Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hitler argument

131 replies

Birchtree1 · 12/08/2022 19:12

Just had a massive argument with my husband.
He thinks our son is a leader....( I think he has adhd) he has been pointing it out for a while. He has just mentioned it again and said he is a leader and Hitler was a leader too. Now. ...I lost my shit Hitler killed millions of people and was an ego maniac amd narcissistic asshole. ( in my opinion) apparently I am not normal with this opinion and he doesn't want to talk to me and whatever happened he was still a leader!? I just spoke to my children re our German heritage and the Jews and gypsies and lots of other minorities which I didn't want to do just yet as they are 5 and 8 years old. My husband is refusing to talk to me as I really lost my shit.
He could have mentioned Churchill or whoever ...but mentioning Hitler as an example of leadership? Apparently it is being taught at schools in this county!?!!?

OP posts:
PollyRockets · 12/08/2022 22:51

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 12/08/2022 21:51

I would be really concerned at this content with a child of that age. With an older teen or adult I think you could have an interesting conversation about what makes a leader by using examples of people who did horrendous evil things but took a lot of people along with them- Hitler would certainly be one example of that kind of leader, but there are others from the twentieth century (Pol Pot for example, or Idi Amin).

Learning about Hitler is covered in KS2 curriculum which is the DS age group

Hobele · 12/08/2022 22:49

My gut feeling is: he wanted to give you an example of a German person. Couldn't come up with anybody else (for lack of historical knowledge probably). But wouldn't back down/admit it was a shit example of a 'leader' and hugely inappropriate.

DeLaLune2022 · 12/08/2022 22:32

AliceS1994 · 12/08/2022 22:19

There are some strange people on Mumsnet. Of course that is a deeply inappropriate and upsetting comparison, and unless he's an idiot he should know the impact saying that would have on you! He is deliberately trying to upset you in my opinion.

I went to an international school and we were taught WW2/ fascism is Europe and fallout of WW1 alongside German pupils who were horrified by the openness and explicitness of the content, it really opened my eyes to how profoundly upset many Germans are, to this day, about this part of history, even young teenagers who have nothing to be ashamed of!

This! I read on another Thread that some people think colonialism should not be taught in schools because it is too harsh for the Kids. I think we absolutetly have to teach these matters (in an age approbriate way) because those cruelties must never happen again. And I understand if people say that they do not want to be lectured by Germans but this isn‘t my Intention- I just still feel the fallout from the generations before me and don‘t want history repeating itself.

ThreeLocusts · 12/08/2022 22:32

Hitler rose to the top in a context of mass hysteria, extreme political polarisation and dysfunction in Germany's political system. He was good at spinning paranoid blame-shifting narratives that resonated in that moment and served as the vessel of morbid fantasies of blood-soaked military greatness for his admirers.

He was shit at military strategy, policy and administration. It was the crisis that made him, not his 'leadership talents'. Your partner is talking out of his arse, mildly put. I'd be well pissed off.

AliceS1994 · 12/08/2022 22:19

There are some strange people on Mumsnet. Of course that is a deeply inappropriate and upsetting comparison, and unless he's an idiot he should know the impact saying that would have on you! He is deliberately trying to upset you in my opinion.

I went to an international school and we were taught WW2/ fascism is Europe and fallout of WW1 alongside German pupils who were horrified by the openness and explicitness of the content, it really opened my eyes to how profoundly upset many Germans are, to this day, about this part of history, even young teenagers who have nothing to be ashamed of!

dapsnotplimsolls · 12/08/2022 22:08

Why does your husband think DS is a leader, what traits is he showing? From what you've said, it does appear that he's used Hitler as an example to wind you up.

DeLaLune2022 · 12/08/2022 22:03

StoneofDestiny · 12/08/2022 21:56

From another German- I would lose my shit. Hitler is the very example of what happens when people lose their abilty of critical thinking and blindly follow an authoritarian regime. And current British politics deeply worry me because I can see a tendency that they try to achieve the same

yes - quite a lot of us are worried about that too........…

And this gives me hope! Please don‘t lose your voice I still think you are the majority :)

Octomore · 12/08/2022 22:02

It's obvious there are some serious issues in your relationship, and YANBU to not want your child to be compared to Hitler

What are your husband's politics usually? Is he hard right wing? I'd leave any man who's default example of a 'leader' was Hitler.

Pinkspice · 12/08/2022 21:59

Mummyoflittledragon · 12/08/2022 20:31

Having lived in Germany, I not surprised you are upset. Does your husband not understand anything about German culture?

I think he does. Which is precisely the point: the OP knows he was trying to hurt her by using this comparison. It's why arguments about whether or not Hitler was a leader are supremely missing the point.

StoneofDestiny · 12/08/2022 21:56

From another German- I would lose my shit. Hitler is the very example of what happens when people lose their abilty of critical thinking and blindly follow an authoritarian regime. And current British politics deeply worry me because I can see a tendency that they try to achieve the same

yes - quite a lot of us are worried about that too........…

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 12/08/2022 21:51

I would be really concerned at this content with a child of that age. With an older teen or adult I think you could have an interesting conversation about what makes a leader by using examples of people who did horrendous evil things but took a lot of people along with them- Hitler would certainly be one example of that kind of leader, but there are others from the twentieth century (Pol Pot for example, or Idi Amin).

