Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum broke leg, now SIL furious

393 replies

RoversEnd · 13/08/2022 09:14

So long story short my Mum broke her leg and we were meant to be dog sitting SIL’s dog this week as they are on holiday. We had to say we can’t do it as my Mum needs care. She’s on her own. I’m an only child and there is no-one else to help. We’ve got her a basic wheelchair and in cooking and caring for her. The response to this was that they are ‘furious’.

DH’s parents actually offered to look after the dog but apparently they can’t give ‘the dog what it needs’ for a week. There has been no concern for my Mum’s situation at all. SIL even said ‘I’m sorry to hear that RoversEnd and RoversEnd’s mum can’t handle this situation by themselves’.

AIBU to feel really hurt? I don’t have any siblings so I tried to make this relationship work for my DD’s sake so she has cousins to spend time with. DD is also an only child due to our secondary infertility. I feel like I’ve made a major effort trying to build this relationship and actually there’s nothing there. DH says he’s so disappointed that there’s no feeling or care for our situation whatsoever. I know she’s disappointed we can’t look after her dog, but her own parents offered to look after it too and sure they wouldn’t be able to take it for ten mile walks but they are very fit and healthy and could do a lot more than us, given we are in hospital every other day. In the end she said ‘she’s sorted something out’ and has now continued to talk on the family chat like nothings happened. I feel like removing myself from the group.

OP posts:
Eightiesfan · 13/08/2022 10:22

NoSquirrels · 13/08/2022 09:36

There has been no concern for my Mum’s situation at all. SIL even said ‘I’m sorry to hear that RoversEnd and RoversEnd’s mum can’t handle this situation by themselves’.

AIBU to feel really hurt?

I think that you are in fact unreasonable to be “really hurt”. Your SIL actually hasn’t said anything that bad if the above phrasing is the worst thing. They’ve sorted something else out and now they’re chatting ‘like nothing’s happened’ - and that’s probably because to them it’s done, time to move on.

If you’re an only child sometimes larger family dynamics can feel odd, but it’s how it is. People fall out a bit in frustration, then they move on. It’s not damaging to the relationship you’ve been building. Least said, soonest mended, as my gran would say.

Don’t overreact.

I disagree, SIL response was patronising and passive aggressive. OPs feelings are her own, she is entitled to be hurt considering the effort she’s made to develop a relationship with this woman. From where I stand it look like SIL is invested in this as much as it benefits her.

MRex · 13/08/2022 10:21

Stravaig · 13/08/2022 10:13

Tell SIL you're absolutely appalled/horrified/furious that they've not cancelled their holiday to help care for Mum. Don't add anything else, just that, and then stop interacting.

😂😂😂😂

Maybe suggest the dog be put in kennels so they can give it their full attention. And the in-laws too. The woman broke her leg dammit, it'll take at least 10 people to help pass her stuff she might want off the shelf.

Nahimjustaworm · 13/08/2022 10:21

Let SIL be furious and then offer her no further free services. No need to be nasty but no need to pander to it either. Life's too short jusy because she's your DH's sister she's only as relevant and important as you allow her to be. Don't stress. You've made your decision. She has a backup offer for dogsitting which she refuses to take up. It's her problem to fix. Hope your mum gets better soon x

UnicornsDoExist · 13/08/2022 10:20

I can understand why sil reacted the way she did 🤷🏻‍♀️They are meant to be going on holiday, bags packed then they get the news the dog sitter has fallen through. I’m sure the words she spoke were just sheer panic, she will probably regret them later and realise how ott she was. Hope she apologises!

Abraxan · 13/08/2022 10:20

Doidontimmm · 13/08/2022 09:17

To be honest I’m not quite sure why you still can’t have the dog?

An active dog who likes 10 mile walks is going to be a huge commitment in an already busy house, let alone where one vulnerable person has had to move in to be cared for and will need to be careful not to get knocked into, etc.

It's unfortunate for the sister but I'm afraid that's the risk when you have a pet. Sometimes your pet care will fall down and you need an alternative.

If they don't trust the alternative care offered they can use a paid for kennels instead.

AlexandriasWindmill · 13/08/2022 10:20

Lots of people break their leg and have a dog so I can understand why SIL was bemused that your DM having a broken leg means you and your DH can't keep a prior arrangement.
I also think it's fair for them not to want your ILs to stay in their house or watch their dog. Dogs are like children. You don't just leave them with anyone.

Badger1970 · 13/08/2022 10:20

Getting a dog looked after is a nightmare, decent kennels are booked up months ahead. Just from a dog owners point of view.

I hope your Mum recovers quickly OP.

SueSaid · 13/08/2022 10:18

Petronus · 13/08/2022 10:16

Some of these replies are weird. It’s a dog, op now has the more important job of looking after her mum. Why should she try to juggle both? The dog goes to the in-laws or to kennels. If someone was more worried about me looking after their dog than how my mum was I wouldn’t be doing them any more favours.

Exactly.

We've always had dogs but people come first.

You have my sympathies the op, your sil sounds a right entitled pita.

Frustratedandsneezy · 13/08/2022 10:18

It is a bit shit to be honest and you have let them down.

perimenofertility · 13/08/2022 10:18

This reply has been deleted

We've removed this post as it's not in the spirit.

Dotcheck · 13/08/2022 10:17

Lots of people manage just fine with a broken leg on their own
Jesus @Afterfire really?

wheresthetimegone4 · 13/08/2022 10:16

vroom321 · 13/08/2022 09:43

It depends how far they live from you.

Can't you leave your mum in a bedroom with the door shut?

Can't your husband stay with the dog?

Both can be left alone for a couple of hours.

Can't you leave your mum in a bedroom with the door shut?

Is this an actual joke?
Why on Earth should she have to do this just to accommodate rude and entitled people...?!

Petronus · 13/08/2022 10:16

Some of these replies are weird. It’s a dog, op now has the more important job of looking after her mum. Why should she try to juggle both? The dog goes to the in-laws or to kennels. If someone was more worried about me looking after their dog than how my mum was I wouldn’t be doing them any more favours.

SueSaid · 13/08/2022 10:14

Some awful comments on here. You offered to have the dog, your circumstances changed and now you can't. Of course your mum will be the priority and who cba walking dogs etc when you're actually looking after a person.

I'm sorry your sil is so very self centred op. She had the offer from her own parents it isn't as if they've had to cancel their trip. Her immediate response should have been 'no problem, I hope your dm is ok'.

Stravaig · 13/08/2022 10:13

Tell SIL you're absolutely appalled/horrified/furious that they've not cancelled their holiday to help care for Mum. Don't add anything else, just that, and then stop interacting.

wheresthetimegone4 · 13/08/2022 10:13

I think their response has been insensitive and inconsiderate. I would be reluctant to help them out at all. You're clearly having to adapt your day to day life by caring for your mum and they don't give a toss as they're only bothered about how it impacts them.

I don't understand posters who are suggesting ways for you to look after their dog when I wouldn't want to accommodate them at all after the comments they've made.

Allschoolsareartschools · 13/08/2022 10:12

YANBU & your comment about trying to build a relationship with SIL only to find there's nothing there really struck a chord with me.
It was a very kind offer in the first place from your mum & of course she can no longer do it.
SIL sounds rather entitled, I'd distance a fair bit in future.

billy1966 · 13/08/2022 10:12

YANBU.

Do not remove yourself from the WhatsApp.

However, her reaction is very rude and selfish..

This is knowledge, and knowledge is power.

She has given you a direct insight into who she is.

So tuck that information away and adapt.

You do not have to have a big reaction, but you can definitely take this on board and accept this is who she is, rather than who you hoped she was.

Be glad you have found out.

I hope your mum makes a great recovery.

KettrickenSmiled · 13/08/2022 10:12

Doidontimmm · 13/08/2022 09:17

To be honest I’m not quite sure why you still can’t have the dog?

To be honest I'm not quite sure why PP are focused on the fucking dog.

The dog will be cared for by PiL.
OP's mum is just a tad more important right now, no?

