Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Oh she looks so much like you, or me when I was younger or just basically anyone like you, the mother’

137 replies

OhDoOne77 · 12/08/2022 23:22

Not said like this obviously, but may aswell be.
Sil has always said and still continues to say how much Dd (4) looks like Dh or failing that, looks like her when she was younger (nothing like her) or their mum etc…or brother…just basically anyone but me.
It pissed me off when Dd was a baby but royally pisses me off now, as she says it in front of her

Aibu to feel rage?

OP posts:
Catsstillrock · 13/08/2022 01:46

Yes it’s the imbalance that makes it noticeable.

Totally normal to discuss it, and look for resemblance to your own family.

Not normal to never, ever acknowledge obvious traits like being fair or having blue eyes have likely come from the fair blue eyed parent.

one of our DC is more like DH and it’s fun to see photos of him as a kid and see the similarities and I join in.

but then,, given virtually everyone else we come across friend, family or stranger (so it’s not memories or genes talking) comments on how like me our other DC is it’s very noticeable that the in laws have never acknowledged or commented on that.

ClinkeyMonkey · 13/08/2022 01:30

I have certainly never had a problem with my children looking like DP's family. Why would I? Half their genes were contributed by DP. But it was definitely used as a stick to beat me with. I was sick of hearing about DS1's resemblance to his uncle, his three aunties, his cousin's cat. It was a joke. And if anyone said 'oh, but he's got Clinkey's blue eyes', there was silence. Honestly, nothing. Because they all have brown eyes. They did try to scrabble around for someone with blue eyes to attribute DS's eyes to, but were unsuccessful! My own family made the odd remark, but it was fleeting, conversational. With DP's mum in particular, it was like a fight to the death. Very territorial. But not a surprise, given the way she behaves in every other area of life.

Changechangychange · 13/08/2022 01:09

You recognise whoever you are most used to seeing in the baby. Presumably your SIL didn’t see much of you as a child, so she “sees” your DH, herself etc.

DM thinks DS5 looks like DBro as a child. DH thinks he looks like me (same colouring, hair and eyes, totally different face). There’s a black and white photo of DH on FIL’s wall, and DS thought it was a picture of him. He looks kind of like all of us. The only person we all agree he looks nothing like is SIL.

PrinnyPree · 13/08/2022 01:01

Also OP remember that your in laws only have seen their side of the family as babies so your DH, SIL etc, they never saw you as a baby so they will draw upon their own memories of what their family members looked like as babies when they were the same age as your child. Don't take it personally. Xx

Merryoldgoat · 13/08/2022 00:57

I’m not sure I really see the issue.

My boys are the image of DH and his side of the family.

I’m mixed black and white, DH white. Both boys look white, one is blonde and blue eyed. As a friend says, it’s like I didn’t show up to the conception.

saraclara · 13/08/2022 00:53

Actually, it was my own mum who did the possessive similarities thing, now I think about it. And yep, it irritated me no end, because DD1 was the spit of her dad and my MIL!

saraclara · 13/08/2022 00:48

I don't get the whole competitiveness thing though! Why does it bother mums on here that their in-laws see their family resemblances? The kid is literally half their side of the family's genes. They're as entitled to find similarities to their own family, as you are to see similarities to you.

The poster who's disappointed that her dh doesn't 'defend her' when his family say they see a resemblance to him? That's just batshit. Who should he? They see what they see, and are entitled to see.

Jeeeze, it's some weird kind of paranoia to be threatened by this. It really is. The baby is not 100% the mother's and you can't make it so.

xJoyfulCalmWisdomx · 13/08/2022 00:32

Maybe it's what your SIL sees though!?

I know you say she has form but why would ''DD looks like ....{somebody from her side of the family} be a dig?

In a way I think it's like saying we feel connected to her.

My x mil used to say everything good was inherited from her but she believed it. I don't think it was a dig at me! We were very different physically.

Missmarps · 13/08/2022 00:30

I get you too OP. My in laws used to do this constantly when my DCs were younger. We used to reply that they just look like themselves.

