Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband and son not getting on

33 replies

stressybessie33 · 12/08/2022 21:40

I have a ds11 and a dh - together 6 years, married 2. When ds was younger they got along well, always had a matey sort of dynamic between them as ds bio dad still very much in his life and dh didn't want to step on his toes. The matey relationship has veered into banter and teasing on both sides at times and has occasionally gone too far and caused rows.

Now ds is approaching his teenage years they are not getting on so well. Ds is admittedly being a little shit at times. Very sulky and rude, bad attitude. Anything, even the smallest request is met with huffing, puffing and protesting. Any reprimanding results in 'everyone hates me'. It is exhausting but par for the course in kids his age.

Dh doesn't get particularly involved in discipline but I know he thinks I'm too soft with ds. I maybe am. The kid has been through a lot and I love him to bits so I do let more slide than I maybe ought to. But when ds is directly rude to dh he will tell him off. Again, this is escalating more and more lately. There have been rows and bad atmosphere between the pair of them and it's making my life a misery. I am constantly mediating, trying to make dh see that ds is just a typical kid while also trying to explain to ds that his rudeness isn't acceptable.

Dh and I also have a baby and tbh I am knackered and fucked off with them all. I know people will say prioritise your ds, LTB etc. but truly I don't think that's the answer. Dh is a good man, he's done a lot for ds and me and our lives would be worse off without him. I once asked ds if he'd be happier just us and he said no. So this isn't a case of him being horrible to ds. It's just them not understanding each other and I guess dh not having that natural parental inclination to let shitty behaviour go like I do.

How can I improve this? I'm really worried about how things will get when ds is a teenager and really pushing boundaries. I love them both and constantly feel stuck in the middle. Has anyone else had this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
kateandme · 13/08/2022 20:36

Just for a little reassurance op.this isn’t just relegated to step and step kids. The teen years,a dad and his son…well shit the bed it can be horrid!ours was.they constantly went for each other.I’d go to say at one point didn’t like eacother.
I would say you dh needs to be able to parent.you say your doc has 2 parents.but your in a relationship with dh now.he needs to be allowed to be step dad.you not allowing this will be making your day unsure and possibly acting on that and making your dh feel more frustrated.
dcs need this walks,safety,boundaries.it’s actually what makes them feel safe.knowing there are rules,someone and so where safe where they can be told what and how to be and do things.where someone will catch them if they fall.
have you sat down as a 3. Discussed this together?

WalkingOnTheCracks · 13/08/2022 13:11

Robin233 · 13/08/2022 12:57

@WalkingOnTheCracks
Absolutely
Sometimes mums do need to step back
Had this between my kids.
In the end I said similar and more or less the minute I step back things changed.

Thank you.

In my case 'dad needed to step back'. But the principle applies in either case.

Robin233 · 13/08/2022 12:57

@WalkingOnTheCracks
Absolutely
Sometimes mums do need to step back
Had this between my kids.
In the end I said similar and more or less the minute I step back things changed.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 13/08/2022 10:56

We went through a bit of this when I got married, having a ten-year-old son from a previous relationship. I was always in the middle, trying to buffer, trying to prevent conflict. It was exhausting, and it was no solution.

I had to go away for a few days, early in the morning. I left a note in the kitchen which said...

"Dear spouse and son,

I can't keep mediating. It's no good for anyone.

You two need to work out your problems between you. You need to understand and then get along. As things are, we're all unhappy and I can't bear that.

Talk about it while I'm away. I mean, actually sit down and have a conversation.

Love you...."

And they did. Didn't solve everything, but it gave them a direct connection that I, in my desire to 'make it all alright', had got in the way of.

Things improved a lot after that, and twenty years later they still get on very well.

Robin233 · 13/08/2022 10:50

Lots to unpick here.
But acting like a mate to your ds has not afforded your dh the respect he's deserves.
He isn't his mate.
He is an adult and a step father.
You cannot be 'mates' with your kids.
The reason is because you may tell your best mate stuff that you wouldn't tell a child.
My dd has 2 fathers (one bio and one step)
They both parent - or did she's 30 now.
Kids need firm boundaries.
Not a bad tempered dad.
And if you left because of that - good on you by the way - your son needs the same protection.
It maybe even classed as abuse these days.

Pyewhacket · 13/08/2022 10:26

stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 09:16

@Pyewhacket you'd end your marriage because your pre pubescent son has an attitude problem? Ok then.