DeLaLune2022 · 12/08/2022 21:49

Und das ist gut so:)ich liebe dieses Forum und hab hier so viel gelernt aber leider nehmen auch hier die Querdenker zu 😚

Cautiouselectric · 12/08/2022 21:47

OP I’m so sorry your DH did this. It’s thoroughly obnoxious. I live in Germany and my husband is German, I kind of get how utterly offensive it is. I cannot imagine why he would say something that dumb to his German wife, about his child.

Birchtree1 · 12/08/2022 21:45

PollyRockets · 12/08/2022 21:39

@Birchtree1

The behaviour you described in your recent post about your son was on the dictator side over leader, so I can see why you're annoyed at him being called a leader when it seems he is making excuses for shit behaviour

Which is why I suspect you feel so strongly about this.

My son isn't neurotypical and has some issues but he is not a dictator. I personally wouldn't call him a leader either. His father does.
I simply object to him being compared to Hitler...or putin or stalin or Kim Jong un. What is your problem with me and my post PollyRockets? Don't be after me I was just looking for support!

OP posts:
DeLaLune2022 · 12/08/2022 21:39

SoSoSusan · 12/08/2022 21:35

The leadership qualities of Hitler and similar is an interesting debate to have, in the right context and setting.

To choose Hitler as the example of a leader to whom your son was being compared is just weird.

I agree that from a philosophical point of view that is a very intersting question. I can fully understand why the op dorsn‘t want her son to be Part of the experiment though!

PollyRockets · 12/08/2022 21:39

@Birchtree1

The behaviour you described in your recent post about your son was on the dictator side over leader, so I can see why you're annoyed at him being called a leader when it seems he is making excuses for shit behaviour

Which is why I suspect you feel so strongly about this.

Birchtree1 · 12/08/2022 21:37

PollyRockets · 12/08/2022 21:33

So your Ds acts like a mini dictator is that why you're so sensitive about this?

As honestly from what you put on your original post it didn't sound all that deep

Awww thanks! Wasn't planning for a 'deep' post just soem advice. And he isn't acting like a dictator. If you read back its about being a leader and me objecting to a Hitler comparison as he was a dictator!!!! But never mind!

OP posts:
SoSoSusan · 12/08/2022 21:35

The leadership qualities of Hitler and similar is an interesting debate to have, in the right context and setting.

To choose Hitler as the example of a leader to whom your son was being compared is just weird.

PollyRockets · 12/08/2022 21:33

Birchtree1 · 12/08/2022 21:21

Obviously he can be a leader even if he has adhd/ autism etc but as a German I don't want him compared to people like Hitler particularly due to my heritage. And by the way he isn't like a mini Hitler he is a little boy with issues and I already dislike the fact my husband calls him a leader when he sees him with other children. He thinks it's a great trait while I don't agree as it doesn't make you s popular play friend. And that's all my little boy wants and all I want for him! Whoever say my 8 year old is a leader when seeing him play with his friends and subsequently says Hitler was a leader too to little boys mum!?

So your Ds acts like a mini dictator is that why you're so sensitive about this?

As honestly from what you put on your original post it didn't sound all that deep

DeLaLune2022 · 12/08/2022 21:32

MyrrAgain · 12/08/2022 21:28

Depends where they're leading you to though. Doesn't it.

And where do you hope this might lead to?

Runwalkskijump · 12/08/2022 21:30

He could have mentioned Churchill or whoever ...but mentioning Hitler as an example of leadership? Apparently it is being taught at schools in this county!?!!?

I can virtually guarantee it isn't

MyrrAgain · 12/08/2022 21:28

Depends where they're leading you to though. Doesn't it.

Birchtree1 · 12/08/2022 21:27

MmeMeursault · 12/08/2022 20:52

This is just awful and so unbelievably horrendous that I'd seriously be questioning whether I would stay with him. He really has no idea does he, of the offence he's caused. Wie lange hat er so gedacht, denkst du?

Mit Idioten kann man überhaupt nicht reden, eben hier mit einigen in MN.

Danke, ich weiß es auch nicht! Deine nachricht hat geholfen! Ich hab versucht ihm klar zu machen wie mist das war aber er schnallt es nicht und will nicht mit mir darübrr reden.
Excuse the German!

OP posts:
Birchtree1 · 12/08/2022 21:21

Obviously he can be a leader even if he has adhd/ autism etc but as a German I don't want him compared to people like Hitler particularly due to my heritage. And by the way he isn't like a mini Hitler he is a little boy with issues and I already dislike the fact my husband calls him a leader when he sees him with other children. He thinks it's a great trait while I don't agree as it doesn't make you s popular play friend. And that's all my little boy wants and all I want for him! Whoever say my 8 year old is a leader when seeing him play with his friends and subsequently says Hitler was a leader too to little boys mum!?

OP posts:
DownNative · 12/08/2022 21:21

Birchtree1 · 12/08/2022 21:16

You are missing the point. I don't mind our son having issues but I do mind him to be compared to Hitler. Particularly as I am German and have had to live with our history.

Naturally, you would be seriously offended by your OH using Hitler as an example. I think most people would, including non-Germans in the same way they'd be offended at Mussolini, Franco, Stalin, Lenin and Saddam Hussein being used as examples of leadership.

Given how many examples of leadership around the world, your OH should have chosen someone else. It's common knowledge you don't mention Hitler or the war to Germans like that.

Especially as Germany still struggles to let go of lingering guilt.