As they grew up they both looked more and more like me. My DD (now a teenager) is the spitting image of me at her age (and my mum). So much so, it's only the 80s clothes that give away which is a photo of me and not her.

They still try to insist she looks like SIL despite the totally different face shape, hair/eye colour, figure, nose.. just because she has curly hair totallyignoring the fact that I have curly hair too 🙄

I just smile and ignore.

Dummycrusher · 13/08/2022 00:28

I think you probably know deep down that it's not meant as an insult and she probably doesn't realise it annoys you. But I totally get why it is annoying! It's natural to feel territorial over your kids. My MIL is DESPERATE to find similarities between my daughter and my partner (MIL's son) and comes out with photos of him as a kid which look nothing like my daughter 😀 In truth, she is the spitting image of me and everyone always says so - and I think MIL actually feels the same kind of annoyance as you because she is protective of her darling boy 😂

teaandtoastwithmarmite · 13/08/2022 00:26

I get this. My dd is the spit of DH's sister. Yes they do have similar features like hair and stuff but never mind she might look a bit like me Confused

OhDoOne77 · 13/08/2022 00:24

@Whohastheenergyfotthis I would so love it if she meant it in a positive way towards me, I really don’t think it is though…but such a nicer way of looking at things

OP posts:
Whohastheenergyfotthis · 13/08/2022 00:20

@OhDoOne77 it does sound pretty annoying, but honestly 90% people are just grappling for some way to engage on the topic of a baby or a toddler. I find parents exceedingly difficult to deal with on the topic of their children in any sort of benign way. It can feel like they’re on a hair trigger of being judged as parents, or they think you’re judging their child.

Parents are great and all but they can be so neurotic, most people are not going to care that much either way about your children, they may love them because they are family but they likely won’t really have any strong opinions about anything- how they look, how the act etc.

Maybe it’s some weird coded message designed to make you feel uncomfortable, or, more likely she thinks it’s a nice thing to talk about the continuity with other members of the family that she knows best. She’s probably saying in her own way “we love your DD, she’s so connected to us and our family, she’s one of us”. Think about how unpleasant it would be if every time you saw her she said “gosh she really is all your side isn’t she? I can’t see us at all, she looks like you, but not her dad at all- or any of us really”. I mean she could just not say the same thing over and over again, but I have some sympathy for people who run out of material on this stuff.

ReadtheReviews · 13/08/2022 00:20

Oh get this all the time. Both my children have dh colouring so at a glance are like him, but totally have my features, eyes, nose, mouth,face shape. Anyone who knows him says oh they look just like their dad. Anyone who knows me says they look like me. It is annoying that dh doesn't correct them actually.

OhDoOne77 · 13/08/2022 00:17

@ClinkeyMonkey That sounds so familiar!

OP posts:
ClinkeyMonkey · 13/08/2022 00:15

I completely get where you're coming from, OP. I had this with DS1 - the outlaws constantly claiming him as one of them. One of DP's aunties even said 'You missed out there Clinkey, he's a ...' (insert DP's family name here). Missed out? Alrighty then. Anyway, I love spotting family resemblances, but it's all in how it's said. DP's family were deliberately trying to push me to the sidelines because they are very, very controlling. They hated that I was breastfeeding and hated that I wouldn't let him stay with them when he was just a few weeks old. So it made them feel better to stake a claim on DS. They would rush off and produce photos (on one occasion a tea towel with DP's brother printed on it🤣) just to prove how he was one of them. By the time he was about 5 they had quietly stopped, because he really was the double of my brother. Still is, right down to the mad hair!

DS2 came along a few years later and there was barely a squeak about who he resembled. Funny enough he looks almost identical to DP when he was young. But I reckon the steam had just gone out of the whole resemblance thing by then and they probably didn't want to say too much in case he morphed into me or my brother😃

OhDoOne77 · 13/08/2022 00:14

@saraclara I still think she’s doing it deliberately to try to claim her as being fully their family or to piss me off 😁

OP posts:
Arthursmom · 13/08/2022 00:10

My MIL has said many times how much DS looks like my partner and his uncle and grandfather. Things is, we're a same sex couple and used a sperm donor. Our son is literally NO genetic relation to that side of the family. Also. He's basically my twin 😂

saraclara · 13/08/2022 00:06

OhDoOne77 · 13/08/2022 00:00

@saraclara It’s really interesting

We did ivf though, so no doubt she’s his

Yes, but it's a subconscious and primitive thing that isn't overridden by anything up to date. And as they're not aware of it themselves, they can't say to themselves 'well of course he's the dad because ivf', because they don't know that some primitive part of the brain is firing in the first place.

