Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Hitler argument

131 replies

Birchtree1 · 12/08/2022 19:12

Just had a massive argument with my husband.
He thinks our son is a leader....( I think he has adhd) he has been pointing it out for a while. He has just mentioned it again and said he is a leader and Hitler was a leader too. Now. ...I lost my shit Hitler killed millions of people and was an ego maniac amd narcissistic asshole. ( in my opinion) apparently I am not normal with this opinion and he doesn't want to talk to me and whatever happened he was still a leader!? I just spoke to my children re our German heritage and the Jews and gypsies and lots of other minorities which I didn't want to do just yet as they are 5 and 8 years old. My husband is refusing to talk to me as I really lost my shit.
He could have mentioned Churchill or whoever ...but mentioning Hitler as an example of leadership? Apparently it is being taught at schools in this county!?!!?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Percyprod · 14/08/2022 18:25

I would say you were wrong, Hitler was a leader, surely you can’t dispute that? He led his country into war, and was thoroughly evil, but like Putin and many other people, he was a leader.

whumpthereitis · 13/08/2022 13:27

Shade17 · 13/08/2022 13:01

He managed to manipulate his forces into murdering millions of innocent people and gained unwavering loyalty whilst doing it. He was certainly skilful and charismatic but not something to aspire to.

Not especially. An effective speaker? Sure, but the reality is that the NSDAP never actually won an election in the Weimar Republic, and indeed his populist support was already on the wane by the time he was engineered into power.

He rose at a time when Germany was facing severe economic turmoil, and provided a handy scapegoat (and indeed an age old one) in the form of the Jews. In regards to the formation, and implementation, of Nazi policy, that was the work of the ministers and bureaucrats behind him (see: the traditional ruling class that were more than a bit fucking salty about a new democratic republic that threatened their claim on power). The man himself was fairly lazy and spent most of his time sat on his arse in the mountains, holding court and waxing lyrical about, well, himself.

When he did start taking control in regards to the military, his decision making was erratic to say the least, and he made some really, really basic fucking mistakes that lead to the overall defeat of the Wehrmacht.

He was an utter failure as a leader, even if you don’t consider the holocaust (although I don’t know why you wouldn’t). Had it not been for a perfect storm of events and people around him, he’d have remained a non entity that, at most, could talk a good game at a party.

Shade17 · 13/08/2022 13:01

He managed to manipulate his forces into murdering millions of innocent people and gained unwavering loyalty whilst doing it. He was certainly skilful and charismatic but not something to aspire to.

whumpthereitis · 13/08/2022 12:28

Birchtree1 · 13/08/2022 09:28

My OH is very bright. I feel he knew it would wind me up and he succeeded.
I guess I may have over reacted. If I was British I wouldn’t have but being German it just really wound me up. He was a despot and he made the best of a situation when people were at their worst and he managed to pull lots of people along with him. A leader for certain but not exactly the best example! When your wife is German and your child is 1/2 German.
also I don’t see my son as a leader, which is another argument we sometimes have. I see a boy desperate for friends who is bossy and doesn’t always get it right!

You’re not being overly sensitive. It’s a shit comparison to make, on any level. He didn’t make the best of a situation, the Weimar Republic was actually on the road to recovery when he was engineered into power. Hitler managed to take the country and decimate it. On no level is can it be considered compliment to anyone that’s vaguely familiar with German and European history.

If your husband wanted to make a point about your child being difficult, just calling him a ‘little despot’ whilst not great, is significantly better than calling him Hitler to his German wife. If he meant it as a compliment, well then, that’s another fucking problem.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 13/08/2022 10:40

And anyone comparing any child or their behaviour in any capacity to hitler in any way needs to seriously examine their thinking because it is a seriously fucked up thing to do.

Hitler was a mass murderer. That fact wipes out any other facet of his personality or actions as an appropriate comparator in any sense. Unless the person you wish to compare is also a mass murderer.

BewareTheBeardedDragon · 13/08/2022 10:33

OP - you are not over sensitive and the people suggesting you are have no idea because they aren't German/haven't German family. I would honestly not take any notice of the voices telling you you're overreacting etc. English people really don't understand. They just don't.

YANBU and your OH is massively U

StreetwiseHercules · 13/08/2022 10:29

BitOutOfPractice · 13/08/2022 00:02

Well then I must not be “allowed” either as I question Churchill and his opinions and policies all the time. Not least that he was well known as an anti-Semite at the time and is still remembered as one on many circles now.

He was also a world class and utterly vicious racist who thought nothing of using chemical weapons on people with no defence forces.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 13/08/2022 10:28

Of course Hitler was a leader. Just not one anyone remotely normal would want to emulate. Putin’s having a good try, though.

Birchtree1 · 13/08/2022 10:24

I hear you! But choosing hitler as an example is still not appropriate. But I see lots of people don’t agree.

OP posts:
BeanieTeen · 13/08/2022 10:11

You're sensitive to him being seen as 'bad' and your DH mentioning Hitler drives this home

It doesn’t drive it home, in the OP’s and her DC’s it crosses a big line.

You could jokingly but not jokingly refer to Hitler if a child with no German ties was being as you say a ‘mini dictator’. It wouldn’t be particularly funny in my opinion but not massively offensive either.
But not if that child is actually half German! WTAF, that’s so offensive. How can people be so tone deaf and think that’s ok?

I think if someone jokingly said it about a child, not knowing they were half German, but then got told ‘Oh my God, Dave, you know that kid is actually German?’ - Dave would feel instantly feel awkward and like an arse because he’s massively put his foot in it. It’s a massive faux pas if you like - if you were to do it by accident. If you do it on purpose, knowing that child is German, you are just an arse plain and simple.

StreetwiseHercules · 13/08/2022 09:30

“Losing your shit” because you don’t like what someone says is a bit ott.

PollyRockets · 13/08/2022 09:30

Birchtree1 · 13/08/2022 09:28

My OH is very bright. I feel he knew it would wind me up and he succeeded.
I guess I may have over reacted. If I was British I wouldn’t have but being German it just really wound me up. He was a despot and he made the best of a situation when people were at their worst and he managed to pull lots of people along with him. A leader for certain but not exactly the best example! When your wife is German and your child is 1/2 German.
also I don’t see my son as a leader, which is another argument we sometimes have. I see a boy desperate for friends who is bossy and doesn’t always get it right!

You just seem overly sensitive all round

Your son is displaying shit behaviour which is where this issue lies imo.

You're sensitive to him being seen as 'bad' and your DH mentioning Hitler drives this home

Some kids can be mini dictators, from what you've said yours fits the bill

Maybe instead of getting worked up about this focus on helping your son

Birchtree1 · 13/08/2022 09:28

My OH is very bright. I feel he knew it would wind me up and he succeeded.
I guess I may have over reacted. If I was British I wouldn’t have but being German it just really wound me up. He was a despot and he made the best of a situation when people were at their worst and he managed to pull lots of people along with him. A leader for certain but not exactly the best example! When your wife is German and your child is 1/2 German.
also I don’t see my son as a leader, which is another argument we sometimes have. I see a boy desperate for friends who is bossy and doesn’t always get it right!

OP posts:
whumpthereitis · 13/08/2022 08:20

Out of all the examples of leaders, he went for Hitler? Jesus Christ. If he wanted a Germanic examples there’s Bismarck, Adenauer, Hindenburg, Frederick the Great….but no, “he’s like Hitler love!”. Outstanding.

