Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to clear out our life savings

39 replies

PumpkinMeadows · 13/08/2022 08:46

So, we were supposed to be selling our home and buying a new one. Two days before we were due to exchange, our buyers pulled out (no real reason given, though said they "may" change their minds again in a couple of months Hmm).

Anyway, the home we were buying is already a little bit of a stretch for us - but should be manageable. We managed to get together a 25% deposit, which was no mean feat.

Our sellers have given us two weeks to find another buyer, or the house goes back in the market.

We are of course considering that option, but time is against us.

Spoke to our broker who said we "might" just be able to get a let to buy mortgage on our current property, so we wouldn't have to sell it, then use the equity from there to buy our new home.

If we did this, we would have to reduce deposit to 15% and also clear out virtually every penny we have in savings. Mortgage payments would also increase by just over 25%. And of course the interest rate is a lot worse than on the current deal we have, but we would still fix for 5 years.

We would likely make a small profit on the first home on the rent, but it wouldn't come close to covering the additional 25% mortgage. That said, it's all theoretically doable based on our joint income (assuming we can even get the mortgage).

I'm just worried about having no savings at a time like this, considering the way the economy is going...but at the same time, we don't want to lose what we consider to be our "forever home".

Or should we be happy enough to know that at the worst, there is a property we could sell (albeit probably not very quickly) if we had to...

*ps - Name changed because family/friends know my regular user name.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JustLyra · 13/08/2022 13:12

Being a LL with no cash behind you would be madness.

I barely broke even last year because of a succession of events (boiler died, then a window was accidentally broken, then a void period, then the usual costs of freshening a place up and getting new tenants) and that’s in a property that has no mortgage.

If you can’t afford expensive repairs tomorrow, or a non-paying tenant, then you can’t afford to be a LL imo. It’s not something to take on lightly.

stayathomegardener · 13/08/2022 13:10

Be aware that you may not actually get a BTL mortgage in time, we are months down the line and have already had one offer withdrawn and the interest rate upped at an unprecedented stage in the process.

The levels of information required is also far in excess of an needed previously and stress tests are very high.

Thefruitbatdancer · 13/08/2022 13:10

Don't go for the buy to let mortgage and do not clear out your savings, this is sheer madness.

Thefruitbatdancer · 13/08/2022 13:09

Stick your current house back on the market at a slightly lower price marketed at cash & chain free buyers only. If it doesn't sell, I would look for a cheaper property or wait for another year to assess how the market is. But do not stretch yourselves to buy the ideal house because of the cost of living rises.

DisforDarkChocolate · 13/08/2022 13:00

That would be far too risky for me. Sounds like a broker after a commission not working in your long-term interests.

LumpyandBumps · 13/08/2022 12:58

@PumpkinMeadows

There are a few ways to try to mitigate risks. Obviously full background referencing for prospective tenants, rent guarantee insurance, a home owning guarantor, etc.
There is no real alternative to having the means to fund the property if there is no income.
There is no ‘can’t afford’ as a landlord. The law is firmly on the tenant’s side when it comes to repairs ( and again this is due to the minority of poor landlords), so if your tenant owes you 6 months rent and the boiler breaks and needs replacing you have no choice but to get the work done.
As I have several properties I can use them to fund each other if necessary, and that is how I manage this risk.
We are hopefully very unlikely to have something like lockdown again, but that was a real problem as I had some degree of issue in every property.
I used to have 3 small HMO type shared properties, and have moved away from that for all but one, due to the huge increases in fuel prices.
I am not looking for more properties. I don’t have any currently advertised for sale, and nor have I given tenants notices to quit, but I have one house that I will definitely look to sell if it becomes vacant.
If I was approached by a landlord wanting to buy the remainder of them with tenants in situ I would probably sell.
I assume that larger landlords with perhaps 10+ properties are in a better position as they can spread the load more, and have flexibility to offer alternative accommodation if necessary.
My view of the proposed changes are that, whilst I can of course see why people want secure tenancies, it will lead to reduced supply, which will make it harder for people to move on, and when the landlord finally gets the property back they may not be so keen to re let. That obviously depends on the sales market at the time.
If you do decide to go ahead I would recommend developing a thick skin. I have never had any issues with people openly criticising my choice to become a landlord, but the last 2 properties I advertised had 20+ applicants, nearly all were in unsuitable accommodation and desperate to find somewhere. I found it genuinely upsetting having to turn most of them down.

whalleyt · 13/08/2022 12:09

I think the economic climate is pretty dodgy & I reckon at some point there will be increases in taxes that aren't income or a wealth tax. My inlaws & their friends have all started getting rid of additional properties.

whalleyt · 13/08/2022 12:06

I think any sensible landlord needs a chunk of savings behind them.