What I'm trying to say is that it's unreasonable to get so angry over it, or be plotting ways to combat it. If it is deliberate it'll be obvious that you're rattled, and if it isn't (and that's my guess) then it's pointless. Just ignore it. It's what people do and it's probably only sticking out to you because you don't like SIL. If it was a much loved sweet auntie, you'd barely notice I bet. And that's normal too.

dottieautie · 13/08/2022 00:06

Yanbu !

My poor niece is my double and my mother is forever going on about it. My SIL gets really hurt because she doesn’t have any other family or her own baby photos to compare to. I’ve asked my mum not to say it and to just think it in to herself but she won’t because she thought she’d “never see that same small face again” and can’t help herself (her reasoning).

my nephew (nieces twin) looks like none of us and in a way it just compounds my sil’s lack of family tree because we don’t know which part of the family he takes after.

I always like to point out they look like DNeice and DNephew and no one else and they both love that.

Restingbiatchface · 13/08/2022 00:03

My response to that is isn't it funny how people see different resemblances as many have said she's more my side than DH. I guess people see different things.

I always get that my DD is the image of DH which is fine but it's annoying when people go on and on. I guess my illogical irritation is that I do the main share of parenting/time with her and desperately want to resemble my child HmmBlush. Makes no sense but I feel your annoyance.

MargaretThursday · 13/08/2022 00:02

MermaidSwimming · 12/08/2022 23:37

Mil used to do this, I then showed her a photo of me age 4 and she thought it was DD! She then changed comments to personality stuff that is 'same as x person on dh side of family'

Yes, my MIL did that with dd1. Every little thing was equated to her family.

I remember when we were out, and I put my hand out to take dd1's hand to cross the road. Dd1 put her hands behind her back and she said:
"Oh look, she walks with her hands behind her, bil did that all the time."
To which I replied: "She's not doing it all the time, she just did it because she didn't want me to hold her hand."
"He did that too..."

DD2 is unmistakably my family through and through so that stopped that one 🤣

Interestingly ds is absolutely dh's spitting image, to a point that people have stopped each of them when alone in the street and asked if they are dh's son/ ds' dad, and she's nothing like as bad with him.

Ladypeg · 13/08/2022 00:01

I had this and it used to annoy me too. My daughter DID look a lot like her Dad, I have to admit, but had curly brown hair. Ex MIL used to say she probably got it from his great aunt…..completely ignoring the fact that I had curly brown hair too! Couldn’t possibly have come from her mother 🤣 As it happens she looks a lot like me now that she’s older, scarily so. I’m no longer with him so don’t have close contact with his family, I’m not sure that they would ever say she was like me even though it’s commented on so much by other people now.

OhDoOne77 · 13/08/2022 00:00

@saraclara It’s really interesting

We did ivf though, so no doubt she’s his

OP posts:
saraclara · 12/08/2022 23:57

Doesn't everyone do this? We think that new members of the family look like the family members that we've known all our lives, partly because they're the people we knew as babies/small children. So our in-laws will relate the child to their own family members.

There might well also be quite a primitive and subconscious thing going on for the father's family. Paternity can never be taken for granted, so though they don't realise they're doing it, they're binding the child to their family by finding resemblances that 'prove' that the baby does have the fathers genes.

I read somewhere years ago, that when a new baby is born, midwives and doctors are more likely to point out to parents that the baby has a feature of the father's, than they are to say a feature of the mothers, by a long, long, way. Something like four times as likely. And the researcher's theory was the same. That subconsciously they're reassuring the dad that he's the father.

Swipe left for the next trending thread