Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

‘Oh she looks so much like you, or me when I was younger or just basically anyone like you, the mother’

137 replies

OhDoOne77 · 12/08/2022 23:22

Not said like this obviously, but may aswell be.
Sil has always said and still continues to say how much Dd (4) looks like Dh or failing that, looks like her when she was younger (nothing like her) or their mum etc…or brother…just basically anyone but me.
It pissed me off when Dd was a baby but royally pisses me off now, as she says it in front of her

Aibu to feel rage?

OP posts:
Classicblunder · 13/08/2022 11:01

Pugdogmom · 13/08/2022 08:50

Can't say any of it bothers me much, but I did giggle at my daughters MIL's friend who insisted that our granddaughter looks like her MIL.
One has blonde hair and blue eyes, and the other has long dark hair and brown eyes.🤦‍♀️. Not sure where the " resemblance" came from. 🤔

Hair colour and eye colour isn't everything - sometimes someone can have identical facial features/structure to someone but totally different hair/eye colour

My kids are like that - they look a lot more like my DH but he was blond and blue eyed and they have dark hair and eyes

buzz91 · 13/08/2022 10:57

If any of my IL’s say anything like this my dh just says, she looks like buzz91 and then will whip out an old photo of me - she looks like me with their hair line though so she’s a mix

Teoteo · 13/08/2022 10:49

@OhDoOne77 oh I totally get you! I get this from my MIL! I have jet black hair as does my baby. DH hair and whole of his family is light brown. MIL: "where does baby get his black hair from? It must be from Sarah (MIL's youngest daughter whose hair is slightly darker brown) HmmHmmHmm

Teddletime · 13/08/2022 10:35

@saraclara
I completely agree. So many posters on here desperate to refute any connection with the father of the child's family then have a meltdown when the MIL having been completely sidelined by her takes huge delight in her daughter's children.
You reap what you sow

Pixiedust1234 · 13/08/2022 10:07

You are being over sensitive. Its normal to compare a child to its relatives. I think you must dislike your sil a lot and using this as an excuse.

My first looks like me and several family members, absolutely nothing of dh in her. My second doesn't look like either of us. It was discussed at length by both sides then one day an old photo of mil as a child was found. Spitting image of dd at the same age. Took us 6 years to "place" her 😂

Just let it go.

35965a · 13/08/2022 10:02

Maray1967 · 13/08/2022 09:51

There is a right way of doing this and a wrong way of doing it. My MIL did it the right way. She used to say things like ‘sometimes I think he is all (my) DH but now I think he’s definitely got a look of (my brother), what does your dad think?’ She never tried to write me out of my child’s features. To say that a child is just like/100per cent/all their son or daughter, is crass beyond belief. Particularly when that child is an ivf baby and therefore presumably taken a while to arrive with some heartache along the way.

This is v true ^

It is totally fine to comment on resemblance, but some people are a bit thoughtless about it. If I’m cooing over a baby or toddler I try to say about both parents “she’s got her daddy’s eyes but mummy’s beautiful smile” or something like that.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 13/08/2022 09:58

Mil used to do this. Dd1 apparently gets her intelligence from dh too (my GCSEs were marginally higher than dh but whatever). My df passive aggressively posted a photo of me age 2 and everyone commented dd1 was identical to me (yep) so much so even mil had to concede. She’s not mentioned it since.

stopringingme · 13/08/2022 09:56

My DD when she was born was the spitting image of my DH, it made my MIL go into overdrive about how she looked the exact image of her dad.

She now has my features and my MIL studies her face intently to try and find similarities, but everything she comes out with are my features and my DH has said quite a few times when she has mentioned something "yes just like her Mummy!"

I just groan internally as it is just the way she is, it is annoying and the only time it really got to me was when my Mum died and she said a few times how DD looked like her and had the same dimples I just looked at her and said yes like my Mum, there was really nothing she could say.

Michellebops · 13/08/2022 09:54

I'm sure she'll change and you'll have the last laugh.

My daughter is almost 7 and for the first 4 years the spit of her dad, now she's more like me with a different colour hair.

My nephew is my brothers (his dad) doppelgänger and my niece is my double. Even more than my daughter. Pics of my niece and nephew from school are double of my brother and I.

Maray1967 · 13/08/2022 09:51

There is a right way of doing this and a wrong way of doing it. My MIL did it the right way. She used to say things like ‘sometimes I think he is all (my) DH but now I think he’s definitely got a look of (my brother), what does your dad think?’ She never tried to write me out of my child’s features. To say that a child is just like/100per cent/all their son or daughter, is crass beyond belief. Particularly when that child is an ivf baby and therefore presumably taken a while to arrive with some heartache along the way.

saraclara · 13/08/2022 09:50

I wonder if dads resent their partner's family enjoying seeing resemblances.

I'm as certain as I can be that the families of the mothers on here also make the same observations, but the mum barely notices and certainly doesn't feel the need to challenge them.

As a grandparent, I know that our wider family comment on likenesses when they see my DD's little girl.

Choccyp1g · 13/08/2022 09:45

DS was the image of his dad as a baby.