Is the plan to sell the first house at some point. any profit will be subject to CGT won't it?

Eeksteek · 13/08/2022 11:52

I am a landlord, and I am part selling up. I am not a typical landlord and have different reasons for selling (largely around sub-optimal finance and different uses of my capital, not eviction reform, EPC or tax). In your situation, this wouldn’t bother me. Being fully stretched in these uncertain times, would though. You do need cash reserves, but if you have good jobs and being fully stretched includes a certain amount of luxury, which gives you wiggle room, I wouldn’t worry about it, providing you have a plan to build cash reserves reasonably soon, your property isn’t falling down and will make a reasonable profit going forward. Obviously only you know what those numbers are.

Be aware that you will be utterly vilified, at least online (this has never happened to me in person) the moment you reveal it. This doesn’t worry me much in itself, but if you use any form of online advice or support that’s not specifically for landlords, then you may lose that (this is fairly new in my experience)

GreenLunchBox · 13/08/2022 11:37

PumpkinMeadows · 13/08/2022 11:06

Hmmm, this change to the rules is giving me more pause for thought than anything.

I thought it would - in the long run - better to own two properties. But if existing landlords are looking to get out of this business, not sure it's something I want to try out as a newbie...

The insights are much appreciated.

Here's a thread if you want more insights
www.mumsnet.com/talk/property/4577781-if-you-are-a-landlord-are-you-thinking-of-selling-up?page=1

BluePineAndApple · 13/08/2022 11:31

Hi Op, we did this two years ago. Everything worked well for us (so far!) and no regrets. First year was a bit stressful as we didn't have any savings left but we've managed to build them up again.
Our old home went up in value as well as the rental income. In the worst case scenario you can always sell your old home and pay off the mortgage.
Good luck!

starpatch · 13/08/2022 11:29

I wouldn’t you will be overly invested in property really given we are on the brink of recession.

Lunar270 · 13/08/2022 11:23

I'm a landlord and am not looking to sell up. I'm not overly phased about the proposed changes really and it works for me and my tenants. It may change in the future but will address that as/when.

PumpkinMeadows · 13/08/2022 11:06

Hmmm, this change to the rules is giving me more pause for thought than anything.

I thought it would - in the long run - better to own two properties. But if existing landlords are looking to get out of this business, not sure it's something I want to try out as a newbie...

The insights are much appreciated.

OP posts:
Darkstar4855 · 13/08/2022 11:03

I’d put yours back on the market at a slightly lower price to try and get a quick sale, or else let the dream home go. I wouldn’t take the risk of letting your current house. If your tenants stop paying it can take months and cost a fortune to get them out.

GreenLunchBox · 13/08/2022 11:02

I'm a landlord and I'm strongly considering selling up next year

PumpkinMeadows · 13/08/2022 10:58

@LumpyandBumps Thank you - I'm not clued up about this admittedly. I only skimmed something as it was flagged by a previous poster - but I will do some reading up on this.

Can I ask, as a Landlord - does it make you want to now sell off your properties? Is there any solution for landlords (other than having large cash reserves)?

When running numbers, I have accounted for some time where rent wouldn't be paid - I'd factored in 8 months. But generally speaking, I do think I need to just re look at everything. Thank you for your advice

OP posts:
GreenLunchBox · 13/08/2022 10:47

LumpyandBumps · 13/08/2022 10:41

On the no fault evictions point, according to the government consultation: "The grounds for possession will be reformed to ensure landlords have effective means to gain possession of their properties when necessary. New grounds will be created to allow landlords to sell or move close family members into the property. Grounds concerning persistent rent arrears and anti-social behaviour will be strengthened."
So not too worried about this.

I am an existing landlord, with several properties. I would strongly suggest that you take further advice. These proposals are just that. There is every chance they will be revised in the tenants’ favour as the consultation progresses, as happened in Scotland.
The ‘ no reason’ section 21 ground for possession is in the process of being abolished. Of course there are some some scum bag landlords who abused it, but for many of us it was the only way of getting rid of an anti social tenant.
Yes, there is an eviction ground relating to anti social behaviour, but only a very naive person would currently try to use that without a conviction or similar as evidence for that action.
Section 8 already covers rent arrears. In theory if someone is currently in arrears by 2 months the notice period to quit can be very short, as little as 14 days. If they don’t leave ( and bear in mind that even people who wish to cooperate can’t always secure alternative accommodation), then expensive and time consuming court action is necessary. Add into that equation that if their only option is social housing the local council will be telling them that they MUST stay put or they will be treated as intentionally homeless and the local council don’t then have to help them.
It is very easy to get court papers wrong, and all of the free advice is for the tenant.
I have found paying to belong to a landlord group has been invaluable.
You COULD end up with no rent, court fees, possibly your own legal fees, for up to a year due to problems with paperwork, court listing delays, deliberate prevarication, etc.
Even when you have a judgement you might then have more delays and expense in instructing bailiffs.
If you don’t have sufficient funds to cover the mortgage for at least 6 months or so, and a contingency that will cover for an unexpected major cost, such as an extensive boiler repair you might end up in a very vulnerable position.

