Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that horse riders shouldn't be given equal access to woodland paths as walkers etc?

106 replies

Yeahreally · 12/08/2022 21:33

Read this article in the Guardian and it kinda made my blood boil: www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/aug/12/give-horse-riders-equal-access-to-english-woodlands-say-campaigners

IMO the spokesperson for the Trails Trust is completely ignoring the safety issues at play here. I have no issue with horses but they are big animals and can cause injury if spooked. So is it really sensible to allow them on all pathways of whatever size where runners, cyclists and people just walking their kids or dogs might be? How exactly do you give them a suitably wide berth on a narrow path?

Being a bloke, I'd be massively interested in the MN view on whether there is some sort of inequality issue at play (ie. because riders are more likely to be women there are being disproportionately affected by the current restrictions)? The argument that current laws were unfair because "They (riders) don’t want to walk, they don’t want to cycle.They feel safe in the countryside on a horse,” is incredibly weak and massively ignores how this affects other path users.

OP posts:
Scepticalwotsits · 13/08/2022 08:23

GoodThinkingMax · 13/08/2022 08:17

YABU

Cyclists are far more dangerous to pedestrians on footpaths, than horses. Many cyclists are disrespectful of shared footpaths, and of course, there are more of them.

depends on the path, where it’s relatively wide and either paved, or compacted I get what you are saying as it attract casual riders which is where I see problems, on the more rugged bridle ways I rarely encounter a cyclist and normally at that point they are a committed one and normally very respectful

Scepticalwotsits · 13/08/2022 08:21

Plenty of bridleways and horses around here, tbh doesn’t bother me, basic respect by all parties and no issues. I think some footpaths could be reviewed and given access to horses, others though wouldn’t fit a horse down as it’s a thin sliver between two large hedgerows.

So it really depends on suitability. If a path is suitable I don’t see why not

ErrolTheDragon · 13/08/2022 08:21

Is part of the reason for specifically not allowing horses in some woodlands that the paths would need to not only be wide enough but also high enough? Thinking more about woodland paths we use, the vertical clearance often isn't much more than head height in places. And quite commonly places a tree has come down which a walker may be able to get over or around.

GoodThinkingMax · 13/08/2022 08:17

YABU

Cyclists are far more dangerous to pedestrians on footpaths, than horses. Many cyclists are disrespectful of shared footpaths, and of course, there are more of them.

allthegoodusernameshavegone · 13/08/2022 08:15

nocoolnamesleft · 12/08/2022 22:07

I'd sooner share a path with horses than with dogs.

^ this 100% I am fed up of being pounced on by unruly dogs

justasking111 · 13/08/2022 08:08

I don't understand haring through woodland on a bike the magic is in hearing smelling and seeing nature. Enjoy it get off the bike and chill

35965a · 13/08/2022 08:00

Would rather have horses than dogs around

Whitehorsegirl · 13/08/2022 07:59

I agree that irreponsible cyclists and people who don't control their dogs are more likely to be a threat to safety than horses and their riders...

arrogantorwhat37 · 13/08/2022 07:44

I walk every day, sometimes in suburban areas, sometimes in country, sometimes by river. The single most fucking selfish, entitled and rude people I meet are cyc.ists. whether MIMILs thinking they are in the tour de france, or women in floaty dresses thinking they are in a flake ad, they rarely warn you of their approach, do not slow down, and expect you to throw yourself aside so they can carry on unimpeded.
And forget a thank you, no such manners or politeness
So yes, would rather have a half-ton beautiful and intelligent creature passing me on a path than a wanker on 2 wheels
Thank you - needed to get that off my chest!

pd339 · 13/08/2022 07:31

Riding horses for your own personal pleasure is a moronic past-time, and should be banned. Then the problem about where you should be allowed to ride them would disappear.

CravenRaven · 13/08/2022 07:24

I'd welcome them. Not a horse rider myself - but would welcome the sight of them in more places.

The barky dog wouldn't. But that's my problem.

MagentaRocks · 13/08/2022 07:00

I come across horses when walking my dogs in the woods. Never an issue, one dog just lies at his stick as obsessed with it, I call the other dog over and make her sit and loosely hold her collar until the horse has passed. She is unlikely to go over and spook the horse anyway but best to be safe. Why can’t everyone enjoy the same space as long as we are all considerate to others.

InChocolateWeTrust · 13/08/2022 06:44

Our local woodland has always allowed horses. We walk there regularly with our young kids and it's never remotely been an issue? We just step to the side and the horses walk calmly passed, sometimes they stop as the children like to say hello.

I'd rather they were out in the woods than on the roads. Nicer for everyone.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 13/08/2022 06:35

I'd prefer horses to cyclists tbf.

Waystation · 13/08/2022 06:28

I walk the dog in the Forrest every day - regularly pass horses, generally get dog to one side, no problem, the only issue I have is (some not all) cyclists riding very fast down narrow paths with no regard for other users.

stuntbubbles · 13/08/2022 06:13

I’d rather see a horse and rider than a dog or a cyclist. Especially the cyclist types who think shouting “Coming through, move!” is the best way to approach things vs slowing down a bit.

And horse poo is fine. If you’ve got a bag you can take some home, leave it to rot through then spread it on your garden. Can’t say that for dog poo which is vile.

sanityisamyth · 13/08/2022 05:51

Smellywellyhoo · 12/08/2022 22:32

Horse shit is bloody disgusting and the read loads of it! Would they clean it up on paths shared with pedestrians?