Fucking hell. Even if you want to look at Hitler outside of the context of, you know, genocide, he was not a great leader by any stretch. He was a good public speaker in regards to the almost hypnotic effect he had on people and how he could fire them up, but actual leadership qualities he was severely lacking in. He was engineered into power in the first place (at a time when it appeared NSDAP support from the electorate had in fact peaked and was falling - he never won an election), and once in power his machine did most of the work. His decision making was erratic to say the least, and once he decided to take over from the generals in running the campaigns the whole artifice fell apart quite quickly.

PutinIsAWarCriminal · 13/08/2022 08:04

It all sounds very dramatic. If my dh had said something like that I would have just pulled him up on it and suggested Hitler, being one of history's criminals, was a bad example. I wouldn't have lost my shit or felt it necessary to explain the holocaust. I accept though that I have English privilege. One of my friends is 3rd generation of a Jewish escapee, and has told me that the family members left behind disappeared. They might well have reacted differently.
What is your dh usually like. Was this purely to trigger you, or is he just a bit thick?

BitOutOfPractice · 13/08/2022 00:05

Anyway, praising hitler is the ultimate whataboutery isn’t it? He made the trains run on time. So let’s forget the atrocities he perpetrated. That reasoning is grotesque.

BitOutOfPractice · 13/08/2022 00:02

Well then I must not be “allowed” either as I question Churchill and his opinions and policies all the time. Not least that he was well known as an anti-Semite at the time and is still remembered as one on many circles now.

OrlandointheWilderness · 12/08/2022 23:55

Your DH is a dick. Obviously Hitler was an incredibly powerful leader to have done what he did. He was also an evil murdering arsehole who no one should compare a child too.

BeanieTeen · 12/08/2022 23:44

The whole thing just seems very off, given what you’ve said. It does come across like your DH was trying to make a hurtful dig at you via your DS. Or even a dig at your DS for being half German. Like a purposefully xenophobic dig. If it was supposed to be ‘funny’, it was meant be nasty humour where the joke is on you.

I can’t help but think if you were Russian he would have gone down the Stalin route. If you were Chinese he would have gone for Mao. If you were Italian he would have said something about Mussolini… and so forth.

I agree with PP this was done deliberately to push buttons. He’s sounds like a real prick.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 12/08/2022 23:23

Christ on a bike, that’s a terrible thing for your husband to say! Especially as you are German.

Ok he did “lead” a country - as did many other evil dictators mentioned in this thread - but your husband was clearly using him as an example of leadership qualities. To be aspired to. That’s abhorrent in my eyes.

As well as being evil, he was also a terrible leader as he left his country utterly destroyed. That’s not even a successful leader.

What’s all this “our son is a leader” nonsense anyway? Let you son find his own path, and don’t let him start pigeonholing him for his own ends.

BMW6 · 12/08/2022 23:14

Comparing ANYONE to Hitler to faux praise their "leadership" is not fucking well OK.

He is quite obviously being a bellend. Any comparison to Hitler is an insult. He chose that person to be inflatory. Perhaps because the OP is German. I think so, because any normal person would never, ever, make such a remark unless as a total jest.

DeLaLune2022 · 12/08/2022 23:12

PollyRockets · 12/08/2022 23:04

The OPs DH doesn't seem to be discussing good leadership

The Op has detailed some troubling behaviour from her son. Which tbh would make me think 'little hitler' if I saw it in a park

Which tbh makes me think you are very ignorant. Of politics. And children.

PollyRockets · 12/08/2022 23:04

DeLaLune2022 · 12/08/2022 22:58

But he was? And hitler shouldn‘t be anywhere near a discussion of good Leadership?

The OPs DH doesn't seem to be discussing good leadership

The Op has detailed some troubling behaviour from her son. Which tbh would make me think 'little hitler' if I saw it in a park

DeLaLune2022 · 12/08/2022 22:58

But he was? And hitler shouldn‘t be anywhere near a discussion of good Leadership?

PollyRockets · 12/08/2022 22:52

@Birchtree1

But he wasn't compared to hitler

Your husband said your child is a leader

And then Hitler was a leader

Which is factually accurate