If I were your husband and was subject to abuse from an 11-year-old, such as you had described, and with no sanction from his parents, then yes, I would leave.

By your own admission, the problems with your son's behaviour and your priorities will affect your marriage.

I'm not sure what you expect from your husband but very few ppl would tolerate being spoken to like that for very long and you're starting to see the consequences of it now.

stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 09:56

@Robin233 his dad and I split up for this reason amongst many others. He does shout and can be intimidating but that's his parenting style. Totally different to mine but seems to work in the sense that he doesn't get the bad attitude and rudeness that we do.

I'm pretty sure I can't withhold contact because he shouts. I don't like it but ds is always happy to go there.

@YellowPlumbob you seem to have an agenda here which is to convince me that my dh is somehow abusive which couldn't be further from the truth. He takes a lot of shit from my ds without saying a word. Maybe you think it's acceptable for kids to be telling adults to shut up for no good reason, I don't. And I'm trying to work on it without alienating my ds or ruining the relationship that is left between him and dh.

OP posts:
Robin233 · 13/08/2022 09:47

@ZekeZeke

He has a dad who shouts is intimidating and has a temper.
A step dad who acts like a mate.
A mother who let's him away with stuff.
And a new baby,
Throw in puberty.
Poor guy!

He needs security, consistency discipline and love.
He cannot speak to your DH in a rude manner and likewise your DH need to stop being a mate and stop teasing your son and parent him.

THIS

What jumped out at me was his dad scaring him.
(I hsve 4 adult children 2 are step. )
That will be the biggest issue and my child would not be visiting until that was resolved

YellowPlumbob · 13/08/2022 09:42

stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 09:16

@Pyewhacket you'd end your marriage because your pre pubescent son has an attitude problem? Ok then.

All behaviour is communication.

I don’t know what you class as a row, but in my world, it would mean prolonged shouting at each other.

Again, this is escalating more and more lately. There have been rows and bad atmosphere between the pair of them

From your OP. Escalation, rows, bad atmosphere.

Who is the adult here, your 11YO or your husband? Because it’s genuinely difficult to tell. If your husband can’t cope with a surly shut up without rowing, he’s got a temper problem too. Seems you’ve got a type.

Sunnyqueen · 13/08/2022 09:39

Hmmm saying its a compliment to your parenting that your son feels safe enough to get away with being rude to your DH is a bit of a joke. What was his reaction to that statement? I'd have been pretty irked in his shoes.
I don't think saying 'everyone hates me' etc. means he is being bullied or even unhappy - tweens are the masters at over generalising for effect.

stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 09:19

@Discrimination1234 I did wonder but there is no evidence of this at all. He has a great group of friends, lots of support there. He sees friends a lot, plays online with them. He's part of two sports teams so friends there too. He isn't reclusive in any way. Outside of the house he is to all intents and purposes a happy and polite boy. It's just us that he does this with.

OP posts:
stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 09:16

@Pyewhacket you'd end your marriage because your pre pubescent son has an attitude problem? Ok then.

OP posts:
Pyewhacket · 13/08/2022 09:15

stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 08:35

@YellowPlumbob sorry at what point have I said dh has verbally abused him? He talks to him and occasionally asks him to do very simple requests and is often met with disrespectful attitude, backchat and told to shut up. It's not as if he's getting at him all the time but I think most people would have an issue being spoken to like that by a child. I hate to hear it myself.

Sorry, I'd be planning my exit, and in some detail.

Discrimination1234 · 13/08/2022 09:12

OP why is he saying “everybody” hates him. I would be checking if he’s getting bullied. Sudden change in behaviour/worrying slip of the tongue etc. Maybe nothing but it’s possible he’s acting out at home because of problems elsewhere.

Christmasiscominghohoho · 13/08/2022 09:08

Stop letting your ds rudeness slide. You are being too soft.

Id never tolerate my child telling me or anyone to ‘shut up’ when asked a simple request.

lunar1 · 13/08/2022 09:03

A difficult age, a new sibling, school transition, two bereavements and a step dad who has a 'mate' dynamic with him.

He's had a lot to deal with, but he just doesn't see your partner as a parent figure, you can't suddenly force that. You need to do 100% of the parenting yourself and hope their dynamic resets to a place where your ds respects him as an adult in his life.

stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 09:01

@ZekeZeke I disagree, he already has 2 parents he doesn't need dh to 'parent' him too. He isn't his parent. That said he does need to show him some respect in the way that I would expect him to show respect to anyone, especially someone who does show him a lot of generosity and kindness.

@PurpleWisteria slow clap for you for having perfect children.

@YellowPlumbob rowing doesn't equate to verbal abuse. If you are the target of constant rudeness even over something as simple as saying good morning or asking to pass a spoon then you are probably eventually going to snap. I don't blame dh for that I just wish it didn't have to come to that.

Lots of varied responses here that make me feel kind of better for not knowing the best way to tackle things. Ds does need to stop this rude behaviour but equally he needs to know he is loved and supported too.

OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 13/08/2022 09:01

I think you and DH need to be a united front here. Set the basic ground rules for an acceptable level of behaviour ( taking into account the age and stage of DS and his new sibling’s arrival). Don’t sweat the small stuff but agree to be consistent and united.

Ask DH to ignore the small niggles, lay off any teasing and maybe encourage them to do some activities together.

with work this will pass and they can continue to have a good relationship. Don’t underestimate the level of impact a new sibling will have at the age of 11.

YellowPlumbob · 13/08/2022 08:54

stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 08:35

@YellowPlumbob sorry at what point have I said dh has verbally abused him? He talks to him and occasionally asks him to do very simple requests and is often met with disrespectful attitude, backchat and told to shut up. It's not as if he's getting at him all the time but I think most people would have an issue being spoken to like that by a child. I hate to hear it myself.

You said there have been rows.

Puberty makes kids like toddlers, only bigger and with swear words in their vocabulary. It’s not personal. Their brains are rewiring so to speak, they have very little impulse or emotional control.

Have a read of The Teenage Brain by Frances Jensen, a Paediatric Neuroscientist and single mother of two boys.

Benjaminsniddlegrass · 13/08/2022 08:44

It's so challenging, I have three DSS and one DC with my DH. In teenage years I became the focus of a lot of anger and upset from my DSD she refused to come to us for a while, would swear and shout, cold shoulder etc. I'd been in her life about 7 years by this point and had been active and caring. She'd always struggled with her parents split more but when the hormones hit and she was angry and confused I was where that was focused. The only thing that really helped was time and patience, I gave her a lot of space, was warm but not too present with her. She found her way through and our relationship has repaired and we have a lovely warm connection now.

PurpleWisteria · 13/08/2022 08:42

Your DS needs to learn some manners.

Neither of mine behaved like that and if they had there would have been consequences.

ZekeZeke · 13/08/2022 08:41

He has a dad who shouts is intimidating and has a temper.
A step dad who acts like a mate.
A mother who let's him away with stuff.
And a new baby,
Throw in puberty.
Poor guy!

He needs security, consistency discipline and love.
He cannot speak to your DH in a rude manner and likewise your DH need to stop being a mate and stop teasing your son and parent him.

Discrimination1234 · 13/08/2022 08:38

New baby
near onset of puberty
stress in household

Have a talk with your dh. Tell him to stay calm and neutral. Kids do say very hurtful things at times, but as adults you have to be wiser.

stressybessie33 · 13/08/2022 08:35

@YellowPlumbob sorry at what point have I said dh has verbally abused him? He talks to him and occasionally asks him to do very simple requests and is often met with disrespectful attitude, backchat and told to shut up. It's not as if he's getting at him all the time but I think most people would have an issue being spoken to like that by a child. I hate to hear it myself.

OP posts:
YellowPlumbob · 13/08/2022 08:31

He’s 11. Puberty. A baby. Two lots of grieving. I think your DH needs to back the fuck off, tbh.

I say that as a mother of 14, 11 and 6 year olds.

11 is a bloody rough age for them anyway, without trauma thrown in.

You cannot hold children to a higher emotional standard than you would yourself or another adult; I see it time and time again, but mostly with blended families.

Doesn’t matter if he’s “done a lot” for DS, that’s part and parcel of being with someone who already had a child, and as his own father is very involved, then I fail to see how he can have done anything so extraordinary for him, that it would result in him being able to verbally abuse your DS, with you sitting there, doing nothing. DS doesn’t have to be grateful forever that a bloke who shacked up with his mother has been nice to him; that’s the bare fucking minimum, no?