Much less disgusting than dog shit. There's plenty of that left all over the place. Horse shit is mushed up grass and harmless. Dog shit carries all sorts of harmful bacteria and toxins.

wetotter · 13/08/2022 05:49

I’d rather see bikes off footpaths before horses, and banned completely from bridleways

And other users trained on proper use of bridleways

sanityisamyth · 13/08/2022 05:46

Yeahreally · 12/08/2022 21:56

There are bridleways that they can already use in the countryside so I don't think anyone was saying we should ban them from the countryside.

Have you ever used an ordnance survey map to see how many bridle paths there actually are? And how do you propose horse riders actually get there? Bridleways aren't just for horses either. They are shared access paths between walkers, cyclists and horses.

NumberTheory · 13/08/2022 04:14

In general, I’d rather have horse riders in woods than cyclists. In general I’ve found horse riders far more considerate of other users than cyclists. Cyclists really need dedicated space, a large minority of them are not able to share space well with others. But I think it would be far better to keep most of woodland out of bounds for anyone except walkers.

NumberTheory · 13/08/2022 04:11

Around here the big push for cycling infrastructure as part of development is part of an attempt to get people to cycle rather than drive a car. It’s not provision of leisure space for middle aged white men in Lycra on a Sunday morning (they’re always on roads here), it’s providing transportation so that people can shop, commute, do the school run etc. It’s not always joined up or successful but in cities like London or Cambridge it’s very normal for people including women, students, school kids to cycle to places. I’m all in favour of space for horse riders, but it isn’t comparable to cycling - very few people are horse riding as a mode of transport.

But the push in woodlands isn’t about transport, it’s about sport and leisure. So the questions about opening up woodlands to horse riders compared to access for cyclists is about sport and leisure, not transport.

And the big increase in infrastructure support for transport supports increased sport and leisure cycling - both of which (transport and sport&leisure) are dominated by men (even in London).

Maverickess · 13/08/2022 01:43

I would think most horse riders would avoid very narrow paths, and I doubt they'd be moving fast on narrow paths, knees and trees springs to mind!
And they're used to sharing the spaces with walkers, dogs, children cyclists because they already share bridleways and roads with them, so by and large, know how to behave around other users appropriately, or we'd have reports of people being mowed down and jumped on from roads and bridleways - I'm not saying it doesn't happen but it's very rare. The same dangers exist there too, but people don't not use bridleways to walk and cycle on because of that.

As a pp mentioned, often riders pay for access to woodland, to help maintain the tracks, I used to have a permit for a local woodland, for my own and my horse's safety I stuck to the larger paths where I could see and where I could pass others safely, I could ride anywhere I wanted to within the woodland but I didn't just because I could, I also took into consideration my horse and myself and our safety, and often narrow paths have low overhanging trees that are tricky to navigate.
As for the safety aspect of women feeling safer, in 40 years experience of the 'horse world', I've never heard that as a reason to ride out.

And if you ban horses from woodland areas because of the safety aspects, then they're being pushed onto roads more - where many, many people don't want them already and aren't shy about letting you know by driving dangerously. We should be aiming to keep horses off the roads, riders for the most part don't like riding on them, but as already said here, bridleways are in decline, poorly maintained, disjoint and used by other users too.

gnilliwdog · 13/08/2022 01:08

I had one issue with horses on a footpath near a railway. A fast train came through which spooked one horse and he started running towards us. I had two small children with me and lifted them over a fence telling them to stand back. The rider managed to steer the horse away from me as it ran down the road. I assume she got control back, but it was slightly alarming at the time. The other horse seemed to ride by OK, but it was odd that the riders didn't apologise or express concern. I do like horses, but I'd say there is a small chance of an accident if they share more paths with walkers.

Penguinfeather781 · 13/08/2022 00:59

Astronutter · 12/08/2022 23:05

I think the point about user demographics is very valid. Over the past 10-15 years there have been on going efforts and projects to add cycling infrastructure (admittedly not always successfully, but it is planning focus for many developments). What are the main demographics of cyclists? I hazard the proportion of middle aged (white) men is likely to be very high.

In contrast, at the amateur level, horse riding is highly female dominated. When there have been numerous articles in the recent months on lack of exercise uptake by girls and women at various ages it seems bonkers to not do more to encourage participation in a female dominated sport. Following the (well deserved) media fawning over the Lionesses’ victory and how this is a turning point in women’s sport there continues to be wholesale media blind spot to our successes at a sport primarily enjoyed by women. This week we’ve won team silver at the World Dressage Championship and the new world champion is a British female rider. We’ve won a bronze and two silvers at the concurrent paradressage World Champs and will likely get a team medal when the final riders go tomorrow. Not a peep of any of these (primarily female) successes from the mainstream press!

Around here the big push for cycling infrastructure as part of development is part of an attempt to get people to cycle rather than drive a car. It’s not provision of leisure space for middle aged white men in Lycra on a Sunday morning (they’re always on roads here), it’s providing transportation so that people can shop, commute, do the school run etc. It’s not always joined up or successful but in cities like London or Cambridge it’s very normal for people including women, students, school kids to cycle to places. I’m all in favour of space for horse riders, but it isn’t comparable to cycling - very few people are horse riding as a mode of transport.

I’m also in favour of more women and diversity in sport, but a sport that requires access to a horse just isn’t accessible to most people- it’s not a lack of paths, it’s a lack of money, lack of knowledge and the fact that culturally it’s very white, very countryside based and quite intimidating for those outside of horsey circles. It’s niche and always will be. It’s an awful lot easier for a teenage girl to try womens football or netball or a gym class or swimming than it is to for them to try horse riding.

Grantanow · 13/08/2022 00:54

Scaremongering. Why waste time on this?