It's good of you to be so patient

I was just astounded anybody would take what this government announce and believe them, so didn't bother trying to explain!

LumpyandBumps · 13/08/2022 10:41

On the no fault evictions point, according to the government consultation: "The grounds for possession will be reformed to ensure landlords have effective means to gain possession of their properties when necessary. New grounds will be created to allow landlords to sell or move close family members into the property. Grounds concerning persistent rent arrears and anti-social behaviour will be strengthened."
So not too worried about this.

I am an existing landlord, with several properties. I would strongly suggest that you take further advice. These proposals are just that. There is every chance they will be revised in the tenants’ favour as the consultation progresses, as happened in Scotland.
The ‘ no reason’ section 21 ground for possession is in the process of being abolished. Of course there are some some scum bag landlords who abused it, but for many of us it was the only way of getting rid of an anti social tenant.
Yes, there is an eviction ground relating to anti social behaviour, but only a very naive person would currently try to use that without a conviction or similar as evidence for that action.
Section 8 already covers rent arrears. In theory if someone is currently in arrears by 2 months the notice period to quit can be very short, as little as 14 days. If they don’t leave ( and bear in mind that even people who wish to cooperate can’t always secure alternative accommodation), then expensive and time consuming court action is necessary. Add into that equation that if their only option is social housing the local council will be telling them that they MUST stay put or they will be treated as intentionally homeless and the local council don’t then have to help them.
It is very easy to get court papers wrong, and all of the free advice is for the tenant.
I have found paying to belong to a landlord group has been invaluable.
You COULD end up with no rent, court fees, possibly your own legal fees, for up to a year due to problems with paperwork, court listing delays, deliberate prevarication, etc.
Even when you have a judgement you might then have more delays and expense in instructing bailiffs.
If you don’t have sufficient funds to cover the mortgage for at least 6 months or so, and a contingency that will cover for an unexpected major cost, such as an extensive boiler repair you might end up in a very vulnerable position.

GreenLunchBox · 13/08/2022 10:35

If it's a pylon in your garden,OP, I get why you're contorting yourself 🙈

applegrumbles · 13/08/2022 10:12

You’d be absolutely mad to do this. Sorry!

PumpkinMeadows · 13/08/2022 09:59

Thank you.

@GreenLunchBox I didn't know about that EPC rule - thank you. I just looked it up, would apply to existing BTLs from 2028 (if introduced).

That said, the property is already at a high D, and that doesn't factor in some changes we made in the last couple of years which would move the needle further. May take us into a c, or not far off. But it's a good thing to know.

On the no fault evictions point, according to the government consultation: "The grounds for possession will be reformed to ensure landlords have effective means to gain possession of their properties when necessary. New grounds will be created to allow landlords to sell or move close family members into the property. Grounds concerning persistent rent arrears and anti-social behaviour will be strengthened."
So not too worried about this.

@Ohsugarhoneyicetea - yes, negative equity wouldn't be good 

@Northernsoullover If we had to /couldn't afford it from our salary income / income from the rental (bear in mind we don't need the rental profit to pay the new mortgage), we could borrow from our childrens savings in an emergency. But that would be a last last last resort. Like we generally don't even act like their money exists. It is for them. But they would still ultimately own both properties at the end of all this. Right now, they are both very little.

It's a big risk though...a big one. Going to rerun and stress test these numbers.

We did get a few offers on the house pretty quickly (after first day of showing). Took the highest. Looking around, there isn't much available now in this price range that's this sort of size. It may still prove attractive. That said, it's one of those houses where there is an external factor which means despite the house, you may (because of the external factor) not want to live here. Even though, having lived here for years, it hasn't proven to be an issue. But it does give people pause - and some have said it was the sole reason they would offer.

OP posts:
GreenLunchBox · 13/08/2022 09:59

The survey results are a red flag when added to this scenario

This whole thing is screaming 'dont do it'

Discovereads · 13/08/2022 09:53

Nope, don’t do it. There are lots of houses out there. There isn’t only one “forever” home out there. This is a sign from the Universe to start over or stay put. I’d say it’s a lucky escape from a property that is a financial stretch in dire economic times.

Northernsoullover · 13/08/2022 09:50

What would happen if your tenants didn't pay rent on the BTL? Or the boiler went? I wouldn't do it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread