all over.
psychcentral.com/blog/podcast-boundary-setting-for-women

WhimsicalGubbins · 13/08/2022 15:35

Have to admit, I jumped to the same judgements as many other posters, that you were being weirdly precious about a simple keg break-until I stepped back and decided to read all your replies

So apologies for jumping to the wrong judgement at first.
Your SIL is an entitled, selfish bitch. You don’t need that kind of constant stress in your life. I had a best friend like her, she made it very hard work to be friends, and in the end I walked away. If everything didn’t always go the way she expected it, then she would turn nasty, for however long she felt like, then one day would randomly be nice again like it never happened.

An hour and a half away is too far to travel every day-multiple times. There’s just not enough hours in the day. If someone asks you to dogsit, you’re doing THEM the favour, Not the other way around. It should primarily be on your terms or they can go whistle.
Dont enable her behaviour-it’s clearly what people have been doing her whole life, because she doesn’t have any compassion for another living soul except herself

BellePeppa · 13/08/2022 15:34

Why don’t they put the dog in boarding. My dog has been several times and seems to love it (I checked their credentials thoroughly).

toomuchlaundry · 13/08/2022 15:33

@meex not all dogs are passive (and this one doesn’t sound as if it is) and would be happy snoozing on the sofa all day whilst DH is busy in meetings.

Some dogs need attention not just company

MRex · 13/08/2022 15:27

SoupDragon · 13/08/2022 15:18

It's not about only being able to do one thing at a time. Have you even read the OP's posts? It was not "perfectly possible" to keep their commitment to the SIL since she would not compromise and let them look after the dog in the OP's home.

i absolutely would not expect someone to look after my dog if they were unexpectedly having to look after their 80 year old mother who had broken her leg and needed frequent hospital trips due to other health issues because I'm not a selfish arse. I can't believe anyone would expect that in these circumstances.

Not quite. SIL thought her brother would have still looked after the dog, while OP looked after her mother. But OP decided she can't look after her mother on her own and needs DH there, while the DH thinks he can't look after a dog on his own while working from home. We can agree the SIL was being unreasonable to lay out demands instead of being flexible once the situation changed. Many of us though feel a bit baffled as to why one adult can't look after a dog when working from home, and another adult can't assist her mum on her own. There may be reasons that haven't been given about why both are so codependent, but it seems odd to those of us who are used to being a bit more capable individually.

EmmaH2022 · 13/08/2022 15:26

Xpost Inquiring wish you better asap.

EmmaH2022 · 13/08/2022 15:25

vroom321 · 13/08/2022 15:06

No obviously not but people keep bringing up that one comment I made.

Because it demonstrated the insanity of trying to do the two things.

I wonder if anyone will come back and say "I was wrong" or if they are gfs.

InquiringMinds · 13/08/2022 15:24

RoversEnd · 13/08/2022 12:56

@Hangingoninthere88 Thank you for this advice. I am an overthinker and the last week has had me not sleeping at all so I’m pretty emotional. 👍

I guess I’m just feeling overwhelmed. I’m scared about my Mums health. I’m scared I’m going to lose her, I know this is ‘just a broken leg’ but with her health complications it’s got me worried sick. I guess this fall has made me realise her age. She’s my best friend other than DH, always has been.

I am just going to forget about building and kind of relationship with SIL now. It’ll be cordial only. Im just concentrating on my Mum, DH and DD.

I suffered a severe hamstring tear grade 3 early hours of Friday morning OP. Just out of A & E yesterday and my entire leg and foot have swollen up. My pain is excruciating. I am mentioning this as I cannot even begin to imagine the pain your Mum is in and the last thing I would want is a dog damaging the leg more. Your Mum is elderly and you have made the right decision. Anyone who disagrees with this has no clue how fragile bones at her age can be. Whenever we have gone away, we always had a reliable back up plan for our pets. Stick to putting your Mum first. You are doing the right thing ♥️

toomuchlaundry · 13/08/2022 15:23

@vroom321 many people are picking up your comment as it is not a suitable solution with a very bouncy dog

GoWokeGoBroke17 · 13/08/2022 15:23

What the hell does it matter if op could in theory still have the dog? The point of the post is that she has had a change in situation and no longer feels able to look after the dog- and, despite a perfectly reasonable backup of her own parents, SIL is being a massive twat.

Why are people so quick to loose their senses when dogs are involved? And I say that as a dog owner myself.

You are in no way being unreasonable here. Your SIL is being a selfish arse.