We used to joke that he had his father's looks and his mother's brains. Just as well really, as I'm nothing special in the looks department, and his father is a bit dim.

brookstar · 13/08/2022 09:41

Isn't this just normal?
When DHs family talk about how much DS is like his dad, grandad etc I think it's lovely. I think DH is handsome so if he looks like him then I'll be happy!

saraclara · 13/08/2022 09:31

"Well I'd like to think she gets that from me seen as I made her"

So her father had nothing to do with making her? She's 100% your genes?

saraclara · 13/08/2022 09:29

Yep, there's so much reluctance here to allow the baby's father's family to express anything that links the baby to them. It's quite bizarre and possessive. Like an extension of the MIL issue on mumsnet really.

Yet more reason to feel sorry for, not just MILs but their entire families.On mumsnet they really are second class citizens who are not allowed anything like the same stake in their new relative as the maternal family.

Again, I'm glad to be the mother of daughters.

Ilikeanimalsmorethanpeople · 13/08/2022 09:26

My MIL does this all the time, everything about DD comes from her family, I do have a few stock responses that always go down well.

"Well I'd like to think she gets that from me seen as I made her"

"Ah that's fine if she looks like your brood hopefully she will get my personality"

But I am a passive aggressive wank so 🙄

Lamentations · 13/08/2022 09:23

Me and my niece look identical in childhood photos. That's not an insult to her lovely mum.

LongLostTeacher · 13/08/2022 09:23

My MIL used to do this a lot and I found it really irritating. Every attribute came from her side of the family and it was honestly like she believed I had had nothing to do with creating our DCs. Unfortunately, this extended to potential negative attributes - “He’s so hard himself, just like his uncle x, and I’ve always been worried he’ll harm himself,” “Maybe she’s bipolar like my cousin,” “There’s a high chance they’ll be dyslexic as all my children are.”

For whatever reason she eased up when we had DC3 and is now much more likely to ask if anyone in my family was blonde as a child or whatever instead of just saying, oh that’s my so-and-so. Most of the negative attribute chat has stopped too, thank god.

KyaClark · 13/08/2022 09:21

My SIL used to get this about my niece and me. It must have pissed her right off.

Now, my niece is all her mum.

Damnautocorrect · 13/08/2022 09:20

I used to reply showing a picture of me as a child and passing it off as my child.
truth be told, some days they looked like me, others dh.
but it is an odd rudeness to utterly dismiss the other parents part in creating them. I don’t think it’s ever meant as that though. It does feel it though.

2ndMrsdeWinter · 13/08/2022 09:19

@Arthursmom laughed out loud at this! Aren’t people so bizarre sometimes.

lioncitygirl · 13/08/2022 09:17

Well - for starters I think you don’t like your sil, and perhaps she doesn’t like you too, and perhaps she’s saying that to annoy you, and your being annoyed because, well you don’t like her to begin with.

Its entirely possible that the kids look like their side of the family and not you too tho, you’re all related after all?

my daughter looks exactly like me - my daughter is almost my twin (tho she has brown hair and me black) there is no way she looks like anyone else and I might as well conceived her myself. My son, is more of a mix and I can see my husband in him a little - my inlaws always say he looks like my husband - his twin (he’s not) but I let it go - they can hardly say that about my daughter so 😂 - I’ll give them my son to claim.

Simonjt · 13/08/2022 09:17

scarletisjustred · 12/08/2022 23:28

People thought my son was adopted because he looked nothing like me. A carbon copy of his dad, as was my second son. Now the eldest looks like a young version of my dad.

Ours are adopted, we get people telling my husband our daughter looks like him, not only are they different ethnicities, even if they had the same skin colour they look nothing alike.

HavfrueDenizKisi · 13/08/2022 09:14

Yes your SIL is annoying and as you don't like her it's even more grating.

I'd retort with 'how funny as he's not even her father' and let her flipping squirm! Obviously warn your DH that her comments are pissing you off so you want to shut her up once and for all.

YourUserNameMustBeAtLeast3Characters · 13/08/2022 09:09

Firstly, my SIL does this about DS2. And I don’t get annoyed because she’s lovely and it’s true, and also DS1 looks almost entirely like me/my brother (which she also says). Once I showed her a photo of me at the same age as DS2 and sil was amazed how much he looked like me too (mostly the suspicious expression).

Secondly, my sister DID get annoyed with her in-laws for saying this about her DS. And that’s partly because they were quite annoying anyway, and definitely the sort to ‘claim’ things for their family - eg my sister and BIL’s house was always referred to as “Bill’s house” not “Bill and Wendy’s house” (names changed to reflect innocent parties).

I agree with PPs that there is an underlying biological need for the dad’s family to see their family in the child, and some reinforce this by the kind of verbal repetition you have with SIL. And my sister’s baby was also IVF - while you say there’s therefore no doubt of paternity, for some people it does create doubt about a mix up. And in fact my sister was worried (irrationally) when pregnant that there could have been a mix up, as their chances of success were so low (due to issues on both sides). So while it was reassuring to her that her son clearly looks like his dad’s family, she found not acknowledging her looks in him unsettling.

But mainly your SIL is just annoying.