MindPalace · 13/08/2022 10:11

Sorry OP, your SIL sounds awful. And no, you should not have to look after your mother and a dog. Your mother comes first. x

MRex · 13/08/2022 10:10

I would never have agreed to shifting the whole family off to their house for a week, that's a ridiculous imposition and quite unreasonable. That said, I don't understand what's incompatible about having a dog and a person with a broken leg, you only need to give each of them a bit of support and you must have anticipated you'd be causing then enormous stress by saying on such short notice that you wouldn't take the dog. It really needn't take 3 of you to support one person with a broken leg either, I don't recall us needing to do anything much when a flatmate broke his leg apart from get stuff from high cupboards and I managed fine living alone with a broken arm many years back, most people just get on despite the inconvenience really.

There were a range of sensible options; dog staying with you as well as mum, a dog walker going to the in-laws, your DH going to their house while your stay with mum etc. What would you have done if they'd already left, surely you'd have just made it work rather than throw your hands up in horror? SIL grumped in a panic, but some people react like that to stress and it's best ignored if it's as mild as what you've said here. So you've all been unreasonable. Time to move on from it and don't offer favours next time if you aren't all capable of flexing plans for the unexpected.

AboutDamnThyme · 13/08/2022 10:10

I wish I was surprised by the lack of empathy for the OP on here but sadly I'm not.

Caring for an incapacitated elderly parent is fucking hard, even moreso when you don't have other family for back up.

Add in the fact it's the school holidays and OP has a child to look after and a dog that doesn't sound particularly well trained and would have to be out of it's home environment.

Your SIL has clearly had an empathy bypass and the attitude and passive aggressive comments would piss me right off. That said if she appears to have moved on for the sake of peace I would try to take a bit of space and do the same.

Giving her the benefit of the doubt from a distance it's possible she carried on like that as she was stressed about the last minute change of plans, although in that case I think an apology should be forthcoming.

KettrickenSmiled · 13/08/2022 10:10

AIBU to feel really hurt?

In the kindest sense OP - YABU.
Because you are daft to be hurt by a woman who is so monumentally selfish.
Her attitude does not reflect on you, only on herself.

Her dog will be absolutely fine with her own parents, but she is kicking off because she can't have her first preference. Instead of looking at the reason for that, & having compassion for your poor mum, she used it as a stick to beat you with. She wasn't even able to ask after your mum's condition.

I don’t have any siblings so I tried to make this relationship work for my DD’s sake so she has cousins to spend time with. DD is also an only child due to our secondary infertility. I feel like I’ve made a major effort trying to build this relationship and actually there’s nothing there.

I am sorry about your struggle to conceive a second child. So again - please accept this in the gentle sense it is meant - do you think SiL has picked up on your desire to keep a close relationship, so knows she has the upper hand? Selfish people like SiL don't have much in the way of self-awareness but they have a shark-sharp sense of other people's vulnerabilities. How else are they going to use people, unless they know who & how to attack?!

Stop with the major efforts. She's not your sister - DH can ensure the relationship remains tolerable & facilitate cousinly get-togethers. Depending on ages, you might find for example that SiL is happy with sleepovers at yours to get a break from her DC. Bending over backwards for this woman has not got you the easy relationship or even common courtesy you'd like, so stop doing it. Women like SiL see kindness as weakness, & it makes them treat you even worse.

TL:DR = don't be hurt. Be righteously pissed off.
If you need to speak to SiL about it (I wouldn't bother, but don't know your circs), let rip with a few choice remarks about the gall of her being "furious" about having to use her second choice of dog care but not giving a shit about your mum's accident.

stuntbubbles · 13/08/2022 10:10

Mally100 · 13/08/2022 10:08

Fgs the op doesn't need to make it up to the sil. What is wrong with you people.

OP must now marry the dog and build SIL a palace, it’s the only atonement for her crime.

Mally100 · 13/08/2022 10:08

EmeraldShamrock1 · 13/08/2022 10:06

Can you offer to walk the dog over the holidays if her parents take care of the dog.

Fgs the op doesn't need to make it up to the sil. What is wrong with you people.